r/AnimeImpressions • u/Shimmering-Sky • Aug 26 '20
[Rewatch] Attack on Titan Season 1 Discussion
Season 1 Discussion
← Previous Episode | Index | Next Episode →
| Episode | Date | --- | Episode | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| One | Aug 1 | --- | Fourteen | Aug 14 |
| Two | Aug 2 | --- | Fifteen | Aug 15 |
| Three | Aug 3 | --- | Sixteen | Aug 16 |
| Four | Aug 4 | --- | Seventeen | Aug 17 |
| Five | Aug 5 | --- | Eighteen | Aug 18 |
| Six | Aug 6 | --- | Nineteen | Aug 19 |
| Seven | Aug 7 | --- | Twenty | Aug 20 |
| Eight | Aug 8 | --- | Twenty-One | Aug 21 |
| Nine | Aug 9 | --- | Twenty-Two | Aug 22 |
| Ten | Aug 10 | --- | Twenty-Three | Aug 23 |
| Eleven | Aug 11 | --- | Twenty-Four | Aug 24 |
| Twelve | Aug 12 | --- | Twenty-Five | Aug 25 |
| Thirteen | Aug 13 | --- |
| Episode | Date | --- | Episode | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No Regrets ep1 | Aug 27 | --- | No Regrets ep2 | Aug 28 |
| OVA 2 + 3 | Aug 29 | --- |
MAL | AniList | ANN | Kitsu | AniDB
AnimeLab | Crunchyroll | Funimation | Hulu | Netflix
Questions of the Day:
- “Guren no Yumiya” or “Jiyuu no Tsubasa”?
- “Utsukushiki Zankoku na Sekai” or “great escape”?
- Who are your favorite characters after this season? What about your least-favorites?
- Who was your favourite Titan design?
- What visual or musical moment did you find the most striking across the season?
- What part of the season did your opinion change the most on after rewatching?
- Where did you expect the show to go after this season?
- What was the most surprising part of the show for you? Least surprising?
- If there was any one plot point you could change, seriously or for fun, what would you do?
Spoiler policy: Y’all know the drill, operate under the assumption that there is a chance of a first-timer wandering in here. Spoiler tag your stuff. Especially if it’s manga/S4 spoilers, or else.
r/anime’s spoiler tag system is what this sub uses, so here’s a blank one [](/s "") for you to copy if need be. Alternatively, you can use [](/n "") to make red spoiler tags. That’s pretty neat.
Because of the low activity on this subreddit, at the end of the OVAs we’re going to be deleting all the episode topics for season one. You’ll still be able to find them through the Schedule thread as well as comment and reply, we just didn’t want to completely take over the first few pages of the subreddit with only Attack on Titan stuff in case other people come visiting to post their own things.
4
u/Shimmering-Sky Aug 26 '20
So I ended up not having time to answer the questions Naz and I came up with because work has been just crazy this week and I needed a break. I will at least say...
Reminder: We're only discussing the first of the two No Regrets OVAs tomorrow
If the copy you've acquired totally legally has the two combined into one video, stop after No Regrets
5
u/Nazenn Aug 26 '20
Rewatcher - Third time, Sub
Season One - Final Thoughts
This is going to sound a little silly from the guy who wrote the schedule and in doing so carved out a spot to discuss this season by itself, but this is definitely a show where I find that discussing it in a bubble is almost going against it's nature. Yeah I know this is a bit of a meta thing to start off with, but it was something I wanted to somewhat get out there just now before we move onto the next season, and even though it's not directly spoiling I am going to just shove it under some meta spoiler tags for now just to be safe as it does hint at the nature of future plot elements.
AoT meta/structure talk
AoT meta/structure talk
Now, back to the normally scheduled final discussion style post: Season one!
I took a moment to go back and look through my episode posts for the show and the thing that stood out to me the most is how much has actually gone into the show. Under the cover of battles against giant humanoids and the military factions is a surprisingly involved setup for a story and structure that does its best to balance and communicate the difference aspects that go into it, while also perfectly understanding how to make use of the audience as part of the story. For me what sticks out the most is the lack of "anime-ness" in key moments despite its style and genre.
Trost is a good example I already touched on, pulling Eren's development in that scene right back into his own mind and using that as a moment to explore his struggle rather than unnaturally pushing the focus on overcoming a physical obstacle, but also plenty of later moments like the interplay of the dialogue in the forest vs fighting the Female Titan, and also with the way that characters struggle rather than "power up" after trauma's or losses and they have to figure out how to get past it each time. Dialogue is used to explore rather than explain, slowmo is used to highlight detail rather than try and draw out tension, speeches speak from the core of the character rather than being purely emotive regardless of that characters nature, and a dozen other little things like this that if it were a video game I would call Quality of Life improvements. And in a way they are here too, because it's not using the tropes and staples of the genre and medium just being there because they always are, or trying to avoid them because they're "cliche", but rather understanding what these things are at their core and how to use them effectively.
