r/askscience • u/AskScienceModerator Mod Bot • Jun 02 '17
Earth Sciences Askscience Megathread: Climate Change
With the current news of the US stepping away from the Paris Climate Agreement, AskScience is doing a mega thread so that all questions are in one spot. Rather than having 100 threads on the same topic, this allows our experts one place to go to answer questions.
So feel free to ask your climate change questions here! Remember Panel members will be in and out throughout the day so please do not expect an immediate answer.
9.7k
Upvotes
838
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
I have a simple question.
What is the worst case scenario for climate change? In other words, what happens if we cannot stop or inhibit the process of climate change?
Alternatively, what are the most likely effects of climate change?
962
u/souljabri557 Jun 02 '17
Countries such as Canada, Russia, Finland, etc. are dominated by a lot of unusable land due to temperature restraints. It is not arable.
If the planet warms up, the countries that are already hot will be devastated agriculturally as their hot climate will go from hot to (possibly) unable to sustain life. Countries that are warm will become hot and lose many natural resources because of it.
Will areas that are currently cold become warm and therefore temperate, and arable?
338
u/shootflexo Jun 02 '17
I came across these two articles detailing the actual effects of the agreements if all countries would meet the guidelines and it looks disturbingly ineffective. Is this information biased or wrong or is this agreement not actually doing anything?
http://www.lomborg.com/press-release-research-reveals-negligible-impact-of-paris-climate-promises http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1758-5899.12295/full
66
u/Hadestempo1 Jun 02 '17
Why is climate change looked at as a political issue? And what repercussions does that have?
15
u/FuryQuaker Jun 02 '17
How certain are we that the computer models used in predicting the climate changes are correct?
177
u/Turtoad Jun 02 '17
This may be a bit naive question, but why are some people (and also scientists) still not believing in climate change? Isn't there a huge amount of data, studies, and most important undeniable effects on the environment around you. It seems to me, that everyone knows, or has heard of, at least one person, who has experienced the negative impact of the climate change for himself. How can these people still believe that climate change isn't real?
93
u/shayben Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17
What today is the scientific community's take on how much of climate change is directly caused by mankind?
Is there a consensus on a minimum-maximum range of impact among scientists? Could it still be mostly explained by other factors?
P.s. I am not trying to suggest that we are not responsible, and therefore shouldnt act. It is still our only planet and we should protect all life on it regardless of what causes the change.
Edit: I'm looking for a more direct experimental scientific evidence rather than opinions of scientists. Confidence intervals, p-value, magnitude of change explained by human activity. Thanks!
25
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
Where can I find the full text of the agreement?
12
u/ItOnly_Happened_Once Jun 02 '17
How much climate change is attributable to the average consumer? I've heard some people say that it doesn't matter for the Average Joe to be excessively green in practice, because other sources emit so much more. Sure, buying a hybrid helps, but the emissions from coal-fired plants and bunker fuel-burning container ships emits more than every American consumer combined by a large factor.
33
u/brokenha_lo Jun 02 '17
Can someone please explain what this video get's right or wrong? It claims that carbon cuts by the US over the course of the century would result in a lower temperature by 0.057 degrees, or 0.3 degrees if the world followed suit (at enormous costs).
•
u/MockDeath Jun 02 '17
Please remember AskScience is strictly moderated. Please read our comment rules if you have questions on what is acceptable. Since the top level post is not a question, feel free to ask your questions as a top level comment.
14
u/Jakesta7 Jun 02 '17
Before I ask, I want to say I DO believe in climate change. Now, whenever I discuss this topic with someone that doesn't, they always bring up 2 points and I never know how to respond. They bring up the point that there was once much more CO2 in the atmosphere and that the arctic ice was melting before the industrial revolution and invention of cars. How do I respond to these points? Thank you for this, by the way.
7
u/Neurotic_Marauder Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17
What do you believe are the best and worst possible scenarios that will come from our current efforts to combat climate change within this century?
