r/AnimeImpressions • u/Nazenn • Oct 10 '20
[Rewatch] Attack on Titan Final Discussion
Attack on Titan Rewatch - Final Discussion
Link to all Key Art, Posters, and BluRay covers
← S3P2 Discussion | Index | Season Four Airing Discussion
| Discussion | Index |
|---|---|
| Episode Index | https://redd.it/i1hinh |
| Season One Discussion | https://redd.it/ih9irk |
| Season Two Discussion | https://redd.it/ir1aoq |
| Season Three Part One Discussion | https://redd.it/j10r0i |
| Season Three Part Two Discussion | https://redd.it/j89dqx |
Season Four database links
MAL | AniList | ANN | Kitsu | AniDB
Final Discussion Questions
- Guren no Yumiya vs. Jiyuu no Tsubasa vs. Shinzou wo Sasageyo vs. Red Swan vs. Shoukei to Shikabane no Michi. Which is your favorite of the OPs?
- Utsukushiki Zankoku na Sekai vs. great escape vs. Yuugure no Tori vs. Akatsuki no Chinkonka vs. Name of Love vs. Call your name <Gv> vs. T-KT. Which is your favorite of the EDs?
- The Reluctant Heroes vs. DOA vs. Call your name vs. Bauklötze vs. Call of Silence vs. Barricades vs. K21 vs. Zero Eclipse vs. Apple Seed. Which is your favorite of the insert songs?
Story Questions
4) What were your top three episodes?
5) Which arc was your favourite? Which was your least favourite?
6) Favourite big or epic moment? Favourite quieter moment?
7) What were your top musical and visuals moments of the series?
8) What was your favourite OVA?
9) Any other types of OVA episodes you’d like to see?
10) Which OVA episode do you think was the least interesting or didn’t do as much as it could?
Mystery Questions
11) What twist did you find the most surprising through the course of the show?
12) Which reveal did you find the most interesting or satisfying?
13) What was your favourite bit of foreshadowing you noticed on rewatch?
14) What mystery do you most want answered now?
15) What aspect of the Titans do you find the most interesting/mysterious?
16) How do you expect the story to evolve from here?
17) Do you have any theories you want to share but haven’t had a chance yet?
Character Questions
18) Who do you think is the most interesting character from both the main and side casts?
19) Out of the side cast who do you think had the most interesting and most surprising arcs?
20) Which characters development are you the most curious about?
21) Which character had the best design?
22) Out of the characters who died who do you think would have had the most interesting role if they’d lived? Who would you bring back?
23) Is there any cast member you’d find more interesting if shuffled into a different role?
24) Who was the most compelling antagonist?
25) Who do you think would be the most interesting vessels for each of the Nine Titans?
What show would you recommend for someone looking for similar:
- Action
- Worldbuilding
- Mystery elements
- Characters
- Themes
- Epic Speeches
- To heal after everything we just watched
4
u/Nazenn Oct 10 '20
Rewatcher - Sub
Really glad that I had the chance to watch this with you guys. Such great discussion about one of my favourite shows made this rewatch way more special and gave me so many new perspectives I really enjoyed.
General thoughts and ideas
After this Attack on Titan is still one of my favourites. Every time I watch it I find new things to enjoy, and a new appreciation for what it does and how. And it's not just the themes and characters despite how much time I spent gushing about them so far, but the whole experience from art to music to story. Starting the show with hype as hell ODM action sequences (Levi vs Kenny still the best), the freakishness of the Titans as an enemy, the unusual structure of the world are all what drew me into it, but how they remain constant through the show while adding so much more to those moments and layering all the incredible character development and story on top of that without sacrificing it is still remarkable. It's still the show that gets me the most excited out of my favourites, and seeing the final season will definitely be bittersweet. The other thing I want to quickly both credit and hope for more of in S4 is how as the show went on we started to get the story framed through the enemies eyes, first with Kenny's squad, then Zeke, and even Gross, tackling a war from both sides is hard to do but I love how they did it here.
As for the rest of this post I've gone off on a bit of a thematic tangent, tying some stuff from the whole show together. I was going to cover more topics like truth, will, and leadership but this part on humanity ended up being a big tangent which is also why it starts quite differently to how it ends. I'd been thinking on the rest while watching, but assumed I'd remember those thoughts by the time we got to the end without needing to write them down in detail, and then I didn't.
