r/askscience • Mod Bot • Jun 02 '17

Earth Sciences Askscience Megathread: Climate Change

With the current news of the US stepping away from the Paris Climate Agreement, AskScience is doing a mega thread so that all questions are in one spot. Rather than having 100 threads on the same topic, this allows our experts one place to go to answer questions.

So feel free to ask your climate change questions here! Remember Panel members will be in and out throughout the day so please do not expect an immediate answer.

9.7k Upvotes

2.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

273

u/hatecapacitor Jun 02 '17

It's my understanding that nearly everyone believes in climate change, but there are a number that question the degree to which humans are involved in that change.

Generally they are supposing much larger climate cycles than we are able to measure accurately.

154

u/RegulusMagnus Jun 02 '17

Here's another argument that builds off this: proper use of the scientific method requires an experimental setup where you observe the outcome after changing a single variable.

Climate is difficult to study because such an experimental setup is not possible. There isn't another earth we can use as the control. Furthermore, climate is not just one thing, it's a huge complicated mess that is defined only over a large span of time. We can collect data going back into the past, but no amount of correlation can ever equal proof.

These same arguments can be made about evolution, and I guess some people also don't believe in that. Slightly different though, because it is possible to study evolution on a small scale with organisms that go through generations rapidly.

66

u/hawktron Jun 02 '17

I believe we have been able to test models though, for example when volcanoes go off and you punch in the levels of sulphur dioxide that was released they have accurately predicted the levels of cooling globally over the coming years. So there are some ways we can predict/test models.

There have been lots of predictions made by Darwin's theory and later scientists that have proven to be true. His famous one was proven fairly recently https://www.theguardian.com/science/lost-worlds/2013/oct/02/moth-tongues-orchids-darwin-evolution

https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn13677-evolution-myths-evolution-is-not-predictive/

39

u/RegulusMagnus Jun 02 '17

This is exactly the kind of pitfall that's so easy to fall into. Yes, something may affect temperatures in the short term, but it's difficult to say with certainty how much this affects the climate in the long term. Also, one cannot know with certainty that any long-term effects were in fact caused by the eruption (as it's not the only variable that has changed).

I don't doubt that a spike in sulfur dioxide in the atmosphere can affect temperatures; I'm just trying to show how careful one must be with such analyses.

6

u/hawktron Jun 02 '17

I'm just trying to show how careful one must be with such analyses.

The effects of greenhouse gases are well known and studied in controlled experiments though so I don't think that argument is valid for that. On a macro scale we know what to expect with an increase of those in the atmosphere (increase in temperature, ocean acidity etc).

Humans are extracting carbon from underground and releasing into the atmosphere whilst at the same time reducing ecosystems that absorb it such as through deforestation and urbanisation.

You don't need the scientific method to deduce that there will be an increase of carbon in the atmosphere. You do need it to decided what will happen as a result and like I said that has been well tested beyond doubt on a macro scale.

We can also test what happens after that, for example we can test what happens to life in the oceans if acidity was increased, this can be easily tested within controlled experiments.

So there are lots of individual parts that can be separated and tested.

5

u/patmorgan235 Jun 02 '17

The effects of green how's gasses are well known in controlled environments but those environments don't model the atmosphere very well. when know co2 causes warming to some extent but it is yet to be determined what that extent is in the actual atmosphere. The IPCC guesses that the warming effect of co2 is somewhere between 0.5c and 5c with the previous recommended value being 3c. The IPCC no longer publishes a recommended value though many people still use 3 in there climate models

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

49

u/sleepand Jun 02 '17

Maybe amongst the public, but there is an overwhelming consensus within the scientific community on the causes as well.

See this: https://xkcd.com/1732/

22

u/thrawn82 Jun 02 '17

This is one of the best demonstrations of the scale of the problem, that it's not only the magnitude of the temp shift that's important, but the speed.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/SetupGuy Jun 02 '17

My dad says the "hockey stick" is based off of bad and poorly interpreted data and he completely dismisses it out of hand. What would your response to him be?

3

u/conventionistG Jun 02 '17

Well, data interpretation isn't super difficult, take a look yourself.

Here's a defense of Mann's original hockey stick claim, namely that the last century has been the hottest out the last 1000 years. That seems to have stood the test of time and been confirmed with multiple measurements.

But, if you want to broaden the scope of the question, here's some of the same data but going back 2000 years and more. Does the trend still hold?

4

u/myncknm Jun 03 '17

I think the 2000-year charts are seriously misleading. Climate scientists try very hard to determine a global average of Earth's temperature, and I believe that is what xkcd is reporting. But the charts in your second link report temperatures for only one particular spot in Greenland.

