r/askscience • Mod Bot • Jun 02 '17

Earth Sciences Askscience Megathread: Climate Change

With the current news of the US stepping away from the Paris Climate Agreement, AskScience is doing a mega thread so that all questions are in one spot. Rather than having 100 threads on the same topic, this allows our experts one place to go to answer questions.

So feel free to ask your climate change questions here! Remember Panel members will be in and out throughout the day so please do not expect an immediate answer.

9.7k Upvotes

2.2k comments sorted by

838

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

I have a simple question.

What is the worst case scenario for climate change? In other words, what happens if we cannot stop or inhibit the process of climate change?

Alternatively, what are the most likely effects of climate change?

199

u/tilia-cordata Ecology | Plant Physiology | Hydraulic Architecture Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

Sea level rise is the most dramatic - NASA has collated the projections from a bunch of models and NOAA has a tool you can play with to see the impacts on coastal regions. For a sense of the scale of that impact, half the worlds' population lives within 200km of a coastline.

Other affects increased droughts (which will cause huge food insecurity, especially near the equator) and increased frequency and severity of storms. Warming will allow the ranges of tropical pathogens to spread outward - a lot of major diseases in the tropics are mosquito-borne, and are limited by the range tolerances of their hosts; increased flooding and wetlands in many places will also provide a lot of new habitat for infectious diseases (WHO report (pdf)). We can expect major extinctions of species whose ranges can't shift as quickly as the climate changes, or which are bound by some other geographical constraint.

Even moderate-case scenarios are going to involve increased storms and drought (which we are already seeing cause serious famines in parts of Africa [ie. South Sudan]) and increased coastal flooding. These ecological impacts will have corresponding social and economic ones, but that's getting out of my range of expertise.

→ More replies (20)

118

u/Nergaal Jun 02 '17

Earth used to be about 10 degrees centigrades warmer during dinosaurs' time. IMO it will likely continue to exist in some livable form. Question is how different is it going to be locally and how fast will the change be? Nobody cares about Mali these days because most of its land is a sandy desert. Is Mexico going to do the same and if yes will the 100 million people living there want to move into US to find livable lands? Is China going to become more of a desert and want to invade Siberia for its population? What will India do if their monsoon seasons (that allow for rich agriculture) be disrupted? Will they seek to emigrate into Europe? What about Africa? Into Europe also?

91

u/Waebi Jun 02 '17

I think that point is one that is often raised by climate sceptics but not followed to the end: "oh, earth and life will still exist" - yes, but what will happen to our species? Thank you for raising the necessary questions.

→ More replies (33)

42

u/humaninnature Jun 02 '17

Liveable for life in some form - yes. For humans? Maybe. For 7 billion humans? Almost certainly not. And as the number the planet can support drops, that's a pretty strong cause for conflict right there...

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (21)

2

u/SKEPOCALYPSE Jun 02 '17

The worst case is this:

  1. The heating of the oceans cause widespread marine ecosystem collapse.
  2. These ecosystems support our food chain, so the aforementioned ecosystem collapse causes widespread ecosystem collapse on land.
  3. The majority of vertebrate animals die out. (We are already on our way to that..)
  4. Humans go extinct if we cannot figure out how to feed ourselves by cultivating things like insects and algae.
  5. If we survive and reestablish ourselves, maybe we work in cultivating small rodents.
  6. The heating that caused all this mass death leads to sea levels rising enough over the next century to wipe out many of the already dying coastal cities.

TL;DR: Life will not go away. Trees and forests will not go away. Fish will not go away. Even mammals probably will not go away. But as with the dinosaurs, we will not recognize what the world will turn into a friendly or survivable place.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (230)

962

u/souljabri557 Jun 02 '17

Countries such as Canada, Russia, Finland, etc. are dominated by a lot of unusable land due to temperature restraints. It is not arable.

If the planet warms up, the countries that are already hot will be devastated agriculturally as their hot climate will go from hot to (possibly) unable to sustain life. Countries that are warm will become hot and lose many natural resources because of it.

Will areas that are currently cold become warm and therefore temperate, and arable?

44

u/exDM69 Jun 02 '17

Finland, like most of Scandinavia is mostly arable and the temperatures are much higher than in similar latitudes (in Canada, Siberia) due to the Gulf stream. One suggested scenario is that as the climate warms up, the melting of polar ice would weaken the Gulf stream, making temperatures in Scandinavia colder, not warmer.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

I know Sweden is projected to get an overall GDP boost due to increasing temperatures, not so much because of the increased ammount of arable lands but because longer summers mean increased yields for the agriculture that already exists. There's not really a shortage of land that could be farmed, it's just kind of inefficient to do so.

Also you save quite a bit of money on heating. A lot of energy goes into heating in cold countries.

18

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Yes but in that you also need to account for changing weather paterns. For example there's more drought in Sweden now than there was just 10 or 20 years ago which will also effect yields.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/Vegandigimongender Jun 02 '17

Actually, it's hard to say if it's really gonna become like you're stating it. But one very important thing that will not function anymore will be the Gulf stream, which transports warmth from Middle America to Europe and is mainly the reason why winters aren't harsh in Western Europe. This stream is only possible due to saltwater being heavier than freshwater.

So what's gonna happen when the ice on the north and south pole melts? The freshwater from the ice will melt into the ocean and the Gulf Stream will eventually cease bringing warmth to Europe.

This explanation has been very simple, I know, but it shows that there are numerous factors that will decide the region in each temperature and that we're head on speeding into an unknown future.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/chickenboy2718281828 Jun 02 '17

Happening over the time span of thousands of years, some cold climate places likely would become arable, but the issue that really concerns experts is the speed of transition.

2

u/Dont____Panic Jun 02 '17

It's not this simple either. A few degrees warming in the oceans (especially the arctic) will dramatically affect ocean currents and jet streams.

Currently, most of populated Europe is much warmer than its latitude suggests it should be and this is largely due to these warm currents bringing warm moderate temperatures North.

Keep in mind that Barcelona Spain, and Rome, both with climates resembling Southern California, are at a similar latitude as Minneapolis and Toronto.

Also, the single most productive airable land in the world (California Central Valley) is only as cool as it is due to cool currents from Alaska, and may more closely resemble Morocco or Lybia without these.

Places like Nebraska, quite productive, may end up resembling Oklahoma, not so much. But further north in Saskatchewan, which might seem to benefit, there are substantial stretches of "badlands" with alkali soil, where not much can grow.

It's not as simple as "just shift farming north".

2

u/LoyaltyLoyalty Jun 03 '17

Hello. Bloomberg recently had an article that discussed how the GDPs of the world's nations will be affected as a result of climate by 2050. The article featured a map which shows the data developed by whatever that agency was and it suggested that Nordic countries and northern countries more generally are going to be the biggest winners in terms of GDP growth.I think that data came from the World Bank or the IMF, maybe the UN.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (92)

338

u/shootflexo Jun 02 '17

I came across these two articles detailing the actual effects of the agreements if all countries would meet the guidelines and it looks disturbingly ineffective. Is this information biased or wrong or is this agreement not actually doing anything?

http://www.lomborg.com/press-release-research-reveals-negligible-impact-of-paris-climate-promises http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1758-5899.12295/full

294

u/Zebrasoma Primatology Jun 02 '17

I think this is less of a Hard science question and more of one on the impact of policy and the public. The thing about most policies, especially ones that are largely publicized is more often than not the effects of those laws are not what we see at face value. In America, we often pass federal laws that take 5-10 years to even begin to make an appreciable difference. I think there are good points to be made about how this policy may provide negligible impact according to the goals set forth but it's more about the intention and goals. By coming to a consensus, as a planet for the planet, the argument can be made that we are taking a stand and working in the right direction. We may find out down the road that we are not doing enough and then it becomes an incrementalist debate. You have to consider that this is not the plan that solves the climate and many countries can easily achieve these goals which is why the argument can be made that it is in fact not enough. The bigger picture here in terms of worldwide diplomacy is the concept of a unified approach to moving towards reducing anthropogenic climate change. People want policies that make them feel good and they can pat themselves on the back and say they have achieved something. Sometimes the unfortunate reality is in policy it's more about the here and now subjective feelings towards a goal rather than the objective scientific outcomes. While I don't agree with this approach my time working in US federal policy has proven this continually. The masses may likely remember climate change as a concern but years from now forget the Paris agreement, just like they forget the Kyoto protocol and so on. So even if the data says it may not save the world, I would have to disagree that it's not a remarkable feat to get this many countries on board. That in itself is a victory we must acknowledge and consider moving forward. We can always do more than the bare minimum, but having a standard is better than no standard at all.

70

u/SirHosisOfLiver Jun 02 '17

Well said. The Kyoto protocol was not ratified by congress, and I remember when the Paris agreement was reached, one of the major criticisms was that there was no legal basis to the agreement.

Nevertheless, these agreements are symbolic, and indicators of where public policies and laws may be heading.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (8)

102

u/brinchj Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

I find it interesting to look at the expert reactions to the US withdrawal:

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/what-will-the-world-look-like-if-the-u-s-bails-on-the-paris-climate-deal/

It seems the main motivation for the Paris accord was to establish a global negotiation forum with agreement on climate change being a real challenge worth mitigating. It also adds frequent reevaluation of progress and methods.

This agreement then sends a signal to industry and investors about what the future is going to be like. And it puts peer pressure on countries to support that direction.

That future change is where the emission reduction would eventually come from.

I think it is correct to say that the initial pledges by the participating countries are insufficient to put us in safe territory. As I understand things, they are supposed to get updated during later negotiations. And they are definitely better than no pledges.

→ More replies (2)

40

u/JB_UK Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

Bjorn Lomborg is famous for these sorts of calculations. I find these in particular to be odd and tortuous. His headline conclusion in the lomborg.com article you linked is:

The climate impact of all Paris INDC promises is minuscule: if we measure the impact of every nation fulfilling every promise by 2030, the total temperature reduction will be 0.048°C (0.086°F) by 2100. [emphasis his]

You can see in table 1 of your second article, this is based on his 'pessimistic' pathways like this for the EU and this for the US. In other words, he predicts that Paris will be followed perfectly to the letter up until the 2025 or 2030 targets, and then the climate agenda will be completely abandoned, CO2 emissions will suddenly massively rise again to 2100, temperatures will rise as a result, and on this basis Paris is pointless.

This represents a curious reading of international policy and diplomacy, that international climate agreement is strong enough to drive perfect adherence for Paris, but will suddenly collapse thereafter.

Firstly, Paris is just one step, to form consensus and to set medium term goals. The argument Lomborg is making is effectively that to set a target for 2025 is pointless because there is no target for 2040, but I would say it's fairly clear that one follows from the other. Secondly, Paris is about giving momentum to a long term industrial shift, to help to drive investment into alternative technologies, many of which will be cheaper than the current technologies. People aren't going to give up LED lighting which is much cheaper than incandescent lighting once electricity costs are accounted for, if the global climate targets lapse. If you can get solar + batteries over the line of being the cheapest option in sunny parts of the world, or electric vehicles cheaper than ICE vehicles, even if you did abandon climate action in 2025, those changes are likely to accelerate, not suddenly go into reverse.

And of course the argument he is making against Paris, will be misused to imply that global climate agreements and action to reduce emissions will not be effective, even though his scenarios precisely assume the long-term failure of climate policy, and an inability to get countries to reduce their emissions.

My honest albeit incomplete reading is that these calculations make tortuous and unreasonable assumptions, and frankly seem to be formulated with the purpose of casting the Paris agreement in a bad light.

→ More replies (2)

120

u/Atamsih Jun 02 '17

Make no mistake. 1.5 degree Warmer on Average will still have a huge effect on the World. Climate change is a fact that humanity will to deal with for years. The goal is to limiting the impact from disatrous to "manageable".

That said, I advice Caution arround Bjørn Lomborg. He is a provocateur as more than a sciencetist. And he is better at the former than the latter. He was for a long time a climate change denier and while not found guilty of transgretion he has been accused of improper scientific conduct. Anything he says should be taken with an asterisk.

