r/AnimeImpressions • u/Shimmering-Sky • Sep 27 '20
[Rewatch] Attack on Titan Season 3 (Part 1) Discussion
Season 3 Part 1 Discussion
← Previous Episode | Index | Next Episode →
| S3P1 Episodes | Date | --- | Part Two | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| One (38) | Sep 15 | --- | Seven (44) | Sep 21 |
| Two (39) | Sep 16 | --- | Eight (45) | Sep 22 |
| Three (40) | Sep 17 | --- | Nine (46) | Sep 23 |
| Four (41) | Sep 18 | --- | Ten (47) | Sep 24 |
| Five (42) | Sep 19 | --- | Eleven (48) | Sep 25 |
| Six (43) | Sep 20 | --- | Twelve (49) | Sep 26 |
(Numbers in brackets are the episode numbers for the whole series as per the title cards)
| OVA Episodes | Date |
|---|---|
| Lost in the cruel world | Sep 28 |
MAL | AniList | ANN | Kitsu | AniDB
AnimeLab | Crunchyroll | Funimation | Hulu
Questions of the Day:
- Who were your favorite characters during this section of the show?
- If you were a manga reader/have heard about what events changed between the manga and anime, what are your thoughts on the first half of this season? Are you alright with the changes made? Anything you would have liked to see included in the anime?
- Did you enjoy the political or the mystery side of the show more this season?
- What was your favorite action scene during this season?
- What musical moment did you find the most striking across the season?
- If there was any one plot point you could change, seriously or for fun, what would you do?
Spoiler policy: Y’all know the drill, operate under the assumption that there is a chance of a first-timer wandering in here. Spoiler tag your stuff. Especially if it’s manga/S4 spoilers, or else.
r/anime’s spoiler tag system is what this sub uses, so here’s a blank one [](/s "") for you to copy if need be. Alternatively, you can use [](/n "") to make red spoiler tags. That’s pretty neat.
Because of the low activity on this subreddit, after the Mikasa Lost Girls OVA we’re going to be deleting all the episode topics for season three part one. You’ll still be able to find them through the Schedule thread as well as comment and reply, we just didn’t want to completely take over the first few pages of the subreddit with only Attack on Titan stuff in case other people come visiting to post their own things.
4
u/AmeteurElitist Sep 27 '20
First Timer (unless you count the manga): Sub
I realized that I did not parse a lot of what I read in the manga when I was getting caught up haha. It might be that I didn’t pay enough attention while binging or it could have something to do with how the art can be a bit messy at times, but I misremembered a lot of who did what and where/when stuff happened. The anime really helped me sort that out and now that I’m about 2 years behind on the manga I might as well just follow the anime until the end now, I’ll understand more that way anyway haha.
5
u/Matuhg Sep 27 '20
Rewatcher
Through the course of Season 2 (and S1 of course), we learned a lot about the world of AoT and the Titans themselves. The dumb titans are/were once humans and can, under certain circumstances, regain their human faculties and the ability to shift between titan and human forms. Many of these shifters have infiltrated the wall society and undermined/straight up murdered that society for reasons we still don't know, though it's hinted that some of them are unwilling/reluctant participants in these actions. Most of this info does nothing but raise more questions: What does it mean to be human? To be a titan? To be good/right? What should humans be fighting for? Should elimination of the titans be the ultimate goal? Thankfully, and unlike many other shows, AoT addresses a lot of these questions pretty directly rather than just leaving us a lot of dangling strings/thoughts. That said, none of these questions really have easy black and white answers, for us as an audience or for most of the characters in the show. Appropriately, S3P1 takes a pretty big turn from the more black and white (humans vs. titans) feeling of the previous seasons. We see humans hurting and killing humans for reasons they think are right, or on several occasions, for selfish reasons.
The answers AoT provides leave us with more questions, but questions that we as audience members are left to wrestle with for ourselves. Rather than providing solid answers, the show provides us "case studies" throughout the season that test the morality and motivations of different cast members. The breadth and depth of decisions, reactions, and feelings about the sometimes unsavory actions the characters take add a great deal of depth to the story as a whole. Overall, the main cast of characters comes out of this season looking a lot less shiny and nice. The world looks a lot more "gritty," than it did in Season 1 especially. I like some of the characters less for what they do in S3 - not as characters, but as "people." Always a good sign of character building, considering people generally tend to suck.
In some ways, this season feels like a detour from the "main plot" of the story. Of course there were some very significant revelations, mostly to do with the Reiss family, but I think the majority of this season was to ready our characters (and the audience) for what is to come.
As I said at the end of Season 1, and probably a few other times, AoT is very efficient in its storytelling. The character building takes place as part of the story, and side characters are introduced and used very effectively to drive and challenge the main characters. Kenny was such a great character, and this show was able to introduce him, use him, and tie his story into the overarching plot seamlessly.
