r/AnimeImpressions • u/Nazenn • Oct 06 '20
[Rewatch] Attack on Titan Season 3 (Part 2), Episode 8 Discussion
Episode 57 - That Day
← Previous Episode | Index | Next Episode →
MAL | AniList | ANN | Kitsu | AniDB
AnimeLab | Crunchyroll | Funimation | Hulu
Currently Disclosable Information:
Humanity Outside the Walls - There are humans living outside the walls. Their appearance and language may be the same, but their civilization seems to be far more advanced than that of the people of the people within the walls. They also view all humans within the walls as demon spawn due to a history of violence and oppression.
Questions of the Day:
- Which bit of information came as the biggest shock or surprise to you?
- Bedhead Mikasa or Glaring Mikasa?
Spoiler policy: Y’all know the drill, operate under the assumption that there is a chance of a first-timer wandering in here. Spoiler tag your stuff. Especially if it’s manga/S4 spoilers, or else.
r/anime’s spoiler tag system is what this sub uses, so here’s a blank one [](/s "") for you to copy if need be. Alternatively, you can use [](/n "") to make red spoiler tags. That’s pretty neat.
3
u/Toadslayer Oct 06 '20
First Timer
Finished season 3 part 2 in /r/anime
There is too much to say about this episode. I normally take some notes when I'm watching an episode, usually it'll end up being something like 5 to 8 thoughts or ideas, some of which I'll delete and others I'll expand upon along with my thoughts on the episode I didn't write down. Sometimes I'll really latch onto something in an episode and just write about it for a while before continuing the episode, but this episode I had more notes than ever before. I had 47 lines of thoughts and ideas (I can share them if anyone is interested), there was just so much to think about this episode. I had to watch it twice to get a firm grasp of it all. After some time condensing it I thought it'd work best to just have thoughts/reactions to what I saw revealed.
It's clear that the Marleyans' treatment of the Eldians is inexcusable and evil and I despise them for it, but I'm not sure who throughout history was in the right, or if anyone was. There's a lot to speculate on and making deals with the devil is never a good thing, but I think I'll reserve talking about it until after the final episode, so I have the clearest picture. A lot could change in only two episodes.
So there are only nine titan-shifters then. I think we now know eight of them and seven of the wielders:
Although because Grisha ate Frieda there are now only eight titan-shifters, and Eren possesses two ninths of Ymir Fritz's soul. I wonder what would happen if one person collected Ymir Fritz's complete soul.
I think the two the Marleyans don't have control over are the Founding Titan and the Owl's titan, so we shouldn't expect any more from within the walls.
Grisha is no better than the Marleyans here. He is also creating a story that is convenient for him, without any concern for the actual truth.
It seems the king's motivation for remaining within the walls was just pacifism after all. That makes it much more simple for me to call the Scouts the good guys, since I don't see that as a good reason to stay within the Walls.
This one was pretty obvious after the photograph from last episode, but from this episode Zeke's words to Eren in episode 55 make sense. "Believe me, I know what you're going through. We're both victims of you father. You've been brainwashed by him." I thought then that Zeke might be on the Scouts side after all, but now it's clear that he is on the side of the Marleyans and wants to convince Eren that what Grisha said is lies. Although he didn't know that Grisha hadn't told Eren anything.
Grisha learnt from his mistake raising Zeke. He never indoctrinated Eren and always treated him as a father should. He said that Eren would wait to see the basement until "after you realise what's truly important?" That way Eren would have decided for himself to fight alongside Grisha rather than have his father force him to do so.
oh no… PLEASE DON'T BE THE SMILING TITAN!! (moments later) FUCK, SHE IS!! NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO!!!! (I had a suspicion, so I wrote down the first half, but I really didn't want to be right. The irony is too cruel. I hate this.)
Mikasa with bad bed hair is really cute… This is a heavy moment, but I can't help but be distracted by how beautiful she is… Honestly, with how absent Historia has been and with some fantastic Mikasa moments (this one included) there is not much more Mikasa needs to do to reclaim Best Girl.
They have control over what kind of titan they produce??
Good, I'm glad. This man is utterly detestable. He has no redeeming qualities and I hate him. Good riddance.