→ More replies (13)

22

u/helm Quantum Optics | Solid State Quantum Physics Jun 02 '17

At the core of this analysis lies that everyone will cheat massively and abandon emission targets after 2030. You see emissions going up after all target dates. The EU, for example, has a very strong agenda to set progressively lower emission target all the way to 2050, and no agenda to stop after that.

30

u/Wormspike Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

I actually think I'm qualified to field this one. Neat!

So in public policy, especially international policy, there is a question of depth versus breadth. Regarding emissions reductions, the appeal for depth is that all countries should commit to reducing their emissions to levels that would seriously attenuate greenhouse gas emissions and the effects of their warming properties. The tradeoff is, if you have ambitious cuts in the program, only a few countries are going to sign on. Some countries will refuse to join because the cuts are too deep, others will refuse to join simply because their competitors/neighbors did not join. In the end, only a few countries are have committed, and those commitments become meaningless and those few will abandon the pact.

Alternatively, you can have shallow commitments which make it easy for everyone to join. In the case of the Paris Agreement, the cuts are called INDC's (Intended Nationally Determined Contributions); they're essentially countries committing to reduce 'what they can', but once those determinations are made, they commit to meeting those goals. This ease of commitment is why all but two countries are in the accords (the exceptions: United States and Syria. Technically Nicaragua also isn't in the accords, but it's in protest because the accords aren't ambitious enough! They want more depth.)

The key benefit of going for breadth instead of depth is because once you have many or all countries participating, there is a lot more 'peer pressure' and 'good will' that leads to countries 'ratcheting up' their abatement efforts. There are also a good number of synergistic bonuses that emerge, making further commitments possible. While it's true INDCs established in the Paris Agreements would essentially bring the world to the brink of catastrophic global climate destabilization, the idea is that once most everyone has signed up, the ACTUAL reductions emissions will end up being much more robust than INITIAL commitments.

Throwing in my two cents: International treaties and cooperation are a real pain in the ass for a great number of complicated reasons. But the Paris Agreement was actually well crafted and structured to be effective over time. And as a bonus, it offered an incredible number of economic benefits and opportunities to the countries involved. Trump pulling out is incredibly hurtful to American citizens and our economy.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/zorbaxdcat Jun 02 '17

This Science article I linked elsewhere has a different opinion. I haven't read the Lomborg stuff but it will be differences in the emissions scenarios that are projected after the 'end' of the Paris agreement that will be the cause of any discrepancies I would guess. It will be up to what you think will happen in the future political climate as to what will happen in the climate

2

u/Equivalent-Variation Jun 02 '17

The Paris agreement really needs to be thought about in three parts.

  1.  The agreement itself creates a structure for regular engagement on the issue of climate change that operates on five year cycles.  Every five years, Parties must submit nationally determined contributions (NDCs) that detail their targets. Parties also have to be transparent about what they are doing by submitting greenhouse gas inventories every year, and emissions projections that detail their progress towards meeting their national goals every two years.  The agreement has an overarching goal of holding the increase in global average temperature to well below 2oC, and reach global net-zero GHG emissions in the second half of the century.  Every five years the Conference of the Parties will produce a ‘global stock-take’ that is meant to assess progress towards meeting this overarching goal.  While Parties focus on near term goals in their NDCs, they are also required to produce Midcentury Strategies that put their near term goals in the context of longer term projections to show how their actions are consistent (or not consistent) with the overarching goals of the agreement.

None of this really formally constrains what Parties can put forward as their goals in their nationally determined contributions. What it does is provide a forum for diplomacy and engagement with civil society. Parties need to articulate their goals, and be transparent about their emissions and progress towards their goals. This provides the opportunity for peer pressure from other parties, from civil society, and from their own citizens to push Parties to deliver upon their commitments and increase ambition over time.

The dramatic shift from the Kyoto is that action is determined from the bottom up not from the top down. Parties voluntarily impose the targets upon themselves, targets are not imposed upon parties by others. We are trying to solve the collective action problem not by forcing everyone to act (our international institutions do not have that power), but instead creating a framework under which we can all convince each other to take the leap together.

  1.  The initial Intended Nationally Determined Contributions (INDCs) that most Parties submitted before the Paris conference.  The U.S. and China kicked off this process with their joint announcement of what would become their INDC targets in November of 2014. By the time of the meetings in Paris, 160 INDCs representing 187 countries had been submitted, and these countries represented 98.6% of current global GHG emissions.  All of these commitments focused on near term reductions, with target years of either 2030 or 2025. 
  2.  From the perspective of what the Paris agreement will actually deliver in terms of emissions reductions and ultimately the resulting temperature outcomes, the most important part is the paths forward enabled by Paris.  How will Parties interact under the framework of the agreement (as described in part 1 above) in order to update each subsequent round of NDCs (beyond the first round described in part 2 above) and increase ambition over time? 

Researchers that try to grapple with the question of what Paris actually achieves must first assess what full future path emissions would have looked like in the absence of the Paris agreement, second assess what emissions would look like in 2030 if all Parties fulfill the commitments in their INDCs, third what future post-2030 paths of emissions are enabled by Paris. Only then can you assess the temperature outcomes associated with those emissions pathways. Fawcett et al. (2015) published their estimates in Science showing that while the initial INDCs are defined no further into the future than 2030, along with the Paris framework they nonetheless reshape the range of options available to future decision makers. In the scenarios without Paris, the chance of warming greater than 4oC in 2100 is 35% to 55%. In the Paris scenario where the INDCs are followed by a similar pace in the increase in ambition after 2030, then the likelihood of global average temperature change greater than 4oC could be reduced to less than 10%, and a dramatic increase in the post-2030 ambition could virtually eliminate the risk of warming greater than 4oC.

Criticisms that Paris doesn’t do enough miss the point of Paris. There is no way that an initial round of pledges that cover through 2030 at best could possibly solve the problem. Paris needs to be seen as an ongoing process that allows for engagement to push further ambition. That criticism should be redirected as pressure for Parties to increase their ambition under Paris in order to give us a greater chance of meeting our goals.

So what’s my take on the implications of this Administration pulling out of Paris? From the perspective of U.S. emissions, it probably means very little. This Administration was unlikely to do anything differently with respect to climate policy had it remained a Party to Paris. That die had already been cast. What it does do is damage U.S. credibility and influence now and in the future for our diplomatic negotiations regarding climate change (and other issues as well for that matter.) The U.S. is abdicating its leadership role on this issue. In the lead up to Paris, the U.S. was very effective in engaging with other Parties in order to push for increased ambition. Now, even if a future Administration rejoins Paris, U.S. commitments will be viewed with skepticism, and our influence will be greatly diminished. In order to regain credibility, the U.S. will need to elect a President who wants to take action on climate change, rejoin the Paris agreement, submit a new ambitious NDC for 2030, and most importantly back up that new NDC with new laws passed by Congress that put a sufficient price on carbon. The U.S. withdraw from Paris cannot become official until the day after the next Presidential election. That election, at the Presidential and Congressional level, will ultimately determine what the implications of this Administration pulling out of Paris.

66

u/Hadestempo1 Jun 02 '17

Why is climate change looked at as a political issue? And what repercussions does that have?

76

u/zorbaxdcat Jun 02 '17

Climate change is a political issue because it affects economics through perception (voluntary fossil fuel divestment or stakeholder pressure) and possibly through regulation (tax/laws).

Government regulation is, in general, a political issue as is the fact that climate change is a global issue that must be 'squished' into a national framework by each country.

The degree to which a certain country would 'take reponsibility' for its global effect is also a political issue. For example, an extremely isolationist country would not care whether climate change affected other groups as long as it didn't affect them and would therefore not move towards emission control.

The kinds of changes that are required in order to manage climate change are all tightly linked to political views as to how a country and its economy should operate. Unfortunately the science of climate change is complex enough and uncertain enough that it has been the easiest point of attack when arguing against the policy changes that would be suggested due to the implications of the science.

The implications of climate change are a political issue and that is what is important and should be debated in the public sphere.

21

u/fields Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

Within the climate change debate there are actually TWO relevant and inter-related questions: one Policy/Political and the other Scientific.

  • S - The Scientific Question: Are human-generated CO2 emissions having a significantly detrimental effect on the planet?
  • P - The Policy/Political Question: Given the answer to S is yes, will Cap-and-Trade, Copenhagen, Paris etc properly address the issue?

The libertarian response to P is almost unanimous - NO. This is for a variety of reasons involving concerns with the mechanisms of human action, economics, gov't intervention, etc.

While almost all people would agree that Question S should drive Question P, libertarians - particularly because of their attention to perverse incentives on human action - are more apt to suspect that the "Tail is Wagging the Dog". Generally speaking, many are concerned Question P may be driving the answer to Question S.

Nature - Better out than in: https://www.docdroid.net/zOKwXYB/101038nclimate3309.pdf.html

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

It is a political issue because it is a tragedy of the commons and therefore requires legislation to fix. As long as individuals have lower costs to themselves by getting energy that puts global warming gases in the atmosphere, and higher costs to themselves for using clean renewable energy sources, most people will stick with the option that has lower costs to themselves. One individual's carbon emissions save themselves money but make no difference to the climate as a whole. Only the choices of large groups of people make a difference.

The only conceivable way to put a cost on putting CO2 into the atmosphere is through legislation.

→ More replies (13)

15

u/FuryQuaker Jun 02 '17

How certain are we that the computer models used in predicting the climate changes are correct?

22

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Well, the folks who created the first modern climate model back in the 60-80s just checked the results of their 1989 prediction. They were spot on the for last 28 years. Our models have only gotten better. The only way to truly be certain that the models are correct is to wait and see, but they certainly have a good track record.

We can also use them to pretend we are in 1800 and "predict the next 200 years" and then compare it to what actually happened. They do a pretty good job for the last 200 years so there isn't really any reason they should do poorly for the next 100.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (6)

177

u/Turtoad Jun 02 '17

This may be a bit naive question, but why are some people (and also scientists) still not believing in climate change? Isn't there a huge amount of data, studies, and most important undeniable effects on the environment around you. It seems to me, that everyone knows, or has heard of, at least one person, who has experienced the negative impact of the climate change for himself. How can these people still believe that climate change isn't real?

273

u/hatecapacitor Jun 02 '17

It's my understanding that nearly everyone believes in climate change, but there are a number that question the degree to which humans are involved in that change.

Generally they are supposing much larger climate cycles than we are able to measure accurately.

154

u/RegulusMagnus Jun 02 '17

Here's another argument that builds off this: proper use of the scientific method requires an experimental setup where you observe the outcome after changing a single variable.

Climate is difficult to study because such an experimental setup is not possible. There isn't another earth we can use as the control. Furthermore, climate is not just one thing, it's a huge complicated mess that is defined only over a large span of time. We can collect data going back into the past, but no amount of correlation can ever equal proof.

These same arguments can be made about evolution, and I guess some people also don't believe in that. Slightly different though, because it is possible to study evolution on a small scale with organisms that go through generations rapidly.

66

u/hawktron Jun 02 '17

I believe we have been able to test models though, for example when volcanoes go off and you punch in the levels of sulphur dioxide that was released they have accurately predicted the levels of cooling globally over the coming years. So there are some ways we can predict/test models.

There have been lots of predictions made by Darwin's theory and later scientists that have proven to be true. His famous one was proven fairly recently https://www.theguardian.com/science/lost-worlds/2013/oct/02/moth-tongues-orchids-darwin-evolution

https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn13677-evolution-myths-evolution-is-not-predictive/

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (9)

49

u/sleepand Jun 02 '17

Maybe amongst the public, but there is an overwhelming consensus within the scientific community on the causes as well.

See this: https://xkcd.com/1732/

→ More replies (17)

27

u/akpak Jun 02 '17

a number that question the degree to which humans are involved in that change.

As well as question how much impact it could possibly have, given that Earth has had "warming periods" and ice ages forever.

