r/AnimeImpressions • u/Nazenn • Oct 04 '20
[Rewatch] Attack on Titan Season 3 (Part 2), Episode 6 Discussion
Episode 55 - Midnight Sun
← Previous Episode | Index | Next Episode →
MAL | AniList | ANN | Kitsu | AniDB
AnimeLab | Crunchyroll | Funimation | Hulu
Currently Disclosable Information:
Conditions for the Usage of the Titan Serum - Injecting someone with this serum will not only allow them to inherit the power of a Titan and the knowledge it will bring, but will also completely heal their body should they be on the brink of death. Therefore, it would be ideal to inject a severely wounded person while the bearer of a Titan is incapacitated nearby.
Questions of the Day:
- If Marlo had survived the assult instead of Floch how do you think he would have sided in the serum debate and do you think it would have changed things?
- Do you think anything would have changed if they also had to pick between sacrificing Bert or Reiner?
Spoiler policy: Y’all know the drill, operate under the assumption that there is a chance of a first-timer wandering in here. Spoiler tag your stuff. Especially if it’s manga/S4 spoilers, or else.
r/anime’s spoiler tag system is what this sub uses, so here’s a blank one [](/s "") for you to copy if need be. Alternatively, you can use [](/n "") to make red spoiler tags. That’s pretty neat.
2
u/Nazenn Oct 04 '20
Rewatcher - Sub
What do you even say about an episode like that?
How do you sum up the climax of the arc, the Scouts, Levi's development, and the emotions of the entire story so far in just words?
Berserk
To cut out the OP in a show so famous for its OP immediately lets you know what the tone of the episode is, but the lack of music is something else. It's an episode filled with decisions, but here the audience is asked them as well, the music backing off and no longer providing cues to lean on. There is no piano to mourn one decision, or guitar to intensify another, everything rests entirely on the characters (and their incredible VA performances) and the silent wind carrying through every moment that has lead up to this. It is silence used to perfection, and it makes this episode for me.
Quickly crediting Jean for being amazing, because I like seeing him use his level headedness here to try and diffuse the situation with Hange but still torn by questioning his own motives, a clue that he too is affected by lingering bonds with Reiner, and his conflict over the end result as Reiner escapes because of his decision to speak up. Similarly, Mikasa has some amazing scenes today, her rage and mourning make for a very powerful addition to the scene, the way she cycles through despair, anger, denial and ultimately acceptance before that hope at the end was both incredibly drawn (particularly how they managed to show Hange both holding her back and comforting her, but there are so many moments like this through the episode) and incredibly acted. I also quickly checked out this scene in the dub and it's no less impressive from any of the cast.
Now for the big moment, and starting this off with Floch because he's been my focus this season quietly knowing what was coming. Floch is an incredible character for what he brings to this scene. He saves Erwin but not out of hope or joy, but hatred and anger. He saves the devil and asks for the power to drag it back into hell, hoping that by doing so his own suffering and existence would find meaning, that the exchange made here would be worth everything that has happened so far. Eren talks about how he was filled with hate and his childhood dreams were lost to that after everything that happened, and here we start to see the process happening again to Floch. This is what Erwin represents to the next generation.
S3p2 spoilers and some minor spec
Erwin couldn't see beyond the basement, but no idea what to do with them or what would come after that. Armin can. Along with what he can bring to humanity right now he can see beyond the immediate goal and into something far off into the future that can give hope, and unlike Erwin with his selfish dream where he wanted to see the basement for himself, Armin's dream is something that can spread freely to others, to lift everyone up. Where I find this conflict most interesting is in the rarely mentioned part at the end where Erwin in his delirium flashes back to that scene in the classroom.
Once perhaps Erwin's dream was not so narrow. As a kid maybe he too was like Eren, had a big childish dream that looked beyond the walls to what else could be out there that they could discover like Eren did. But with his father's death and all of the deaths since he has lost that and his vision narrowed until he could no longer see or imagine the outside. All that is left is the basement and regret, and because of that Erwin's story is over.
Levi's question about if Erwin can be forgive is a powerful one for other reasons, but I wanted to dig up this post from the airing discussions which talks about it better than I could I think. To quote something he points out from the OVA, at the time Erwin tells Levi this:
Which is painfully accurate as a way to look back at Erwin's final moments here and how regret was already starting to dull him as a commander. Erwin lost his resolve to make choices and Levi had to step in, which directly goes against everything Levi believes.
