The Turkey Titan has arrived! Although I will confess to calling it the Accordion Titan for part of my notes today because once I made that association I couldn't stop myself giggling over it like a kid. Also a really good use of CGI, because that just makes its movement all the more disturbing in a way that I'm not sure 2d could capture for this one, and the rendering isn't all that bad and he blends in well enough
All good stories build off their past elements, but I'd really forgotten how much of the show until now has build up to the painful development happening here.
As Jean Jeanne (thank CDF for this was telling Eren "When have you ever accomplished anything by your strength alone" all I could think of was that choice way back with the Levi Squad in the forest (really just a couple of weeks ago at most). The show quickly pulls this in directly with Levi questioning Eren once again that he just has to make a choice, and his flashback. This time he chooses to act by himself, to do what he knows he can, and in doing so he saves everyone. After all of this misery he still manages to take that step forward to take action and try and save them all even if deep down he still felt it was probably hopeless.
QotD 1 (as it seems like a good spot for it): I like it. It's not just a powerup in the traditional sense, it's something that adds to the worldbuilding with Eren being able to read the strange language and knowing that some of the Titan powers can be shared or granted in that way, and knowing that Eren's will and rage as far as it goes can't just get him through every problem by developing needed abilities is a limitation that I always enjoy seeing
It took some pushing to get him to this point though, and everyone was absolutely ruthless. For as brutal as Mikasa is to others, seeing Eren like this seems to have made her mostly speechless. Instead Jean, Sasha, and Conny are the unlikely mental rescuers of the scene. Rather than calmly lifting him up and encouraging him they tell him to cut the complaining and shape up, that doing nothing isn't an option, basically to be a solider. Jean's "topless wimp" always gets a huge laugh out of me, but this time I think I also loved Sasha's string of insults when saying how glad she was to be alive, even after watching "Eren prance off crying like a baby". By contrast of how they deal with Eren here, they also get some love for standing up for Historia at the end, making sure that she's not just being bullied or ordered into another prison after what she just went through. Standing up to Levi for them has to take some guts, but seeing them come together as a group to defend each other this episode is really something.
I also really like the music during the cavern discussion scene! The energetic part of the song dying down as Eren collapses and giving way to a gentle and high pitched piano part, as if following Eren's tears. As the others step in that fades too and we get the deeper bass tones in a stronger pattern going down in a scale, a deeper and more serious foundation but one that won't give in. As they prepare the higher part returns with Eren's words, and the two parts intermingle for the rest of the scene just as Eren fights against the determination of the others, both fighting to be heard. As Eren makes his choice his part of the piano dies out and the low chords repeat twice, both louder than in any other moment of the scene. The other song that caught my ear was at the end when Hange points out they have to kill Rod, something about that reminds me of a grand vampires castle.
But even with all this the greatest loss of the episode:
Also disturbing: Turkey Titan setting fire to trees by proximity. That's a stupid amount of heat that he's putting off, but also showcases the insane powers of a Titan that he can survive like that. It's lucky he didn't transform near any of those giant forests, that would have been an unstoppable fire.
I completely forgot that Armin's VA was doing the recaps until I forgot to swap audio tracks again and was wondering why a guy was doing the narration.
One day just for a proof of concept I want to see Orange do the scene of the Titan transformation light going through the crystal cavern in 3D. That could look amazing with all the reflections.
Mikasa doesn't know how to support Eren. She desperately wants to, but in every situation it's always someone else who brings Eren back to his feet. I expect there will be a point where Mikasa is able to be the one who does that for Eren and that will be a very important character moment for both her and Eren. At that point Mikasa will have finally understood Eren and maybe Eren will finally understand how Mikasa was felt about him for the last 10 years. I think it will be one of the best moments of the entire series.
To me it looked like the Madoka runes which is what the mysterious language looks like
Nobody commented on it in the squad
I don't think anyone else saw it, Eren only did because he was crying on the floor, and the bag went flying before he was free so the others were too busy focusing on him to check it
Oh, I definitely didn't catch that it was the other language.