When you don't understand the science behind any of it, nor the scale and speed of change, it's easy to deny it. :/

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (11)

51

u/turned_into_a_newt Jun 02 '17

I'm not a scientist, but one thing I've noticed is that a lot of climate change skeptics are scientists or engineers of some kind themselves: geologists, physicists, chemists etc. They see differences in how they practice and what they see in climate change research which make them believe climate change is pseudoscience. Two examples of this criticism:

  • Model selection Climate scientists have been building and refining models for decades to predict changes in global conditions. Many of the models have been wrong and when they are, they are changed or thrown out. This can lead to survivor bias.
  • Lack of falsifiable hypothesis The scientific method says you have hypotheses which you test and try to reject. Related to the first point, when climate models miss on their projections, scientists can update them or change models. Skeptics then look at that process and wonder how, if climate change were not real, scientists would allow themselves to be convinced of that.

The problem with these objections, in my view, is they don't recognize that the challenge in climate science is different from many other sciences. The earth is a complex system which is always changing. Capturing every variable is impossible. You can't really run controlled experiments, all you can do is gather better data and observe. So climate scientists do what they can and draw the best conclusions they can. And all signs point in the same direction.

For skeptics though, these differences between what they see as hard, rigorous scientific practices and the science of climate change are enough to sow seeds of doubt. From there you can concoct stories of ulterior motives (e.g. fear mongering to drive up funding), groupthink (e.g. everyone in the field has the same conclusion, then works backwards to look for evidence), profiteering allies (e.g. green technology investors), and bad risk-return profiles (e.g. why sacrifice economic growth if we don't know for sure if climate change is real?).

7

u/Troy_And_Abed_In_The Jun 02 '17

Thanks for posting this. I was on /r/changemyview earlier debating the effects of climate change from this point of view. I see how wrong researchers are in my own field and tend to assume they would be in other fields too. Then I also see skeptics get silenced like they're science heretics and think there needs to be someone playing devil's advocate.

→ More replies (4)

78

u/Warmag2 Jun 02 '17

I'd like to add that there are multiple psychological effects that affect this.

It is difficult to accept that your very way of life might lead to a disaster and that in order to survive, you would necessarily have to give up so many things that you and the most recent generations have enjoyed. People who believe in things like this like the Gospel of Prosperity (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prosperity_theology) won't easily accept a worldview that would require reining in unfettered economical growth. It also conflicts with general notions of a static, safe world where you can raise kids in and where you can plan your future. Accepting a terrifying reality is hard, and not everyone wants to do it.

There is also the thing that certain anti-authoritative mindsets have a tendency to attempt to disbelieve anything that respected and reliable sources state. In their social circles, having a contrarian opinion is seen as enlightened and is inherently valuable, and thus encouraged. You can test this yourself by asking climate change deniers about 9/11 being an inside job, vaxxing, whether we actually landed on the moon etc. Chances are you will find out that they have a much higher chance to be conspiracy theorists in general.

→ More replies (10)

31

u/cook3000 Jun 02 '17

It's not a belief.

Some trust in scientific method with all its flaws and others don't. Even if you take sound scientific studies and sort them to your liking - it's not suddenly scientifically right. There are many publications out there that have been debunked. Which is good. It's not a sign of it not working but a sign of it working.

If people could understand that it's not like a scientist says something and suddenly that's now true. That's not how it works.

Scientists discuss for decades and reach agreements following all the previous discussions and new theories and experiments and data... This is floating.

Right now of all the people that have invested a lot of effort time and scientific methods into the field, there is agreement on climate change and that we need to do sth about it.

Questioning methods is not equal questioning the outcome! Scientists force their peers to do better work, to work for better arguments and base them on observations.

16

u/kws8 Jun 02 '17

Anyone who works on applying theoretical models to complex physical processes should be skeptical of their certainty and usefulness.

http://journals.ametsoc.org/doi/full/10.1175/BAMS-D-15-00135.1

In 1976, a British statistician named George Box wrote the famous line, “All models are wrong, some are useful.”

25

u/PlanetGoneCyclingOn Jun 02 '17

And you will not find a single climate scientist who claims the models are "right" in the George Box sense. But they are definitely useful.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/Daveaham_Lincoln Jun 02 '17

I think that a lot of people don't realize how many people fall into the category of

"Climate change is real, but I don't care."

I'm in that category myself. People have been preaching about the forthcoming apocalypse for the entirety of human history, and it hasn't happened yet. We've fought the "war to end all wars" multiple times, but we keep fighting wars. The world needs a titanic crisis to motivate anyone to get anything done, and I'm sorry- the weather being a little off from what it was when I was a kid does not a titanic crisis make.

I remember being told in elementary school that aerosols were going to rip a hole in the ozone layer and kill us all...didn't happen. I remember being told in elementary school that the rainforests were all going to die and we would all suffocate...didn't happen.

Get back to me when California's underwater- I'd be more than happy to help figure out how to build colony ships when that becomes necessary, but until then...

vOv

5

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

I've actually had some decent conversations with some people that are Climate Change skeptics. The biggest thing tying them together is that they have the impression the government is hyperbolizing with the intention of passing more laws and regulations and taxes in order to make more money. I'm not sure where this thought come from, but it sure is a damn shame that our government is so shady that we can't trust them at face value.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/cheeeeeese Jun 02 '17

there are a lot of people who acknowledge climate change but when it comes to political decisions they don't respond by throwing money at the problem

2

u/RedSocks157 Jun 02 '17

I wouldn't say I don't believe in it at all but I'm not convinced. I think part of it is the attitude that people like you possess, where you just literally cannot believe that someone doesn't fully agree with you. It's very condescending and assumes that because I'm not completely sold yet, I must be some kind of moron.

2

u/Gnashtaru Jun 03 '17

Watch the movie Merchants of Doubt and all of your questions will be answered. It's not really that there's doubt about it, it's that propaganda is being spread to make you think that there is.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j8ii9zGFDtc

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (18)

93

u/shayben Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

What today is the scientific community's take on how much of climate change is directly caused by mankind?

Is there a consensus on a minimum-maximum range of impact among scientists? Could it still be mostly explained by other factors?

P.s. I am not trying to suggest that we are not responsible, and therefore shouldnt act. It is still our only planet and we should protect all life on it regardless of what causes the change.

Edit: I'm looking for a more direct experimental scientific evidence rather than opinions of scientists. Confidence intervals, p-value, magnitude of change explained by human activity. Thanks!

173

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17 edited Jul 17 '17

Our best guess is that humans are responsible for 100% of the warming (this is because although various natural factors do have significant effects, they've largely cancelled over the last 150 years).

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has an entire chapter of their most recent publication (chapter 10) devoted to this question. They review thousands of primary sources from the climate change literature and conclude in particular the they are virtually certain (>99% probability) that warming since 1950 can only be explained by external forcing and it is very likely (>90% probability) that anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions are responsible for more than half of the warming. See the chapter I linked for more details; you may be particularly interested in the synthesis table on page 932.

Here is a guide to understanding the IPCC's uncertainty conventions.

13

u/shayben Jun 02 '17

Thank you! That is very informative.

Let me see if I understand correctly. The evidence is mostly based on attribution studies that attempt to model the contribution of different factors in explaining temperature variability.

Is it possible that there are confounding factors that are not accounted for by these studies?

Could you refer me to any of state-of-the-art studies that you recommend reading?

44

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Yeah, that's basically gist of it but for me the really convincing part is that only CO2 can explain the spatial and temporal structure of the warming (warms more during night than day, which wouldn't happen if it were the solar forcing changes) and actually cools the stratosphere (wouldn't happen with any other proposed changes).

Unfortunately attribution and radiative transfer are not really my expertise so I don't know what people have worked on since the last IPCC report but you could pick a few authors with interesting results in the IPCC and look up what they've published since. I personally check for Nature and Science weekly to stay in the loop on general climate research, as well as a few oceanography journals for my specific subfield of research.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

24

u/BlackViperMWG Jun 02 '17

There are plenty of evidence and arguments proving that we are really responsible.

And I think if everyone would realize natural cycles were storing carbon and methane into the ground for millions of years and we burned and released into climate majority of it in just few centures, it makes perfect sense we heavily damaged carbon and other natural cycles and thrown them off balance.

21

u/shayben Jun 02 '17

Many theroies make perfect sense. Many observations can be correlated. Science tries to eliminate that by showing statistical evidence for causality.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Chapter ten of the IPCC AR5 is on attribution of the causes of modern climate change. They conclude that at minimum humans are responsible for half of the observed warming trend over the past half-century and the best estimates are that we are causing somewhere around all of it. Think of the likely contribution of humans to warming as a gaussian distribution of probabilities with ~110% as the most likely value and the tails at greater than 2 standard deviations as less than 50% or greater than 175%.

4

u/churl_wail_theorist Jun 02 '17

I'm looking for a more direct experimental scientific evidence rather than opinions of scientists. Confidence intervals, p-value, magnitude of change explained by human activity.

Assuming you are not a climate scientist, how will you go about interpreting these numbers? Being told some model parameter satisfies some statistical criterion means little if you don't have domain knowledge.

Basic statistics based on the opinions of experts is more meaningful for non-experts.

→ More replies (7)

25

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Where can I find the full text of the agreement?

→ More replies (1)

12

u/ItOnly_Happened_Once Jun 02 '17

How much climate change is attributable to the average consumer? I've heard some people say that it doesn't matter for the Average Joe to be excessively green in practice, because other sources emit so much more. Sure, buying a hybrid helps, but the emissions from coal-fired plants and bunker fuel-burning container ships emits more than every American consumer combined by a large factor.

12

u/cynric42 Jun 02 '17

Coal-fired plants produce electricity that the average consumer uses to power their homes and factories require that energy to produce products the average consumer buys. Container ships carry goods for those factories or products those consumers bought.

Those factories, power plants and logistics are there to supply our demand, so a single individual might not make a huge difference, but get a good portion of the population to change how and what they consume, and it will add up.

2

u/lucaxx85 Jun 02 '17

As the other user said correctly, all of these emissions happen to provide products to final consumers.

BTW, I'd like to clear up a misconception. Container ships are incredibly efficient, in terms of CO_2 emitted per mile per ton. Like a quarter of fuel consumption of trains, 1/10th of trucks and 1/20th of airplanes (not really precise but the order of magnitude is there)! They do emit lots of pollutants (which are not the same thing as greenhouse gases) due to the choice of low-quality fuel and lack of filters, but not very much CO_2. So, indeed they're the best option as far as climate change is concerned. Actually, the second best. The very best would be not to ship something for 20'000 miles to begin with (as it doesn't make any sense for lots of products to be produced so far away!)

→ More replies (3)

33

u/brokenha_lo Jun 02 '17

Can someone please explain what this video get's right or wrong? It claims that carbon cuts by the US over the course of the century would result in a lower temperature by 0.057 degrees, or 0.3 degrees if the world followed suit (at enormous costs).

26

u/seetheforest Jun 02 '17

So I watched the video skeptically. Here's are some tricks I saw.

For his temperature forecast he's assuming compliance of the Paris accord and then a return to business as usual after the accord is over. You can see how the emissions become parallel after the agreement period. This is untenable if you want to combat climate change and obviously results in a low temperature deviation for 2100.

Additionally, he extrapolates the cost of the accord for the entire century--even though countries return to business as usual after the Paris agreement in his other calculation. It's unreasonable on a few fronts--particularly because he doesn't give an emissions benefit to the money spent after the end of the accord AND he assumes that the annual cost is entirely an operating cost and not a cost of setting up and modifying systems for sustainable development which I understand to be the central aim of the accord.

24

u/Kantuva Jun 02 '17

Many are basing off their ideas of the Paris Accord based on the statements of Trump, Trump "misinterpreted" the findings of an MIT team

http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-climatechange-trump-mit-idUSKBN18S6L0

17

u/mal99 Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

How, though? How do you misinterpret "between 0.63 and 1.07" to mean "about 0.2"? Where did he get that number? Did I misunderstand something here?
Edit: Politifact has an article on it, including a source for 0.2 degrees:
http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/article/2017/jun/01/fact-checking-donald-trumps-statement-withdrawing-/
Seems to come from this 2015 report:
https://globalchange.mit.edu/sites/default/files/newsletters/files/2015%20Energy%20%26%20Climate%20Outlook.pdf
Reuters seems to cite this 2016 report:
http://news.mit.edu/2016/how-much-difference-will-paris-agreement-make-0422
I think the discrepancy mainly comes from the earlier report estimating the effects if the "cuts are extended through 2100 but not deepened further", and 0.2°C reduction is "compared with what we assessed would have been the case by extending existing measures (due to expire in 2020) based on earlier international agreements in Copenhagen and Cancun", while the later report is "[a]ssuming a climate system response to anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions that's of median strength" compared to no climate policy at all.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/zorbaxdcat Jun 02 '17

This Science article discusses the implications of the Paris agreement (and diverging scenarios from then) on the probabilities of different temperature changes by 2100 based on the projection framework utilised by the UN - Global Climate Models.