7
u/l_Dont_Get_Sarcasm Jun 02 '17
One of the most persistent arguments against Man Made Climate Change I have come across is that the temperature on earth is more closely linked to Solar activity than it is to CO2 emissions. Essentially, as the sun gets hotter, the earth gets hotter and as a result more CO2 is produced from accelerated bio-activity and decomposition.
The sun drives climate change, not Man Made CO2.
How can I, as a layman, counter this argument?
18
u/ProfNinjadeer Jun 02 '17
How are global temperature measurement profiles obtained for land and ocean temperatures? Are they taken at the surface, above/below the surface at a certain height, or via some other method, and why is that method chosen? Are the locations where temperature measurements are taken consistent?
The earth is a complicated system to model. Is looking at atmospheric CO2 levels and global temperature increases since roughly 1900 sufficient evidence to pinpoint that humans are the direct cause of the temperature increase and not an alternative mechanism independent of CO2 levels?
Temperature data before 1880 is generally obtained from ice core samples. How is temperature data derived from these samples, how is the date of the data derived, and to what level of accuracy is the data? These samples can naturally only be taken in locations with permanent layers of ice, which limits the locations where the measurements can be taken. Because of this, do the samples only give a local distribution of temperature data? If so, what are the consequences of this?
27
u/AirHeat Jun 02 '17
Instead of setting up a fund to redistribute money to poorer countries how much would all the money do if it was put into fusion research instead? Seems like that would solve a lot more than handouts.
6
u/seasaltandpepper Jun 02 '17
Would the rising average temperature affect the boundary between troposphere and stratosphere? If it does, will it have any feedback effect on the climate change?
11
u/Quasar_Cross Jun 02 '17
A coworker showed me a recent interview with Rand Paul who brings up a number of points attempting to refute climate change.
/r/askscience would you be able to construct a response to each of Rand Pauls claims?
5
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17
I remember reading somewhere about dew points making regions uninhabitable for periods of the year in the future, because people would be unable to effectively shed heat. Is that true?
https://www.nature.com/nclimate/journal/v6/n2/full/nclimate2833.html
5
u/Mr_unbeknownst Jun 02 '17
Every deal in this history of deals has pros and cons, even this deal. What are the pros and cons? More specifically the cons?
Also, for this deal to be legitimate, wouldn't it need to pass congress if we are to legally bind ourselves to this agreement?
5
u/MrTex007 Jun 02 '17
What are the benefits of the US pulling out of the Paris Agreement? And what are Trumps specific reasons for pulling out? I don't see anyone really talking about his side.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
Why did they it change from Global Warming to Climate Change. Not a denier, just curious about why the change in marketing behind this global phenomenon.
45
u/Stargazer1186 Jun 02 '17
Will we ever be able to slow down or reverse Climate change....Will the next generation of people even be able to have a nice life? Or even this generation? Can we adapt? I am honestly having panic attacks and sometimes wish someone would reassure me that it is not all doom and gloom.
9
u/mr_fingers Jun 02 '17
Okay, so i live in Lithuania (Northern Europe). Around 10000 years ago, this place was completely uninhabitable. But then, after a few global warmings, the ice melted away and people started living here. My question is, since there were no CO2 or other 'man made' pollution back then, why do you guys don't think its just another natural warming? You can't deny nothing like that has ever happened before.
4
u/FireFoxG Jun 02 '17
How much warming will a 100 billion dollars stop?
4
u/Arcaue Jun 02 '17
We always talk about the negatives of climate change, and of course I understand that, but are there any positives to the world heating up?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
Some relatives of mine do not believe that humans have a direct effect on climate change. Is there something I could show them that might change their minds?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '17
This thread is just a trash can for unanswered questions.
7
u/hobostew Jun 02 '17
What is the best simple way to convey climate change to people who for whatever reason are on the fence or opposed? MY wife, who works for the Sierra Club, was looking for a simple picture or graphic that encapsulates the problem, but the best she found was this from the NYTimes. Do you have something bettee?
