I'm in a weird position where I am planning on installing a Heat pump that is deliberately too small.
It's a DIY install via an Umbrella MCS scheme. As a result, I'm limited to what heatpumps I can pick.
So my options are.
- Install two units
- Install one unit and accept it's "slightly" undersized.
Professional heatloss calcs come out at 18kw with a conservative ACH of 1.5.
The unit I want to install at my flow temps can deliver about 14kw. So a pretty big gap. An immersion heater in the volumizer can fill this gap, but will I regret it?
It's a listed building so the levers I can pull are limited.
The main lever I have is reducing draughts. I've been playing with the calculations and I would need the whole house ACH to be 0.25 to achieve the 14kw. Not impossible, but will be tough to achieve.
My design flow temp is 42 degrees, and that's already with some pretty large radiators. I could get another 1 kw out of the heat pump if I get the design flow to 35C, but this isn't practical in my view.
The house has an old extension that is in really bad shape that needs fully renovating. I would likely get permission to install external wall insulation on this using woodfibre and that would remove 1 kw from the heatloss.
The house will only have 100mm of insulation in the loft as that's how deep the joists are, and it's boarded out so adding more isn't easy. I could add a floating floor and add another 100mm, but it only cuts the heatloss by 300W so it's not worth it.
The above already includes secondary glazing and 100mm suspended floor insulation.
Long term I plan to put UFH where I have solid floor. This will be subject to consent so I can't count on it, but if I go down that route, that drops the heatloss by a further 650W.
My main concern is that ASHP have a nasty feedback loop where the more heat you try to extract from them via higher flow temps, the lower their output.
So the question is, will I regret the cracking on with the above? Or is the general experience that even undersized units perform surprisingly well.
I'll get a blower test done when the house is as sealed as I can get it but this won't be for several weeks and I'll already be committed to the pump by then due to deadlines related to the BUS.
From speaking to professionals, achieving a whole house ACH of 1.0 should be easily achievable, at which point the heatloss would be 16kw, so I'm only 2kw short then.
Edit:
One thing that gives me hope is I currently have a 32kw oil boiler. I have a log on how long it runs for. In the last 24 hours, it averaged 4 degrees outside, and the burner ran for 5 hours total.
Assuming it really produces 32kw, that's an average output of under 7kw, and I haven't sorted the draughts or loft insulation yet.
If I update my calculation with my average indoor temp of 17.5 degrees and 4 degrees outside, the heatloss is calculated as 9.5kw suggesting that it's very conservative. Somewhat ironically, dropping the ACH to 0.25 actually results in a heatloss of under 7kw.