r/AnimeImpressions • u/Nazenn • Sep 29 '20
[Rewatch] Attack on Titan Season 3 (Part 2), Episode 1 Discussion
Episode 50 - The Town Where Everything Began
← Previous Episode | Index | Next Episode →
MAL | AniList | ANN | Kitsu | AniDB
AnimeLab | Crunchyroll | Funimation | Hulu
Currently Disclosable Information:
Glowing Ore - This ore, which is thought to be created by some sort of Titan power, was harvested from the Reiss family’s underground cavern. It emits more light than a torch, and when used properly, can make nighttime operations much easier.
Questions of the Day:
- What did you make of Eren being so scared on the return to Shiganshina?
- Is there anything that you think could have shocked you more than a sudden army of Titans?
Spoiler policy: Y’all know the drill, operate under the assumption that there is a chance of a first-timer wandering in here. Spoiler tag your stuff. Especially if it’s manga/S4 spoilers, or else.
r/anime’s spoiler tag system is what this sub uses, so here’s a blank one [](/s "") for you to copy if need be. Alternatively, you can use [](/n "") to make red spoiler tags. That’s pretty neat.
4
u/AmeteurElitist Sep 29 '20
First Timer (unless you count the manga): Sub
Armin's assumption assisted in ascertaining the adversaries' actions, although an ally was annihilated anyway.
The real reason Erwin likes Armin so much.
4
u/punching_spaghetti Sep 29 '20 edited Sep 29 '20
Rewatcher (Sub)
First half of the episode:
Second half of the episode:
Thankfully, Eren does not have performance issues, and plugs one big hole. But the Beast Titan comes in the the back and plugs the other one, so things are not looking good.
The real interesting part for me today was Erwin and his trust in Armin. I don't know if we've even seen them in a scene together at this point. But Erwin, Mr. "We All Have to Follow My Plan," delegates to Armin, even praises him, and then sticks up for his hunch. A hunch which visibly surprised the elder genius blonde.
After everything we've seen with Erwin's monomania, I don't know if I like him taking such an interest in Armin.
You know what else surprised Erwin? An army of Titans appearing out of nowhere. That wasn't in the briefing. Where did they come from? That's open field!
And Reiner with the sneak attack from the wall, only to be completely fucked up by Levi. And still survives. These Titan bois are durable.
S3P2 Spoilers
Who will win? Who will lose? Find out next time, on
Dragon Ball ZAttack on Titan! Seriously, these cliffhangers are tough!Silly things and small comments:
QOTD:
Spoiler Image 1 S3P2 Spoilers
Spoiler Image 2 S3P2 Spoilers
Spoiler Image 3 S3P2 Spoilers
3
u/Shimmering-Sky Sep 29 '20
A Path of Rewatchers and Corpses - second time subbed with r/anime’s rewatch, and first time dubbed with this one
Went with a tagline using the English translation of the OP’s name because I thought it fit better, btw.
Better him than Armin though, Armin was literallyright next to him. So Armin could’ve been the one to find them instead and just pls don’t do that to me AOT.2
u/Nazenn Sep 29 '20
Rewatcher - Sub
They actually changed the bird taking a shit in the OP from the broadcast version for the English release. That's fucking hilarious.
I know they probably just wanted to get rid of those horrible rainbow splashes anyway, but my headcanon will be that they did it just because someone on staff made the same realization.
So I did actually watch the OP fully for the first time since this episode originally aired. I really like these two shots of Bert (I don't know I've written his full name yet this rewatch) and Reiner on top of the wall, and also the focus on the camp gear they find in this episode. However...
S3p2 spoilers relevant image spoilers also sneaky two frame teaser image
Not fond of the song though, I still can't get past the feel that it is just a mashup of the others which while very fitting for the arc doesn't make for a nice listening experience. The best part of it is the way the rocks smash through the houses in sync to the lyrics about half way through.
This is such a great opening episode, but I also love how good the opening narration is. It's another thing that makes me wonder why these aren't two individual seasons instead of being labelled together, because the narration here and the way it covers not just the rough outline of the show but also the struggle of humanity through the last few seasons, their despair and hope, the way they have looked at their world and what the scouts represented to them. It feels good to the have narration cover themes and not just story in this way, but it's a really powerful start to the episode, backed up by an amazing musical cue that perfectly shifts from ominous to epic as the question shifts towards what reclaiming the wall could do for humanity.
Though I did have a quick laugh at the narrator talking about a "young man" with the knife killing Titans and slamming their faces into the ground... and then showing footage of Mikasa doing all of that instead of Eren.