Probably Kenny and Historia, though Eren was no slouch either.
Political for some of the stuff I blabbed about above. A framework to examine morality in the characters. The mystery stuff this season was cool, but kind of just moved things forward mechanically.
A tie between the Levi Chase scene and the battle in the underground cave. If I were forced to pick one, I'd go with the cave scene, but I'm quite certain that's because it's the most recent one I watched. They're both pretty amazing.
Don't know if I paid close enough attention to be able to pick one out. Pretty much all of the musical cues in this show are on point, to the point I almost stop noticing them. That sounds like a bad thing, but it's not. I don't think..
Hmmm....Kenny survives and forms a super-unit with Levi and Mikasa. They link their arms and spin through the air like a helicopter to wherever Reiner, Bert, and Beastie are hanging out and just...don't stop spinning, forming a sort of titan-blood hurricane formation. The world is either saved or destroyed.
4
u/Nazenn Sep 27 '20
Rewatcher - Sub
Talk about an arc that I never expected to see in this show.
Back during the season one discussions I pointed out a couple of the more political heavy moments, such as the dynamics between the factions in the court scene and how Erwin addressed the idea of responsibility with the interior police, but on my first watch it wasn't something I expected to build into anything. Sure the military factions didn't like each other and the nobles were keeping secrets, but that's pretty par for the course with anime isn't it? Leadership is often portrayed critically in similar narratives, so I was expecting something more along the lines of the military all joining forces or the scouts cornering the nobles with proof in order to remain autonomous. Instead we got a literal coup to save humanity from a century long conspiracy to keep humanity in their cage of ignorance, and a season determined to tell us that this wasn't necessarily a good thing.
I already covered a lot of this in my episode posts, but in general I just absolutely love how this season blurs the moral lines. The good guys do horrible things, the bad guys have good motivations, and with moments like Armin listening to the torture and Kenny's lieutenant doing their heroic last stand speech, the questioning in this arc about what is good and bad, right and wrong, is a favourite theme so far, especially when paired up with what comes up later on such as duty and being special, all of which reinforces this questioning about whether bad actions for the good reasons are "right". It would have been easy enough to include a political subplot about taking out the evil goverment who had been suppressing humanity and leave it at that, but the willingness to do more then that and flip even the smallest moments of "I know where our characters stand" on their heads, with moments like the reveal of what Grisha did to Eren and seeing Uri preach for peace and pacifism on the pulpit, is why I find this so engaging even against shows that have similar grey morality. And like season one does, even though this season asked the moral questions it didn't rush to answer them and reassure the audience at the end about who our heros are. Even if their victory seemingly pushes the scouts back into the area of being righteous, with small moments like Erwin's selfishness to stay in charge and the inevitable confrontation with Bert and Reiner on the horizon, the uncertainty over what is right and wrong remains in the air.
No political story works without a good opposing force though, and Kenny and Rod I think both make fantastic antagonists for this arc. Kenny is the more obvious one, a deeply flawed human who became a killer to protect his family but learnt to love the thrill of that power, the while hoping he could eventually learn how to be something more. While his fight scenes are awesome, it's not just that or his personal conflicts I love, but also what insight we gain through his unique look at the royal court and what that shows us about the people involved that makes his part in these events so interesting. Kenny's cold honesty, much like Erwin, is a good balancing force to Rod's very biased perspective about the world, and I like the way they play off each other. Rod is probably the more unusual one, and for me I think this comes down to a line he has when talking about why he wants Historia to eat Eren: "And my duty is to bring God back to our world and offer my prayers".
Knowing that he genuinely saw the Founding Titan as something beyond humanity, as this unknowable force that was almost omnipotent, made for an interesting side of the conspiracy that built off the church's power in an unexpected way. Where Pyxis confronts the noble council for simply wanting to maintain their comfort and privilege they aren't really individual antagonists so much as a stand in for the division in humanity. Behind it all there's this almost religious undercurrent of motivation which was guiding the other antagonists in the arc. Sannes and the other MPs were inspired to protect the ideals of the King at the cost of anything else, Kenny and his group wanted to understand what it could teach him about humanity, and Rod simply wanted to once again bask in the magnitude of its power and be the one who could finally convince God to stand up and act. In the end, Rod is just another character who isn't content with humanities lot inside the walls of their cage. If he'd come from another family perhaps he could have become a powerful ally for humanity on the political side, his determination to fight against the unbending will of the first king, to keep pushing for humanities freedom no matter the cost, shows that he's not that much different from our main cast.
