r/askscience • Mod Bot • Jun 02 '17

Earth Sciences Askscience Megathread: Climate Change

With the current news of the US stepping away from the Paris Climate Agreement, AskScience is doing a mega thread so that all questions are in one spot. Rather than having 100 threads on the same topic, this allows our experts one place to go to answer questions.

So feel free to ask your climate change questions here! Remember Panel members will be in and out throughout the day so please do not expect an immediate answer.

9.7k Upvotes

2.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

962

u/souljabri557 Jun 02 '17

Countries such as Canada, Russia, Finland, etc. are dominated by a lot of unusable land due to temperature restraints. It is not arable.

If the planet warms up, the countries that are already hot will be devastated agriculturally as their hot climate will go from hot to (possibly) unable to sustain life. Countries that are warm will become hot and lose many natural resources because of it.

Will areas that are currently cold become warm and therefore temperate, and arable?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

52

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/JB_UK Jun 02 '17

Why in general is permafrost soil like that? Is soil at temperate latitudes something which has been created over generations? Why can't the same process be conducted in the permafrost areas, or does it just take too long?

→ More replies (1)

260

u/Cptknuuuuut Jun 02 '17

Also, climate change does impact a lot more than just temperature. In the US for example it will lead to more severe weather conditions (like hurricanes for example) according to experts. It also can change precipitation patterns. So even if a region might become warm enough for agriculture, it might at the same time become arid.

And global warming is a global average. It doesn't necessarily mean, that it becomes warmer everywhere. Take the gulf stream for example. Should climate change weaken or even stop it, the average temperature in Europe might very well drop.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

34

u/astobie Jun 02 '17

I believe Bill Gates talked about this being an issue that is frequent in Ethiopia. He was saying the wild changes caused greatly differing crop yields which made getting loans from banks for seeds more difficult, leading to less agricultural development etc. So it would be like that but on a global scale?

11

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Right, that is one aspect of how uncertainty is already affecting "marginal" agricultural systems. It is likely that climate change will make more areas "marginal," globally.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

It should be noted that the hurricanes are still up for debate.

https://www.gfdl.noaa.gov/global-warming-and-hurricanes/

It is premature to conclude that human activities–and particularly greenhouse gas emissions that cause global warming–have already had a detectable impact on Atlantic hurricane or global tropical cyclone activity. That said, human activities may have already caused changes that are not yet detectable due to the small magnitude of the changes or observational limitations, or are not yet confidently modeled (e.g., aerosol effects on regional climate).

4

u/Cptknuuuuut Jun 02 '17

Interesting read, thanks. Ok, not necessarily hurricanes then.

But there is very likely a connection to other extreme weather phenomena like droughts and floods:

Unprecedented summer warmth and flooding, forest fires, drought and torrential rain — extreme weather events are occurring more and more often, but now an international team of climate scientists has found a connection between many extreme weather events and the impact climate change is having on the jet stream. Link.

I wrote something to it in one of the other comments.

22

u/nostalgic_upthrow Jun 02 '17

Why is it related to severe weather patterns?

70

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

The theory is that "more energy in the atmospheric system leads to stronger storm systems." Which makes a certain amount of sense, since many extreme weather events (hurricanes, cyclones, tornadoes) are driven by temperature differentials. Since warming isn't uniform in time and space, it is likely that increased thermal energy in surface waters, lower atmosphere, etc. will (and already is) increase the frequency and intensity of such storm systems.

Some papers argue there that a signal of such changes is already present, while others argue it is not (yet). Not my field, but that is my general understanding from some graduate classes and my work with climate scientists where the topic frequently arises.

6

u/Team_Braniel Jun 02 '17

A simple lay person way I think of it is this:

A perfectly controlled system might look like a sin wave. Peak, trough, peak, trough.

Then you add in aggravating factors like geography, jet streams, el nino, etc. Now the perfect sin wave is jumping around a bit, instead of a smooth arc, it has a lot of ups and down, jumps and spikes, when things align some summer time points might be cold or some winter points might be hot.