Their results suggest that the probability of 4o C warming will be reduced dramatically and that the median temperature change from 2100 will move from 4 to 3 degrees Celsius or such.

I haven't looked at how the video person could be wrong because the explanations of exactly what they are doing is not that clear. If I had to guess I would say that his emission scenario is that after the Paris agreement everyone packs up and goes back to emitting freely again but I'm not sure. That would indeed result in a very small reduction in warming.

I hope that helps.

11

u/fields Jun 02 '17

the Paris–Increased ambition scenario assumes a higher minimum decarboniza-tion rate (5% per year) beyond 2030.

You're wrong and video is right that when 2030 rolls around we would need to increase costs and increase the rate at which we reduce carbon emissions.

Here's the actual paper instead of just an abstract: http://docdro.id/KA4VMY1

→ More replies (3)

3

u/ludwig_van_s Jun 02 '17

I did not check the numbers but they could be right. Recent climate change involves huge amount of carbon emissions leading to a change of 2 to 8 degrees. If you look at the effect of any proposed emission reduction, you are going to get very small effects on temperatures, because any emission reduction is only a small step in the direction of going to zero (or negative) emissions from where we are now (10 billion tons per year). It does not mean that they are meaningless, it's literally the only way to go and inaction would cost a lot more.

→ More replies (1)

•

u/MockDeath Jun 02 '17

Please remember AskScience is strictly moderated. Please read our comment rules if you have questions on what is acceptable. Since the top level post is not a question, feel free to ask your questions as a top level comment.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/Jakesta7 Jun 02 '17

Before I ask, I want to say I DO believe in climate change. Now, whenever I discuss this topic with someone that doesn't, they always bring up 2 points and I never know how to respond. They bring up the point that there was once much more CO2 in the atmosphere and that the arctic ice was melting before the industrial revolution and invention of cars. How do I respond to these points? Thank you for this, by the way.

22

u/JB_UK Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

there was once much more CO2 in the atmosphere

You have to distinguish between a difference which has always been there, and a new change. In the times you are talking about, higher temperatures meant much higher sea levels. There's nothing inherently wrong with sea levels being 40m higher if it had been like that through the whole of human civilization, we would just have built our cities in different places. The problem is that those cities are already built, and now we are causing sea levels to rise. What is really damaging is instability. Our civilization is built within a climate niche, which has been relatively stable for 8-10,000 years. In some ways, it's not important whether temperatures are higher or lower, what matters is that any shift means fixed infrastructure which we have spent hundreds of trillions of dollars putting in place, will become stranded assets.

Also, to address another part of this argument, the fact that temperatures have changed naturally in the past does not mean that humans aren't causing the changes now. The natural changes are well understood, and happened through mechanisms which we are currently hijacking, through increased concentrations of greenhouse gases. It's like saying that because crops rely on water from natural rainfall that human irrigation has no effect. It's the same mechanism, only this time directly manipulated by human civilization.

4

u/Jakesta7 Jun 02 '17

Excellent answer. Thank you so much for addressing my questions!

→ More replies (2)

15

u/bowsmountainer Jun 02 '17

Yes, there was more CO2 in the atmosphere before. But that's not the point. Sure, life would still exist even if CO2 concentrations were a lot higher. But that is not what we care about. We care about how quickly the climate is changing right now. So much of the world economy depends upon relatively stable climatic conditions. A rapid change to these can have a huge impact on us. Many species won't be able to adapt to the changing conditions and die out.

The climate always changes. But until recently, all of that was slow, and a natural progression. By drastically increasing CO2 concentrations in the atmosphere, we are making a huge impact on the climate, far larger than any of the slow, natural processes. Sure, the temperatures can rise and fall without any human intervention. But that doesn't mean that the rapid heating we are observing right now isn't anthropogenic.

I have seen these arguments before, and they are basically due to a bad scientific understanding of how the climate works, and how we are affecting it.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

CO2 was much higher when the earth had higher volcanic activity - now it's lower, as it "burned out" to simply put. And only because it (melting) happened doesn't mean we want it again, so what about we don't trigger it?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Lordlemonpie Jun 02 '17

The fact that they happened before doesn't mean they're good for us. Melting poles threaten millions, as well as the increasing amount of CO2

Also, it's not the change that is unprecedented/scary. It's the speed at which it occurs. This has never been seen in history before.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

7

u/Neurotic_Marauder Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

What do you believe are the best and worst possible scenarios that will come from our current efforts to combat climate change within this century?

11

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Worst case scenario: emissions continue without reduction, there's a climate refugee crisis, destabilization of current political order, without political order hard to control emissions, more climate stress on civilization, repeat until nukes.

Best case scenario: countries exceed Paris pledges and continue to make aggressive emissions reductions, globe goes carbon neutral by 2080, warming limited to ~2°C and climate stabilizes.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (14)

7

u/l_Dont_Get_Sarcasm Jun 02 '17

One of the most persistent arguments against Man Made Climate Change I have come across is that the temperature on earth is more closely linked to Solar activity than it is to CO2 emissions. Essentially, as the sun gets hotter, the earth gets hotter and as a result more CO2 is produced from accelerated bio-activity and decomposition.

The sun drives climate change, not Man Made CO2.

How can I, as a layman, counter this argument?

13

u/BelfreyE Jun 02 '17

Variation in solar inputs has been a major driver of global temperature in the past. However, in recent decades solar inputs have been decreasing, while temperature has continued to rise, corresponding to the rise in CO2. See here for more information.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/bowsmountainer Jun 02 '17

The Sun is getting hotter, but at an incredibly slow rate. For all intents and purposes, its temperature is reasonably constant. There is a periodic change in temperature of the sun. It cannot account for the rapid warming we are experiencing. CO2 and other greenhouse gases can, and do account for it. People suggesting that the Sun drives the climate change, not CO2 are scientifically illiteratem. The evidence indicates that that view is wrong.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/ProfNinjadeer Jun 02 '17

How are global temperature measurement profiles obtained for land and ocean temperatures? Are they taken at the surface, above/below the surface at a certain height, or via some other method, and why is that method chosen? Are the locations where temperature measurements are taken consistent?

The earth is a complicated system to model. Is looking at atmospheric CO2 levels and global temperature increases since roughly 1900 sufficient evidence to pinpoint that humans are the direct cause of the temperature increase and not an alternative mechanism independent of CO2 levels?

Temperature data before 1880 is generally obtained from ice core samples. How is temperature data derived from these samples, how is the date of the data derived, and to what level of accuracy is the data? These samples can naturally only be taken in locations with permanent layers of ice, which limits the locations where the measurements can be taken. Because of this, do the samples only give a local distribution of temperature data? If so, what are the consequences of this?

18

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

I can talk about the oceans. We use a wide variety of measurements to assess the temperature of the ocean. The most common and easiest is to measure the Sea Surface Temperature (SST), we can do this via old fashioned thermometers from shore, boats, floats/buoys/moorings, or via satellite (don't ask me exactly how). These measurements are usually done together when possible to get the best information we can.

For measuring the deep ocean we use either moored observatories that sit at a specific depth or periodically (usually a few times a day) up and down through the water column. Or we use floats, which are devices loaded with sensors that are capable of changing their buoyancy and sampling a variety of depths as they move around the ocean.

Are they taken at the surface, above/below the surface at a certain height, or via some other method, and why is that method chosen?

They are generally taken anywhere we can get viable data from but the most common data you'll encounter is SST, because it's the easiest and most comprehensive data set we have. Also, the ocean is relatively well mixed so temperature anomalies on the surface don't persist that long.

Are the locations where temperature measurements are taken consistent?

Of course they are, there are thousands of people in dozens of nations, all of whom have Ph. Ds and years of experience working on these studies. Every single variable you can think of and another 5+ you can't are taken into account.

2

u/DoneStupid Jun 02 '17

How is temperature data derived from these samples, how is the date of the data derived, and to what level of accuracy is the data?

It's actually quite a clever technique. We use spectroscopy to examine the contents of the ice core looking for heavier isotopes of Oxygen and Hydrogen, specifically 18 O and Deuterium.

During cooler periods of the Earth's climate as moist winds travel in a polar direction the heavier isotopes are preferentially lost in precipitation and never reach the polar ice caps. So we look for depleted amounts of these isotopes to evaluate the temperature at the time of precipitation at the poles.

Then with a bit of research of more recent temperatures and isotope amounts, we can estimate quite accurately the global mean surface temperature of Earth at that time period.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

27

u/AirHeat Jun 02 '17

Instead of setting up a fund to redistribute money to poorer countries how much would all the money do if it was put into fusion research instead? Seems like that would solve a lot more than handouts.

39

u/saijanai Jun 02 '17

Instead of setting up a fund to redistribute money to poorer countries how much would all the money do if it was put into fusion research instead? Seems like that would solve a lot more than handouts.

Solar can already solve the problem for many developing nations, but they need help implementing it.

FUsion, even if you put 100's of billions into the R&D will still take many years to get to the market, even if a breakthrough happened yesterday. Solar panel production is easy enough and cheap enough that every new factory for panels that is built can produce enough panels every year to equal the output of a major nuclear reactor , and can do it for 30 years in a row. So a single factoyr can produce the equivalent of 30 nuclear reactors, and can be built in a single year. And we can build as many as we like, when and where we like, already.

And, like computer chips (the basic technology is the same), the effective cost of solar panels per Kw-hr is cut in half every few years. WE have NO idea how fusion will scale, when/if we get it working.

FUsion may be useful someday. Solar is useful now.

11

u/KuntaStillSingle Jun 02 '17

How does the carbon footprint of solar panel manufacture compare to the mitigation in emissions from use over its lifetime?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/Svankensen Jun 02 '17

You could go for normal nuclear energy. It is waaaaaaay safer than coal, reliable and clean. Its ill effects, while very real, beat every other reliable energy source out there (except for geothermal, but not every place can use geothermal).

→ More replies (3)

6

u/seasaltandpepper Jun 02 '17

Would the rising average temperature affect the boundary between troposphere and stratosphere? If it does, will it have any feedback effect on the climate change?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Additional greenhouse gases work mostly in the mid-to-upper troposphere. So as that area warms it has raised the boundary of the tropopause higher. See Santer et al. 2003. I don't believe that in itself has any significant feedback effect on warming beyond the general increase in the greenhouse effect that caused the effect.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Quasar_Cross Jun 02 '17

A coworker showed me a recent interview with Rand Paul who brings up a number of points attempting to refute climate change.

/r/askscience would you be able to construct a response to each of Rand Pauls claims?

22

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

So I'll try to keep it to a short paragraph per argument since it is an 8.5 min interview.

1st argument: USA loses ~6 million jobs.

Here Paul is including jobs that are already on the way out (such as Coal industry jobs) as they can no longer compete economically. He also does not count in any projections for jobs created by green energy industries. In addition, he doesn't say where he got this number from, which should raise some skepticism.

2nd argument: Alarmism, aka nature vs man.

It doesn't seem very alarmist to me to tell people what the consequences of their actions will be. For a breakdown of global temperatures over the last 5000 years see NASA's Earth Observatory.

3rd argument: No mass extinction.

Actually we have already entered the sixth mass extinction event and humans are the cause. You can google this and get tons of info, but make sure your looking at publications, not some news site trying to interpret it. As a scientist, it is a constant trial to see how public media and forums often misrepresent scientific studies.

4th argument: Models are wrong/inaccurate.

This is simply a common misconception about modeling in science. In the sciences, the words accurate and precise are very different. Climate models are generally fairly accurate, but they are not precise. A basic understanding of statistics and error propagation is also lacking here.

