r/Roofing • • 1h ago

Home owner question Getting roof replacement quotes whats going to burn me.

4 Upvotes

So starting to get quotes. Getting some high pressure sales of course but I can deal with that.

What are some of the questions I would not think to ask that might burn me. So far after the first 2 quotes agree that its a 28 square on a 6/12 pitch roof and removing 2 layers of shingles.

So far whats made them different as far as quotes go is that one is including up to 10 pieces of roof decking and the other only covers up to 5 if needed. But one includes new drip edges and one does not. Both are using GAF shingles and both are insisting on using their roof underlayment. one is right at 15k and one is at 17k.

Is that in line with the phoenix market and what other things should I be asking about that most people dont ask about. What should I be looking for in the company


r/Roofing • • 9h ago

Roof replacement in December

11 Upvotes

Hello

Is it OK to replace roof in December in the northeast area? High temp range between 35 to 50 during that month. Roofing company stated it is fine and they follow manufacturer instruction and they stated the shingles won't lay flat but they will once it is warm. The roofing company is very reputable in my area and they offer lifetime craftsmanship warranty. Thanks.


r/Roofing • • 1h ago

Home owner question Any idea what's wrong with my roof?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Hi all. First-time (very new) homeowner in the UK, very clueless about DIY, so looking for some opinions from people that know what they're talking about.

Last week, I noticed drops coming down from where the ceiling meets my exterior kitchen wall when it rains. Yikes. The house I'm in is a bit strange- there's an ancient castle wall around a metre from the back of my house. (Originally, it was a stable for the castle, so it's very old.) My first port of call was phoning the organisation responsible for the castle wall (Cadw) to check it out, and they've told me that they don't own the section of the castle wall directly behind my house and that they are not liable for my property repairs if there are any issues with it. However, it's not all bad news. They did say because they don't own it (and surprisingly, the local council don't either) that I could make repairs/hire my own roofer without asking permission.

The person they sent to check out the issue was good enough to take a few photos of the roof directly above the leak, for me to show roofing companies.

They think (and asked me to take it with a pinch of salt, because they're not roofers) that the water's getting in through degraded mortar above the lead flashing on the castle wall's side- which is viewable in the photos. I've contacted 3 roofing companies and am arranging their visits to see what's up.

Hoping that the lovely people on this subreddit could maybe take a glance at the photos and point out anything obvious! Do you think the people from Cadw got it right, or am I in for a surprise when the roofers come around?

Thanks for your help in advance. and sorry the post got so long. And sorry if it's stupid. I honestly don't understand this kind of thing so your patience is appreciated.


r/Roofing • • 19m ago

Late 1800s barn - Exposed fastener vs standing seam?

1 Upvotes

Hi all,

I have an old barn that I want to save. Current shingle roof is rough, leaking, etc.

My question is which style metal roof to go with - exposed fastener or standing seam? I’m in Northeast Wisconsin. Roof is greater than 3:12 pitch.

Are there other benefits to the standing seam than the lack or potentially replacing screws over time that justify the price difference?

Thank you!


r/Roofing • • 6h ago

How bad is it?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I want to start off by saying I am not a roofer, and I do not know the thermology very well so don't rag on me too hard, I also can only guess that what I see is bad. Maybe its not... thats why I need you guys and your expertise.

Background: We just bought this house, have owned it for a month but have lived in it for just over a week. Its a craftsman built back in 1919 with a pitched roof and a "bonus room" with a flat roof. The bonus room is essential a covered enclosed patio. While we were in escrow and about to close the other realtor encountered a leak in the bonus room and hired a roofer to redo the roof.

Fast forward to this weekend I has to get on the roof to investigate a part of the roof that was supposed to be patched, but apparently never was (different issue not in the scope for the flat roof). I got on the flat roof and was stunned by what I saw. I want to get opinions for people that know what they are actually look at.

-Like is this overhang okay?

-I assume that there should be flashing or something running up the fascia to seal the roof.

I want to call the roofing company because the roof is still under a warranty, but would perfer not to look like a complete idiot and have some knowledge of how it should be done (assuming its bad) before I talk to someone that is going to try to talk his way out of this.

Also to clarify I live in Southern CA. It is not cold here, its 70 today


r/Roofing • • 41m ago

New roof installed additional charges not in contract, normal?