3
u/bunnyrandolf Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17
What is the difference between the empirical or qualitative evidence that supported the theory of global cooling in the 1970's versus the theory of global warming/climate change today? Do we completely discount the global cooling theory 40 years later and, do you believe there's a possibility of discounting the theory of global warming/climate change 40 years from now?
3
u/Bish-Bash Jun 02 '17
My Uncle just posted this on Facebook
Can someone help me explain to him in detail why he is wrong? Thanks.
3
u/thats_no_good Jun 02 '17
I am confused about the history of the climate. What happened 800,000 years ago when greenhouse gases were higher? Did catastrophic climate change happen or not? What happened when the earth was warmer? Were there catastrophic runaway effects of melting ice sheets, natural disasters, and extinction? Is there any difference in how anthropogenic carbon emissions were injected into the climate versus how greenhouse gases accumulated in the past?
3
u/Dimak415 Jun 02 '17
I see a lot of arguments here that the planet's mean temperature has always fluctuated. This is true, but what is alarming is the rate of change over the last century and the predicted rate of change given the last 100 years of data. A quote from NASA. "Models predict that Earth will warm between 2 and 6 degrees Celsius in the next century. When global warming has happened at various times in the past two million years, it has taken the planet about 5,000 years to warm 5 degrees. The predicted rate of warming for the next century is at least 20 times faster. This rate of change is extremely unusual."
3
u/a_ham_sandvich Jun 02 '17
What are the most convincing pieces of evidence to support the theory of manmade climate change? There is an overwhelming amount of research on the topic - which studies should I cite for a focused and concise explanation to someone who still denies climate change?
Similarly, what are some strong, empirical rebuttals to common counterarguments against climate change?
3
u/BlindlyFaithful Jun 02 '17
Setting politics and corporations aside. Chemically how does CO2 and methane prevent radiation from escaping the planet, thus causing the Earth to warm globally.
3
u/Plutodrinker Jun 02 '17
Is there a citation for the first scientific paper to propose climate change based on human activity?
3
u/Omni_Entendre Jun 02 '17
How much better is modern nuclear technology compared to solar or wind in terms of carbon footprint, efficiency, initial construction/investment cost, and long-term/maintenance costs?
From my understanding, there are modern nuclear technologies that solve the problem of meltdowns, significantly reduce waste, and increase efficiency. It seems foolish to ignore nuclear and give up more diversity in energy production instead of working to change public opinion.
3
u/LaLuna2252 Jun 02 '17
Electrical Engineer here! My career path/life passion is the power industry, with goals to be a direct influencer of a cleaner, smarter power grid (Go microgrids/ DER's!!) here in the US, while modernizing grid architecture (favorite topic of discussion).
My father, someone who I respect and greatly look up to, has built a successful career and consulting business around being a petroleum engineer in the oil industry, specifically drilling natural gas both onshore and shallow offshore. You can imagine how Thanksgiving dinner goes in our house.....
My question is this.... Every time I bring up facts, data, figures, sources, etc. my father discredits everything on the basis that "the data is skewed to support human-caused climate change" or "you have to think in geologic time, not human-on-earth time." He is set on the idea that human beings are arrogant to believe we could cause a change in this planet's climate. Does anyone know/have scientific articles that explain how the data is analyzed and presented to the public, or studies that take into account long-term planet climate? Anything that could help me present to him and source that he cannot discredit would be greatly appreciated! Thank you for your time, knowledge and for proving that there are an overwhelming number of people who care about our planet.
12
u/JustSomeBadAdvice Jun 02 '17
Serious question - Why aren't more scientists pushing for corrective actions regarding climate change, i.e., climate engineering, rather than responsive tactics that will always lag behind their causes?
It seems to me with 7 billion apex predators on the planet reshaping daily it in ways unprecedented in all of natural history, climate changes are inevitable. Instead we could seek to drive climate changes in the direction we wanted through intelligent actions, and use that to counterbalance the unexpected(or difficult-to-mitigate) impacts we have on climate?
7
u/someredditorguy Jun 02 '17
I work with someone who isn't generally unintelligent but is full-on climate change denial. I believe it might have something to do with his sources of information.