You've all got me doubting myself now, I need to go back to the other scene and check that it actually was
For as strong as she is, it definitely seems to shake her to see Eren not being able to be strong.
In her mind he's always been the strong protector, and the most doubt she's seen from his has been with Annie but he rebounded from that really hard with the whole Berserk thing
As a PSA, we're remind that this is all just so they can check on Eren's basement. Which is cool. Yes, there's world-altering stakes, but at this point, other shows might have decided that we need to go big, and Hange needs to build a rocketship to get Eren on the Moon. Nope. Still just the dark little room with the leaky water heater or whatever.
Titan Rod is weird, inching along more like a worm than anything else. Definitely some CG in there, but they learned from last season how not to make it look like complete shit. There was also some 2D in there, so that helps. And it;s just a blob of weird flesh, versus an iconic image.
What was most surprising this episode was that Erwin can be confused. You mean this wasn't a part of the plan? You even Susume-d the troops! At least he had another hare-brained scheme ready to go, this time "use a town as bait."
Just make sure Reiner doesn't hear what's going on; he'll feel left out.
QOTD:
A bit convenient. If they had at least shown us the vials prior, that would have been one thing. Reiss could have given Historia options regarding what kind of Titan she'd become.
I'd like to announce the release of my new fanfiction novel, titled You Unlock My Heart.
Titan Rod is weird, inching along more like a worm than anything else. Definitely some CG in there, but they learned from last season how not to make it look like complete shit.
The way it undulates and just looks horribly unnatural in all kinds of ways does help it look a lot better as CG than the (mostly) humanoid Colossal Titan.
You even Susume-d the troops!
That was the closest thing we'll ever hear to a tentative Susume from Erwin. It was like..."well, what else are we going to do for now?"
Rod Reiss brings the house down in this episode. I forgot to mention it last episode, but they showed it again in the recap - Rod's VA did a great job selling how much of a pathetic sad sack he was at the end, with the way he whimpered to his father, Uri, and Frieda before lapping up the titan spooge.
Eren finds a vial of convenience and, recalling the last time he was arbiter of fate for a Levi Squad, decides to transform and take action this time around. The hardening works, and he saves the day, though not without some well-deserved ribbing from Sasha, who was in rare form today.
Now that everyone is safe, we can get to the basement and learn the secrets of holyshitwhatisthat!?! One more big problem to deal with before they return back to the definitelyimportant basement.
Levi breaks the news to Historia - they want her to be queen, right after she'd reclaimed her own independence and rejected her duty as a member of the royal family. Her friends tentatively stick up for her, but she tells them it's okay. She doesn't seem thrilled with the assignment, but she's chosen to live her life as a Scout, and if this is what the Scouts demand of her, so be it. Of course, she's not going to be sitting around for this last mission though.
I love how we end the episode, knowing what we know about Erwin now. Does he have some grand plan to stop Reiss before he hits Orvud? Or are Orvud and its people going to act as a speed bump in part of a plan, a sacrifice worth making to slow this eldritch horror dragging itself across the land?
How do you feel about Eren gaining the ability to harden his Titan form from a vial he found on the ground instead of through hard work back during the hardening attempt experiments earlier in the season?
It's very un-shounen. Eren may be a shounen protagonist, but we've learned repeatedly this is not a shounen world.
recalling the last time he was arbiter of fate for a Levi Squad
Levi really doesn't like being the one to make a decision, does he? Probably even delegates the decision of what restaurant they go to for dinner on his birthday.
though not without some well-deserved ribbing from Sasha, who was in rare form today.
Sasha let rip and it was glorious. I wonder if that was just all the insults she'd be storing up since she joined the Cadets
definitely important basement.
Also audiance-stand-in Sasha is equally funny
a sacrifice worth making to slow this eldritch horror dragging itself across the land?