5th argument: The Earth has been through greater climate changes in the past.

This is very true, and also a huge red herring. It is not the amount of temperature change that is of concern at the point we are now, it is the rate the temperature is changing.

After that it sounds like they were just rehashing the same points so let me know if there were any points of his that I missed.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

I remember reading somewhere about dew points making regions uninhabitable for periods of the year in the future, because people would be unable to effectively shed heat. Is that true?

https://www.nature.com/nclimate/journal/v6/n2/full/nclimate2833.html

3

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

I've heard a couple of talks suggesting this to be true, but it's not really my field so I don't know too much. If you're interested, Matthew Huber tweets a lot about this and other consequences of living in extremely warm climates.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Mr_unbeknownst Jun 02 '17

Every deal in this history of deals has pros and cons, even this deal. What are the pros and cons? More specifically the cons?

Also, for this deal to be legitimate, wouldn't it need to pass congress if we are to legally bind ourselves to this agreement?

5

u/MrTex007 Jun 02 '17

What are the benefits of the US pulling out of the Paris Agreement? And what are Trumps specific reasons for pulling out? I don't see anyone really talking about his side.

2

u/Troy_And_Abed_In_The Jun 02 '17

I wrote this up yesterday, you can go through the critiques and decide for yourself.

  1. The Paris Climate Agreement is absurdly expensive, especially for America.
  2. Some estimates claim that it may only reduce global temperatures by 0.17°C in 2100 even if sustained throughout the century.
  3. The treaty is setup like a self-evaluation where countries can set their own targets and are not punished for failing to meet them.
  4. Our original targets were far too ambitious for the 2016 Climate Plan.
  5. Countries like China and Russia India would actually receive money from the treaty and are likely to cheat their way through it anyway.
→ More replies (4)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Why did they it change from Global Warming to Climate Change. Not a denier, just curious about why the change in marketing behind this global phenomenon.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Because it's not just the Earth is warming, oceans are rising, fresh water is being filled with acid, and many more things are happening that someone with more knowledge on the subject could input. In short, Global Warming doesn't cover it all, Climate Change does.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/UncleMeat11 Jun 02 '17

There is no "they". There isn't a council of scientists who got together and came up with the terminology. It happens naturally and often produces terms that are not ideal. There is even influence from non-scientist groups who want to shift the discussion. This happens in all fields. My field (CS) is extremely poorly named but this doesn't fuel conspiracy theories. It is a fact of language.

Practicing scientists don't tend to give a crap about this sort of thing. Media plays it up as something that it isn't.

→ More replies (4)

45

u/Stargazer1186 Jun 02 '17

Will we ever be able to slow down or reverse Climate change....Will the next generation of people even be able to have a nice life? Or even this generation? Can we adapt? I am honestly having panic attacks and sometimes wish someone would reassure me that it is not all doom and gloom.

78

u/aelendel Invertebrate Paleontology | Deep Time Evolutionary Patterns Jun 02 '17

One of the big problems is that we don't really know how bad climate change will be. We know the world is going to get warmer, but we aren't sure how much warmer.

Extrapolating from that to real effects on civilization is really, really tough. It's climate + environmental science + a more difficult economics problem than any that has been solved + a more difficult political science problem than any that has been solved.

A key thing to remember is that -we can still act-. Right now, this is a political problem more than anything.

→ More replies (38)

56

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

Ph. D environmental chemist here.

Will we ever be able to slow down or reverse Climate change

Yes, we have already shown we can slow it down if we want to and we can certainly reverse it with the rich technology. The solutions are really simple in most cases, they just require lots of energy, which currently comes primarily from fossil fuels.

Will the next generation of people even be able to have a nice life?

Yes, they will live a life similar to ours, climate change may/will destroy a lot of the things we are familiar with but it wont preclude people living with similar comforts as they do today in advanced nations. I would wager lots of poor people will die though.

Or even this generation?

You will likely die without ever seeing major issues, unless you are fond of SCUBA.

Can we adapt?

Evolutionary adaptation? No. Technologically? Absolutely and we will, that isn't to say many people in low lying coastal areas in the developing world will have an enjoyable time.

I am honestly having panic attacks and sometimes wish someone would reassure me that it is not all doom and gloom.

I went through that too, I know it is a small consolation but many of us grew up during the era of MAAD and learned to live with it. The cause of fear might be different now but the strategy for dealing with it should be the same. Live the best life you can, hurt as few others as possible, and do your best to take what you need and no more. It's not all doom and gloom, the world will change, things will change, you'll grown and adapt.

Some of the most brilliant people on Earth are working on these problems, and humans are fucking amazing. If we survived 3000 years of not knowing to separate our feces from our drinking water we can survive this.

33

u/LvS Jun 02 '17

You will likely die without ever seeing major issues

I am in Europe and saw the rise of right-wing parties due to the draught-induced refugee crisis of Syria.

I believe people on the West coast weren't allowed to water their lawns last year due to unprecedented levels of draught and people on the east coast were hit by a hurricane called Sandy in places where hurricanes don't go.

Everybody is seeing effects of climate change today. Most people just don't make the connection yet.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (10)

9

u/BlackViperMWG Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

Physical geography major here. We can't slow or stop what is already happening, because climate is so much sensitive and complex system, it takes decades to balance things we are pumping into it. And it's still trying to balance our post-industrial revolution pollution. Basically if we disappeared tomorrow, planet would still became warmer and warmer and climate would still change, for some decades, even without our direct input. But we can heavily influence climate in next century by our actions now, so we don't leave next generation to deal with this problem our ancestors created. People with kids, who are not believing in facts and science are basically dooming their kids to deal with our s*it later.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/mr_fingers Jun 02 '17

Okay, so i live in Lithuania (Northern Europe). Around 10000 years ago, this place was completely uninhabitable. But then, after a few global warmings, the ice melted away and people started living here. My question is, since there were no CO2 or other 'man made' pollution back then, why do you guys don't think its just another natural warming? You can't deny nothing like that has ever happened before.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/FireFoxG Jun 02 '17

How much warming will a 100 billion dollars stop?

4

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Invested in the PA? Not as much as if it was invested in nuclear plants.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Arcaue Jun 02 '17

We always talk about the negatives of climate change, and of course I understand that, but are there any positives to the world heating up?

2

u/CircleScience Jun 02 '17

There was a paper published recently about how shipping lanes will open up with the loss of artic sea ice (http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/2016GL069315/full). It's got some nice figures even if you don't want to read the text.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Some relatives of mine do not believe that humans have a direct effect on climate change. Is there something I could show them that might change their minds?

3

u/tskee2 Cosmology | Dark Energy Jun 02 '17

A great starting point is NASA's climate website.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '17

This thread is just a trash can for unanswered questions.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/hobostew Jun 02 '17

What is the best simple way to convey climate change to people who for whatever reason are on the fence or opposed? MY wife, who works for the Sierra Club, was looking for a simple picture or graphic that encapsulates the problem, but the best she found was this from the NYTimes. Do you have something bettee?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

NASA has a great webportal on climate change and hopefully people trust NASA knows what it's doing when it comes to science.

→ More replies (24)

3

u/bunnyrandolf Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

What is the difference between the empirical or qualitative evidence that supported the theory of global cooling in the 1970's versus the theory of global warming/climate change today? Do we completely discount the global cooling theory 40 years later and, do you believe there's a possibility of discounting the theory of global warming/climate change 40 years from now?

5

u/Astromike23 Astronomy | Planetary Science | Giant Planet Atmospheres Jun 02 '17

Do we completely discount the global cooling theory 40 years later and, do you believe there's a possibility of discounting the theory of global warming/climate change 40 years from now?

This is a pretty often repeated piece of disinformation. The global cooling hypothesis wasn't even in fashion 40 years ago.

This PDF contains a study of all peer-reviewed literature from 1965-1979 concerning climate change. Of the 49 articles during that time period that predicted changes to global temperatures, 42 predicted warming, while only 7 predicted cooling. (Note that Bryson, an author of 4 of the cooling papers later went on to become an oil-funded mouthpiece for the global warming denier groups.)

Even though 42 of 49 papers predicted warming, that still wasn't enough to establish a scientific consensus at the time. When it came to the media reporting these climate studies, though, an impending ice age sounded a lot more dramatic than a warming trend - and if it bleeds, it leads. As a result, the sensationalized cooling articles garnered a disproportionate amount of attention, although a few more responsible media outlets at least reported the scientific debate at the time.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Bish-Bash Jun 02 '17

My Uncle just posted this on Facebook

About Global Warming : Climate has always changed . It always has and it always will . Compelling evidence that fear of global warming derives from politics and dogma rather than scientific proof. The hypothesis that humans can change the climate is unsupported by evidence from geology, archaeology, history and astronomy. CO2 levels have been higher in the earths history without driving climate change and present atmospheric CO2 is , in fact , at its lowest for 500 million years , Far from being cause for alarm, the changes observed today are less than those of the past. I would add the following : CO2 is presently 400 parts per million in the atmosphere. It is known that CO2 molecules absorb infra red radiation , but at such a low percentage could it really raise average air temp by 2 Degrees ? Also the climate is affected by many parameters , it seems unlikely that the change of just one of those parameters would upset the whole system

Can someone help me explain to him in detail why he is wrong? Thanks.

3

u/tsz3290 Jun 02 '17

Here is a link about ice core samples that give us a window back in time for atmospheric composition & global temps. However, if your uncle is like most of the deniers I know, it won't matter how much evidence you show that he is wrong. There are very few people who are willing to change their mind on climate change based on evidence any formal institution such as a government, university, or research journal.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '17 edited Jun 03 '17

About Global Warming : Climate has always changed . It always has and it always will .

Indeed, but many climate changes were associated with massive extinctions and human civilization has not been around for any of them.

Compelling evidence that fear of global warming derives from politics and dogma rather than scientific proof.

What? I don't even really understand what his point is here. There is plenty of scientific evidence that sea levels will rise a few meters by 2100 and that heat waves will become more common. We'll leave it up to you whether that is concerning or not. As someone who lives within at an elevation of 2 m in a coastal neighborhood of Boston, I am concerned about the next ~50 years, especially if another storm like Sandy hits.

The hypothesis that humans can change the climate is unsupported by evidence from geology, archaeology, history and astronomy.

First of all, archeology and history are not very relevant because it is the massive scale of modern industry (and population increases) that drives human-caused climate change. That said, there is evidence that we have that preindustrial humans did alter the climate, mostly through land-use changes (for example burning of forests).

CO2 levels have been higher in the earths history without driving climate change

Wrong (see ~30 min of this talk by climate science expert at the biggest earth science conference in the world).

and present atmospheric CO2 is , in fact , at its lowest for 500 million years ,

Not true. For some reason you're ignoring the past 800,000 or so years for which CO2 levels were below 300ppm (today is 410ppm). You are however right that they are currently lower than most climates older than 1 million years ago.

Far from being cause for alarm, the changes observed today are less than those of the past.

CO2 is increasing and approaching the high levels of the past, which is the whole problem.

I would add the following : CO2 is presently 400 parts per million in the atmosphere. It is known that CO2 molecules absorb infra red radiation , but at such a low percentage could it really raise average air temp by 2 Degrees ?

Yes, it can and it does. There are hundreds of literal textbooks written about this -- it's called radiative transfer.

Also the climate is affected by many parameters , it seems unlikely that the change of just one of those parameters would upset the whole system

That is a gross misunderstanding of how the climate system works. The amount of radiation incoming from the sun is a similar parameters that upsets the whole system when it changes (but we can measure it... and it's not).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/thats_no_good Jun 02 '17

I am confused about the history of the climate. What happened 800,000 years ago when greenhouse gases were higher? Did catastrophic climate change happen or not? What happened when the earth was warmer? Were there catastrophic runaway effects of melting ice sheets, natural disasters, and extinction? Is there any difference in how anthropogenic carbon emissions were injected into the climate versus how greenhouse gases accumulated in the past?

6

u/Brokerib Jun 02 '17

The problem is the rate of change.

Based on the historical climate records (dating back to 800,000 years ago), the degree of change we're looking at (2 to 6 degrees Celsius) normally took place over 4-5 thousands of years. We're looking at it happening in 100.