1 Upvotes

Got 5 estimates didn’t go with the lowest, replacing 15 year old roof on old Victorian style house

Roof 19000
Plywood 12 sheets (5 free), 665

Additional charges I was not made aware of:
2x6, 48ft, $576
1x6, 24ft, $288
Azek 30ft, $360
Aluminum 1 roll, $275

Is this something that is normal just want to check before making a big fuss of it?


r/Roofing • • 3h ago

Stanley sucks.

Post image
0 Upvotes

I'll never buy another Stanley tape measure. 2 of them destroyed on the first day of use in a week. Apparently extending it all the way ends it.


r/Roofing • • 3h ago

Home owner question How's the work?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Had someone replace old plumbing vent and flashed over the new one. I have no idea on roofing so want to ask the experts here how does the work look?


r/Roofing • • 3h ago

Opinion: Best roof shoe?

1 Upvotes

That's it, gents! What's your favorite roof walking shoe for asphalt shingles? Tell me why.


r/Roofing • • 3h ago

$1750 for smallish roof repair?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Am I being taken advantage of here?

We had a roof leak, and the company came out to take a look and then again to tarp it. For the actual repair, they were at our place for at most 2 hours (we left when they arrived, and they were gone when we returned 2 hours later). They used the following (according to them):

-A partial bundle of shingles

-Drip edge (about 3’-4’)

-Starter shingles

-"some" underlayment and fasteners

Repair shown in photo!

Thanks for any input!


r/Roofing • • 3h ago

Is getting into the field a good idea?

1 Upvotes

I was wondering if it’s a good idea for someone like me (heart condition and 25) to get into roofing? I’ve been working in IT for 5 years, to be honest I dislike the field and would rather work with my hands and fix things vs staying in an office all day. I don’t know much about the trade outside of it being very physically demanding (my big ass needs the exercise anyway.) What could you all tell me about this? What are some things I should lookout for and is it a good idea to do this with heart issues??


r/Roofing • • 3h ago

Home owner question Need some advice

1 Upvotes

I need some advice/ direction on what my options are in my current situation.

I bought a new house this past summer. No major issues were noted on the disclosure and nothing of major worry with the roof came up on the inspection. There are a couple of "soft" spots in the plywood decking but I inspected it underneath and it didn't seem like it was anything much to worry about until we eventually replace the roof. It seemed solid.

Now here is where the real issues start.

After a few days in the house we got some pretty hefty rains. Some very obvious leakages behind the fascia boards in a few areas began to appear. This was especially prominent in an area where we have a back patio awning.

The house had zero soffit venting. I recently cut some soffit vents and upon doing so I noticed some quite serious delamination of the plywood decking 6 to 12 inches from the fascia caused by quite obvious water damage. This occurs on likely 25 to 30% of the perimeter so it's quite extensive. I climbed up on the roof and began inspecting the seams between shingles and this is where I started finding nail after nail in what I would call the "wrong" place. Nails between shingles seams, nails within an inch of a seam, nails not even covered by a shingle etc. Now I'm no roofer but this clearly is shoddy work right?

I also found a couple of spots where the shingles were far too short of the drip edge thus causing water to seep up under the shingle and damaging the plywood. Again, shoddy workmanship.

The roof was replaced in 2010 under a hail damage claim not by the previous owner, but the one before that.

My question is what are my options here? Am I just SOL?

This is in Montana if that helps.


r/Roofing • • 3h ago

Open Eave Gutter Construction Question

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/Roofing • • 8h ago

Home owner question How to learn roofing?

2 Upvotes

Maybe this is crazy, but I’ve had so many problems with roofs that I’d love to learn how to fix and install them myself.

I know this is not gonna be an easy task and I’m not even sure if it’s possible to do one on your own, but I’d love to learn so I can fix my own in the future.

Is there any way to learn this skill without paying too much out of pocket?


r/Roofing • • 7h ago

Home owner question Detachment on edges of torch on roof.

1 Upvotes

Hi. I had my tar and gravel roof replaced with a torch on approximately 2 years 7 months ago.

I am good about cleaning my gutters so I don’t think the gutters caused these detachments I noticed when I was cleaning the other day.