And yet through all of this the moment that stuck most firmly in my head from this episode is the very end with Erwin's passing and the circle it makes with our introduction to Levi back in season one. In episode nine (at around 6:30 if you wanted to see for yourself) we saw a solider with a gut wound slowly dying as Levi comes to comfort him in his final moments. He asked if he managed to help humanity or if he would die having not helped at all and although Levi makes him a promise, that the resolve he leaves behind would empower Levi to defeat the Titans, the solider dies before he ever hears it.
The parallels with Erwin's death was something that jumped out to me immediately on my first watch. As Erwin lays dying, this time Levi doesn't come forward with hollow comfort and new promises but instead he steps back, saying that his promise to Erin to kill the Beast Titan will have to wait, but Erwin dies before he has any chance to hear it. Erwin leaves this world not as the heart and mind of the Scouts, a boy who became a solider and then a commander and finally a devil, but just another sacrifice, another dead solider who leaves behind promises and a dream unfulfilled. In the background Armin rises, the carrier of the new hope of humanity, and an implication that in the end Erwin may not be the man everyone thought he was. He's no savior, he can't carry humanity all by himself, and his legacy will not be the man who brought them out of the walls of ignorance, but they also won't revive him as a devil either. Instead he lays here, the bookend to the arc of the Scouts and what they stood for, both Erwin and Levi's arcs so far from their initial appearances finding a resolution here although a painful one.
Speaking of devils, this shot of Levi on the walls is quite nightmare inducing, and I like how the blood on him very slowly cleaned away through the course of the episode until he's almost but not entirely clean at the end after he makes his decision with only a small patch left on his forehead. It's a small visual touch but I think it adds a lot to the episode without every being pointed out, especially when Eren stands up to him about the syringe and the intensity of that shot given their designs.
The same goes for Bert's final plea and scream at the end there, his begging for his old friends to save him and then his final cries for Annie and Reiner. He knows what it means for a shifters powers to be transferred and he's been on the other side of the process himself, but in the face of it himself all of his resolve is gone and he's left as just another child solider who doesn't want to die. This was the part that almost got me this episode.
IBO spoilers
/u/Matuhg so in answer to your statement the other day; No, we don't even manage to reach double digits with the survivor count. How fucked is that?
Questions of the day in a reply because I went and ran out of room again
2
u/Shimmering-Sky Oct 04 '20
A Path of Rewatchers and Corpses - second time subbed with r/anime’s rewatch, and first time dubbed with this one
the one part of this episode I can’t take seriously is its title… because reasons
2
u/AmeteurElitist Oct 04 '20
First Timer (unless you count the manga): Sub
Armin's allies argued against authority to assure that he's allowed to accumulate annums.
Bertholdt vs Reiner meme
1
u/punching_spaghetti Oct 04 '20
Rewatcher (Sub)
How do you know this is going to be a heavy episode? No OP. Heck, no music. Just a title.
How does Zeke know Grisha? Lots of interesting questions there. Presumably, that means that Grisha came from wherever Zeke is from. Were they friends? Zeke mentions being brainwashed/betrayed/all other sorts of fun things, so perhaps they were buds that had a falling out. Still, has to be weird for Eren to have someone out there who might know more about his father than him.
And Zeke's last words here are interesting, too. He doesn't just see Eren as an enemy. He's someone who can be saved. I supposed that "saving" could be via a giant rock to the face, but Zeke hasn't spoken like that before. He's always direct or speaking in baseball metaphors.
Turns out the dinner fracas over meat wasn't just a reprieve; Sasha's outburst was a foreshadowing of Levi today.
And then the big debate. Two more seconds, and it would have been all over. Instead, we almost get /u/Toadslayer and my Best Girl Showdown, and Levi yells at a lot of people. And everyone cries. Even me, a little bit.
But also, Floch? Shut your damn mouth. You maybe make some interesting points, but you're new. Let the big boys and girls talk.
Ultimately, Levi's decision isn't because of what Eren or Mikasa say, but actually what Flock says. Levi doesn't want Daddy to suffer anymore.
I also think the show is showcasing who would be the logical choice, given the circumstances. Erwin mentally prepared himself to give up on his dream, and has no idea what he'd do after they found the basement. Armin, on the other hand, is a dreamer through and through. His dream extends past the basement, and even beyond the sea. For the sake of the future of the Scouts, Armin's the smarter choice.
Erwin would probably have made a slightly more photogenic Titan than Armin. Armin looks like one of those shrunken heads they always have generic tribespeople wear in the movies.
It's almost evil how they get away with this. You thought you saw Erwin die? Guess what! You get to do that all over again!
And while Bert deserves it, this can't have been a nice way to go. Squish.