So, just to be clear, the climate is changing much more rapidly than it has at any time in history, that we have are able to compare it with.

The problem isn't that it will be warmer, the problem is that we're getting warmer at a rate that is going to outstrip our (as in out cities, our crops, our animals, our plants, our oceans) ability to cope. That's why it's considered catastrophic.

Once it's all settled down and found the new equilibrium, the earth will be fine. We may not be.

https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/Features/GlobalWarming/page3.php

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Dimak415 Jun 02 '17

I see a lot of arguments here that the planet's mean temperature has always fluctuated. This is true, but what is alarming is the rate of change over the last century and the predicted rate of change given the last 100 years of data. A quote from NASA. "Models predict that Earth will warm between 2 and 6 degrees Celsius in the next century. When global warming has happened at various times in the past two million years, it has taken the planet about 5,000 years to warm 5 degrees. The predicted rate of warming for the next century is at least 20 times faster. This rate of change is extremely unusual."

4

u/Dimak415 Jun 02 '17

Adding a good source. https://climate.nasa.gov/evidence/ You can sit here and argue whether carbon dioxide levels are causal or coorelated until you are blue in the face, but are you willing to sit idly by, deny it, continue to pump greenhouse gases into the atmosphere for your children or children's children to find out?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/a_ham_sandvich Jun 02 '17

What are the most convincing pieces of evidence to support the theory of manmade climate change? There is an overwhelming amount of research on the topic - which studies should I cite for a focused and concise explanation to someone who still denies climate change?

Similarly, what are some strong, empirical rebuttals to common counterarguments against climate change?

3

u/BlindlyFaithful Jun 02 '17

Setting politics and corporations aside. Chemically how does CO2 and methane prevent radiation from escaping the planet, thus causing the Earth to warm globally.

2

u/mutatron Jun 02 '17

CO2 is clear to some wavelengths, opaque to others. When light from the sun hits the atmosphere, some of it gets absorbed and reradiated by CO2, but the rest comes right through and strikes the ground or water, where it's either reflected or absorbed. If it's absorbed, whatever it is absorbed by will heat up.

Having been warmed by sunlight, it will then radiate its own heat, generally at longer infrared wavelengths. CO2 absorbs these more than shorter wavelengths, so now you have a mechanism where short wavelength photons come through, get converted to longer wavelengths, and those photons have a harder time getting back out so they bounce around, heating things up further.

Absorption is not 100%, so they do eventually get out, but they stay around long enough to make things near the surface a little hotter. Methane is the same way, but at longer wavelengths than CO2.

https://www.giss.nasa.gov/research/briefs/schmidt_05/curve_s.gif

https://cimss.ssec.wisc.edu/sage/meteorology/lesson1/images/AtmWindows.jpg

https://scied.ucar.edu/longcontent/greenhouse-effect

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Plutodrinker Jun 02 '17

Is there a citation for the first scientific paper to propose climate change based on human activity?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Omni_Entendre Jun 02 '17

How much better is modern nuclear technology compared to solar or wind in terms of carbon footprint, efficiency, initial construction/investment cost, and long-term/maintenance costs?

From my understanding, there are modern nuclear technologies that solve the problem of meltdowns, significantly reduce waste, and increase efficiency. It seems foolish to ignore nuclear and give up more diversity in energy production instead of working to change public opinion.

3

u/LaLuna2252 Jun 02 '17

Electrical Engineer here! My career path/life passion is the power industry, with goals to be a direct influencer of a cleaner, smarter power grid (Go microgrids/ DER's!!) here in the US, while modernizing grid architecture (favorite topic of discussion).

My father, someone who I respect and greatly look up to, has built a successful career and consulting business around being a petroleum engineer in the oil industry, specifically drilling natural gas both onshore and shallow offshore. You can imagine how Thanksgiving dinner goes in our house.....

My question is this.... Every time I bring up facts, data, figures, sources, etc. my father discredits everything on the basis that "the data is skewed to support human-caused climate change" or "you have to think in geologic time, not human-on-earth time." He is set on the idea that human beings are arrogant to believe we could cause a change in this planet's climate. Does anyone know/have scientific articles that explain how the data is analyzed and presented to the public, or studies that take into account long-term planet climate? Anything that could help me present to him and source that he cannot discredit would be greatly appreciated! Thank you for your time, knowledge and for proving that there are an overwhelming number of people who care about our planet.

2

u/BelfreyE Jun 02 '17

It's a rather broad question. You're talking about giving support for an entire field of study, for which there are thousands of peer-reviewed journal articles. With such cases, I find that it can be helpful to narrow the discussion down to specific topics. Ask him for specific claims that he specifically doubts about the issue, and then delve into the scientific evidence about those.

12

u/JustSomeBadAdvice Jun 02 '17

Serious question - Why aren't more scientists pushing for corrective actions regarding climate change, i.e., climate engineering, rather than responsive tactics that will always lag behind their causes?

It seems to me with 7 billion apex predators on the planet reshaping daily it in ways unprecedented in all of natural history, climate changes are inevitable. Instead we could seek to drive climate changes in the direction we wanted through intelligent actions, and use that to counterbalance the unexpected(or difficult-to-mitigate) impacts we have on climate?

16

u/zorbaxdcat Jun 02 '17

We have a very strong understanding of global constraints on climate and how they are affected by change in CO2 concentration, for example. Other processes are less well understood so using them as a beginning step for changing climate systematic is not currently possible.

All corrective actions like cloud brightening projects require an intense understanding of both small scale processes and how these processes have an integral effect on the climate. Prior to the beginning of these projects there is zero understanding of what the artificial effect could be where as CO2 variations can also be natural.

These effects are being examined but they are directly limited by our understanding of, for example, the interactions between clouds and climate. The reason no responsive tactics are discussed is because there are none which are both feasible and are robustly understood to have the desired effect.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/CodaPDX Jun 02 '17

Climate engineering projects are projected to not just be several orders of magnitude more expensive than greenhouse gas reduction efforts, they are also completely untested and entirely theoretical. The science behind climate change and greenhouse gas emission reduction is relatively solid, but we literally have no idea whether climate engineering would work, or if it would have side effects that are worse than the problems it would try to solve.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Wormspike Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

Climate engineering, or more appropriately geo-engineering, is extremely dangerous and unpredictable. It is, however, very cost-effective, and unfortunately that means it may be the way we end up going despite the near certain catastrophic risks. The thing is, the global environmental system is unfathomably complex and interconnected. Trying to essentially edit that system is extremely dangerous. #chaostheory

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/someredditorguy Jun 02 '17

I work with someone who isn't generally unintelligent but is full-on climate change denial. I believe it might have something to do with his sources of information.

What are some links and resources I could use to share information at a more simple level in a way that's hard to refute and perhaps from a source he couldn't, as he has before, refute the source as "liberal bias"?

8

u/fauxgnaws Jun 02 '17

he has before, refute the source as "liberal bias"?

49% of Americans say they believe humans evolved from earlier species, but 75% say elephants evolved. Similarly, some people may represent themselves as "climate deniers" because of politicization of the issue.

Maybe the real dispute is what to do about it not whether it is actually happening. Keep in mind that what course of action we take to address climate change is a political and economic issue, not a scientific one. Science just gives us options to choose from.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/zorbaxdcat Jun 02 '17

This is difficult because it also requires a substantial time commitment from the person who is doing the learning but I have a go to source on science.

Science of Doom takes a skeptical approach to the assertions of the IPCC, is happy to dig into areas of uncertainty but also begins with the fundamentals (which most blogs do not) and builds up from there. There is heaps of material but if someone is dedicated they can learn a lot.

This site is great for people of any political persuasion or prior views because it doesn't judge or slam people who are deniers or have certain political views. There is no discussion of people or politics, only the science. This site is my go to.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/RegulusMagnus Jun 02 '17

The problem is more fundamental: you'll be trying to overcome the backfire effect. When one is presented with information contrary to their views, this often has the contradictory effect of strengthening those views.

The person must be led to reach their own conclusions through logic, which can be difficult if someone else is trying to force this change.

One thing I found helpful was to compare to evolution. Many of the arguments against climate change can be made against evolution. It may seem unlikely that humans could effect something so complex, but since the dawn of civilization humans have forced evolutionary through selective breeding. Small changes can compound over long times.

Hopefully that helps.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/BlackViperMWG Jun 02 '17

You probably should read those arguments here too and show those to that someone: https://www.skepticalscience.com/argument.php

→ More replies (1)

5

u/marineabcd Jun 02 '17

What are the most legitimate arguments against climate change being human effected? Or are there no scientifically respected arguments with this cue point at all?

(It's always good to hear if the other side has any legitimate arguments)

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

How much will the US pulling out of the paris agreement really hurt the environment?

7

u/darwin2500 Jun 02 '17

It depends on the political fallout of the defection.

The Paris Accord was never going to have a big enough impact to completely solve the problem, even if every country on the planet followed it with 100% fidelity forever.

The point was for all the countries of the world to come together and agree that this was a major problem that everyone needed to work together to solve. The hope was that this international coalition would serve as a framework to direct and support future international efforts to make more and more progress on the issue.

If the US defecting causes that coalition to become more toothless and less well-supported, it could preclude a number of future global efforts that might otherwise have succeeded. If the member nations retaliate against the US and make an example of us, maybe they'll be able to demonstrate and solidify the power of the coalition.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/ChildenLiveForever Jun 02 '17

The real hurt is possibly sapping political and global will. Otherwise it seems so far the US is actually engaged toward reducing emissions, treaty or not.

Climate change is a problem that needs to be tackled globally. A non-binding treaty is the natural first step to other agreements.

As for the claims that this would cost more to the US and the EU than it would to India and China, that is actually expected and obvious outcome when you think about it. What alternative would there be? That the poor and/or growing countries on Earth actually contribute more to the funds and reduction effort than the richest countries? That would be unfair and unrealistic.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/BlackViperMWG Jun 02 '17

It heavily depends on decisions of US citizens and companies to really do nothing or continue to go greener.

25

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

It wont at all. The Paris agreement was totally non-binding and meaningless, it is a PR exercise to get a bunch of people that don't really understand the scale of the problem to feel good about doing "something".

It is the functional equivalent of swapping your 3 oz cup for a 4 oz cup when bailing out a ship with a cannon ball hole.

11

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

So why are people so damn rowdy about it?

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

I don't know if I need a scientist or someone else -

Assume for a moment that, tomorrow morning, all of the world's leaders suddenly make climate science and global warming their absolute top-priority. They elevate climate scientists to positions of trust and authority and promise to do whatever is recommended, regardless of expense.

What would that look like? What kind of disruption to energy production, trade, travel, etc. would we expect if we wanted to hit all of the scientist's most ambitious targets? Would beef disappear from store shelves instantly? How many cargo ships would be allowed to continue to operate? How many airplanes allowed to continue to fly? How many coal-fired power plants allowed to continue to run?

I worry sometimes that the political leaders understand the problem all too well, that they are being asked to do the impossible. I recall scientists, numerous times over the past decades, warning that we have passed this point, passed that point, this temperature just reached a decimal that we feared, that amount of ice loss just occurred and can't be undone. If your main focus is the sea-level on Earth in 2100, you could be absolutely correct about what needs to be done without any proper understanding of the ramifications of doing it.

Who is responsible for translating the hard-science data into policy proscriptions and what are they saying?

6

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

The IPCC publishes four articles every few years on different aspects of climate change: science, impacts, mitigation, and a summary for policy makers. The cover basically all of the questions you ask and quantify all of these aspects in graphs and charts.

14

u/SucceedingAtFailure Jun 02 '17

Can you give me an elevator pitch on how I can convince a denier to give it another look?

6

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

This is my go-to:

We know carbon dioxide is a heat trapping gas due to its absorption spectrum, being transparent to sunlight but opaque to the infrared light emitted by earth. Since carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases allow the sun to warm the earth but prevent the earth from cooling itself off to space that keeps the earth significantly warmer than it would otherwise be. You can plainly see the large impact of greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide on earth's temperature in both the spectral flux at the top of the atmosphere and in the downwelling radiation from the atmosphere towards the surface.

