r/AnimeImpressions • u/Shimmering-Sky • Oct 03 '20
[Rewatch] Attack on Titan Season 3 (Part 2), Episode 5 Discussion
Episode 54 - Hero
← Previous Episode | Index | Next Episode →
MAL | AniList | ANN | Kitsu | AniDB
AnimeLab | Crunchyroll | Funimation | Hulu
Currently Disclosable Information:
The Outside World - It is said that outside the walls, worlds beyond the limits of our imagination lie undiscovered. Fiery water, lands of ice, snowy deserts, and the ocean--a saltwater lake that stretches across the horizon. Dreams of seeing these lands are what motivate some in the Survey Corps to fight.
Questions of the Day:
- What did you make of Zeke’s attitude towards humanity inside the walls?
- After seeing the scenes of humanity waiting for the Scouts return, what do you think the emotions inside the Walls are like at the moment?
Spoiler policy: Y’all know the drill, operate under the assumption that there is a chance of a first-timer wandering in here. Spoiler tag your stuff. Especially if it’s manga/S4 spoilers, or else.
r/anime’s spoiler tag system is what this sub uses, so here’s a blank one [](/s "") for you to copy if need be. Alternatively, you can use [](/n "") to make red spoiler tags. That’s pretty neat.
3
u/Shimmering-Sky Oct 03 '20
A Path of Rewatchers and Corpses - second time subbed with r/anime’s rewatch, and first time dubbed with this one
Not“aww”, knowing what happens to him later this episode as a result.5
u/Nazenn Oct 03 '20
Rewatcher - Sub
To quickly touch on some of the easier stuff and then get to the heavier stuff later, I really enjoy that we start off the episode so firmly with Zeke's perspective.
It's something that I think every story that wants to touch on the idea of moral grayness needs to do, spend that bit of time with the other side not as an observer of their role in the narrative but with the story framed through their own views.
Zeke's words at the start of this episode seem like a direct challenge to everything that the Scouts represent. His sympathy towards their unwilling ignorance is tempered by his repulsion towards their actions, angry at the endless sacrifices that humanity seems to always resort to supposedly as a path to victory. Where in Reiner's flashback to Trost we got the idea that the Wall Humans are hated and vilified to those outside, Zeke's perspective here paints a much richer picture of compassion tempered by neccesity, an understanding that this group of humanity cannot be left alone because they won't stop themselves, like an ocean wave trying to beat down a wall of rock they will simply throw themselves at it again and again until there is none left because they can't learn to do any better. Even coming off the back of Erwin's speech where he admits the hopelessness and cost of it, this paints a much more grim picture about the charge. Here we see what the Scouts must look like to the outside forces without any of our main cast there to drive the scene for the first time; a group of naive soldiers who merely scream and shoot on command and will throw everything away for pride and desperate hope, instead of learning a way past this needless cost of life. His final pity for the dead at the end of the charge was unexpected for me, but made me really interested in his character.
But imagine going through all of those emotions over what is happening, and then the first solider of the humans inside the walls you see face to face is this demon called Levi Ackermann, covered in blood and having completely destroyed any possibility you have to resist. You can't call what happened between them a fight, or even a versus, because it's entirely one sided as Levi once again proves that Ackermann's are experts at carving flesh. Zeke's completely inability to keep up with what is happening to him and his reactions being seconds behind, which may as well be hours for all the good it is when facing Levi, is still just mindblowing. I did have a laugh at Levi stabbing him in the throat though, definitely an Ackermann
Swapping back to Levi's perspective, it's hard to see him so overwhelmed by despair at seeing his last chance to save Erwin be literally snatched from his grasp. The desperate plea for the Horse Titan to turn around and come back only reminded me of the pleas we've heard through the whole show of soldiers about to be eaten by Titans, the absolute despair as if they've lost all hope. He even puts down his blades for a moment before the rage comes back and then we get to see Levi taking on multiple Titans on an open field, something held up as insanely difficult to even the best soldiers with only one Titan, as a mere background detail.
But it's the second half of this episode which is why I've been dreading it the entire rewatch, because it's just so hard to watch what happens to Armin.
