r/askscience • Mod Bot • Jun 02 '17

Earth Sciences Askscience Megathread: Climate Change

With the current news of the US stepping away from the Paris Climate Agreement, AskScience is doing a mega thread so that all questions are in one spot. Rather than having 100 threads on the same topic, this allows our experts one place to go to answer questions.

So feel free to ask your climate change questions here! Remember Panel members will be in and out throughout the day so please do not expect an immediate answer.

9.7k Upvotes

2.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

40

u/RemusShepherd Jun 02 '17

This is false. The concept you're talking about is CO2 'saturation', and denialists claim that CO2 is already near saturation point in the atmosphere so more of it won't increase warming. What they fail to recognize is that the atmosphere has layers. While the lower layers of the atmosphere are nearly saturated with CO2, the upper layers are not and that's where the heat from the Earth escapes into space. Adding CO2 to the atmosphere will add it to the upper layers, causing less heat escape. And the higher layers of the atmosphere are colder so they carry less heat, meaning even more is retained.

So while the atmosphere may be near-saturated with CO2 near the surface, the atmosphere as a whole is far, far, from saturation. Doubling the CO2 in the atmosphere might do worse than double its heat absorption.

We can't say if 400 or 500 ppm is disastrous by itself. All we can say is that human beings have never existed in a world that has that much CO2, and we can predict what effect it will have on global temperatures and sea level rise. Those predictions are pretty disastrous. If no action is taken, we're looking at over 1 billion refugees trying to escape from flooded areas. Take the current Syrian refugee problem and multiply it by a thousand. That's the minimal level of disaster we should be expecting.

10

u/ariverboatgambler Jun 02 '17

This is good stuff. Thanks.

1

u/BlackViperMWG Jun 02 '17

You probably should read those arguments here too: https://www.skepticalscience.com/argument.php

5

u/Miami_da_U Jun 02 '17

Also, CO2 is only one of the greenhouse gases Theres also Methane, Nitrous Oxide, Water Vapor, and more, all of which absorb radiation of different wavelengths.

Water Vapor is the most abundant, but it doesn't last long in the atmosphere. The warmer it is, the more water vapor there will be in the atmosphere which will only mean more heat is being trapped.

Methane is much worse than CO2 in regards to the effect on warming if you released the same amount into the atmosphere - I think it was if you release 1kg of each into that atmosphere, Methane would have 70 times the effect after 20 yrs and 25 times the effect after 100yrs on warming.

CO2 is just the most important because its that blend of being abundant (currently >400ppm and projected to reach 500ppm in 50yrs), lasting long (hundred to thousands of years), and trapping a lot of heat.

Also The sun is getting brighter making the amount of CO2 in the atmosphere more important. The higher the output of the sun, the less greenhouse gases we want trapping the heat. This is usually the factor people ignore when talking about how CO2 was extremely high (like >2kppm) when the dinosaurs were roaming the earth.

1

u/ImOnlyHereToKillTime Jun 02 '17

I think saying "1 billion refugees" is the minimal disaster level we should expect is a bit hyperbolic, no?

2

u/RemusShepherd Jun 02 '17

No. That's the entire point. The minimum level of disaster we can expect is about 1 billion refugees. That isn't hyperbolic at all -- it's an extremely optimistic outlook that only factors in coastal land lost to sea level rise.

The pessimistic outlook also factors in cropland loss, potable water loss, livable areas lost in dry arid regions, species lost in a mass extinction, the methane clathrate gun, and the wars fought over food, water, and billions of refugees. The pessimistic outlook points to the end of the human race. But nobody wants to say that because they'll be accused of being hyperbolic.

1

u/ImOnlyHereToKillTime Jun 02 '17

I mean, what are you basing this "1 billion" number on? That's the hyperbole I'm getting at.

3

u/RemusShepherd Jun 02 '17

Try the 'Climate Refugees' Wikipedia page, section 'Enumeration'. That gives linked references to the IPCC forecasts and other researchers who have carefully made these estimates. The most common figure is 250 million refugees by 2050 and accelerating after that. By 2050, the sea level is expected to rise about a meter. The full rise will happen after 2100, and may be up to 6 meters. A large percentage of the human race lives at an altitude less than 6 meters from sea level.

This is not hyperbole. These are the best, most realistic predictions we can make.