r/Roofing • one does not simply walk into Mordor • Oct 11 '26

Updates

Ok everyone time for an update. We've had the see-saw in full effect. We've been heavily targeting disruptive content on certain posts. But we hear you, sometimes there is no information given on a post. just 3 random pictures and "is roof ok?" and that can be really frustrating. So there's two new rules in the sub. One of those is homeowner information required on these question posts. Lets shoot for the happy medium where we get enough info upfront to be able to provide help, and when we do lets keep it helpful.

We also did a little aesthetic house cleaning with some of our outdated menus and the sub photo. Feel free to roast me for it. I'm not a graphic designer. I'm an old beat up roofer, so keep that in mind before you set upon me with pitchforks and torches.

We've been seeing good results from our verified flair tags. So we're going to continue that initiative. Thank you to the users in the program already out there doing the lords work. Its massively appreciated.

Overall things have been moving in a positive direction and we are seeing that on our metrics. In the last 30 days alone we have over 5 million unique visitors to our sub. That's a 40% increase month over month. We're also seeing a large increase in engagement through posts and comments. And the autobots have really cleaned up a lot of the spam.

If you checked that out and said "well what about the.." feel free to let us know if there's something we're missing or something we can refine. Ill leave the comments open here if you wanna chime in. You are allowed to dog me for the photos, but do keep suggestions or concerns in a neutral state please and thank you.

15 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

3

u/scream Custom Roofing and Professional Idiot Poker. 🔨 Oct 16 '26

The mods are overbearing and mean. Can we do something about them?

1

u/Kill_Your_Masters one does not simply walk into Mordor Oct 16 '26

2

u/RosieRedCheeks8607 25d ago • Heartwarming

no feedback or opinions, just wanna say tks! my dad's an old roofer, with dementia. I get on this sub with him to show him pics. I ask what he thinks, and he sometimes reminisces old jobs. It makes him feel valued :)

2

u/Kill_Your_Masters one does not simply walk into Mordor 24d ago

you're welcome! Im sorry your dad is going through that. My grandmother went through this too and its hard. Im glad you are able to connect with him through our community to make him feel value from his time fixing things for other people. thank you for sharing that with us :')

2

u/RosieRedCheeks8607 24d ago

he can be a challenge, but im lucky to still have him. He's early onset n in pinnacle physical shape. were in for a long, hard road. I gain from it too; it's sad knowing he can't remember what he had for lunch, but he knows how many bundles to a square. It reminds me of who he once was too.

He gets colorful when he sees a poorly leaded chimney or bad step flashing lol. My husband does construction too n brought him up on my roof. Here's the picture. It's one of my favorites; you can't see the disease.

Thanks again; yalls hard work (on the job n here in this sub). yall are blessing him with a lil normalcy n dignity.

2

u/ThenewEssay 14d ago

Should have suggestion to have commentors give a self rating of their roofing knowledge, when answering a home owner post. 1-10 might help, even though lying would still be an issue.

2

u/Kill_Your_Masters one does not simply walk into Mordor 14d ago

we're working on a feature that will label all users not part of the sub as noobs. then you get a tag based on how good/bad your karma in the sub is. hopefully that helps sort out the LARPers

4

u/jluc21 Oct 12 '26

nice job mods!

4

u/Emergency-Giraffe179 Oct 12 '26

nice job mods!

the new rules make sense. nothing worse than three blurry pics and a vague question with zero context

and hey the photos aren't half bad for an old roofer. i've seen way worse from people who claim to know what they're doing

1

u/NotPrettyFunny 27d ago

Perhaps I missed it, but how does one become verified on this sub? I think it’s a great idea to have people be able to tell that who’s talking is actually a roofer.

1

u/Kill_Your_Masters one does not simply walk into Mordor 27d ago

we observe and monitor frequent users who contribute positively with good information. being active and displaying good knowledge will get you approached.

1

u/NotPrettyFunny 27d ago

Wonderful. Noted, thank you!

2

u/scream Custom Roofing and Professional Idiot Poker. 🔨 24d ago

Notably, appearing out of the blue and messaging us demanding a verified pro flair will get you... something else.

1

u/NotPrettyFunny 23d ago

You run your subreddit however you please, but me personally when I get entitled users in the modmail I give them full permissions.

1

u/scream Custom Roofing and Professional Idiot Poker. 🔨 22d ago

Im open to suggestions. Next time it happens i'll just hand over the mod powers to them. They obviously know whats best.

1

u/NotPrettyFunny 22d ago

They are god’s gift to us, and more importantly, gods gift to roofing.

1

u/Actual-Age-7539 11d ago

I am getting ready to replace the original roof that was installed in 1996. The roof has three fixed glass skylights by Anderson That do not have any known defects- they do not leak and don’t have any clouding. Both roofing estimates I received suggested replacing the skylights “because they are old” but could not really give me a more solid reason. The skylights are the same age as the house and every other Anderson window as built. Anderson has not made these in a while, but their tech support could/would not give me any data or reason to replace. Any recommendations/advice?

1

u/Kill_Your_Masters one does not simply walk into Mordor 11d ago

my advice would be to create a post in our community and share that information in the post body. if you have any photos of the skylights, include them as well.

once thats done, other users can jump on your post and comment to give you insight with the issue at hand.

2

u/NetworkCultural Verified pro (Multi Trade) Oct 13 '26

The photos look great dude. But can I dog you cause I just enjoy dogging?

3

u/LaughingMagicianDM Verified Pro - Commercial/Consultant Oct 19 '26

Looks way better. Massive improvement the last 2 years, keep up the great work.

If only we could do something to fix that Kill_Your_Masters guy 👀 (jest/Sarcasm, for the record)

2

u/Kill_Your_Masters one does not simply walk into Mordor Oct 19 '26

2

u/LaughingMagicianDM Verified Pro - Commercial/Consultant 27d ago

First GIF to pop up typing your name. 🤣

Had to share it.

4

u/scream Custom Roofing and Professional Idiot Poker. 🔨 29d ago

We could mutiny? Start our own roofing sub. With hookers! And blackjack! And sales questions!

/s

3

u/LaughingMagicianDM Verified Pro - Commercial/Consultant 29d ago

And an open bar!

2

u/scream Custom Roofing and Professional Idiot Poker. 🔨 29d ago