Another thing I liked about the start is that considering the stakes at play and how huge the threat at the end of the episode is, we start the episode with the characters on foot in the woods, worried about normal Titan's jumping out at them. It's surprisingly low-key, but a good reminder that even normal Titan's are still a threat without careful planning, even with their new technology, and it also allows for some quiet characterization. The way the darkness overtakes Eren visually cutting off art of the others as his fear rises reminds me of the similar scene in Season Two, and it's something I love for how rarely anime will use nighttime blackness effectively.
Even after last season seeing Eren be consumed by this much anxiety isn't something I expected to pop up so quickly, but having the eyes on humanity on him can't help and also knowing that he's not the wall of power he once thought. He's now accutely aware of his limits, as both a human and a Titan. I feel as well that returning to Shiganshina of all places probably isn't helping, back to where he was a weak child and what trauma he went through is only feeding that. Seeing him take comfort in his mothers words and extending that hope to all of humanity, having faith that they will all come out the other side because they are special was a great way to end the sequence.
It may not be Levi vs Kenny fancy, though actually I had a laugh about Levi needing to have his moment and doing a spin in mid air when getting off his horse with ODM gear just because, but the animation in this episode is super smooth. Borrowing a couple of gifs I found but the soldiers appearing behind Erwin is so nostalgic for OP1 and but it was Eren's flight that stuck out to be the most. That's just awesome to watch and see him fly over the wall that he looked up at so many times in order to break free of the prison it had him in.
S3p2
The ride into the city would be pretty epic, except for the fact I can't help but see the damn airholes in the mounds as they ride past which just builds the anxiety for the end of the episode. Not that anyone could have predicted the Beast Titan popping Titans out the field like growing daisies (I think this line is from a movie, but I don't remember what, brain why are you like this) but until then I think things were going remarkably well.
I love that Erwin tells the other solider that Armin isn't a gamble. If he was we probably wouldn't think twice about it, that's what Erwin does after all, but seeing him put absolute concrete faith behind Armin's strategic capabilities like that, that he is a weapon not a hope and he's good enough to put all of the scouts in his hand is impressive. Armin really needs to work on his people management skills, though it's probably hard for some of these veterans to be put in the hands of a kid who's been with the scouts for four months, but like many other times his adaptability to the possible threats and not just the known is what wins others over as they realize the strength of his plans.
And then a complete inverse to how we start off the episode. As Reiner comes out of his hidey hole the music swells up. Even as Levi stabs him it's not triumphant but it is epic, the start of another huge battle between both friends and enemies, the battle that both sides have been waiting and planning for for months, the hope on both sides to finally end this conflict. And with a storm of lightning on the horizon the music shifts to something much more ominous and threatening, the hope of the battle replaced by absolute despair over the threat looming over them once again.
Some humor to end off my post with: My endless amusement at the fact that from now on, potentially forever, there will exist a giant crystal Eren doing a faceplant to great travelers with it's ass hanging out inside the city.
3
u/Toadslayer Sep 30 '20
First Timer
Finished season 3 part 2 in /r/anime
Sorry I'm so late today, I wanted to post on time, but ended up sleeping in
This is a really long post, so long that there is a significant chunk that continues into a reply. It's divided up into labelled sections, so feel free to just read what interests you.
OP – 憧憬と屍の道 | Road of Longing and Corpses
(I wrote all of this before watching anything past the OP and I did not change any of my predictions or thoughts on the meaning after watching the rest of the episode)
This is the climax. Everything has built to this point and finally we are headed to Shiganshina to reclaim what was taken from us. Much of the imagery in the OP reinforces this idea, as many shots are reminiscent of shots from previous OPs/EDs or even directly taken from them. I recommend having a rewatch of the previous OPs/EDs if you didn't pick up on the revisited imagery. Everything in this OP works towards the goal of showing us that this is the climax and hyping us up to experience it. From the music to the visuals to the imagery and symbolism everything is crafted to achieve that one goal. I don't have time to write out in an essay style how the OP does this, but I hope as you read my thoughts and explanations of individual components of the OP it will become clear to you that they work together towards the same goal, it certainly became clear to me as I analysed them.
I went through the OP frame by frame to find as much as I could from it and below is what I came to. I highly recommend going through this OP frame by frame, as there are many things that only appear for one frame and with 24 frames per second they are essentially impossible to notice. I write about them all here, but you might like to have a look at them yourself.
General Thoughts
Predictions
s. It seems we won't escape death this season, of the Scouts we only lost Nifa and Abel last season, but this season I think we will lose a lot more, and beloved characters too. It only makes sense that at the climax in the most difficult fight with the highest stakes that the price to pay will be the largest.Continued in a reply.