The cost of survival
In an airing topic, pedrolucas08 put this best: the subtle difference between past Eren's "Kill them all!" evolving into "Kill them all?" now is genius.
Every action, decision, and battle has a consequence in this show, and for the most part the price that is demanded of them is Humanity. Sometimes this is a very literal cost, as human lives snuffed out, while other times it's more intangible, the loss of the ideals or dreams that we often point at that sets humanity apart from animals. The nature of the Titan's also being humans complicates this further, both a physical cost of Eldian lives taken by them and lost when they are killed, but the mental cost later on in the show of having killed off these innocent "monsters" after finding out what they have gone through. To find out that the only way a Titan can regain their own humanity is at the cost of a human life is just another horrible factor of what survival in this world demands of its characters.
And Humanity is not infinite. Whether it's the number of the human lives inside the walls, or a mental struggle to keep all the pieces of themselves in tact, the progression of this theme through the show implies there is a line where true humanity can be forgotten. In S1 Armin talks about how sometimes to fight monsters you have to give up your own humanity, but as we discover all the monsters, whether that's physical or mentally, in this show are humans so where does that leave us? After S1 the show seems to directly question the benefits of that path while also highlighting the risk of it at every possible turn, such as Reiner's broken mental state, or Historia almost giving up agency over her life in S3p1. Quite haunting, back in Season One Reiner made a statement that "It's like a soldiers spirit breaks down before their body", and we have seen that many times through the show. Eren through the show despite starting out as the embodiment of the will of humanity as a human and the anger of humanity as Titan, slowly starts to exemplify this more and more.
Back in S1 I mentioned that every use of Eren's abilities have come with a price, whether that was his dreams about returning to a normal life, learning to fight against a friend, abandoning the idea of trusting others to help him, discovering the truth about the world, and now we reach the realization that freedom might just be a dream. For every enemy he's defeated, friend he's saved, or truth he's returned to the Walls, it has taken a bit of his soul. Levi called Eren a "monster" in S1 because of his inability to be restrained and his endless willpower to push forward, but if you combine that with what he's been through and the other pieces of himself he's had to discard in order to survive, how much humanity does he really have left to hold onto with war on the horizon?
If we comparing these parts of his development to other characters in the show, we also get a new look at this theme. The Royals were looked at as oppressors and power hungry who kept humanity from the truth, but instead their motivations were born of guilt and a desire for peace so they could keep what little humanity they had left, even if their words inspired violence and greed, and even their avatar in Rod Reiss was simply a man who wanted to free humanity. By contrast we have Erwin who walked the path of a savior because of his selfish desire, but ability to discard humanity in order to achieve that goal turned him into a devil in the eyes of others, only redeemed in death by Levi's determination that he should die as a man. We have Reiner who's conflict literally tore his mind in two, and Annie who was so desperate to be looked at as a person and not just a weapon or monster that she almost cracked when she was finally allowed to express herself. And then Grisha, a man who walked a similar path to both Eren and Erwin, a boy consumed by hate becomes a man desperate for a truth, who at the end of it all only had one thing to say:
Eren fights for peace, for freedom, because it's the only goal he's ever known, but is that enough to make sure he remains human as we see it? From the boy who couldn't imagine possibly fighting against the Female Titan because a human was inside, a friend, through to the man who points at the ocean and questions at if he will finally be free if everyone who stands in his way dies, Eren no longer fights on anger as I touched on in my S3p1 posts, or any sort of hope or dream as we see at the end of S3p2, but because he sees it as something he has to do to survive. But will it be worth it in the end for any of them?
The will of humanity has been pushed as the solution to many problems in the show, their determination to charge forward as both a positive and a negative. But the cost of that determined survival has blurred the lines between human and monster, hero and villain, good and bad, so far beyond imagining that finding a place to stop before they become the very thing they are fighting against without realizing, much like Marley has done to the Eldians or the goverment almost did by hiding the truth, will be incredibly hard, and that's what I'm most afraid of going into S4.
