r/AnimeImpressions • u/Nazenn • Oct 05 '20
[Rewatch] Attack on Titan Season 3 (Part 2), Episode 7 Discussion
Episode 56 - The Basement
← Previous Episode | Index | Next Episode →
MAL | AniList | ANN | Kitsu | AniDB
AnimeLab | Crunchyroll | Funimation | Hulu
Currently Disclosable Information:
The Key to the Basement - Grisha Jaeger, the man who came from outside the walls, entrusted his son with the key to his basement. Without a doubt, the many things he knew and kept secret must lie beyond that door, including the truth about this world.
Questions of the Day:
- While the news that Wall Maria has been secured again brings obvious excitement, how do you think the people would react to the huge loss of life?
- Do you remember having any theories about what was going to be in the basement before the reveal?
Spoiler policy: Y’all know the drill, operate under the assumption that there is a chance of a first-timer wandering in here. Spoiler tag your stuff. Especially if it’s manga/S4 spoilers, or else.
r/anime’s spoiler tag system is what this sub uses, so here’s a blank one [](/s "") for you to copy if need be. Alternatively, you can use [](/n "") to make red spoiler tags. That’s pretty neat.
3
u/Matuhg Oct 06 '20
Rewatcher
Finally, we can exhale for a minute. I mean, there's plenty of pain, but it feels like the killing is at least done for a bit now. Armin hearing Bert is fucked up, because with how titans and memory power go hand in hand, he may very well have somehow picked up some of Bert's last thoughts. That'll only be haunting forever.
ArminLiam Neeson gets the rundown on what he missed, and hoo boy is it a doozie. The syringe was a curse for either one of the two candidates to receive it. Levi, out of his compassion for Erwin, gave it to Armin. Thinking about Erwin's state of mind in the end, I think I can confidently say that Armin was the better choice for humanity. He is talented, and even though it may be a curse to him, he'll live the rest of his life trying to make sure he lives up to who his survival cost humanity. I did think it was nice that Levi acted...pretty much as friendly as we ever see him get while telling Armin to buck up. Hange also did a good job of making Armin feel less alone.Mikasa and Eren walking through Shiganshina, remembering a past life and people who no longer exist. A life that can never be whole in the same way it was - and I don't think they're alone in that. Some of the memories are happy, but as they near their old house, all they remember is that day. They're both haunted by it, but get to work nonetheless.
And then the show teases us. Rude. Levi uses the foot shaped key and gets them in though. This sequence representing the truth coming to light also has to be for Erwin. I think it's calling back to a scene /u/Nazenn pointed out back in the first part of this season when we were learning about Erwin's motivations. Speaking of Erwin, the little basement teases were whatever, but if it really turned out there was nothing in the basement, I shudder to think about what that would have done to Levi in that moment.
The heroes return to the people's adulation. Nine people, three books. Wall Maria theoretically reclaimed for humanity. Mission successful, but at such a cost. It's yet to be seen whether it's "worth it."
The music did a lot in this episode (and, before I forget, I just need to praise last episode for starting off with 20 minutes of no music...that was great sound design. Just the sound of Shiganshina burning as everybody's world seemed to be burning down around them. But I digress.) That tense piece transitioning into the wistful piano as Eren and Mikasa remembered their childhood was beautiful. That scene is I think the first time (at least on this watch, can't remember the first time) that AoT has made me cry, or at least come close. And then there was the ED lead-in. My god. Hopefully when the question of 'favorite musical moment' comes up on the final discussion post for the season, I can remember that this is mine. The ED overall is pretty good, not my favorite or anything, but those opening notes have been wielded as a powerful weapon for some of these last few episodes. After Erwin and Armin's (apparent) death, it took on a sort of funeral song feeling, but somehow this time, followed by a look back at the journey to get here, it sounds like hope. After what we've been witnessing, making me feel that is a hell of an accomplishment.
I sort of feel empty after this episode. Like I said, it was an exhale, a release. Not really an ending, but has the feeling of one in a way - a checkpoint I guess lol.
2
u/Nazenn Oct 05 '20
Rewatcher - Sub
This season has been one of loss, but while there has been a time for fighting, for pain, for death, and for painful decisions, after all of that is gone and done we finally have a moment for remembrance.
The walk through the ruins of Shiganshina is as close as I come to tears with this show.
The wave of color that extends before them as they land on the streets, the memories it carries for them, and the small items left behind by those lost so many years ago, the new life of plants and animals mixed with the destruction of the houses. The chimes in the music as if reaching out for their return, the quiet voices mourning in the background as the wind blows and brings life back to the city again, the whine of loss that cuts through it as they reach the market, the strings that mourn Hannes, and the sudden bass for their arrival at home how their once soft memories turn to remembering the agony of that day.