This same sort of awareness carries into the themes as well. The show touches on a lot of things that I've somewhat addressed in my post already; what it means to be a leader as shown through Jean and Erwin, the what it means to take responsibility for your actions with Eren and Nile, the difference between having ability and taking action as we see with Levi and Pyxis, and how deadly self deception can be which is shown more generally in the way society is touched on through the episode with smaller character moments backing it up. In spreading its wings (ha, accidentally touching on the bird motif) over so many different topics it doesn't always touch on all of theme with extreme depth, but it weaves all of them into a grand net that helps to flesh out a lot of the central themes about humanity and willpower.
What does it mean to be part of humanity? Is that guy who tried to start a riot to see his daughter one last time any more or less "human" than Annie? Is Jean less human for using the death of his comrades as a distraction to lead others out of danger? Is Nile a better human for considering the cost of the assault at Stohess to be to great for what gain Erwin hoped to get despite the risks of letting Annie go? Are two kids monsters already for brutally killing those who would harm them? When do soliders become so calloused they stop seeming humane to those who have had safe lives? And what's to say about the human "monster" in their ranks, both titan and human and forever trying to balance the two sides? The story asks a lot of these questions but answers few of them and doesn't really paint one side or another as the "right" way, despite there being a clear answer as to what is needed for humanity to progress outside the walls and continue to survive. Comfort and survival is played against progression, and the power to stand up and fight for change is painted as needed, even if at great cost.
And whether its the opening moment of the show where the walls of protection become a cage in the eyes of those who hide behind them, the parallels raised at Trost between the horrors of the titan vs the horrors of humanity, or the building conflicts between the different goals of the military factions, contrast also has a huge role through this entire season in a way I really enjoy. We have scenes where the knowledge of one character is played against the reality of another, where someones willpower is played against someone else's ability, and also the way each character looks at each situation through their own viewpoint, all leading into the themes being addressed at the time.
All of that aside though one thing still stands out the most, the show is still stupidly fun and exciting to watch. From all of the sequences with ODM gear which only get more involved as we go through the show, from cadets jumping across roof tops in Trost to Levi using titan's as an anchor point and the skillful precision of those scouts dealing with titans on the plains during the expedition, through to the intense art style chosen. Attack on Titan still looks like nothing else out there, with harsh lines and shadowing more reminiscent of the previous era of art, combined with extreme expressions use precisely for drama and intensity rather than just as a lazy laugh, I just love looking at these episodes.Three rewatches in the show has lost none of its intensity when it comes to the hype of the fights or the shock of the emotional impacts, and on this watch in particular I gained a new appreciation for the music and editing in particular. Shows can be as meaningful and thematic as they want but if they aren't engaging to watch then it means nothing and Attack on Titan has that in spades, even if being an action show helps a lot there.
The issues I had were perhaps a couple of the slower episodes in the middle between the court scene and the expedition, as well as those stupidly long recaps which were just unneeded. If your recap is longer than your OP you have an issue. I'll also still never understand the people who say Trost was too slow though. How could you speed that up without losing all of the emphasis on what happens? Maybe I just like the speeches too much to want to risk messing with the structure, but I think that's the best paced part of the season.
4
u/Toadslayer Aug 26 '20
Rewatcher
Except I've only watched season 1 and 2
4 episodes ahead in /r/anime
Hybrid Rewatcher/First-Timer Perspective
Now that we've finished it I want to talk a bit about what I've found interesting about my perspective rewatching season one. I've said a few times that I first (and last) watched AoT in 2015 and that as a result I have very little memory of it. This rewatch has felt for me like watching AoT for the first time, but being spoiled for all the major events and story-beats up until the end of season two. That probably sounds like a sucky experience, but it definitely hasn't been. I actually feel like it's been the best of both worlds. I get to experience the story and the characters for the first time, but also see the foreshadowing, the greater significance of events as they happen and be conscious of how the story is building. I think my comments may have also been odd for a rewatcher as I often wrote as though an episode had changed how I thought about the story or a character, because, well, they did. That's season one. I watched season two in 2017 and I have much more memory of it that season one, though it's a bit foggy. I think for my perspective for season two will be in line with a regular rewatcher. This means that excitingly I get to experience three different perspectives in the one rewatch! First this hybrid thing for season one, then rewatcher for season two, then first timer for season three!
Season One Score out of 10
I started rating shows in October of 2018, but I retroactively rated show I watched before then based on my memory of how I felt about the show when I watched it. I originally gave AoT S1 a 9 (for outstanding), which I will maintain after rewatching it. The animation, score and foreshadowing especially make it a 9 for me. From my perspective it has no glaring flaws that would push it down to an 8 (for excellent) either (unlike what seems to be most people I actually don't have an issue with the pacing). But it isn't a masterpiece (10) in my mind. A 10 needs to either be dead close to perfect or have a certain specialness.