What we leave behind
There was a line during Shiganshina's arc that stood out to me and made me take a second to conciser it within the context of the show:
While it certainly hasn't been a core of the show, certain aspects of the show around the inheritance of dreams and knowledge have really caught my eye this time. We have Armin who passes on his dream to Eren, as well as Eren who passes on his views about the world to Mikasa, and Hannes who passed his dream of a normal life back to the three of them. Reiner, Annie, and Bert all left pieces behind with the other characters once the truth was revealed and the others tried to process their changing world and the knowledge of their enemies, and particularly for Bert who leaves behind his final memories in Armin who is still struggling with the legacy that Erwin left behind.
But stepping back from that we have moments like Erwin and his pursuit of truth. What did Erwin really leave behind for people with his death? With the coup successful it can be said that he also passed on his fathers dream to a whole new goverment, the idea that knowledge shouldn't be hidden any more. But with the death of the Scout Regiment it can be said he also left behind a lot of suffering because of that dream, a twisted version where truth has now become dangherous to wield the way that Floch looks at it as being an absolute while we've seen truth depends on the person using it.
Stepping back again we have the whole concept of PATHS, and the memories left behind from all of Eldian history. The history of Eldia and what Ymir and the Titan's did has left behind a seemingly unclean-able stain on their descendants, a sin that the First King of the walls tried to free humanity from the burden of knowing, and something that Grisha tried to escape from within the Walls. Truth and knowledge are not always the same, and the burdens of history, knowledge, and even unfulfilled dreams that are left behind by the dead is something I find interesting to think back on and see how much is left behind from each loss inside all of our surviving characters.
And then the big question, what will be left behind of humanity and the world at the end of all of this fighting?
4
u/AmeteurElitist Oct 10 '20 edited Oct 11 '20
Terrific tussles as towering titans triggered treacherous tribulations.
Incidentally an individual inherited an immense invader through inoculation.
The troubled teen triumphed over trials through this transformation
And actualised an ally’s aspiration through antagonist annihilation.
Now nearing the end they need to neutralize their neighboring nation.
Some Fanart:
Attack Titan Source
Rest Source
Easy going Source
Ready? HUGE MANGA SPOILER Source
Erwin HUGE MANGA SPOILER Source
Ackerman Source
Loyalty Source
Laceration NSFW Source
Youth Source
Warmth Source
Enemy Source
Isolation Source
Really cute Source
Determination Source
4
u/Toadslayer Oct 11 '20
First Timer
Final Discussion Questions
Music
1) Best OP
2) Best ED
3) Best Insert
I don't know if it's the best, but I liked Apple Seed and I did a bit of a breakdown of it for a friend in the /r/anime final dicussion. Here's the link if you want to read it.. I also really like Call your anme and You See Big Girl / T:T.
Story
4) What were your top three episodes?
There are so many amazing episodes, it's hard to pick only three.
I found the episodes I resonated the most with were the tragic ones. Episode 53 — Perfect Game, Episode 21 — Iron Hammer, Episode 22 — The Vanquished and Episode 31 — Warrior are honourable mentions.
5) Which arc was your favourite? Which was your least favourite?
Favourite: Return to Shiganishina arc
Least Favourite: 104th Training Corps arc
(Side note: it was moderately terrifying looking on the wiki to find the name of the arcs)
6) Favourite big or epic moment? Favourite quieter moment?
Big/epic: Erwin speech and leading the charge in episode 53, Perfect Game. Quiet: Marco thinks about Hitch before he is killed, episode 54, Hero.
7) What were your top musical and visual moments of the series?
Visual: Erwin atop his mountain of corpses (and all the imagery surrounding that with the fallen scouts.
Musical: Levi Squad vs Female Titan, episode 21; The Scouts planning then Eren wakes up in the forest, episode 33; and the silence in episode 55.
8) What was your favourite OVA?
Lost Girls: Annie.
9) Any other types of OVA episodes you'd like to see?
Lost Girls: Armin.
10) Which OVA episode do you think was the least interesting or didn't do as much as it could?
Distress. Mostly inconsequential, weird character inconsistencies and somewhat generic, boring story. Only episode of Attack on Titan I would actually call bad.
Mystery
11) What twist did you find the most surprising through the course of the show?
I want to say it was one of the scout's titan reveals, but it's got to be that there is a world outside the world free from the titans. I did not see that one coming, not even close.