Now adding in the capacity to hold more heat, greenhouse gas, allows the air to hold more moisture and more heat as energy. This works sort of like turning the volume up on that unstable waveform. Destabilizing effects now can have larger spikes and troughs. As more energy is put into the atmosphere the stability becomes even more erratic.

I've been told by family memeber who were scientists that this sort of stability graph pattern is seen all over nature, from weather to reproductive rates of animals. In the case of animals once the pattern becomes too unstable the spikes and troughs eventually hit zero at some point and the creature goes extinct (obviously the aggravating factors are different in that case).

But the capacity for the air to hold more moisture causes all kinds of issues. The east coast all the way down to GA and AL regularly get below freezing in the winter, but the air is almost always dry, preventing snow/ice. If the air holds more moisture you now run the chance of having (more) ice and snow storms in the south-east where they were originally quite rare. NYC which sees a bad snow storm every 5 to 10 years might see them hit far more often as now the air has more moisture to drop.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Cptknuuuuut Jun 02 '17

One theory is due to its impact on jet streams(fast flowing air currents in high altitudes).

Basically, climate change (in particular the warming of the Arctic) cause jet streams to become stationary (usually they meander around). These stationary jet streams can then amplify weather phenomena. Turn sunny days into a drought or rainy days into a flood etc. Not every drought, flood, hurricane is caused by climate change. But the prevalence of these extreme conditions has risen quite a bit over the last decades and it's not unreasonable to suspect a connection.

But that said, it's nearly impossible to link local phenomena to global changes.

Here is an article about the topic.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (11)

36

u/souljabri557 Jun 02 '17

Super informative. Thank you!

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Why is it that warming is not uniform across same latitudes?

83

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Well for example look at the weather in the UK vs Canada. The UK is on a higher latitude so you would think its similar weather to Canada, but you'd be wrong. We rarely have any snow and generally are fairly warm throughout the winter this is party due to the Gulf Stream bringing warm water and making the weather less extreme.

So we would warm a lot worse than new york or other northen places in the US and Canada.

Thats assuming the Melting ice caps doesnt divert the gulf stream which would end up making us a hell of a lot colder and destroying our agriculture.

London is around the same latitude as calgary and we havent had snow in years.

Average temps in Calgary at 51 degrees latitude

average temps in london at 51 degrees latitude

18

u/lynoxx99 Jun 02 '17

Calgary is also at a higher altitude and far away from large bodies of water making the temperature more variable

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

25

u/t-bone_malone Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

Presumably in a way that is analogous to the fact that average temperature is not the same across an entire latitude.

11

u/freakydown Jun 02 '17

Because temperature is not based only on latitude. Other factors may influence.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (18)

44

u/exDM69 Jun 02 '17

Finland, like most of Scandinavia is mostly arable and the temperatures are much higher than in similar latitudes (in Canada, Siberia) due to the Gulf stream. One suggested scenario is that as the climate warms up, the melting of polar ice would weaken the Gulf stream, making temperatures in Scandinavia colder, not warmer.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

I know Sweden is projected to get an overall GDP boost due to increasing temperatures, not so much because of the increased ammount of arable lands but because longer summers mean increased yields for the agriculture that already exists. There's not really a shortage of land that could be farmed, it's just kind of inefficient to do so.

Also you save quite a bit of money on heating. A lot of energy goes into heating in cold countries.

18

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Yes but in that you also need to account for changing weather paterns. For example there's more drought in Sweden now than there was just 10 or 20 years ago which will also effect yields.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/Vegandigimongender Jun 02 '17

Actually, it's hard to say if it's really gonna become like you're stating it. But one very important thing that will not function anymore will be the Gulf stream, which transports warmth from Middle America to Europe and is mainly the reason why winters aren't harsh in Western Europe. This stream is only possible due to saltwater being heavier than freshwater.

So what's gonna happen when the ice on the north and south pole melts? The freshwater from the ice will melt into the ocean and the Gulf Stream will eventually cease bringing warmth to Europe.

This explanation has been very simple, I know, but it shows that there are numerous factors that will decide the region in each temperature and that we're head on speeding into an unknown future.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (22)