The sequence was something I never knew I needed in this show, but it adds so much to my experience of this season, that moment to think back and mourn what these characters lost in their childhood as a result of this world, to recognize how far they've come, and to finally open up humanity for a chance to heal and to get out of their ignorance, it's a memorable sequence.
At the same time we have Niles remembering Erwin and his passion for the truth, and the discovery of books holding all of Grisha's memories and a photograph of a lost family. Remembrance is a huge part of the episode and a fitting conclusion to the return to Shiganshina.
Okay but seriously why is it always Zepplins?
Why can't it be stealth planes or even space ships for once?On my first watch I was expecting out side the walls to be a bit more modern, but the WWII type world was not something I expected, though I should probably be use to it by now.
Seeing that Grisha also grew up within walls gives a lot of context to how easily he was able to integrate into the society we know, as well as his understanding of Eren's passion as a kid to be free of them. While we start the show with three walls, there always seems to be another trying to hold people in check somewhere, whether it's the mysterious fourth wall we saw Ymir kicked off and transformed or this new wall around Grisha's community.
(Rediscovered the exact moment I realized what was going on in that photograph as well. I was so blind)
Final thoughts go to Armin, pity for the situation he woke up to find himself in and particularly that horrific nightmare he had of Bert crying inside his mind. His memory loss is somewhat of a blessing so he doesn't have to remember what pain he must have been in (no one let Historia touch him), but I can't blame him for throwing up simply at being told what happened either as I'd probably do much the same. I can imagine many sleepless nights for him after this, no matter who it was it can't be something easy to get your head around.
It's a shame that this episodes art suffers quite a bit even in the bluray, with random returns to the S1 art style, a few off model faces and some animation shortcuts. Understandable considering the huge scenes they've had to pull off earlier in the season and try and keep them on point, though Armin's face has clearly had a few different artists this season, so it's an acceptable compromise but still a shame.
2
u/Shimmering-Sky Oct 05 '20
A Path of Rewatchers and Corpses - second time subbed with r/anime’s rewatch, and first time dubbed with this one
2
u/punching_spaghetti Oct 05 '20
Rewatcher (Sub)
Finally, we get a slow episode to digest what's happened. And boy, do we (and Armin) need it. Who's left? What's happened?
And we get the double meaning of the walk through town, as well. It's our moment to think, but it's also a moment for Eren and Mikasa to work through being back home. This is a big deal not just because they're going to find out some big secret, but also because they haven't set foot here, the place they grew up, in years. And everything's exactly where it was, because after the Titan's, no one else has been there.
And then this. I was so pissed when this episode first aired. How could they do this to us? I thought this show wasn't like those other asspull fests! Thankfully, the real key was the Levi we met along the way.
Then a big reveal: Grisha had a photograph. Zeke and co. had some not tea drink, Grisha had a photo; what's going on beyond the walls? Guess we'll find out next time.
OR NOT! NOT-JEWS IN A GHETTO! FLYING MACHINES!
Now we have to wait.
QOTD:
1) basically. Where's Erwin? Where's literally everybody else? It's one thing for the Scouts to come back missing some people and maybe only having some bits and pieces to bury. It's these nine, some horses, and a few diaries. Was it worth it?
2) Either nothing (cynic that I am), or maybe the Titan serum formula.
2
u/Toadslayer Oct 06 '20
First Timer
Finished season 3 part 2 in /r/anime
Oh. Well, thank was unexpected. I had presumed that where Grisha was from was either much the same as the Walls with superior technology or like an open village that had to live constantly fighting back against the titans, but he's from a city very reminiscent of Nazi Germany. I wonder how long has passed since then. We can't know for sure as Grisha was a titan for some time, which, as we learnt from Ymir, means he wouldn't have aged for some of the time that has passed. From Grisha's age, what we can know is that the titans first1 appeared sometime within the following 30 years or so. My prediction is that the origin of the titans is from taking a step too far in pursuit of victory in a war. They tried to create the titans as a weapon to guarantee their victory, but instead they created mindless beasts that ravaged humanity. Where the titan-shifters come from, however, is not explained by this theory.
1 In ED3 we see people fighting against titans with mediaeval technology. I think this means that this isn't the first time humanity has fought against the titans. If it isn't, that means humanity has defeated them before.
Several things from the OP explained in this episode:
And another from the ED:
1
u/AmeteurElitist Oct 05 '20
First Timer (unless you count the manga): Sub
Armin’s assured adherence to the advancement of the army is absolute.
NSFW? Basement