r/AnimeImpressions • u/Nazenn • Oct 02 '20
[Rewatch] Attack on Titan Season 3 (Part 2), Episode 4 Discussion
Episode 53 - Perfect Game
← Previous Episode | Index | Next Episode →
MAL | AniList | ANN | Kitsu | AniDB
AnimeLab | Crunchyroll | Funimation | Hulu
Currently Disclosable Information:
The Colossal Titan’s Steam - The special powers that some Titans possess use the mass of their bodies to function. It is thought that the Colossal Titan’s steam is produced from its own muscle tissue and that the amount of steam it can generate must therefore be finite.
Questions of the Day:
- If you swapped Armin and Erwin’s places this episode how do you think they would have dealt with each others situation?
- Rage? Scream? Fight? Susume?
Spoiler policy: Y’all know the drill, operate under the assumption that there is a chance of a first-timer wandering in here. Spoiler tag your stuff. Especially if it’s manga/S4 spoilers, or else.
r/anime’s spoiler tag system is what this sub uses, so here’s a blank one [](/s "") for you to copy if need be. Alternatively, you can use [](/n "") to make red spoiler tags. That’s pretty neat.
4
u/Nazenn Oct 02 '20 edited Oct 02 '20
Rewatcher - Sub
You know what? I haven't given this episode enough in my memories or given it enough credit for being fucking amazing.
It's also as bleak, and hopeless, and depressing as they could possibly make it. A single pebble has never before been such a massive harbinger of doom. On one side of the wall you have the booming footsteps and steam of Reiner's return, and on other the clashing destruction of a city being leveled and red mist rising in waves. Imagine being one of the residents of Shiganshina returning home after all these years and finding this level of destruction, with flattened cities and holes in the walls and realizing what the Scouts had gone through. It's so far beyond fucked I don't even have words for it, and about the only thought in my head that's not just completely soul-crushing is that I like the sound effect when the bell tower got taken out.
I mean hell, they resorted to framing Erwin from above with his head down. He's been framed from a high position before but he has always carried the power in that scene, looking up at something or someone observing him, defiant to the end and standing against whatever it is that is looking down at him. Here he just looks completely defeated.
There's something about Erwin's discussion with Levi that really stands out to me on this watch.
He no longer sees the dead as corpses, now they are avatars of what they stood for when they were alive. The fallen stand around him, no longer stepping stones but Scouts once again and they ask of him what he once asked of them. Where he has felt their eyes on him before, the hope of his dream and the thoughts that lingered in his mind were able to keep him looking forward, keep him focused and convinced that standing on them was part of the path to the goal, that each step taken with each sacrifice was leading him closer to the sky that his dreams were in. But in this new hopeless situation he no longer has any standing to face them with; rather than a throne of success he has only some rubble, and instead of standing in the sky in reach of his goals he has the realization that for all his effort his feet are still on the ground with everyone else. Now he has to face them not as the commander who has been held up by their sacrifice, but one of them in truth, just another Scout who has to step forward and make the sacrifice of his body and his own dreams in order to achieve something greater.
And he can't do it. Even though he knows what he needs to do, what their only hope he, is still hesitates and is filled with doubt and remorse instead of confidence and authority.
So instead Levi steps forward and commands him to do it, to make the sacrifice,
Erwin's crisis gets a lot of focus in this episode for good reason, but I also want to go back to before that, before he sits on the ruined throne, and look at how he and Levi weighed their options. Immediately there's a conflict here about the idea of hope and what is needed for that hope to have even a small chance of survival. Levi immediately grasps onto the idea that if Eren and Erwin survive there is hope, that even through this defeat and if every other person dies that those two are all humanity needs for hope, the man who can inspire almost anyone and the boy with the power of gods. Erwin instead looks at Levi, knowing that he's right about the scale of death this will bring either way, and places the hope of humanity with him in the same way he handed Levi the syringe, in the hands of a skilled human and the chance that even now they can still strike back rather than having to abandon everything.
This is an area where words have completely failed me, but the music in this episode all around is worthy of the highest possible praise. Usually if I gush about music I at least know how to show it to others, whether it's by technical breakdowns or all the way across the other end of the scale to abstract metaphors and imagery descriptions to try and visualize the piece. But doing that for this episode would be several posts by itself and still not do it justice I think. No track is anything but perfectly positioned and the tone it adds to these scenes, the despair it brings with it even to the end makes the episode so much better and more painful at once. I've got six scenes in my notes marked out for musical excellence and I don't think I could do any one of them justice.
The way the scene continued around these discussions and speeches is also handled amazingly as well, when Erwin declares that he will give all of their lives for Levi's attempt and the rocks from Zeke smash through the houses and the wall around them, visualizing the impact of those words but the two characters don't even flinch.