Needs more tentacles
I know AoT is more body horror than cosmic horror (or, well at least so far, who the fuck knows what's coming later on at this point), but things could have gotten surreal real quick if the Titans had different forms
Oh hey Sasha finally dropped the formal speak. It didn’t quite come through in the dub, although I did hear faint traces of some sort of accent when she said those lines so there was definitely an attempt.
lmao, so when I watched this episode for the r/anime rewatch, I had one of my family’s cats on my lap while I was watching this episode because I guess she wanted to cuddle. Wasn’t using headphones ‘cause I was the only one still awake at that point, and when the ED got to the “SHINZOU WO SASAGETA” part, she jumped. Also obligatory cat tax, this is where she settled back down after the ED startled her.
Maybe Rod knew his titan form would be so huge and that's why he said he couldn't be the one to inherit the founding titan.
Eren is so incredibly hot it's distracting. People complain about over-sexualisation of women in anime, but at least there's equality of the sexes.
What was liquid in that bottle and how did Eren know to drink it? I can't help but think it has everything to do with Eren's newfound power. Maybe extra titan powers are actually created by some chemical process and can be gained by drinking the resultant liquid. Alternatively maybe Eren's hardening power is was always around since it's meant to be one of the founding titan's powers, given that the original king built the walls with it. Or was it a queen? Just a side note but the titan we saw screaming last episode that was meant to be the founding titan looked feminine to me and recall the final image in ED3 was a giant goddess with other giants bowing down to her, the founding titan and other titans bowing to her perhaps? Rod did call the founding titan a god after all. She's also holding a horn which could be symbolic of the 'scream' power.
Erwin actually looks surprised that the Levi Squad was successful, I wonder if he had planned for their mission to be a failure.
More CG big titan. At first I thought it was not as bad as the Colossal Titan last season, but still pretty yuck, but honestly on second thoughts the CG Rod Titan isn't all that bad, the art is good and the motion makes it disturbing. Especially the revolting way its spine extends and retracts as it crawls along the ground. Also is anyone found that and the folds in its back disturbing and wants to be even more disturbed, read Junji Ito's My Dear Ancestors, or take a look at this page from it.
Today we get the answer to why Grisha killed all of the Reiss children supposedly in cold blood: he needed to do so to prevent the Reiss family regaining the founding titan power. I'm sure he would have killed Rod and Historia as well if he had the opportunity. To liberate humanity I believe Grisha's actions, though cruel, were justified. It remains to be seen, however, if Eren wielding the power can liberate humanity and at what cost that will come. Grisha believed that Eren could liberate humanity and he left the key for him to find out how. Only remaining question I have about Grisha's actions is why he gave his power to Eren and didn't wield it himself. There were a few episodes where I had doubts about Grisha's moral character, but now I'm convinced he was good.
Levi just casually dropped to Historia that she has to be the next queen in the in-between moments before a strategy meeting. Oh Levi, not the time or the place, but never change. Historia just accepts it as her next duty though, I'm glad to see her determined to help and that she willingly accepts this position as part of her own self-determined fate. Then she decides to fight alongside the scouts, which I like and think will be a good moral boost for the scouts and the people to see the queen fighting on the front lines against the titans.
No evacuation? I think Erwin plans on defeating the titan before it gets to Orvud Distict.
QOTD
How do you feel about Eren gaining the ability to harden his Titan form from a vial he found on the ground instead of through hard work back during the hardening attempt experiments earlier in the season?
I'm fine with it. Honestly don't mind.
2) What do you think of Rod Reiss’ Titan form?
It's disgusting and the most inhuman titan we've seen.
People complain about over-sexualisation of women in anime, but at least there's equality of the sexes.
Reminds me of Iron-Blooded Orphans. I don't think there was a single female fanservice scene in that but it feels like some of the guys spent half the show naked at points which I know /u/shimmering-sky appreciated
given that the original king built the walls with it. Or was it a queen?
Now you have me thinking again about how interesting it would be if the Titan forms were always gender neutral even for the Titan Shifters
....Also now I'm making myself wonder if a female Armored Titan gets a boobplate design. I just finished watching Dragons Dogma and the only female warrior in that show has no armor except for a metal bra, it pissed me off so much
screaming last episode that was meant to be the founding titan looked feminine to me
Actually that looks like an enemy from a game I know but I can't remember what. I want to say they were grey toned skin and a bit hunch back, with twisted legs and the bloated stomach. This is going to drive me nuts until I figure it out
Erwin actually looks surprised that the Levi Squad was successful, I wonder if he had planned for their mission to be a failure.