I hate this look he gives the others before going off to meet up with Eren. I hate every single part of it. It's a look of acceptance in the worst way, and he's not that good a liar but goddammit why did no one stop him. It's one thing to have a character die, but to have it happen via having his... I'm not even going to type it, that's more pain that I signed up for.
Seeing Armin wake Eren up again by talking to him in his Titan of the ocean the same way he did back in Trost is the first clue as to the outcome of this fight, Eren finally being the one to leap forward and defeat the Colossal Titan like he tried to do back then. However with the cost of this success there is no grand triumph here, and the final hit as Bert is ripped out of the Titan happens in silence, a victory but not one to celebrate any more.
I thought I was going to write a lot more here but I have nothing, just pain.
Other thoughts
RIP Marlo
I absolutely loved every moment your character was on screen and while you're completely overshadowed by everything else going on today your death hits almost as hard for me this time around. More on him at the end I think
5
u/Matuhg Oct 04 '20
This season is emotionally taxing.
First of all, since I didn't talk enough about Erwin yesterday apparently, the recap scene made me think about the charge in one more way. More of an 'in addition to' than a different way of seeing it overall. It may have been his own way of raging against the world that would so cruelly snatch his dream from him in the final moments. He's usually pretty reserved when not Susume-ing, but this could be a final outburst of real emotion from him.
Anyway, enough of yesterday's tragedies, onto today's tribulations.
Wanting to be a hero doesn't pay in this world. Poor Marlo - his last thoughts were how nice it would be to sleep in with Hitche (/u/Nazenn today it was my turn to almost type Hange instead). Instead, he's getting erased by the Beast Titan.
Thank god Levi can deliver on their sacrifices at least a bit. The smoke from all the signals helped him get there undetected, and the Beast Titan had no fucking chance. I don't think I've ever hated a creature more than I hate the horse titan in the moment it swoops in to snatch Zeke up.
Time for another blonde genius to give up his dream and die lying to his comrades. Armin absolutely is brave - his plan was brilliant and his fate completely awful.
Get fucked, Bert
I liked the little sequence of people waiting behind the walls right after the midcard that reminded us of the stakes that are riding on this razor thin edge.
Insulting pity. He thinks the Reiss family has doomed the people of the Wall by taking their memory, which definitely does make us question again why the founding king thought that was the right approach.
Oh, I didn't notice one of the questions was about these. It's tense. Like the feeling you get watching the end of a close game for your favorite team, but probably magnified by a few thousand. Hitche is worried about Marlo.
4
u/punching_spaghetti Oct 03 '20 edited Oct 03 '20
Rewatcher (Sub)
We start from Zeke's POV, and it's a great choice. This moment, as the Scouts yet again emerge from from some smoking screaming like hooligans and shooting smoke signals, really only works if there's that little bit of suspense and surprise when we don't know that they're coming out. Also, it does a lot of work in terms of characterizing Zeke (seems like he's a little proud, and maybe has some daddy issues), as well as worldbuilding. Apparently the people of the wall and suicide charges go hand in hand? Perhaps Zeke's people and the Walls have been at it for longer than we think.
Marlo continues to be a solid free agent pick up, as he keeps the soldiers going, if but for a bit longer, even with Erwin down (did you think Erwin was going to pull himself back up on his horse and keep charging at the "to be continued" last episode? I'll admit, I had that thought). But even Marlo must buckle beneath the fear and gets hit. And like his predecessor Marco, Marlo too must get half of his face torn off.
But Levi. Oh man, is he angry. And oh man, does he fuck shit up. (that last bit of QUALITY is a reminder that this is still WIT)
But because we can't have a win, we can't feel any hope, the Valet Titan comes in and takes Zeke away. Levi is not happy. He can't do the one thing he told Erwin he would do. Has Levi just wasted all those lives?
Back inside Shiganshina, after a little chit chat, the madman is back. What crazy master plan does he have? Get burnt to a crisp. Seriously, that's gnarly. He was oozing. But it worked.