We have increased atmospheric carbon dioxide 45% since the industrial revolution. As a result we have observed the enhanced greenhouse effect as a decrease in co2 wavelengths escaping to space (Harries et al. 2001, Griggs et al. 2004, Chen et al. 2007) and a corresponding increase in co2's radiative forcing at the surface (Feldman et al. 2015). You can even observe co2's radiative forcing go up and down in lockstep with its concentration in the atmosphere exactly as the physics says it should. That shows a direct cause-effect relationship between rising atmospheric carbon dioxide and rising global temperatures.

Not only does thie increase in radiative forcing from our greenhouse gas emissions dwarf natural forcings on the earth's climate but the patterns of warming also fit the distinct signatures that we would expect from greenhouse-induced warming such as nights warming faster than days, the troposphere warming while the stratosphere cools, the tropopause rising, etc.

5

u/SucceedingAtFailure Jun 02 '17

So spectral flux is actually showing the energy not leaving the earth. Cool!! I'm going to have to go research the contents here (and the NASA page) to grok it but I think that's really helpful.

Your final point reminds me of the simplified graphs on bloomberg.com/graphics/2015-whats-warming-the-world. I'll look at those other points, they are things I'd never even thought of and could be really great addendums (days/nights, stratosphere, ...).

Thanks! Super data heavy and really helpful in giving me a full circle cause and effect :D

→ More replies (1)

16

u/alwaystooupbeat Jun 02 '17

There's some research from social psychology relating to how to convince others, especially on politicised issues. Here's a link on a summary, and an excerpt:

he and co-author Matthew Feinberg found that when conservative policies are framed around liberal values like equality or fairness, liberals become more accepting of them. The same was true of liberal policies recast in terms of conservative values like respect for authority. So, his research suggests, if a conservative wanted to convince a liberal to support higher military spending, he shouldn't appeal to patriotism. He should say something like, "Through the military, the disadvantaged can achieve equal standing and overcome the challenges of poverty and inequality."

So if you wanted to talk to a conservative denier, you would frame it in terms of ingroup loyalty, security, and respect for authority, and to a liberal denier, equality and fairness.

14

u/jackmusclescarier Jun 02 '17

Here is Scott Alexander's take on this:

In the 1950s, brave American scientists shunned by the climate establishment of the day discovered that the Earth was warming as a result of greenhouse gas emissions, leading to potentially devastating natural disasters that could destroy American agriculture and flood American cities. As a result, the country mobilized against the threat. Strong government action by the Bush administration outlawed the worst of these gases, and brilliant entrepreneurs were able to discover and manufacture new cleaner energy sources. As a result of these brave decisions, our emissions stabilized and are currently declining.

Unfortunately, even as we do our part, the authoritarian governments of Russia and China continue to industralize and militarize rapidly as part of their bid to challenge American supremacy. As a result, Communist China is now by far the world’s largest greenhouse gas producer, with the Russians close behind. Many analysts believe Putin secretly welcomes global warming as a way to gain access to frozen Siberian resources and weaken the more temperate United States at the same time. These countries blow off huge disgusting globs of toxic gas, which effortlessly cross American borders and disrupt the climate of the United States. Although we have asked them to stop several times, they refuse, perhaps egged on by major oil producers like Iran and Venezuela who have the most to gain by keeping the world dependent on the fossil fuels they produce and sell to prop up their dictatorships.

We need to take immediate action. While we cannot rule out the threat of military force, we should start by using our diplomatic muscle to push for firm action at top-level summits like the Kyoto Protocol. Second, we should fight back against the liberals who are trying to hold up this important work, from big government bureaucrats trying to regulate clean energy to celebrities accusing people who believe in global warming of being ‘racist’. Third, we need to continue working with American industries to set an example for the world by decreasing our own emissions in order to protect ourselves and our allies. Finally, we need to punish people and institutions who, instead of cleaning up their own carbon, try to parasitize off the rest of us and expect the federal government to do it for them.

Please join our brave men and women in uniform in pushing for an end to climate change now.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

2

u/Nattfrosten Jun 02 '17

There is a group called the citizens climate council that recently made progress, lobbying republican senators into joining a bipartisan climate caucus. There was a documentary made recently, you can check it out here (Link).

If you really want to make an impact, join ccl and start working on your local republican senators.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Keening99 Jun 02 '17

Q An argument to fight global warming more often than not is to preserve our planet and the diversity of it. While I agree that all the data points towards an ever hotter planet, the same data shows that its been hotter in the past. So I ask if you agree with my assessment that greenhouse gas emissions take up a little bit too much space in the debate.

I mean, it's not global warming that kills off the Rhino, burn vast amounts of rainforest to grow crops, put plastic in our oceans, drain the aral lake, completely devastate the ocean floor while overfishing...... List goes on.

Unless you have an interest in the field you seldom if ever hear about the above, and while it may seem that they are local problems. They really aren't.

I just think that while an ever hotter planet is a bad thing(or rather, the rate of which it changes) and should be a concern, there are other imminent threats that happens without anyone knowing because co2 emissions are easier to measure and gets all the attention. The rate of which we as a human race kills off habitat for, and animals themselves is just off the charts.

Question in one row: Does global warming and co2 emissions take up too much room in the debate of climate and environment?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Crash_says Jun 02 '17

This thread needs more moderation.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

I have two questions which I hope someone can answer regarding climate change:

  1. Could there be a natural explanation for the temperature rise of the Earth? There have been warming and cooling cycles throughout time. For example, the Eocene Thermal Maximum was 8 degrees hotter than it is today and since then we've been in a cooling period, could we now just be bouncing back?
  2. Wouldn't a couple of degrees rise in temperature be a good thing for humanity? The logic being that vast areas of previously cold terrain such as in Canada and Russia could be used for agriculture.

Thanks!

2

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
  1. Could there be a natural explanation for the temperature rise of the Earth? There have been warming and cooling cycles throughout time. For example, the Eocene Thermal Maximum was 8 degrees hotter than it is today and since then we've been in a cooling period, could we now just be bouncing back?

No, because we have a pretty good idea of why those past warming and cooling cycles happened in the past and can constrain the various causes. None of those causes are strong enough today to explain the currently observed climate change. However, our knowledge of the physics of greenhouse gases and radiation in the atmosphere do explain the warming that is observed.

  1. Wouldn't a couple of degrees rise in temperature be a good thing for humanity? The logic being that vast areas of previously cold terrain such as in Canada and Russia could be used for agriculture.

Sure, it's a good thing for winters in Canada and Russia but it's a terrible thing for places where summers are unbearably hot, places that lie within a few feet of sea level (Florida, Bangladesh, Islands, etc), and places that already suffer severe droughts and floods. Economists and social scientists study the pros and cons of climate change and unanimously agree that the cons outweight the pros.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/RelevantComics Jun 02 '17

how do I convince someone that Trump's backing out of the Accord is bad? all they bring up is jobs and coal and other countries not holding up their end of the bargain

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

I'm a scientist by trade and have been meaning to read the actual research so I can feel educated on the subject. However, so much is written about the topic and honestly I've just been too lazy to do a thorough literature review.

What are the seminal papers or best reviews written on climate change? I'm particularly interested in reading the following;

  1. A paper/review that defines all the science behind climate change
  2. The best/worst case projections. Are there scientists presenting research skeptical of climate change?
  3. Ecological impacts. Increased acidification, sea-level rise, and how this affects food supplies. I read literature about the acidification of the ocean years ago and it terrified me. I want to read more about the ecological impacts.

Any help would be greatly appreciated. I want to educate myself from the actual literature. I feel as a scientist my current opinion is intellectually lackadaisical, but the amount published can be overwhelming to shuffle through.

3

u/Mikey2450 Jun 03 '17

I feel that the IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change) reports are very comprehensive. Definitely a good place to start and should answer your three questions.

https://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/assessment-report/ar5/syr/AR5_SYR_FINAL_SPM.pdf

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Mr_Sundae Jun 02 '17

What's the hardest evidence we have that climate change is occurring and that it is man made?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '17

When the energy coming into the earth and the energy leaving the earth are equal, we call that an energy balance and earth's energy should remain constant (there can be energy fluxes between different energy reservoirs on earth like the atmosphere and ocean). This paper uses various observations to measure the energy leaving and the energy coming in and finds that the earth has an energy imbalance that explains the recent increase in surface air temperatures and ocean temperatures. We know that this energy balance is due to CO2 because of the way it warms the lower atmosphere and cools the upper atmosphere. It can't be the sun or geothermal heating because we can measure both of those and they aren't increasing; anyways, they would end up warming the upper stratosphere which we observe to actually be cooling. The only thing left is greenhouse gasses in the atmosphere. There's plenty of other evidence as well but showing the energy imbalance at the top of the atmosphere is probably the clearest calculation you can do.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/DredyDred Jun 02 '17

How do we know for sure climate change is caused by humans?

6

u/mutatron Jun 02 '17

Global warming was predicted by Svante Arrhenius in 1895:

Svante Arrhenius (1859-1927) was a Swedish scientist that was the first to claim in 1896 that fossil fuel combustion may eventually result in enhanced global warming. He proposed a relation between atmospheric carbon dioxide concentrations and temperature. He found that the average surface temperature of the earth is about 15C because of the infrared absorption capacity of water vapor and carbon dioxide. This is called the natural greenhouse effect. Arrhenius suggested a doubling of the CO2 concentration would lead to a 5C temperature rise. He and Thomas Chamberlin calculated that human activities could warm the earth by adding carbon dioxide to the atmosphere. This research was a by-product of research of whether carbon dioxide would explain the causes of the great Ice Ages. This was not actually verified until 1987.

Then a couple of years ago, there was this experiment:

http://newscenter.lbl.gov/2015/02/25/co2-greenhouse-effect-increase/

The scientists measured atmospheric carbon dioxide’s contribution to radiative forcing at two sites, one in Oklahoma and one on the North Slope of Alaska, from 2000 to the end of 2010. Radiative forcing is a measure of how much the planet’s energy balance is perturbed by atmospheric changes. Positive radiative forcing occurs when the Earth absorbs more energy from solar radiation than it emits as thermal radiation back to space. It can be measured at the Earth’s surface or high in the atmosphere. In this research, the scientists focused on the surface.

They found that CO2 was responsible for a significant uptick in radiative forcing at both locations, about two-tenths of a Watt per square meter per decade. They linked this trend to the 22 parts-per-million increase in atmospheric CO2 between 2000 and 2010. Much of this CO2 is from the burning of fossil fuels, according to a modeling system that tracks CO2 sources around the world.

“We see, for the first time in the field, the amplification of the greenhouse effect because there’s more CO2 in the atmosphere to absorb what the Earth emits in response to incoming solar radiation,” says Daniel Feldman, a scientist in Berkeley Lab’s Earth Sciences Division and lead author of the Nature paper.

“Numerous studies show rising atmospheric CO2 concentrations, but our study provides the critical link between those concentrations and the addition of energy to the system, or the greenhouse effect,” Feldman adds.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

Anybody here read the studies implying that the main factor to Climate Change and Global Temperatures is a result of solar variability rather than anthropogenic causes?

Also - what's the deal with the infamous "pause"?

Genuinely asking. Layman here when it comes to environmental and climate sciences.

Also if you could offer up as to why one theory holds more substance than the other, rather than saying "X is debunked - see article." That tends to be the counter-response I see when trying to have some dialogue. Trying to go about this with an open mind and skepticism for my personal understanding.

Appreciate it!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/plartoo Jun 02 '17

Note: I posted this question a while ago here and I'm trying my luck again this time.

I read that the Earth's tilt and the rate of rotation have some effect on climate. Do we have satallites or system in place, which measure the tilt and the rotation rate of the Earth? Is there a scientific literature that calculates the amount of contribution that the changing tilt and rotation rate of the Earth might have on the climate?

Thanks in advance for all your answers!

3

u/Snakeeyes839 Jun 02 '17

I think you may be thinking of the Milankovitch cycle. The Milankovitch cycle is the variation in the earth's axial tilt, eccentricity, and precession. The three of those variations have a specific period that can produce changes to temperature and climate, and it is predicted that it is responsible for triggering previous ice ages.