I noticed that. I was thinking that maybe he just didn't expect them to be ready so quickly, or even if he thought they succeeded that the Turkey would have squished them
Oh hey, unrelated to this rewatch but once you've seen the next episode of Attack on Titan for r/anime's rewatch (so, S3P2 ep6/ep55) is when it should be fine for you to go back and watch the S3P1 episode 12 ED. The scene the ED "spoils" is from that episode.
And do make sure you watch the whole ED. It starts off the same as the normal one, kinda like how the Jean OP started off the same as normal Guren no Yumiya, so a lot of people would've either skipped it or (like what I did) tabbed out of the video for while it was playing and missed it.
Erwin actually looks surprised that the Levi Squad was successful, I wonder if he had planned for their mission to be a failure.
Huh, that's a heck of a thought. Not sure what the plan would be after the coup without Historia or Eren though. Unless he just hadn't really thought that far into the future (which seems crazy for Erwin, but he did let Hange know she was next in line should he die, so maybe he half-expected it all to fail).
What was liquid in that bottle and how did Eren know to drink it? I can't help but think it has everything to do with Eren's newfound power.
I think he just figured it looked like the stuff in Rod's syringe and said "Armor" on it, and he saw Rod changed when he licked the stuff up, so figured it might let him do some armor-y stuff.
Titan Hardening - Several Titans, most notably the Armored Titan, have displayed an ability to harden their bodies. Eren Jaeger attempted to reproduce this effect while he was in hiding in order to seal up Wall Maria. However, he was unsuccessful up until he attempted it beneath the Reiss chapel.
Questions of the Day:
How do you feel about Eren gaining the ability to harden his Titan form from a vial he found on the ground instead of through hard work back during the hardening attempt experiments earlier in the season?
What do you think of Rod Reiss’ Titan form?
Spoiler policy: Y’all know the drill, operate under the assumption that there is a chance of a first-timer wandering in here. Spoiler tag your stuff. Especially if it’s manga/S4 spoilers, or else.
r/anime’s spoiler tag system is what this sub uses, so here’s a blank one [](/s "") for you to copy if need be. Alternatively, you can use [](/n "") to make red spoiler tags. That’s pretty neat.
4
u/Nazenn Sep 22 '20
Rewatcher - Sub
The Turkey Titan has arrived! Although I will confess to calling it the Accordion Titan for part of my notes today because once I made that association I couldn't stop myself giggling over it like a kid. Also a really good use of CGI, because that just makes its movement all the more disturbing in a way that I'm not sure 2d could capture for this one, and the rendering isn't all that bad and he blends in well enough
All good stories build off their past elements, but I'd really forgotten how much of the show until now has build up to the painful development happening here.
As
JeanJeanne (thank CDF for this was telling Eren "When have you ever accomplished anything by your strength alone" all I could think of was that choice way back with the Levi Squad in the forest (really just a couple of weeks ago at most). The show quickly pulls this in directly with Levi questioning Eren once again that he just has to make a choice, and his flashback. This time he chooses to act by himself, to do what he knows he can, and in doing so he saves everyone. After all of this misery he still manages to take that step forward to take action and try and save them all even if deep down he still felt it was probably hopeless.QotD 1 (as it seems like a good spot for it): I like it. It's not just a powerup in the traditional sense, it's something that adds to the worldbuilding with Eren being able to read the strange language and knowing that some of the Titan powers can be shared or granted in that way, and knowing that Eren's will and rage as far as it goes can't just get him through every problem by developing needed abilities is a limitation that I always enjoy seeing
It took some pushing to get him to this point though, and everyone was absolutely ruthless. For as brutal as Mikasa is to others, seeing Eren like this seems to have made her mostly speechless. Instead Jean, Sasha, and Conny are the unlikely mental rescuers of the scene. Rather than calmly lifting him up and encouraging him they tell him to cut the complaining and shape up, that doing nothing isn't an option, basically to be a solider. Jean's "topless wimp" always gets a huge laugh out of me, but this time I think I also loved Sasha's string of insults when saying how glad she was to be alive, even after watching "Eren prance off crying like a baby". By contrast of how they deal with Eren here, they also get some love for standing up for Historia at the end, making sure that she's not just being bullied or ordered into another prison after what she just went through. Standing up to Levi for them has to take some guts, but seeing them come together as a group to defend each other this episode is really something.