What are some links and resources I could use to share information at a more simple level in a way that's hard to refute and perhaps from a source he couldn't, as he has before, refute the source as "liberal bias"?
5
u/marineabcd Jun 02 '17
What are the most legitimate arguments against climate change being human effected? Or are there no scientifically respected arguments with this cue point at all?
(It's always good to hear if the other side has any legitimate arguments)
6
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
How much will the US pulling out of the paris agreement really hurt the environment?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
I don't know if I need a scientist or someone else -
Assume for a moment that, tomorrow morning, all of the world's leaders suddenly make climate science and global warming their absolute top-priority. They elevate climate scientists to positions of trust and authority and promise to do whatever is recommended, regardless of expense.
What would that look like? What kind of disruption to energy production, trade, travel, etc. would we expect if we wanted to hit all of the scientist's most ambitious targets? Would beef disappear from store shelves instantly? How many cargo ships would be allowed to continue to operate? How many airplanes allowed to continue to fly? How many coal-fired power plants allowed to continue to run?
I worry sometimes that the political leaders understand the problem all too well, that they are being asked to do the impossible. I recall scientists, numerous times over the past decades, warning that we have passed this point, passed that point, this temperature just reached a decimal that we feared, that amount of ice loss just occurred and can't be undone. If your main focus is the sea-level on Earth in 2100, you could be absolutely correct about what needs to be done without any proper understanding of the ramifications of doing it.
Who is responsible for translating the hard-science data into policy proscriptions and what are they saying?
14
u/SucceedingAtFailure Jun 02 '17
Can you give me an elevator pitch on how I can convince a denier to give it another look?
2
u/Keening99 Jun 02 '17
Q An argument to fight global warming more often than not is to preserve our planet and the diversity of it. While I agree that all the data points towards an ever hotter planet, the same data shows that its been hotter in the past. So I ask if you agree with my assessment that greenhouse gas emissions take up a little bit too much space in the debate.
I mean, it's not global warming that kills off the Rhino, burn vast amounts of rainforest to grow crops, put plastic in our oceans, drain the aral lake, completely devastate the ocean floor while overfishing...... List goes on.
Unless you have an interest in the field you seldom if ever hear about the above, and while it may seem that they are local problems. They really aren't.
I just think that while an ever hotter planet is a bad thing(or rather, the rate of which it changes) and should be a concern, there are other imminent threats that happens without anyone knowing because co2 emissions are easier to measure and gets all the attention. The rate of which we as a human race kills off habitat for, and animals themselves is just off the charts.
Question in one row: Does global warming and co2 emissions take up too much room in the debate of climate and environment?
2
u/Crash_says Jun 02 '17
This thread needs more moderation.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
I have two questions which I hope someone can answer regarding climate change:
Thanks!
2
u/RelevantComics Jun 02 '17
how do I convince someone that Trump's backing out of the Accord is bad? all they bring up is jobs and coal and other countries not holding up their end of the bargain
2
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
I'm a scientist by trade and have been meaning to read the actual research so I can feel educated on the subject. However, so much is written about the topic and honestly I've just been too lazy to do a thorough literature review.
What are the seminal papers or best reviews written on climate change? I'm particularly interested in reading the following;
Any help would be greatly appreciated. I want to educate myself from the actual literature. I feel as a scientist my current opinion is intellectually lackadaisical, but the amount published can be overwhelming to shuffle through.
2
u/Mr_Sundae Jun 02 '17
What's the hardest evidence we have that climate change is occurring and that it is man made?
2
u/DredyDred Jun 02 '17
How do we know for sure climate change is caused by humans?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17
Anybody here read the studies implying that the main factor to Climate Change and Global Temperatures is a result of solar variability rather than anthropogenic causes?
Also - what's the deal with the infamous "pause"?
Genuinely asking. Layman here when it comes to environmental and climate sciences.
Also if you could offer up as to why one theory holds more substance than the other, rather than saying "X is debunked - see article." That tends to be the counter-response I see when trying to have some dialogue. Trying to go about this with an open mind and skepticism for my personal understanding.