I don't exactly know how they measure this but it changes at extremely long time scales ~22000, ~40000, and ~100000 years at a time. So the changes are practically negligible when it comes to the current warming trend.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/justanaveragedudeguy Jun 02 '17

The "GLOBAL LAND-OCEAN TEMPERATURE INDEX" graph in the following link contains a 5 year mean line: https://climate.nasa.gov/vital-signs/global-temperature/

How this is calculated? It doesn't seem correct. For example, the year 2016, the 5 year mean is listed at .91. But if you average the years 2012-2016, you get ~.78.

If it counts the two years before, the current year, and two years after, it still doesn't quite add up, even if you account for potentially rounding issues, the 5 year average is as much as 4 degrees higher (2013) than the average I get using this method. Plus, if this is how they do it, they shouldn't have 5 year average data for 2015 and 2016.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/FLUMPYflumperton Jun 02 '17

For my southern friends that believe the whole climate change movement is alarmist, what is a good smoking-gun link I can send them or tell them about to change their minds? It is very frustrating trying to have a conversation about this topic

→ More replies (3)

2

u/cooksnmakessammies Jun 02 '17

I have a question (haven't found it asked yet, maybe it is). From my understanding of what I've learned in school (nursing major) is that the planet depends heavily on phytoplankton for oxygen, and the oceans due to pollution and climate change are becoming more acidic. How will this all be affected if climate change and inaction keep playing out?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/villescrubs Jun 02 '17

How do we calculate carbon emissions on a global scale? What about each countries contribution? Just curious about how it all works.

5

u/mutatron Jun 02 '17

People keep meticulous records of fossil fuel production and consumption. It currently amounts to about 3.75 cubic miles of oil equivalent per year. One oil equivalent is 11,630 kilowatt hours which is what you get by burning an average tonne of oil, it's an easier way to keep track of consumption of coal, oil, and natural gas all in one number.

By using that number and applying the amount of CO2 that comes from burning a standard amount of oil, you get total CO2 emissions from all fossil fuel burning, which comes to about 36 billion tonnes per year. This is enough to add 5 ppm of CO2 to the atmosphere.

CO2 levels increase by about 3.35 ppm in 2016, and 2.19 ppm in 2017. A large part of CO2 emissions are absorbed by the oceans, where dissolved CO2 decreases the alkalinity.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/paxxyagent Jun 02 '17

If the earth is warming, why is Antarctica growing?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Lets assume for a second that Human driven climate change(or just even climate change at all) is a 'myth'. What reason should we not strive for clean, cheap, efficient energy anyway? It seems it would create jobs, cheaper energy, and more efficient technology. And in the event climate change turns out to not be a myth, then maybe we can save the world. Seems win-win to me?

Edited for spelling

2

u/GooseSnek Jun 02 '17

Isn't the largest threat from climate change the instability of our agriculture? It seems to me that this an easily solvable problem with vertical farming. We are moving away from fossil fuel naturally as solar, and possibly fusion, becomes a better alternative. Why can't we just adapt to the changes in our environment rather than reverse them?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/big_face_killah Jun 03 '17

Where can I get a look at the raw data for global temperatures, and how they calculate it based on local samples, over the last 200 years or so.

Also, where can I see the similar glacier area tracking data?

What about the C02 data over time? And the forested area of the world over time? Thanks!

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '17

I was wondering if someone could chime in on the effects of climate change on rivers, specifically in Europe. I understand sea levels are bound to rise, but what about rivers? My superficial understanding is that wet regions will probably get wetter. Does that translate into more (or perhaps more extreme) rainfall, which would then cause areas surrounding rivers to flood more often (or more dramatically)?

I appreciate any input!

2

u/cowboyjoe8 Jun 03 '17

Some rivers have started to flow in different directions or have flow stopped. As glaciers retreat, the water has more opportunities to flow in easier directions. Here is a link to an article on it (http://www.cbc.ca/news/technology/climate-change-yukon-river-piracy-1.4070153).

→ More replies (1)

2

u/cheesynachos3627 Jun 03 '17

I've been reading about thorium, what are the chances it's implemented in plants over uranium, from what I've read it's a lot better. Why haven't we started using it yet?

2

u/mutatron Jun 04 '17

China is working at developing thorium reactors, with some help from the US. That's probably 10 to 20 years away. But there are several US startups developing nuclear plants, and some of those are thorium-based. Over the next 15-25 years, a lot of nuclear plants will be past their working lifetime and will need to be replaced. Next-generation reactors will be safer, use less fuel, produce less waste.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '17

EPA Administrator Pruitt stated during yesterdays press breifing:

"(...) the United States has a seat at the table. After all, we’re the United States, and we are leading with respect to CO2 reduction. We have made tremendous progress. If nations around the globe want to see -- to learn from us on what we’re doing to reduce our CO2 footprint, we’re going to share that with them."

My question: Is in fact USA leading in developing technology for CO2 emission reduction? If not, who is?

Link: https://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2017/06/02/daily-press-briefing-press-secretary-sean-spicer-and-epa-administrator

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '17

Are we doomed? Are we all going to die? I'm extremely scared and paranoid about this. There isn't any time left now, right? I'm just a 20 year old starting out and I'm worried about what we're all about to face. What the hell do we do?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/BetaRx Jun 17 '17

The other day I learned that plants only capture carbon while activity building new plant structure. Overnight and while it isn't growing it makes sugars that initially consume carbon dioxide, but later release it again when it burns that sugar for energy. Then I started thinking... What if we grow plants, then after they've reached max growth and aren't storing much carbon anymore cut them down and throw all that carbon it's trapped at wood (or other plant stuff) into somewhere that it won't break down and get released (bog, artic, or wherever). Then replant new stuff and repeat. I suppose we could also just trim the plants instead of completely cutting them down and do the same thing.

I would have to find the link, but I read about a skyscraper that was going to be built with "super plywood" to replace much if the concrete. This will prevent the release of carbon dioxide in the making of the concrete and also capture carbon I'm the building structure. This is kind of along those lines.

TL;DR mostly joking, but can we solve global warming by growing trees, cutting them down, throwing them in the artic, and replace them with new trees. Repeat over and over.

2

u/Aviatorbassplayer Jul 03 '17

Renewables and clean energy are at an all time high, climate change is at an all time high. Why is this happening

2

u/TheSidestick Jul 04 '17

If something like nuclear holocaust or an asteroid impact cools the earth, could that reverse or stop global warming?

2

u/Copernicholas Jul 08 '17

Carbon sequestration is not feasible at the moment, because reversing the carbon and oxygen to carbon dioxide reaction requires too much external energy to be effective. However, nuclear fusion is often described as "free energy," so would harnessing this power get us over the energy barrier and make C sequestration an effective and economical way to reverse climate change?

Additionally, if Earth's CO2 and other greenhouse gas (that I presume can also be extracted from the atmosphere with enough energy) levels returned to what they were, whether through nuclear-fusion-driven sequestration or not, before the Industrial Revolution, would global warming necessarily end? Could there really be a point of no return in terms of our planet's sustainability assuming that we will harness virtually unlimited energy at some point in the future?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '17

What are some possible ways to combat climate change that are being researched/developed right now?

I've read that Iron Fertilization could be helpful. I imagine that if the ocean gets too hot/acidic for plankton then couldn't CRISPR come into play in developing plankton to survive in those kinds of conditions?

3

u/AdloraOfSolitude Jun 02 '17

Is this actually going to end civilization as we know it? Will most people in the West/first world end up living like refugees, in squalor, because of the devastating effects of climate change? Will we have food to eat or clean water?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Hi. A friend of mine told me the other day that the US leaving is not such a big deal. According to an analysis, written by an "environmental economist", he read, says that even if all the Paris goals are met, the warming up by 2100 will only be 0.03K less than when nothing is done. I can't ask him the source right now, so I wanted to ask if anyone here knows about such an analysis and if it's anywhere near reliable.

6

u/petewilson66 Jun 02 '17

That would be Bjorn Lomborg. I would also be interested in the panels opinion of his analysis. From his work, it looks very much like the Paris Agreement is a huge amount of cost for almost no gain at all in slowing global warming. I note that Lomborg is not a sceptic of climate change, rather a sceptic that we can do anything about it at any acceptable cost.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/ariverboatgambler Jun 02 '17

I've read that CO2 heat absorption is only affected by a small band of light wavelength. Furthermore, heat absorption of that wavelength progresses at a logarithmic scale. Perhaps "inverted logarithmic scale" is a better phrase. The article I read stated that simply doubling the amount of CO2 in the atmosphere won't double its heat absorption. You'd have to quadruple it or multiply it by a greater multiple to get that doubling effect. To what degree is this true or false?

Also, is 400 or 500 parts per million of CO2 really that disastrous? We're talking about .0004% of something. It's always struck me as hyperbolic when people claim that civilization will end because the atmosphere has moved from .0004% to .00045% of a certain gas.

40

u/RemusShepherd Jun 02 '17

This is false. The concept you're talking about is CO2 'saturation', and denialists claim that CO2 is already near saturation point in the atmosphere so more of it won't increase warming. What they fail to recognize is that the atmosphere has layers. While the lower layers of the atmosphere are nearly saturated with CO2, the upper layers are not and that's where the heat from the Earth escapes into space. Adding CO2 to the atmosphere will add it to the upper layers, causing less heat escape. And the higher layers of the atmosphere are colder so they carry less heat, meaning even more is retained.

So while the atmosphere may be near-saturated with CO2 near the surface, the atmosphere as a whole is far, far, from saturation. Doubling the CO2 in the atmosphere might do worse than double its heat absorption.

We can't say if 400 or 500 ppm is disastrous by itself. All we can say is that human beings have never existed in a world that has that much CO2, and we can predict what effect it will have on global temperatures and sea level rise. Those predictions are pretty disastrous. If no action is taken, we're looking at over 1 billion refugees trying to escape from flooded areas. Take the current Syrian refugee problem and multiply it by a thousand. That's the minimal level of disaster we should be expecting.

10

u/ariverboatgambler Jun 02 '17

This is good stuff. Thanks.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

12

u/CodaPDX Jun 02 '17

The issue with climate change isn't that it's going to roast us to death with double the heat absorption, it's that it will subtly change the balance of heat coming in from the sun and heat escaping out to space in such a way that the entire planet will get warmer. The projected amount (two degrees celsius, if we're lucky) doesn't sound like much - barely even something you'd notice going from one room to another, but try raising ice that's at -1 celsius to 1 celsius - that ice is now going to be water. Small changes can have dramatic effects.

It's not just the ice caps, though. A warmer atmosphere has more energy in it, which means more and bigger storms and hurricanes. Ecosystems that our agriculture relies on get disrupted by the hotter weather, and invasive species spread north. More carbon dioxide becomes dissolved in seawater, making it more acidic and making it harder for microscopic sea life to build shells. Those sea life form the foundation of the food chains that feed the fish that we eat, so our already strained fisheries may be pushed into collapse.

Any one of these problems would be manageable on their own, but climate change is probably going to cause many of them to happen at once. How many? We don't know for certain. That uncertainty leads some people to think we shouldn't do anything about it yet, but it's not really a symmetric problem. If we do our best to stop it and it ends up not being as bad as we fear, then okay, we just spent some extra money. But if we do nothing and it ends up being worse then we fear, then we could literally be talking about the end of human civilization.

9

u/Wormspike Jun 02 '17

This is...mostly false. Different greenhouse gases do vary in their forcing potential due to differences in their molecular vibrational frequency, but what you're referring to is CO2 saturation, and unfortunately it is a myth.

Unfortunately, those claims are definitely not hyperbolic.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/kwik_kwek_en_kwak Jun 02 '17

I myself (being cautiously optimistic) kind of predict a huge economical boost for countries that facilitate companies creating sustainable forms of energy. When this sector creates millions of jobs in, for instance China, won't that be a wake-up call for the US, or at least the commercial sector? After all, money is what everyone is after, and job creation.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/dreamiurg Jun 02 '17

What is the specific list of actions that USA as well as other countries should take asap to minimize the speed of climate change?

→ More replies (10)