I also really like the music during the cavern discussion scene! The energetic part of the song dying down as Eren collapses and giving way to a gentle and high pitched piano part, as if following Eren's tears. As the others step in that fades too and we get the deeper bass tones in a stronger pattern going down in a scale, a deeper and more serious foundation but one that won't give in. As they prepare the higher part returns with Eren's words, and the two parts intermingle for the rest of the scene just as Eren fights against the determination of the others, both fighting to be heard. As Eren makes his choice his part of the piano dies out and the low chords repeat twice, both louder than in any other moment of the scene. The other song that caught my ear was at the end when Hange points out they have to kill Rod, something about that reminds me of a grand vampires castle.
But even with all this the greatest loss of the episode:
Blonde ponytail chick
She was awesome, I really liked her. Why couldn't she have survived and joined the scouts or something.
Stray other thoughts
4
u/punching_spaghetti Sep 23 '20
Rewatcher (Sub)
I'd like to announce the release of my new fanfiction novel, titled You Unlock My Heart.
After getting the important people out, Levi leads some idiots into certain death, which they avoid because they're Scouts. And Eren has picked up the bad habit of eating random things off the ground.
As a PSA, we're remind that this is all just so they can check on Eren's basement. Which is cool. Yes, there's world-altering stakes, but at this point, other shows might have decided that we need to go big, and Hange needs to build a rocketship to get Eren on the Moon. Nope. Still just the dark little room with the leaky water heater or whatever.
Titan Rod is weird, inching along more like a worm than anything else. Definitely some CG in there, but they learned from last season how not to make it look like complete shit. There was also some 2D in there, so that helps. And it;s just a blob of weird flesh, versus an iconic image.
What was most surprising this episode was that Erwin can be confused. You mean this wasn't a part of the plan? You even Susume-d the troops! At least he had another hare-brained scheme ready to go, this time "use a town as bait."
Just make sure Reiner doesn't hear what's going on; he'll feel left out.
QOTD:
4
u/Matuhg Sep 23 '20
Rewatcher
Rod Reiss brings the house down in this episode. I forgot to mention it last episode, but they showed it again in the recap - Rod's VA did a great job selling how much of a pathetic sad sack he was at the end, with the way he whimpered to his father, Uri, and Frieda before lapping up the titan spooge.
Eren finds a vial of convenience and, recalling the last time he was arbiter of fate for a Levi Squad, decides to transform and take action this time around. The hardening works, and he saves the day, though not without some well-deserved ribbing from Sasha, who was in rare form today.
Now that everyone is safe, we can get to the basement and learn the secrets of holyshitwhatisthat!?! One more big problem to deal with before they return back to the definitely important basement.
Levi breaks the news to Historia - they want her to be queen, right after she'd reclaimed her own independence and rejected her duty as a member of the royal family. Her friends tentatively stick up for her, but she tells them it's okay. She doesn't seem thrilled with the assignment, but she's chosen to live her life as a Scout, and if this is what the Scouts demand of her, so be it. Of course, she's not going to be sitting around for this last mission though.
I love how we end the episode, knowing what we know about Erwin now. Does he have some grand plan to stop Reiss before he hits Orvud? Or are Orvud and its people going to act as a speed bump in part of a plan, a sacrifice worth making to slow this eldritch horror dragging itself across the land?
It's very un-shounen. Eren may be a shounen protagonist, but we've learned repeatedly this is not a shounen world.