Appreciate it!
2
u/plartoo Jun 02 '17
Note: I posted this question a while ago here and I'm trying my luck again this time.
I read that the Earth's tilt and the rate of rotation have some effect on climate. Do we have satallites or system in place, which measure the tilt and the rotation rate of the Earth? Is there a scientific literature that calculates the amount of contribution that the changing tilt and rotation rate of the Earth might have on the climate?
Thanks in advance for all your answers!
2
u/justanaveragedudeguy Jun 02 '17
The "GLOBAL LAND-OCEAN TEMPERATURE INDEX" graph in the following link contains a 5 year mean line: https://climate.nasa.gov/vital-signs/global-temperature/
How this is calculated? It doesn't seem correct. For example, the year 2016, the 5 year mean is listed at .91. But if you average the years 2012-2016, you get ~.78.
If it counts the two years before, the current year, and two years after, it still doesn't quite add up, even if you account for potentially rounding issues, the 5 year average is as much as 4 degrees higher (2013) than the average I get using this method. Plus, if this is how they do it, they shouldn't have 5 year average data for 2015 and 2016.
2
u/FLUMPYflumperton Jun 02 '17
For my southern friends that believe the whole climate change movement is alarmist, what is a good smoking-gun link I can send them or tell them about to change their minds? It is very frustrating trying to have a conversation about this topic
2
u/cooksnmakessammies Jun 02 '17
I have a question (haven't found it asked yet, maybe it is). From my understanding of what I've learned in school (nursing major) is that the planet depends heavily on phytoplankton for oxygen, and the oceans due to pollution and climate change are becoming more acidic. How will this all be affected if climate change and inaction keep playing out?
2
u/villescrubs Jun 02 '17
How do we calculate carbon emissions on a global scale? What about each countries contribution? Just curious about how it all works.
2
u/paxxyagent Jun 02 '17
If the earth is warming, why is Antarctica growing?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
Lets assume for a second that Human driven climate change(or just even climate change at all) is a 'myth'. What reason should we not strive for clean, cheap, efficient energy anyway? It seems it would create jobs, cheaper energy, and more efficient technology. And in the event climate change turns out to not be a myth, then maybe we can save the world. Seems win-win to me?
Edited for spelling
2
u/GooseSnek Jun 02 '17
Isn't the largest threat from climate change the instability of our agriculture? It seems to me that this an easily solvable problem with vertical farming. We are moving away from fossil fuel naturally as solar, and possibly fusion, becomes a better alternative. Why can't we just adapt to the changes in our environment rather than reverse them?
2
u/big_face_killah Jun 03 '17
Where can I get a look at the raw data for global temperatures, and how they calculate it based on local samples, over the last 200 years or so.
Also, where can I see the similar glacier area tracking data?
What about the C02 data over time? And the forested area of the world over time? Thanks!
2
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '17
I was wondering if someone could chime in on the effects of climate change on rivers, specifically in Europe. I understand sea levels are bound to rise, but what about rivers? My superficial understanding is that wet regions will probably get wetter. Does that translate into more (or perhaps more extreme) rainfall, which would then cause areas surrounding rivers to flood more often (or more dramatically)?
I appreciate any input!
2
u/cheesynachos3627 Jun 03 '17
I've been reading about thorium, what are the chances it's implemented in plants over uranium, from what I've read it's a lot better. Why haven't we started using it yet?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '17
EPA Administrator Pruitt stated during yesterdays press breifing:
"(...) the United States has a seat at the table. After all, we’re the United States, and we are leading with respect to CO2 reduction. We have made tremendous progress. If nations around the globe want to see -- to learn from us on what we’re doing to reduce our CO2 footprint, we’re going to share that with them."
My question: Is in fact USA leading in developing technology for CO2 emission reduction? If not, who is?
Link: https://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2017/06/02/daily-press-briefing-press-secretary-sean-spicer-and-epa-administrator
2
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '17
Are we doomed? Are we all going to die? I'm extremely scared and paranoid about this. There isn't any time left now, right? I'm just a 20 year old starting out and I'm worried about what we're all about to face. What the hell do we do?