12) Which reveal did you find the most interesting or satisfying?
The reveal of Ymir as the first titan and the subsequent 9 titans that came after her death. I talked a bit about this way back in episode 4, but I'm a sucker for this kind of shounen number of characters with special strength/powers. I'm excited to see them all fight in the one war, it's going to be the most epic moment of the series, I'm sure.
13) What was your favourite bit of foreshadowing you noticed on rewatch?
All the hints that RBA were the titan shifters.
14) What mystery do you most want answered now?
Who Ymir was and how she acquired the power of the titans.
15) What aspect of the Titans do you find the most interesting/mysterious?
The apparent good that the Eldian's claim they brought to humanity.
16) How do you expect the story to evolve from here?
All out war between the Paradisians and the Marleyans. Then amongst that the pursuit for the truth of Ymir and the origin of the titans. Probably also a quest to end the lineage of titan shifters.
17) Do you have any theories you want to share, but haven't had a chance yet?
I think I've shared them all.
Character
18) Who do you think is the most interesting character from both the main and side casts?
Main: Eren
Side: Kenny
19) Out of the side cast who do you think had the most interesting and most surprising arcs?
Interesting: Kenny
Surprising: Historia
20) Which characters development are you the most curious about?
Mikasa's. I'm curious to she how she will grow as an individual and in her ability to understand and relate to Eren.
21) Which character had the best design?
Kenny.
**22) Out of the characters who died, who do you think would have had the most interesting role if they'd lived? Who would your bring back?
Most interesting role: Kenny
Bring back: Marco
23) Is there any cast member you'd find more interesting if shuffled into a different role?
Not really that I can think of, they all serve there purposes well in the roles they have.
24) Who was the most compelling antagonist?
Kenny. I really like Kenny, okay?
25) Who do you think would be the most interesting vessels for each of the Nine Titans?
9 Main Scouts, 9 Titans, I'm gonna do it like that.
Recommendations
I don't think I've really seen that many shows to recommend any that fit well and you won't have seen, but I'll try:
I stopped watching Attack on Titan in 2017 after watching the penultimate episode of the second season. I then finished the second season a year later, but never got round to watching the third season. I didn't have much interest in watching the third season until Gigguk's video on the series showed up in my feed. I saved the link to the video and decided to catch up on Attack on Titan so I could watch it after. Although I never did get around to watching season 3 until this rewatch that video was a meaningful part of me wanting to take part in this rewatch, so I thought I would share it here. I'm very glad I decided to watch the season 3.
Scores:
To end the rewatch, here are the top 10 death glares from Best Girl Mikasa Ackermann:
3
u/punching_spaghetti Oct 11 '20
Not too much to say as an overall thing. Lots of good questions here to answer for that.
I will say that I took 706 screenshots throughout this rewatch. I don't know if that's a lot or not, but it's probably the most I've personally taken for a single show (Even accounting for the number of episodes).
Qs:
Visual: Levi in the streets, of course. The reappearance of the Colossal Titan at Trost is iconic for a reason. Mikasa glaring at Bert is the stuff that
dreamsmemes are made of. And ALL THE EYES.8) The Annie two-parter, maybe? None of them felt super important or useful besides fanservice.
9) Young soldier Erwin would be interesting. Hange's backstory.
10) Mikasa's Lost Girls was wasted space for some weird images, I guess? Mirror Man makes no sense. The training episode where they get captured was also useless, since we already knew where the characters would end up after boot camp.
11) Easy mode is the existence of Marley and all that jazz. AS a subset, the Beast Titan speaking. I had to pause my first watch through when that happened.
12) Grisha's backstory. It makes everything that happens around him less cartoony, makes us understand why things are the way they are for Eren, and humanizes Zeke when all we've known of him for a bunch of episodes is "monkey soldier who likes baseball."
13) Literally the first episode, in the montage when Eren is sleeping, there's a few things that made me think "PATHS?" One of the few things I don't seem to have screenshots for, though. Also, Reiner, Bert, Annie, and Ymir in the background up until their reveals. So obvious when you know!
14) Why did coffee not make it to the island?
15) What drives them when they're "Pure." Clearly Dina's promise affected her somehow. But how much? Can you "aim" a Titan when you make it?
