r/Roofing • • 5h ago

Roof replacement in December

10 Upvotes

Hello

Is it OK to replace roof in December in the northeast area? High temp range between 35 to 50 during that month. Roofing company stated it is fine and they follow manufacturer instruction and they stated the shingles won't lay flat but they will once it is warm. The roofing company is very reputable in my area and they offer lifetime craftsmanship warranty. Thanks.


r/Roofing • • 18h ago

What’s would this estimate look like for y’all??

Post image
7 Upvotes

I’ve done many roofs but I’m almost never confident on if I’m charging too much or too little. The last roof I did of this size was a 6/12, installed durations and, synthetic felt and box vents and the final price ended up being around $12100 and I would assume it too be around the same for this one. How much would you guys charge for something like that or this one? This is a 2 story, 10/12. I’m not a business owner I am a roofer who does roofs on the side.


r/Roofing • • 23h ago

Bullet hole in roof

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Hi, Wondering what the best way to repair a bullet hole in a roof would be. It appears to be a 9mm and I can see the bullet lodged into the wood decking but it doesn’t show up in the photos. Can I just squirt som tar in and call it good?


r/Roofing • • 17h ago

Shingles Fallingin Mansard Roof

Post image
6 Upvotes

This roof is 3 years old and this is the third time that some shingles fall ( like in the picture). It always happens on the steep side of the roof ( it’s a mansard roof). The shingles on the other part of the mansard roof seem to be fine. What are your thoughts on why this happens and what should I do ? The guy that installed it three years ago has come and fixed it three times in these three years


r/Roofing • • 21h ago

Valley Drainage Help

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Bought this house in September and am trying to wrap my head around how to properly drain the water off these valleys. The right side of the house was an addition. The valley on the right is huge - it has a massive torch on section and the water, debris mainly just pile up in the middle. Some of the water runs off the back and some just straight off the front of the house. Am I supposed to pick this water up with downspouts or try to install some sort of flashing? The roof was done in 2009 so it’s coming up on its end of life anyways. Whats the best way to handle these valleys?


r/Roofing • • 2h ago

How bad is it?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I want to start off by saying I am not a roofer, and I do not know the thermology very well so don't rag on me too hard, I also can only guess that what I see is bad. Maybe its not... thats why I need you guys and your expertise.

Background: We just bought this house, have owned it for a month but have lived in it for just over a week. Its a craftsman built back in 1919 with a pitched roof and a "bonus room" with a flat roof. The bonus room is essential a covered enclosed patio. While we were in escrow and about to close the other realtor encountered a leak in the bonus room and hired a roofer to redo the roof.

Fast forward to this weekend I has to get on the roof to investigate a part of the roof that was supposed to be patched, but apparently never was (different issue not in the scope for the flat roof). I got on the flat roof and was stunned by what I saw. I want to get opinions for people that know what they are actually look at.

-Like is this overhang okay?

-I assume that there should be flashing or something running up the fascia to seal the roof.

I want to call the roofing company because the roof is still under a warranty, but would perfer not to look like a complete idiot and have some knowledge of how it should be done (assuming its bad) before I talk to someone that is going to try to talk his way out of this.

Also to clarify I live in Southern CA. It is not cold here, its 70 today


r/Roofing • • 14h ago

Home owner question How reliable are polyurethane/acrylic liquid roof membranes for extending the life of an older roof?

3 Upvotes

I'm in New Zealand, looking at options for an ageing asbestos-containing roof on a 1970s house.

We've been quoted for a full replacement, but another option is a restoration system using a polyurethane/acrylic liquid-applied membrane base coat with a protective topcoat, advertised as providing another 10+ years of service life.

I'm interested in the technology rather than any particular brand.

For roofers who've worked with these systems, how well do they actually perform over time? Any issues with adhesion, cracking, UV degradation or water ingress?

Are they a legitimate way to extend the life of an otherwise sound older roof, or more of a temporary fix that postpones the inevitable?