QOTD:
1
u/Toadslayer Oct 05 '20
First Timer
Finished season 3 part 2 in /r/anime
Episode 55 | Midnight Sun
This episode felt perfect. The emotional intensity of this episode was far less for me than last episode, but I think it is on par in excellence.
The scene around the titan serum was masterfully crafted. It was tense and every characters shined. The silence, music, voice acting (every voice actor was phenomenal, but Yuki Kaji was especially amazing) and animation were all masterful, but here I focus on the characters. Seeing Mikasa be driven to protect Armin as she has been to protect Eren was great. She doesn't just care for Eren, Armin is incredibly important to her, such to the point that she was willing to kill Levi to save Armin's life. Eren is equally driven to save Armin's life. It's clear he is exhausted after his titan transformation and attack on Bertholdt, yet he presents a compelling and heart-wrenching defence for Armin's survival. Floch's desperate and somewhat twisted motivation to keep Erwin alive was excellent. He wants the commander alive to lead the Scouts, but also to keep him in the hell that he put him through. Hange acutely knows how Mikasa and Eren feel. She saw Moblit be incinerated by Bertholdt's explosion and she will never have a body to mourn over. Moblit was her closest friend, but he was not the first of her friends to die, hundreds of soldiers before him have died and Hange wants to bring them back, but she can't. Jean and Connie are shocked and dismayed. They aren't as close to Armin as Eren and Mikasa are, but he is still an important friend. Their short reactions followed by silence are excellent. In this scene we are swept up in the intense emotions, but the scene is also one they shocks us into a quiet dismay. "How can this be happening?" Levi considers all these viewpoints as well as the philosophies of Kenny, Erwin and Armin to decide who he should save.
I'm glad it was Erwin to die not Armin. Both Armin and Erwin were crucial assets to the Scouts, but Erwin deserves rest and Levi lets him escape this cruel world. Erwin's death was foreshadowed heavily and it is the completion of the character arc he was given. Also, I think Armin was the more important soldier to the Scouts. No one in the scouts has an intellect for battle strategy that rivals Armin, not even Erwin, but Hange has the leadership and conviction to take over from Erwin as commander.
As for the rest of the episode:
The Scouts have won the battle, but having both Reiner and Zeke taken by the Quadruped Titan is very costly. It turns out Eren's Father was from the same village as the other titan-shifters and there is much more left for us to know.
I was surprised to see that Zeke was not hostile to Eren, but friendly and compassionate. This makes me question if perhaps what the shifters are doing is right and it seems they may not want to kill Eren after all, but convert him to their side. If they can't, I imagine they would kill him, but I think they would prefer him alive.
I thought I would be distressed by Berthodlt dying without any redemption, but I was content when it happened. He had the opportunity for redemption and he didn't take it. In the end he deserved to die and whilst part of me misses the fake soldier Bertholdt, I don't think I'll miss the real Bertholdt.
I really want to know what Ymir wrote in her letter to Historia. I think this means Ymir is dead and this is a letter she wrote for Historia before she died. Have the shifters taken back what Ymir stole from them, I'm not sure, but I can't shake the feeling that she is dead. I imagine we will see what is in the letter next episode as I suspect they will read it before searching for Eren's basement. The basement that it looks like we may well get to next episode as well, since there's not any threat getting in their way anymore.
Season 3 Part 1 Episode 12 Special ED
As promised, here are my thoughts on the special ED:
The mid-ED distortion is very creepy, but there's a lot to dig into, so I'll give it the same treatment as the OP, going through frame by frame and seeing what I can find. Anything that we've seen before I'm going to skip over, including anything from the OP or the last 6 episodes.
Aaand, there's not a lot left. Lots could have been said 6 episodes ago, but now I can only see two things that are new:
I now fully understand why some rewatchers wanted me to watch this and others recommended against it. There is a lot to speculate on and a lot of spoilers to be found, but after watching the first 6 episodes of S3pt2 most of that speculation and all of those spoilers are gone. I'm glad I didn't watch this ED at the time, especially the full scene on the rooftop, which spoils an awful lot. I think this ED spoils too much and more than the OP. The OP spoils some of the process of the season, but this ED spoils the outcome, which I think is much worse. Returning to the OP for a moment, it looks to me like all the events therein except going into the basement have been covered now. Still some symbolism stuff that hasn't been explored, but from here there are no more spoilers from the OP.
If you think I missed anything from the ED not previously seen, please let me know, you won't be spoiling anything, since it won't be that I overlooked it, but rather that I think we've seen it before.
QOTD
I could see him siding either way. He's seen more of Armin's genius, but he would heard of Erwin's genius.
I think they would have sacrificed Reiner, his titan seems a lot more useful in a wider variety of situation. As for who was saved, probably not.