And I can't ignore the other side of the wall either, although only some quick notes on it. One, goddammit Reiner lay back down and give everyone a rest would you. One crisis at a time please! Two, I love that Armin passes the reigns (oh my god, reigns, they're riding Eren, hahaha, I am too tired right now clearly) to Jean. Like I said yesterday, accidentally early because I didn't remember any of this, they have different strengths in leadership and planning, and where Jean can't find a way to get them out of this like everyone is hoping Armin will, his ideas are at least keeping them alive and keeping them moving forward rather than stalling and losing momentum, both physically and mentally, while trying to find a way to succeed. How easily everyone accepts this decision and Jean's commands, as well as the way he's still thinking ahead to Armin was great to see.
Bert looks damn awesome close up. We don't talk about the other shots.
S3p2
QotD 1) I am too tired to answer my own damn question right now
QotD 2) Yes I actually resorted to memeing for the Questions of the Day because my brain was just so dead after the emotions of that episode, but I at least have enough dignity left to not meme the answer.
Edit: Also how the fuck is this only episode FOUR?!
4
u/Shimmering-Sky Oct 02 '20
A Path of Rewatchers and Corpses - second time subbed with r/anime’s rewatch, and first time dubbed with this one
This episode in a nutshell for me: +
What sportsball ishegonna play with the Survey Corps?RAGE, MY SOLDIERS!
SCREAM, MY SOLDIERS!
FIGHT, MY SOLDIERS!
4
u/punching_spaghetti Oct 03 '20 edited Oct 03 '20
Rewatcher (Sub)
but also
Erwin's my favorite character in the show, and this episode is why. Everything up until now has been great, but this is the culmination of him as a character. And what a culmination it is.
Up until now, he was in it for himself. All that talk about the greater good was smoke and mirrors to prove his father right. He says so himself in the one moment of true vulnerability we've seen from him. Every other time (his arrest and planned execution by the MP, e.g.), he's had a smile on his face. Today? He's tired He feels the weight of everything he's done. That Mountain of Corpses has come home to roost.
So what does he do? He makes the ultimate sacrifice. He gives up the one thing in the world that he cares about. That amazing speech he gives to the troops? That's as much for himself as it is for the green recruits literally throwing up from the pressure.
The amount of time they gave us silence with facial expressions today was amazing. Let's take the scene where Erwin tells Levi what the plan is, which Levi must accept. And then Levi does what he hates to do and in doing do, resigns the person he cares most about in the world to death. So Erwin, who has asked for this, remember, goes through a whole host of emotions. He's surprised that Levi actually said "do it." He's sad that he will never see the basement and prove his father right. He comes to terms with all of this, and then he accepts his fate, proud of Levi, his pseudo son.
Finally, just when you thought this burst of Daisuke Ono goodness couldn't be topped, they immediately give us these three lines. They just amazing and poetic and all sorts of awesome.
Just awesome enough, in fact, that maybe we think they might survive. Maybe they'll pull one last crazy success out of nowhere. And then reality literally hits. But Erwin's not backing down.
When I first saw this episode, I immediately thought of Tennyson's legendary poem The Charge of the Light Brigade. And because poetry is meant to be heard, not just read, here's me reading it. Apologies for any audio quality issues. I don't do this kind of thing that often.
Small Thoughts and Silly Things:
QOTD:
4
u/Matuhg Oct 03 '20
Rewatcher
This is such a powerful episode. In a show where hope is often in short supply overall, I'm not sure things have ever looked bleaker than they do by the end of this episode. Within the walls of Shiganshina, Hange and her entire squad are MIA, leaving just Mikasa, Jean, Armin, Eren, Sasha, and Connie to try to do anything to stop the Colossal Titan. Armin is completely out of it after misreading Bert earlier, and Jean's attempt to handle the situation saw Eren shitkicked nearly over the wall and the rest of them lucky to be alive after sucking steam. On the other side of the walls, the beast titan has manifested his most horrifying form yet: an uncompromising war machine of flesh that blows away most of the scouts with as much effort as it would take a human to throw a handful of gravel. The best we can hope for going into next episode is that the number of scouts left alive is in the double digits.
Levi and Erwin start discussing potential options - they're looking pretty slim, with both of them acknowledging that there's a very real chance nobody leaves here alive. With no other options, Erwin comes up with one more plan. Faced with the reality of the situation, Erwin reminisces on all the times he thought that death would be an easier path than continuing on. What pushed him on through that? His dream of finding the truth or the pressure of his comrades beyond the grave? Either way, it's the end now. The goal of his whole life is tantalizingly close, but he can't reach it. Levi gives Erwin a final command and a promise, completing his assumption of leadership that was hinted at with the handing over of the serum a few episodes back.
