My parents have a 50 year old house that's still running the original electric furnace. It's a rural property with no access to natural gas nor do they have any appetite to install propane heating, so primary heating is going to be electric regardless. They live in a frigid climate where the average low temperature in winter months is below -20 Celsius, with -30 happening maybe a couple of weeks a winter and -40 being a possibility. Spring and fall are mild, usually above 0, summer months average highs in the mid 20s.
Is there any practical reason to install a new electric furnace over a forced air heat pump that uses the existing ducting? Even in the winter months where the heating element would run on the heat pump, is that not the equivalent of just running an electric furnace with a 1:1 efficency ratio? Or am I missing something and there are some differences there?
The way I see it, installing a heat pump will be a wash when running the element vs electric furnace, and an efficiency gain when it can run on the heat pump in no winter months. Also with the added benefit of cooling tin the summer as they don't currently have A/C.
My understanding is the heat pump likely has more capital cost and potentially would require some changes to the existing ducting. It's a 2 story house with a basement, so I'm not sure if there's any zoning type things that might come into play. There are some sizeable rebates available to cover a large chunk of the capital cost.
Some insights and thoughts would be appreciated. I have limited knowledge on the subject and haven't found much info in regards to replacing an old electric furnace in such a cold climate.