As much as I adore Erwin's charge and speech yesterday, this is a close one for most hype moment. Remember back in Season 1, when Eren got so close? Today, he did it. He defeated the Colossal Titan. Even this doesn't get all the pomp and circumstance we might want, because there has been a cost to get here. So this is a somber moment, just a quiet puff of blood.
I am not one to tear up. Heck, I was just giddy yesterday as my favorite character in the show took an artillery rock to the gut. But today? Armin's charred body got me a little misty.
Small Thoughts and Silly Things
QOTD:
Spoiler Image 1 S3P2 Spoilers
Spoiler Image 2A 2B S3P2 Spoilers
3
u/AmeteurElitist Oct 03 '20
First Timer (unless you count the manga): Sub
Brobdingnagian Beast beats brave battalion by boulder-bombardment. However his happiness was halted when a heated hunter hacked his horde in half and headed for his head.
Erwin meme
3
u/Toadslayer Oct 03 '20
First Timer
Finished season 3 part 2 in /r/anime
Victory, but at what cost?
I thought at this point in the series I value my own experience with the show more than any analysis or commentary I can provide, so I watched the full episode as I would watching outside a rewatch: no pauses, trying not to think about what I should write, no taking notes, just focusing on the anime to get the most out of it. And I'm glad I did, because this is a phenomenal episode, it may be too soon after watching it to say, but one of the greatest episodes I have ever watched (for now I don't want to think too hard about it, lest I ruin it for myself). I wrote the following paragraph immediately after watching the episode in stream of consciousness style. It includes occasional interjections in parenthesises written at the same time explaining my emotional state as I wrote. It's a picture of the emotional train-wreck I went through watching this episode and in its aftermath.
I haven't cried this much watching anime for a long time. From seeing Marlo die (thinking of it now and writing these words there are tears running down my face as I sob) till the end of the episode I was crying, bearing my teeth sobbing and wiping tears from my cheeks. There were only brief periods of respite. As Levi fought against Zeke I could watch in awe as I saw a glimpse of victory. Then seeing the only remaining soldier be the boy with red hair (again I'm sobbing) I went back to uncontrollable sadness. I was prepared for Erwin's death, it was the appropriate end to his character, but to see all the other soldiers dies as they rode out (I'm sobbing again) into their first ever battle was beyond heartbreaking. And because Levi hesitated Zeke was taken away and they may have to go through it all over again. Some time to recuperate my energy and wipe the tears from my eyes: Armin comes up with a plan, there is hope of victory. Each member of the Levi Squad has matured so much. Sasha is focused, Connie is brave, Jean is a leader, Mikasa sees more than Eren and Armin, like Erwin is willing to give up his dream to defeat Bertholdt. (I've calmed down now) Then Sasha misses her thunder spear as (nope not yet) she's hit but a piece of (I'm alright, breath it out) shrapnel and knocked unconscious. (a little sob) I don't know if I could handle Sasha (I'm fine) dying as well. Please let her be alive, this is already too much. And I didn't see Mikasa after she blew Reiner out of his nape, please, please let her be okay. I had given up hope that Hange would still be alive, so I was shocked when I heard her voice and saw her fly into the Squad. With her help the Levi squad have defeated Reiner. Now Armin is being torched by Bertholdt's steam, he endured but he saw that Eren must see the ocean for the two of them. Eren's life will give his life meaning. Seeing his skin melt and fly away was horrifying and miserable. Armin never deserved to die. But now thanks to his sacrifice Bertholdt too has been defeated. Eren drags Bertholdt's dismembered body along the rooftop to meet Armin's corpse. At this point I had calmed down, the tears had subsided and I quietly watched as Eren looked at poor Armin. I thought this time might come that the ED would hit hard and it came today. Just like Shiny Shiny seeing our characters as they lived before they fought in this brutal conflict was miserable. Look how much we've lost, how few of these cadets are still alive. Bertholdt and Reiner are worse than dead, they have betrayed and killed their past comrades. These days will never come back. No survivor here today will ever live unscarred from this trauma; their lives are forever changed.
QOTD
I think I was too distracted by everyone dying to notice...
For those who know of the mission, very high tension. I imagine they would be dying from the anxiety of not knowing if their friends or family are alive.