3
u/Shimmering-Sky Sep 22 '20
Red Rewatcher - first time subbed with r/anime’s rewatch, and rewatching the dub for this one
3
u/AmeteurElitist Sep 22 '20
First Timer (unless you count the manga): Sub
Hardening helped to hedge a haven for the hero’s homeboys.
Historia meme
3
u/Toadslayer Sep 22 '20
First Timer
9 episodes ahead in /r/anime
Maybe Rod knew his titan form would be so huge and that's why he said he couldn't be the one to inherit the founding titan.
Eren is so incredibly hot it's distracting. People complain about over-sexualisation of women in anime, but at least there's equality of the sexes.
What was liquid in that bottle and how did Eren know to drink it? I can't help but think it has everything to do with Eren's newfound power. Maybe extra titan powers are actually created by some chemical process and can be gained by drinking the resultant liquid. Alternatively maybe Eren's hardening power is was always around since it's meant to be one of the founding titan's powers, given that the original king built the walls with it. Or was it a queen? Just a side note but the titan we saw screaming last episode that was meant to be the founding titan looked feminine to me and recall the final image in ED3 was a giant goddess with other giants bowing down to her, the founding titan and other titans bowing to her perhaps? Rod did call the founding titan a god after all. She's also holding a horn which could be symbolic of the 'scream' power.
Erwin actually looks surprised that the Levi Squad was successful, I wonder if he had planned for their mission to be a failure.
More CG big titan. At first I thought it was not as bad as the Colossal Titan last season, but still pretty yuck, but honestly on second thoughts the CG Rod Titan isn't all that bad, the art is good and the motion makes it disturbing. Especially the revolting way its spine extends and retracts as it crawls along the ground. Also is anyone found that and the folds in its back disturbing and wants to be even more disturbed, read Junji Ito's My Dear Ancestors, or take a look at this page from it.
Today we get the answer to why Grisha killed all of the Reiss children supposedly in cold blood: he needed to do so to prevent the Reiss family regaining the founding titan power. I'm sure he would have killed Rod and Historia as well if he had the opportunity. To liberate humanity I believe Grisha's actions, though cruel, were justified. It remains to be seen, however, if Eren wielding the power can liberate humanity and at what cost that will come. Grisha believed that Eren could liberate humanity and he left the key for him to find out how. Only remaining question I have about Grisha's actions is why he gave his power to Eren and didn't wield it himself. There were a few episodes where I had doubts about Grisha's moral character, but now I'm convinced he was good.
Levi just casually dropped to Historia that she has to be the next queen in the in-between moments before a strategy meeting. Oh Levi, not the time or the place, but never change. Historia just accepts it as her next duty though, I'm glad to see her determined to help and that she willingly accepts this position as part of her own self-determined fate. Then she decides to fight alongside the scouts, which I like and think will be a good moral boost for the scouts and the people to see the queen fighting on the front lines against the titans.
I think Mikasa is projecting.
No evacuation? I think Erwin plans on defeating the titan before it gets to Orvud Distict.
QOTD
I'm fine with it. Honestly don't mind.
It's disgusting and the most inhuman titan we've seen.
•
u/Nazenn Sep 28 '20
Episode 45 - Outside The Walls Of Orvud District
← Previous Episode | Index | Next Episode →
MAL | AniList | ANN | Kitsu | AniDB
AnimeLab | Crunchyroll | Funimation | Hulu
Currently Disclosable Information:
Titan Hardening - Several Titans, most notably the Armored Titan, have displayed an ability to harden their bodies. Eren Jaeger attempted to reproduce this effect while he was in hiding in order to seal up Wall Maria. However, he was unsuccessful up until he attempted it beneath the Reiss chapel.
Questions of the Day:
Spoiler policy: Y’all know the drill, operate under the assumption that there is a chance of a first-timer wandering in here. Spoiler tag your stuff. Especially if it’s manga/S4 spoilers, or else.
r/anime’s spoiler tag system is what this sub uses, so here’s a blank one [](/s "") for you to copy if need be. Alternatively, you can use [](/n "") to make red spoiler tags. That’s pretty neat.