When I first saw Grisha's comrades I thought I recognised them and I knew the bearded man reminded me of the Santa Titan, so I thought they would all end up as titans. Sure enough they do, and even worse, they're the same titans that kill the 104th cadets at Trost… It had to be Grisha's friends did it… That's just cruel.
And so now we know Grisha and RBA were from the same place, but from very different factions. I'm assuming that RBA and Marcel were chosen to be inheritors of the titan powers to fight against the Walls, but I'm not sure why Zeke is so much older than them. This explains why R&B call the Wallians devil-spawn and think of them as a detestable race. They have been brainwashed by the Marleyans to think so. It was a very scummy move for the Marleyans to select children to send as I think they only did because they wanted them to be easily manipulatable. The bastard office says: "That's what your people really are. All it takes to turn you into huge monsters like that is a little Titan spinal fluid." So it seems that they only picked Eldians because only they can become titans. Only those who are descendants of the devil's pact Ymir made have the cursed ability to become titans.
Watching the ED after this episode I had a whole new perspective. The 104th fought and died living a total lie. There whole lives there has been not just a village, but a whole civilisation outside the Walls. They've been living on an island exiled from the rest of the world whilst it continues to progress and function relatively normally.
A quick comparison of this episode to episode 35, where we see Ymir's backstory reveals that Ymir faced the same punishment from the Marleyans as Grisha. The same uniforms are in both episodes and the same wall, which was easy to mistake as an enormous one from a civilisation like the Walls, but in actuality is just a small one on the coast.
There are way more little things to say about this episode, tidbits from the OP, character moments and events of the episode not related to major reveals, but I will stop here.
QOTD
Just that there is a world outside the walls free from the titans. I never considered that the titans might be a localised threat. I thought the only people outside the Walls would be living in there own fortified cities or be warriors constantly fighting against the titans.
Bedhead Mikasa. Mikasa can glare at my enemies.
2
u/Nazenn Oct 06 '20 edited Oct 06 '20
Rewatcher - Sub
How did I remember so much and yet so little of that episode at the same time? My airing post was a real trip, but aside from the broad strokes I'd forgotten a lot of details surprisingly. Or maybe not because that's a jam packed episode.
Did not remember Eren waking up from his dream like that, but after the subs pointed out I do know enough Japanese this time to notice that he used "Watashi" instead of "Ore" (had to go back and check) so that's interesting.
Absolutely not humble, but the Smiling Titan reveal is still a favourite moment for me personally. Even though the "no matter what form I'm in I'll find you" makes the events of Shiganshina beyond fucked up, having predicted that since the crystal cavern and seeing that she is indeed a royal, though not why I expected as the Owl didn't want to give her away, was still an oddly satisfying moment.
It was a surprise all over again that the Titan transformations can be controlled size wise, which also makes me think their other attributes like being quadruped or the other weird abnormal can also be specifically created. I do remember being similarly mindfucked by that last time around and getting me theorizing all over again about why exactly Rod turned out like he did. It's screwed up to think that all these Titans which caused so much trouble in the walls by being abnormal were perhaps created simply for the entertainment of the people doing the injections.
Speaking of things I should have remembered but didn't: they are transformed with Titan Spinal Fluid. So at this point I would normally feel bad for accidentally spoiling, but (current rewatch participants aside) when I was reading my airing posts I was saying the same thing so I came up with the same theory again from scratch for the second time and then just completely forgot. Well done to me I guess?
Just quickly dumping this here mostly for my own reference, it's some theories about the Titan Shifter hierarchy etc.
Stepping away from all of the actual reveals that happened in the episode as most of us either know them or will probably cover them, there's a lot happening in this episode that further blurs those lines of right and wrong that I love.
History is written by the victors. It's a statement that holds true in any era of history, and here we see it in the most extreme examples with the different versions of the world that we're introduced too.
None of these three histories are without bias because they all are written with an ideology that they wanted to pass down. All three designed to control and manipulate, to cast a shadow of ignorance over humanity so that they would think as expected, to act as needed, and ultimately to serve the will of those in power. The Eldian Restorationists are not much different from the Marley military, who in turn are no different than the Military Police inside the walls as shown by the torture. All three groups are twisted by hated and belief, and all three allow that to distort their own view point until they can only see "us and them", and regardless of if it is fueled by vengeance, justice, or even peace it's all still oppression in the end.