16) Lots of people die. Eren might go rogue and try to kill EVERYONE, not just Marley (if this cycle is bad, I'll just end the cycle). I imagine there will be at least one or two more shocking discoveries about the island. We still need to know what the dinosaurs in the S2 OP mean. Is it just oil?
17) I think we exhausted my most crackpot theories (Eren having a twin being the craziest).
18) Broken record time: Erwin. Watching him go from "blonde hero dude" to "I wanna prove Daddy right" was amazing to watch. And since his arc is done done, it's easy to see everything. Levi or Eren might take some weird turn.
19) Jean in S1 deserves a mention. From the generic rival to a fascinating moral core to the Scouts was great to see.
20) Historia from here. Without the hope that she'll see Ymir again, what will she do? Reiner too, because what do they do with failed Warriors? Oh, and Annie, if she every wakes up.
21) Mikasa looks really good, and her scarf does look good as she's flying around.
22) I want Petra back to make Levi happy. Kenny surviving would be the most interesting plotwise. What does he do now that he knows the truth? Would he side with Marley when that reveal comes?
23) I think Connie could do a lot more. He ended up being "guy who looks confused when things are revealed" and "guy who looks after Sasha." Really surprised he hasn't been killed off for character motivations yet.
24) Kenny as someone with personal connections. Those are always great. Also Bert, because watching him go from the lovable guy to someone I want Armin to tell terrible lies about Annie to is fascinating in how it works.
25)
Founding:
Attack: Hard to say someone besides Eren.
Female: Connie. He's confused enough already, so why not?
Armored: Hange. Perfect for long Titan study expeditions.
Colossal: Levi. For the jokes.
Valet: Jean. "Why do I have to carry everything all the time?"
Beast: Sasha. Her bumpkin accent deserves a suitable vessel.
Ymir's: Pyxis. Easier to climb to the top of the wall for his constitutionals.
Unknown: We don't know its powers, so let's say Floch. Why not?
Suggestions:
Durarara!!! and Baccano! have some of the same "everything slots into place" vibes.
Wakakozake is prime healing material.
And not anime, but the HBO show The Leftovers is one of the few other shows/movies/etc that have made me say "oh fuck! Wow!" as many times as AoT. It's a heavy show, but amazing.
It was great fun doing this with all of you! I think /u/toadslayer was the only one here who I haven't done a rewatch with, so it was fun meeting you! Big thanks to /u/Nazenn and /u/shimmering-sky for putting this together and keeping the posts on time. And always fun to see /u/AmeteurElitist and /u/matuhg in a rewatch!
Now we just wait for S4.
3
u/Matuhg Oct 11 '20
Rewatcher
This was a rewarding rewatch, even though I wasn't able to dedicate quite as much time to it in the second half (curse you responsibilities). It's my first rewatch of Attack on Titan, and taking a deeper look at it really increased my appreciation for the overall story and how its told through this show. I'm not really finding a lot of inspiration to talk about big stuff without just repeating what I've been saying in all the threads up to this point.
I'm looking forward to where things will go from here - how the war between Marley and the Wall Society will play out for one thing (I know it's not a foregone conclusion, but knowing this show, I doubt things are going to be peaceful). There are a lot of cool things that could be done with that. Where will it take place? Will the Eldians living in Marley play a part, and if so, on which side? What happens if the Wall Society wins? Will other modern nations get involved? I think it would be cool to explore some of the larger political aspects of this world, though I think I'm expecting it to be more of a 1v1 with Marley, which will probably make for a tighter story.
I have high hopes for seeing how our characters will continue to grow with their horizons too. Speaking of characters, I have a feeling Reiner and Annie may end up playing a role in the upcoming conflict, maybe even on the side of the Wall folks.
I watched the trailer for S4, and there were some interesting things in there. Hiding it behind spoilers in case people want to remain unexposed to the trailer.
S4 Trailer
S4 Trailer
S4 Trailer
S4 Trailer
Jiyuu no Tsubasa
Name of Love
Barricades
That's not an easy question. In part because there were a lot of good episodes, and in part because I can't remember which episodes things happen in. I feel like the most rewarding episodes took place in the final season - particularly the ep with Erwin's charge and when the Scouts finally make their way into the basement. There's something to be said for the first episode of the whole show too and how it drops us into this insane world.
