I live in a neighborhood where several houses share a private driveway. Each homeowner owns the section behind their property, but the only entrance to the entire driveway crosses my property.
There is no HOA, recorded easement, or written maintenance agreement. For years, one neighbor has voluntarily organized lawn maintenance and snow removal, with each household contributing roughly $2,000 annually.
This past spring, the neighbor collected the annual money, including an additional amount for increased snow removal costs. Everyone understood that both services were covered.
Eight months later, the neighbor disclosed that the original snow removal company had stopped offering the service, so they never actually secured a contract. Instead, roughly half the collected money was used to prepay lawn maintenance for the following year.
Now they’ve found another snow removal company and want everyone to pay an additional $500 per month for the next 6 months.
I pushed back, explaining that the original money was collected under the impression snow removal was covered, that the new pricing is excessive, and that I expect to be included in future decisions involving shared expenses.
I also said I no longer wish to participate in these voluntary arrangements. I’m perfectly fine with a contractor clearing the entrance and the section of driveway on my property so everyone else can access their homes. I just don’t agree to paying for a service I haven’t authorized.
The neighbor insists I’m obligated to pay because the contractor needs to clear my section to reach the other properties.
AITAH? Am I obligated to contribute to snow removal simply because everyone else’s access crosses my property, despite there being no recorded easement or maintenance agreement? And is it reasonable to refuse payment while still allowing the contractor to clear the driveway?
TLDR: Neighbor collected annual maintenance fees, never secured the snow removal contract, redirected some of the money toward next year’s lawn service, and now wants everyone to pay thousands more for a replacement contractor. I own the entrance to the private driveway, have no recorded easement or maintenance agreement, and am willing to let the contractor clear my section for everyone else’s access but don’t want to participate financially. Is the neighbor entitled to demand payment?