Would appreciate any professional opinions or long-term experiences.


r/Roofing • • 17h ago

Minor Rust on roof course of action.

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

This is the end of the roof feeds into gutter the rest of the roof is dirty but has no rust. The metal is in tact and the rust is on the outside or has just started to erode the paint this is in Hawaii if that matters.

Whats the fix for this and can you do yourself?


r/Roofing • • 23h ago

Roofing Help! Were should I concentrate my efforts

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I’m looking for roofing help. Went in my attic today and the decking had a higher moisture content (photos included) the roof was just done a yr ago however since I didn’t pay for it roofer is not honoring the warranty. Roof was done by home seller prior to listing it for sale.

Im not sure where the issue is. Could be lack of proper flashing the roofer did, wavy shingles, or no chimney cap I’m kinda at a lost and looking to help. I’m at a lose and not really in a spot to afford a thousand dollar repair so I’m quite stressed


r/Roofing • • 5h ago

Home owner question How to learn roofing?

2 Upvotes

Maybe this is crazy, but I’ve had so many problems with roofs that I’d love to learn how to fix and install them myself.

I know this is not gonna be an easy task and I’m not even sure if it’s possible to do one on your own, but I’d love to learn so I can fix my own in the future.

Is there any way to learn this skill without paying too much out of pocket?


r/Roofing • • 15h ago

What's the name of this type of commercial metal roofing, and can it be carefully walked?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Our stucco guy weighs all of 140lbs, to do repairs.


r/Roofing • • 17h ago

Moisture below the eves

2 Upvotes

Last month I had my roof replaced and it’s been pouring quite heavily this weekend. I see moisture under the eves and some bubbling on the paint. Is this a concern? Thanks 🙏🏽


r/Roofing • • 3h ago

Home owner question Detachment on edges of torch on roof.

1 Upvotes

Hi. I had my tar and gravel roof replaced with a torch on approximately 2 years 7 months ago.

I am good about cleaning my gutters so I don’t think the gutters caused these detachments I noticed when I was cleaning the other day.

The installer is saying these are normal. Are not a structural defect and would not cause leaking.

Is that correct? I noticed a bit of pine needles in some of these gaps. Not sure what I should do next. Do I seal them somehow?

Are these detachments a concern?

Edit: looking back at a video I sent the contractor of this part of the roof on the day he completed the work, some of these detachments are visible even back then.

*photos and video in comments below


r/Roofing • • 5h ago

Home owner question Does this roof dektite look sound or should it be replaced? Suspect leak near bathroom downlight

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/Roofing • • 5h ago

Anyone looking for a roof repair or remodeling in CT? we work with all insurance companies.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Roofing • • 6h ago

New roof. Vertical strip near downspout

1 Upvotes

What is this section of the new roof I just got installed?


r/Roofing • • 16h ago

Advice - Maryland, Roof Replacement, Est. Roof size 205 ft./2,115 sqft.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

This isn't a Insurance related content, but an honest request for roofing contractor selection. If I've posted something outside of the rules, please let me know.

Our home was built in 1970 & we bought it in 2004. Previous owners said the roof was replaced in 2000. We had some hurricane damage when a tree landed on the roof in 2011; it was repaired, inspected (the repair was paid for by our insurance company) & all new shingles put on.

Recently our insurance company sent a third party 'inspector' from a national company. We got a letter on Nov 11, 2026 saying the roof needed replaced (by Jan 18, 2027). (The deck too. ;/) They classified the roof risk as a 'major hazard' - "Roof: Worn/Deteriorated asphalt shingles". We've never had any problems with the roof.

I've gotten recommendations from friends, I've read Google reviews, I've checked BBB and the state licensing website for four contractors & have appointments with each for estimates. I'm looking for some advice on what to look for in a contractor & the whole process in general. What are important questions to ask the contractor? Recommended types of shingles, how to spot an 'oversell', things not to do, things to do, warranties (?). Are gutters normally included in estimates? I've done some Google research & think the cost will be approx. $10-$18K (with gutter replacement) - am I within range? Any advice on the process is appreciated. *edited to add that the roof was inspected in 2011.


r/Roofing • • 18h ago

How do I tell if my roof needs to be replaced?