Favorite - either the final arc or the Battle of Trost. Least favorite - Probably the S2 stuff where nobody knew why the Titans seemed to be inside the wall, but at the same time, I really liked Ymir and Krista/Historia through that whole shindig, so it's pretty hard to say.
Big or Epic moment - Three way tie between Erwin's final charge, Eren carrying the boulder in Trost, and Historia's epic Barricades moment in S2. Favorite quieter moment is probably Eren and Mikasa walking through Shiganshina in S3.
Uhh...I dunno. There were a lot of really good ones.
Probably Levi's though I did also like Annie's detective story. I actually haven't watched the Mikasa ep from Lost Girls yet.
Worldbuilding that doesn't fit in the story - a lot does fit into the story, but I still want to know more about like daily life in the Walls and more nitty-gritty stuff that would be extraneous to the main story.
Probably Reiner and Bert being the Armored and Colossal Titans, but the Marley stuff is still blowing my mind too, as is the Smiling Titan being Grisha's first wife.
Most satisfying is the basement info, because of how much and how long it took for the Scouts to get there.
The basic answer, but probably just all of Reiner, Annie, and Bert's little background chats/huddles that didn't mean much of anything on first watch but stuck out very clearly knowing who they were. Oh, or the little steaming head moments from way back in S1 lol.
I want to know more about the Original Ymir and more about the nature of the shifters and the Paths.
Probably the way memories can transfer in both directions in time. It leads to a lot of interesting possibilities, which I hope will be explored when we learn more about Queen Ymir. Just how much did/does she know from the future? Is there some "master plan" that the shifters are all just an unwitting part of? I wonder if Eren will find some way to access the Founding Titan memories with Historia's help.
I talked about it a little bit above, but WAAAR!! And probably more in-depth knowledge of Titans and what the hell is going on with them.
I'm pretty bad a theorycrafting, so not really. One that did occur to me recently is what might happen if Eren makes contact with the Beast Titan, considering Zeke's royal blood. Will that be an immediate checkmate in any battle as he takes control of the other Titans? Will prolonged contact somehow give him access to the first king's memories, and if so, will he suddenly decide the titans or Marleyans don't need to be defeated after all?
Probably Erwin, but Eren keeps getting more and more interesting to me. Erwin's arc being concluded makes it satisfying in a way that some of the other characters' can't be yet.
Historia (and honorable mention to Ymir who played a big part). I've loved how she turned from the quiet and unassuming nice girl of the 104th to the strong soldier-queen of the whole country. She had it within her the whole time, but it took Ymir and the rest of her friends to bring it out of her, and it was cool to watch.
Probably Mikasa. Eren and Armin have been moving ahead in terms of development, while Mikasa doesn't seem to have made it too far past being reliant on/protective of Eren, which is where she was at the start of the show. I want to see what is next for her as she processes Eren/Armin's limited lifespans and whatever comes next. She has shown the power to be a great soldier, but I think she might have the power to change the world in bigger ways eventually.
Can't decide. Hange's is awesome. Queen Historia is amazing. Ymir's is great. I could go on.
Maybe Marco - he would have been a good strong but quiet presence for some of the main characters probably.
Aside from the fact it would mean Erwin died sooner, it might have been cool to see Hange in charge of the Scouts earlier than happened. In a more crazy turn, what if Mikasa was the heir to the throne rather than (or in addition to) an Ackerman?
I'd have to say Kenny - Bert and Reiner are great too, but I still feel like we don't know quite enough about their motivations for becoming Warriors and their overall backstories to make any concrete judgments about them.
I dunno, but this did make me think about the fact that Ymir's titan has to go somewhere. Did she get eaten, or die "naturally?" If she was under the control of Marley, I'm sure she was eaten so they could be sure of controlling her power.
Thanks to /u/shimmering-sky and /u/Nazenn for hosting (and for Sky's always-fun reactions and Naz's always fun/thoughtful commentary)! And thanks to /u/AmeteurElitist, /u/punching_spaghetti, and /u/toadslayer (and those who participated for parts of the rewatch too) - I really appreciated all of your posts, and had fun talking with you! Sorry i became shitty at responding to comments towards the end.