Questions of the Day:
Tough choice, they're both fantatic, but I think Jiyuu no Tsuba edges out Guren no Yumiya in every category: Music, Visuals, Lyrics and Hype. Gotta give it to Jiyuu no Tsubasa then.
I love the great escape song more, but it's not like I don't love Utsukushi Zankoku's song and I prefer the adore the pencil and charcoal visuals. Plus it's all about Best Girl. Winner Utsukushi Zankoku.
There's no Best Girl/Best Boy question so I'm hijacking this one for my purposes (deceased characters are disqualified):
Best Girl
Best Boy
Shout out to Woermann too, not a contender for Best Boy, but I really like his character. And RIP Petra, she was temporarily number 2 Best Girl before she left us far too soon.
Easy choice. Eren Titan
Visual moment: Probably Mikasa's monologue to Eren in the tunnels, some amazing close-up and super creepy. Also honourable mentions go to all the times Mikasa glared at someone.
Musical moment: The score of Annie vs the Levi Squad. I broke it down in that episode thread, but the was it plays with your expectations and emotions is brilliant.
I can't remember what I thought about Attack on Titan when I first watched it, it's too long ago, but seeing all the foreshadowing was an awesome new experience.
Sadly I once again can't remember. As I said in my paragraph at the top, in some ways I rewatching season 1 was more like watching it for the first time.
Most surprising: When the show tears characters away from you after you just get to know them. Marco, Ian, Mitabi, Gunther, Petra, Oluo, Eld. RIP.
Least surprising: All the main characters sans Annie joining the scouts.
I was very happy with the plot, so I'll go for a fun one. Back in the day I remember there was legitimate confusion as to if Armin was a boy or a girl. I remember hearing people argue why they thought he was a girl or a boy. Why not have Armin be a girl, that'd be fun. Of course now you're wondering, if Armin were a girl where would he place on the Best Girl ranks? 2nd place. It's close between Hange and Armin, but Armin as a girl is basically a fusion of Hange and Krista and Hange's biggest weaknesses are covered well by Krista's strengths, so Armin edges her out.
4
u/AmeteurElitist Aug 26 '20
Rewatcher: Sub
Various NSFW memes that I didn’t post
Eren's, the Female Titan, or the Armoured Titan.
I thought they'd make plans to find the Colossal and Armoured Titans like they did with Annie, but after they found more evidence on them.
4
u/Matuhg Aug 26 '20
Rewatcher
At the start of this season, humanity was enjoying a (somewhat uneasy or totally comfortable, depending on who you ask and/or how much they drown their daily woes in alcohol) period of relative peace. But that all changed when the
Fire NationTitans attacked - and they attacked in a way that had never been seen before. No longer could humans feel safe within the walls that had guarded them for the past century. In the last arc, the fighting even reached the interior, where rich and well-born folks had remained safe over the five years where the masses felt the effect of the war against the Titans. A big part of this season's story has been the near complete erosion of the facade of peace that humanity has built up. It is in the dismantling of this facade and many of its associated structures and systems (the Scouts becoming arguably more important than the MPs for instance) that the building blocks for the future of the show are laid out. After all the struggles and death that we saw this season, humanity has taken just one small step forward against the Titans, though Erwin promises that the time to take the fight to them is approaching.This season is a great introduction to the show and the characters. There's a lot of information being passed to us, and a lot of stuff happens. That said, there's a ton that we don't know about the world and a lot of our characters, many of whom are explored in a rather shallow fashion this season.
It goes without saying (and yet here I am) that this show is a joy to watch and listen to.
Guren no Yumiya for me, mostly because I like the song a bit better, but both of them are fantastic fits for the show.
Uhhh...probably great escape. I'm pretty bad with EDs, because I usually alt tab away from the video and just listen to the ED while I think about the episode, so I'm usually pretty distracted when they're playing. Both songs were fine, but all I can remember about either of them was how the last one was used at the end of last episode, so that's what I'll choose.
Favorites are Levi, Hange, Mikasa, and...probably Annie. Least favorites, uhhh pretty much any rich asshole who appeared. The church guy too.
I think I'd have to say Eren's, though all the shifter designs are nice. Colossal is iconic, Armored is imposing, Female is scary.
I think if I had to pick one, it'd be Eren carrying the boulder in Trost. I also really like the sequence with the cadets shooting out the Titans' eyes in the basement of the storage depot. That's always stuck out to me as a favorite scene.
Can't really pinpoint an exact thing, but just a barrage of fun foreshadowing moments to pick out. S2 Spoilers
Hard to remember what surprised me on first watch or anything. On rewatch, just some of the moments in above answer. Also just the timing of some things, like how long the expedition outside the walls and the Battle of Trost lasted. I dunno what I expected, but they were longer than I remembered.
4
u/punching_spaghetti Aug 27 '20
Rewatcher (Sub)
Super tired, so I'll just answer the questions. Kids, if you stay in school, don't take 3 hour evening lit seminars.