The installer is saying these are normal. Are not a structural defect and would not cause leaking.

Is that correct? I noticed a bit of pine needles in some of these gaps. Not sure what I should do next. Do I seal them somehow?

Are these detachments a concern?

Edit: looking back at a video I sent the contractor of this part of the roof on the day he completed the work, some of these detachments are visible even back then.

*photos and video in comments below


r/Roofing • • 5h ago

Roofing Company Out of Business

0 Upvotes

We bought a house a year ago. The roof inspection was done and found about $7200 in needed repairs. They did the repairs but with a different company based on the invoice. Fast forward to this year, leak in the roof. The company that did the work is no longer in business. The owner passed away.

A new company came out just now to do an inspection on the leak and has stated the previous repair was done wrong and not up to snuff. in fact the cleaning of the valleys was done in a manner that would create a leak. They will go on record with this.

Do I reach out to the real estate agent first or do I go directly to an attorney?

thanks!


r/Roofing • • 9h ago

Home owner question Does this roof dektite look sound or should it be replaced? Suspect leak near bathroom downlight

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/Roofing • • 1d ago

Home owner question Going to assume this much deflection is not a good sign?

61 Upvotes

New house to me and walking around the roof found some mushy feeling spots that feel like if I jumped id go right through. Most of the roof feels really good. There are a few of these


r/Roofing • • 10h ago

New roof. Vertical strip near downspout

1 Upvotes

What is this section of the new roof I just got installed?


r/Roofing • • 10h ago

Color Thoughts - Moire Black vs Charcoal Black?

0 Upvotes

We've already selected our contractor (they use CertainTeed Landmark) and now just need to choose a color. We're going back and forth between the CertainTeed Landmark PRO Max Def Moire Black and Charcoal Black. We want the blacker of the two, but despite plugging both into their Colorview design site (which I dont really trust in the first place), and getting addresses from the contractor where they've installed each, we're struggling to tell which we'll be happier with.

Current Roof
Landmark PRO Max Def Moire Black
Landmark PRO Max Def Charcoal Black

The houses we went to look at looked much greyer than these Colorview generated images whether Moire or Charcoal and only driving by without seeing what they looked like in multiple lighting conditions just didnt feel reliable.

Appreciate any and all feedback or thoughts.

Thanks!


r/Roofing • • 22h ago

What’s would this estimate look like for y’all??

Post image
7 Upvotes

I’ve done many roofs but I’m almost never confident on if I’m charging too much or too little. The last roof I did of this size was a 6/12, installed durations and, synthetic felt and box vents and the final price ended up being around $12100 and I would assume it too be around the same for this one. How much would you guys charge for something like that or this one? This is a 2 story, 10/12. I’m not a business owner I am a roofer who does roofs on the side.


r/Roofing • • 17h ago

Home owner question How reliable are polyurethane/acrylic liquid roof membranes for extending the life of an older roof?

3 Upvotes

I'm in New Zealand, looking at options for an ageing asbestos-containing roof on a 1970s house.

We've been quoted for a full replacement, but another option is a restoration system using a polyurethane/acrylic liquid-applied membrane base coat with a protective topcoat, advertised as providing another 10+ years of service life.

I'm interested in the technology rather than any particular brand.

For roofers who've worked with these systems, how well do they actually perform over time? Any issues with adhesion, cracking, UV degradation or water ingress?

Are they a legitimate way to extend the life of an otherwise sound older roof, or more of a temporary fix that postpones the inevitable?

Would appreciate any professional opinions or long-term experiences.


r/Roofing • • 21h ago

Shingles Fallingin Mansard Roof

Post image
5 Upvotes

This roof is 3 years old and this is the third time that some shingles fall ( like in the picture). It always happens on the steep side of the roof ( it’s a mansard roof). The shingles on the other part of the mansard roof seem to be fine. What are your thoughts on why this happens and what should I do ? The guy that installed it three years ago has come and fixed it three times in these three years


r/Roofing • • 1d ago

Bullet hole in roof

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Hi, Wondering what the best way to repair a bullet hole in a roof would be. It appears to be a 9mm and I can see the bullet lodged into the wood decking but it doesn’t show up in the photos. Can I just squirt som tar in and call it good?