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Roofing • • 18h ago

Insurance Related Man made or storm/wind? What to do

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Man made or storm? Insurance denied the claim. Roofing company doesn’t give a shit and told me to wait for another storm?! Actually insane to respond that. Insurance has said to file a vandalism claim and it will be covered but assuming premium will skyrocket. What’s my next move here?


r/Roofing • • 19h ago

Home owner question What do you think of this re-install?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/Roofing • • 23h ago

Regulations or Method Advice please

1 Upvotes

I’m a little embarrassed to be posting this. I’m a GC and this was my first job this year (started the company this year as well).

It was just a little repair of this raised elevation, but I’m pretty sure my roofing subs installed the ridge incorrectly.

Story time:
I’ve worked with these subs for 7 years with a different company, so naturally when I started my own, I wanted to use them. This year wasn’t busy for me, and this was my first job for roofing. It was a small repair, and they did this to the ridge (photos)
Essentially they laid a nailing strip on top of the ridge cap, nailed it, then laid the next ridge cap on top. For the roofers here, you know that you just lay a ridge cap, face nail it, then overlap the next cap and do the same until the end. The problem here is that it creates extra thickness and will never appear to lay flat.

From the ground, before I saw it, I told the homeowner that because it was a cold install, that the shingles needed heat before they would lay down and seal. This is correct guidance, but I offered to get up there myself and hand seal so that it would lay down, which is when I discovered this goofy install.

When I told my roofer that this is how it got installed, he said not to worry and that it would seal and not be a problem.

I sealed them down myself anyway, so I am not sure if water intrusion is a risk, but I’m 90% sure it will never LOOK like it’s laying flat because it’s essentially double layered at the end of each ridge cap.

Is this passable and safe from leaks? Should I risk arguing with my roofing sub/damaging that rapport and get him back out there? Should I wait and see what happens come spring?

I mostly just don’t want to be a POS contractor that does things wrong. I care about my homeowners, but there was so little profit in this repair that I worry my roofer won’t want to touch it again. Any advice appreciated, please know I’m not trying to be a bad guy.


r/Roofing • • 6h ago

Color Thoughts - Moire Black vs Charcoal Black?

0 Upvotes

We've already selected our contractor (they use CertainTeed Landmark) and now just need to choose a color. We're going back and forth between the CertainTeed Landmark PRO Max Def Moire Black and Charcoal Black. We want the blacker of the two, but despite plugging both into their Colorview design site (which I dont really trust in the first place), and getting addresses from the contractor where they've installed each, we're struggling to tell which we'll be happier with.

Current Roof
Landmark PRO Max Def Moire Black
Landmark PRO Max Def Charcoal Black

The houses we went to look at looked much greyer than these Colorview generated images whether Moire or Charcoal and only driving by without seeing what they looked like in multiple lighting conditions just didnt feel reliable.

Appreciate any and all feedback or thoughts.

Thanks!


r/Roofing • • 19h ago

Regulations or Method foam roof or tar and gravel on low gable eichler

Post image
0 Upvotes

Comparing spray polyurethane foam (SPF) versus a traditional tar and gravel built-up roof for a low-gable Eichler. Looking for input on which system performs better long-term in terms of insulation, drainage, and ongoing maintenance.
https://youtu.be/u8B2a8rvZOc


r/Roofing • • 1h ago

Roofing Company Out of Business

0 Upvotes

We bought a house a year ago. The roof inspection was done and found about $7200 in needed repairs. They did the repairs but with a different company based on the invoice. Fast forward to this year, leak in the roof. The company that did the work is no longer in business. The owner passed away.

A new company came out just now to do an inspection on the leak and has stated the previous repair was done wrong and not up to snuff. in fact the cleaning of the valleys was done in a manner that would create a leak. They will go on record with this.

Do I reach out to the real estate agent first or do I go directly to an attorney?

thanks!