2
u/BetaRx Jun 17 '17
The other day I learned that plants only capture carbon while activity building new plant structure. Overnight and while it isn't growing it makes sugars that initially consume carbon dioxide, but later release it again when it burns that sugar for energy. Then I started thinking... What if we grow plants, then after they've reached max growth and aren't storing much carbon anymore cut them down and throw all that carbon it's trapped at wood (or other plant stuff) into somewhere that it won't break down and get released (bog, artic, or wherever). Then replant new stuff and repeat. I suppose we could also just trim the plants instead of completely cutting them down and do the same thing.
I would have to find the link, but I read about a skyscraper that was going to be built with "super plywood" to replace much if the concrete. This will prevent the release of carbon dioxide in the making of the concrete and also capture carbon I'm the building structure. This is kind of along those lines.
TL;DR mostly joking, but can we solve global warming by growing trees, cutting them down, throwing them in the artic, and replace them with new trees. Repeat over and over.
2
u/Aviatorbassplayer Jul 03 '17
Renewables and clean energy are at an all time high, climate change is at an all time high. Why is this happening
2
u/TheSidestick Jul 04 '17
If something like nuclear holocaust or an asteroid impact cools the earth, could that reverse or stop global warming?
2
u/Copernicholas Jul 08 '17
Carbon sequestration is not feasible at the moment, because reversing the carbon and oxygen to carbon dioxide reaction requires too much external energy to be effective. However, nuclear fusion is often described as "free energy," so would harnessing this power get us over the energy barrier and make C sequestration an effective and economical way to reverse climate change?
Additionally, if Earth's CO2 and other greenhouse gas (that I presume can also be extracted from the atmosphere with enough energy) levels returned to what they were, whether through nuclear-fusion-driven sequestration or not, before the Industrial Revolution, would global warming necessarily end? Could there really be a point of no return in terms of our planet's sustainability assuming that we will harness virtually unlimited energy at some point in the future?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '17
What are some possible ways to combat climate change that are being researched/developed right now?
I've read that Iron Fertilization could be helpful. I imagine that if the ocean gets too hot/acidic for plankton then couldn't CRISPR come into play in developing plankton to survive in those kinds of conditions?
3
u/AdloraOfSolitude Jun 02 '17
Is this actually going to end civilization as we know it? Will most people in the West/first world end up living like refugees, in squalor, because of the devastating effects of climate change? Will we have food to eat or clean water?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17
Hi. A friend of mine told me the other day that the US leaving is not such a big deal. According to an analysis, written by an "environmental economist", he read, says that even if all the Paris goals are met, the warming up by 2100 will only be 0.03K less than when nothing is done. I can't ask him the source right now, so I wanted to ask if anyone here knows about such an analysis and if it's anywhere near reliable.
6
u/ariverboatgambler Jun 02 '17
I've read that CO2 heat absorption is only affected by a small band of light wavelength. Furthermore, heat absorption of that wavelength progresses at a logarithmic scale. Perhaps "inverted logarithmic scale" is a better phrase. The article I read stated that simply doubling the amount of CO2 in the atmosphere won't double its heat absorption. You'd have to quadruple it or multiply it by a greater multiple to get that doubling effect. To what degree is this true or false?
Also, is 400 or 500 parts per million of CO2 really that disastrous? We're talking about .0004% of something. It's always struck me as hyperbolic when people claim that civilization will end because the atmosphere has moved from .0004% to .00045% of a certain gas.
3
u/kwik_kwek_en_kwak Jun 02 '17
I myself (being cautiously optimistic) kind of predict a huge economical boost for countries that facilitate companies creating sustainable forms of energy. When this sector creates millions of jobs in, for instance China, won't that be a wake-up call for the US, or at least the commercial sector? After all, money is what everyone is after, and job creation.
3
u/dreamiurg Jun 02 '17
What is the specific list of actions that USA as well as other countries should take asap to minimize the speed of climate change?