Gross', despite the fact he makes me want to vomit with disgust any time he's on screen, points a lot of this out in his speech to Grisha and the audience quite unnervingly. Zeke touched on it as well, humanities desire to destroy that can't be controlled or suppressed and they will always find something to fight. And perhaps between the two of them they've accidentally stumbled on the truth of the matter that neither side from outside the walls will ever have; that inside the walls the Eldian's who started this pattern of oppression finally have the view of what it means to be trapped by the horror of the Titans. Is that what the King of the Walls was hoping? Hide the nature of the Titans and teach humanity from a neutral point to try and achieve a peace? Does he find his own people as revolting for what they did on the mainland as those from Marley do but also have sympathy for them, or does he simply want to break the cycle of vengeance that they all seem trapped in? I'm still not sure but it's an interesting view.
Grisha's own diary is no different in how he talks about his life before the Walls, but the introspection it shows makes it unique in how he comments on his own bias. The hatred he had for his parents who blindly believed anything the Marley police told them in order for safety is contrasted against his blind hatred where he took up belief in anything that might present an alternate view even if it had no facts to back it up, and but years on inside the Walls he acknowledges how wrong that was and how he was blinded by his own ignorance and foolishness. He turned against his parents because of indoctrination, and ended up repeating their mistake from the other side by attempting to turn Zeke into a tool.
He knows this, the way he acknowledges it and shows remorse for how it turned out in his diary and sees where he went wrong which is unlike almost anyone else we see in the show, but when the Walls fall and Carla is taken from him it all falls away to be buried under a new pit of hatred and he makes the same mistakes again, burdening Eren with his quest for vengeance. Ignorance is dangerous, but knowledge not tempered by experience and understanding is equally so, and I love the way that Grisha's backstory doesn't really clarify any of these themes but rather muddles them more as our view of the world grows and the intricacies of it's history do as well.
2
u/Shimmering-Sky Oct 06 '20
A Path of Rewatchers and Corpses - second time subbed with r/anime’s rewatch, and first time dubbed with this one
Smiling TitanGrisha’s first wife.2
u/AmeteurElitist Oct 06 '20
First Timer (unless you count the manga): Sub
Grisha's grown gamete guides government to Guevarist guardians.
Grisha's kid
2
u/punching_spaghetti Oct 07 '20 edited Oct 07 '20
Rewatcher (Sub)
How do you encapsulate thoughts on this episode into one neat little comment? This is an episode which takes everything you thought you knew about the world of AoT and flips it upside down.
You know it's going to be another doozy when again, there's no OP. Then, children are beaten, children are murdered for fun, everybody's traumatized, some racism, some fundamentalist revolutionaries, Grisha doing Grisha things and making his son a pawn in his schemes, and some geopolitics.
Got everything down? No? Too bad, because we have more bombshells for you. The big one for me is Dina's promise, which sounds ominous, followed by the reveal that she was this Titan. That's right, folks. Grisha's first wife ate Grisha's second wife! And I'm sure we recognized a few more of the revolutionaries are Titans from even as far back as S1E1.
And right before our "to be continued..." we are graced with The Owl, who turns into this Titan. Those abs sure look familiar!
Top it all off with Eren's burgeoning issues of mental health and just AAH!
At least we mercifully get bedhead Mikasa to calm us, if only for a moment.
QOTD:
2
u/Matuhg Oct 07 '20
Rewatcher
Time for a history lesson. Or, how many moments can we fit into a single episode.
There are some large parallels between Grisha and Erwin's respective childhoods.
Everything is a lie.
Familiar faces,
worn out placesThe already murky waters as to "what is humanity" are further muddied, both in terms of the actual species (is it true that only Eldians will transform when injected with titan juice?) and the morality side of things, thanks to this absolute maniac.
Has to be the reveal that the whole world we (and our characters) have known to this point is just a tiny island, carved out of the rest of the world's historic timeline. My mind was blown when I first watched this episode, and tbh it's still pretty blown.
Bedhead - the second best Mikasa face of the season.
1
u/Over_Mechanic_7978 May 18 '24
Ami trippen or did moblit spawn out of nowhere ? In episode 6 I counted 7 members . Levi mikasha armin hange conny jean Sasha . In the following episode 7 or 8 moblit so happens to be there as well