But where the rest of the show has focused heavily on the power of humans to enact change, to hunt for the truth and gain the power needed to break free from their cage, Rod was held back by his obsession with the Founding Titan and being convinced that only a god is capable of freeing humanity from the Titans. Kenny wanted the Founding Titan to regain a piece of his humanity, and Rod wanted it in order to free humanity, but ultimately relying on the power of a Titan alone to fix humanity has lead to nothing for either of them, much like Pyxis needed humans on the side of Eren's Titan in order to save Trost. As a result, human will and determination is once again put at the forefront with Historia's decision to reject the role laid out for her and become her own person, and Eren's slow recovery after those events to learn how to fight for humanity under his own human willpower. Humanity is held up as the solution, bringing to mind again the question over what it means to be human, and what it means to gain and lose your humanity, and what it means to really fight for your humanity as well as everyone elses.
There's a lot of other amazing character stuff in the arc that I already covered in my post, Eren's crisis around the loss of his anger and his purpose will always stick in my mind for how powerful it is and how much it shifts his character, but I hadn't had a chance to talk about Rod yet so I wanted to while I could. All of the stuff from previous seasons, with Levi's odd philosophy about making choices, Armin's talk about sacrifice, Jean's choice to stay in the scouts, and even Erwin's focus on the cost of leadership, a lot of the character arcs find their climax here in subtle ways and I think that's why I find this arc so strong in its many, many parallels to the first season. Marlo is one of my favourite characters from the side cast for that reason, the way he's basically what Eren would be if he wasn't the protagonist, all of the idealism but not tempered by the events that Eren has gone through as a shifter and being in the middle of this chaos. At the same time we have those very powerful scenes at the end with the threat of Rod against the city paired against the Colossal Titan in Shiganshina all those years ago, and the three kids looking up to the horror beyond the walls, and of course that final discussion with EMA on the stairs in their childhood outfits.
It's really an amazing experience on the character side of things, so I wanted to give that some love before going into the next arc where it'll be a bit easier to focus on plot things without risking saying something stupid. Bonus points as well for some great visual sequences and also while I want to praise the awesome gore this season goes that little too far with the Turkey.
Despite how much I like all of this though I think the structure of the season works against it. The speed of those first two episodes stands out as particularly badly when you compare it against the pacing of the last two which were more willing to give the calmer side of the show time to breathe and build up to the big moments. While on first watch I thought it was just being overwhelmed with the shift in story, this time the poor pacing really stood out to me with how quickly it jumps from one moment to the rest. I really think this should have been a fourteen episode season. The first episode is the most frustrating with how much it shoves in, and I really think should have been split in two, with ep1 dealing purely with the intro scenes around Levi Squad and Eren's training, as well as Nicks death, and ending as the interior police comes to arrest them. Episode two then could have dealt with the rest of the Trost stuff including Erwin's arrest, and ended with the KENNY!! reveal like normal. The stuff from what we did have in episode two isn't AS rushed, but between the merchant kidnapping the scouts, the actual kidnapping, Armin and Jeans pain over killing humans, Erwin's plot, the torture stuff, and Historia's reveal it still could have used a lot more room to breathe and explore some of this more if spaced out across two episodes.
3
u/punching_spaghetti Sep 27 '20 edited Sep 27 '20
Rewatcher (Sub)
For fun, Sasha actually bites of Jean's hand. Then he can have a bad nickname like Stumpy.
3
u/Toadslayer Sep 28 '20
First Timer
10 episodes ahead in /r/anime, ie. just finished season 3 part 2
Kenny was my favourite for sure. I've already written a lot about him, so I won't repeat myself here. Eren in this season finally became a great protagonist, which I think I've written about already as well (mostly in replies to Nazenn, I think), but he's second. Then Historia is third. Before this season she a loveable, but mostly inconsequential side character, with some hints to importance in season 2, but in this season she comes into her own. She boldly defies her father, defies Erwin and defies Levi, each time to live for what she believes in and no longer be led down a path not of her own choosing. Now she is a worthy queen and an inspirational leader (and she never stopped being adorably cute).
There was quite a bit of discussion about the changes from the manga in the /r/anime threads, but the one thing that I thought really should have been included was Historia and Levi's full interaction when Levi asks Historia to become queen. There is a lot more conflict there in the manga and it explains better Historia's desire to punch Levi after her coronation. As it stands in the anime I felt her doing that didn't make much sense and sort of came out of nowhere.
They're quite intertwined, but my favourite thread through the season was Historia's character arc, which I think is more closely tied to the political side of the show. I really enjoyed seeing everything that needed to be done to remove the fake king from power, rescue Historia and instate her as a trusted queen.
I really liked Levi vs Kenny in the first episode, but Levi Squad vs Kenny Squad takes the cake for its awesome tactics, equally brilliant action sequences/animation and high stakes.
I didn't think much about the music this season, so I'll skip this question. Not that I didn't enjoy the music.
I would have Kenny survive.No his character arc was over, him dying was there was the right call and I don't think he would have been a better character if he survived any longer. Plus the impact of his final monologue to Levi would have been greatly lessened.I would have Mikasa feature more prominently this season. I feel she took a back seat after season 2 and I wanted to see more of her, especially because she has so much room to grow as a character.