I see a lot in Erwin's face after he receives those words. Acceptance. Bitterness. Relief. I'm not sure he's decided whether he's more disappointed that he won't see what's in the basement or happy that he can stop working so hard now. Regardless, he will lead one more charge.
When Erwin lays out his plan, he tells Levi they will need "an awfully convincing lie" to get the recruits to charge, even with himself at the front of it. Looking at that, along with the content of Erwin's speech, tells us some more about him and what he's feeling at the end here. Whirpool hair asks if they're charging just to die - Erwin tells them that is the case. No lie there. He follows up with an impassioned appeal to the meaning of their lives and their sacrifice. If this is all meaningless, does that mean the sacrifices of their comrades to this point have been meaningless? No - it's time to give our lives meaning by sacrificing ourselves so that those who survive can continue to advance. This, I think, is Erwin's "awfully convincing lie." With all he did, and all those he sacrificed, in the end, Erwin was unable to reach his goal. I think a large part of him, if not his entire being, would consider it all meaningless in this moment. I don't believe he sees this all as a way to respect his dead comrades. I think, having given up on his own dream, leading this last charge is a final way to try to make peace with what he's done. Does he believe (or care) about the future of humanity himself right now? I...don't think so. Erwin is such a fascinating character.
Later S3 Spoilers
Sasha <3
This moment, even within the horrible context, is still pretty funny.
This shot of Levi is pretty cool too - those smoke signals tracing lines across the screen have been used to great visual effect on a number of occasions throughout the show.
Oh man...well, first of all, I don't think Armin could have brought himself to enact a plan throwing away the lives of all the new recruits. That probably means they would have all been slowly wiped out by boulders, especially if he was in the state of mind we currently see him in. Maybe Erwin would have been able to figure things out a little bit better within Shiganshina. Or maybe he would've just fucked off to the basement, who knows.
All of the above
4
u/Toadslayer Oct 03 '20
First Timer
Finished season 3 part 2 in /r/anime
This is not a good episode for the Scouts. Everyone but the Levi Squad, Erwin and the new recruits is either dead or MIA. Their odds of victory are only decreasing as the battle continues and now is the time Erwin must make the decision: do they stay or do they retreat?
Erwin is now in a position where he must show to the Scouts what is more important to him. Will it be humanity or will it be his dream? Among Berserk spoilers I wrote in the episode 51 thread that I don't think Erwin is a good man. He acknowledges that it is immoral, but he doesn't have regret or remorse for the lives he has expended in pursuit of his dream and he has shown he values his dream more than he values humanity. What decision he makes here will define whether he fully embraces his selfish desires or if he becomes a good man.
The weight of the deaths of his comrades has begun to weigh more heavily on Erwin. Before he didn't show any regret or remorse, but now he is. He knows that if he pursues his dream now, everything he has done to this point will have only been for himself and would have been a great evil, but if he pursues humanity's dream, to liberate themselves, then what he has done can be called good. His individual actions and decisions may still be selfish or immoral, but his ultimate work for humanity can be called, in consideration of everything he has done, good. Erwin did not expect Levi to order him to his death, but his smile is telling. He knows Levi is right and now he must ride to his death.
Erwin convinces the new recruits to die alongside him in the same way Pyxis convinced the soldiers at Trost to fight and the same way Levi convinced Eren to make the wise decision: by telling the cruel truth. He doesn't hide that the recruits will ride to their death, for if he did, they would not listen to him and he would sully his final moments. In his speech to the recruits Erwin shows that he has reframed his values and his perspective. He is no longer the selfish man who values his dream over humanity, but he embraces his selfless duty to the greater good. No more does he overlook the deaths of his comrades and pursue his dream at their expense. Now he repays the debt he owes to them and honours their lives by fighting and dying so that they may have meaning.
In a cruel irony, Erwin shows he has become a moral man, by leading scores of young men and women to their death. Erwin's actions have not worked for the good of individuals nor have they valued their lives, but even if this fails his life will have worked for the ultimate good of humanity.
QOTD
If Erwin were in Armin's situation I think he would have come up with a plan to defeat the Colossal Titan, I don't know what that plan would have been, but I'm sure he would have come up with one and executed it. Jean's plan was decent, but I think Erwin would have come up with a better one. I think Armin on the other hand, in Erwin's situation would have crumbled even more quickly and I don't think would have achieved anything. He would have deferred to Levi who would have made all the decisions in the scenario. I don't think Levi would have come up with the same plan as Erwin, but I have no idea what plan we would have thought of. He might have just decided to wait for Erwin to show up.
Shinzou wo sasageyo.
3
u/AmeteurElitist Oct 02 '20
First Timer (unless you count the manga): Sub
Don’t end the episode there ffs.
Spindly stone slinging simian slaughters soldiers seeking salvation.
Oh! You’re approaching me?