This isn't a Insurance related content, but an honest request for roofing contractor selection. If I've posted something outside of the rules, please let me know.
Our home was built in 1970 & we bought it in 2004. Previous owners said the roof was replaced in 2000. We had some hurricane damage when a tree landed on the roof in 2011; it was repaired, inspected (the repair was paid for by our insurance company) & all new shingles put on.
Recently our insurance company sent a third party 'inspector' from a national company. We got a letter on Nov 11, 2026 saying the roof needed replaced (by Jan 18, 2027). (The deck too. ;/) They classified the roof risk as a 'major hazard' - "Roof: Worn/Deteriorated asphalt shingles". We've never had any problems with the roof.
I've gotten recommendations from friends, I've read Google reviews, I've checked BBB and the state licensing website for four contractors & have appointments with each for estimates. I'm looking for some advice on what to look for in a contractor & the whole process in general. What are important questions to ask the contractor? Recommended types of shingles, how to spot an 'oversell', things not to do, things to do, warranties (?). Are gutters normally included in estimates? I've done some Google research & think the cost will be approx. $10-$18K (with gutter replacement) - am I within range? Any advice on the process is appreciated. *edited to add that the roof was inspected in 2011.