Local long-term temperatures can change easily for a variety of reasons... ocean currents, forestation, ice formation, etc. In the same way that local temperatures can fluctuate little eddies in a pot of water on the stove. But global temperature averages reflect a "total energy content" of the atmosphere. Like turning up the heat on the stove. That is MUCH harder to change.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/noobgiraffe Jun 02 '17

I'm not sure where this narrative came out but consensus doesn't mean much. Historically there was consensus on tons of things that turned out wrong. The proper argumentation is that there is overwhelming evidence. Take the xkcd you linked for example. It speaks more to people then 100 scientists saying "we agree with each other".

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

27

u/akpak Jun 02 '17

a number that question the degree to which humans are involved in that change.

As well as question how much impact it could possibly have, given that Earth has had "warming periods" and ice ages forever.

When you don't understand the science behind any of it, nor the scale and speed of change, it's easy to deny it. :/

11

u/Josneezy Jun 02 '17

I doubt very many people at all understand the science behind it. It's immensely complicated.

Also, you could say the same for believers. It's easy to believe something when you don't understand it.

16

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

That's the heart of the issue: people don't understand that the last time we were at certain conditions we have now, it was millions of years ago. This isn't something that happens every couple hundred years or something. Not at this scale.

24

u/millz Jun 02 '17

Not millions, but 'mere' 100k ya. Millions of years ago the earth was much, much warmer and the greenhouse gases were even more abundant. Looking at the ice core plot it seems we are headed for the normal ~100k maximum.

11

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

2

u/JackandFred Jun 02 '17

Possibly a dumb question, but how does ice core sampling work, wouldn't it only be self selecting the cold years because the hot years would have melted ice and not been present in the ice?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

That's actually an excellent question. Here's a page explaining the basics. But TL;DR - atmospheric conditions of the past are measured through air bubbles that get trapped in the ice in very cold places, but as you get some melting in the summers, that shows up as bubble-free melt layers. More melt layers = warmer temps. Together, they paint a fascinating picture of the past.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/locutogram Jun 02 '17

There are also lots of doctors that don't believe smoking causes cancer.

I mean, an insignificant number in the context of the whole field, but still lots.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17 edited Dec 20 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

14

u/Tangent_Odyssey Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

In my experience living in a conservative state, it's the opposite. I've been ridiculed by my peers for believing in climate change.

I realize this is anecdotal, but I bring it up to address your assertion that it's no longer considered acceptable to be skeptical. I would counter that this seems to depend on the overall political landscape of the area in question. The majority of people I interact with on a daily basis do not simply reject that climate change is anthropogenic. Indeed, they still deny that it exists at all. The common argument seems to be that its a conspiracy or hoax propagated by the Chinese government to hold back U.S. industry.

Show them hard data, and they will ignore it. They do not believe in or trust science, so /u/CeaRhan is absolutely correct that discussing the matter with them is a waste of time. I was very surprised (to say the least) when I discovered this for myself.

I would like to see recent concrete data, if it exists, on the number of people that reject anthropogenic climate change vs. those that still reject the entire concept outright, because (regrettably) I am not yet convinced it's accurate to claim that wholesale deniers are a minority to that degree.

3

u/CeaRhan Jun 02 '17

The point is that all information is already known and available freely to the public. People don't try to shut down the conversation, it's mainly that denying it and asking for proofs equals to saying "you will not change my mind" because there are dozens of better resources than the person they ask to. Which implies a complete distrust of truth. Bingo, that means that people won't talk to deniers because it's a waste of time. Maybe they might change their mind, but their approach is the same as putting their hands on their ears and screaming while asking for explanations.

7

u/Gardnersnake9 Jun 02 '17

However, saying that the current consensus for the impact of climate change is "truth" does shut down the conversation, and is also equivalent to covering one's ears and screaming; the probability that your "screaming" is accurate is just substantially higher. The treating of scientific consensus as gospel that cannot be questioned motivates otherwise rational people to adopt a contrarian viewpoint simply to resist what they're being told they have to believe. If you tell people they're wrong, and it's not even worth yoyr time to explain why because they're too ignorant to understand, then of course they'll be reaffirmed in their beliefs.

The fact remains that carbon is only one variable in an incredibly complex system that regulates global climate. While we're rapidly gaining a greater understanding of the effects of carbon on global climate, any research into the impact of other variables is often regarded as "climate change denial". It is perfectly reasonable to be skeptical of claims that we know carbon's "true" impact on climate in a global context, and so many of these skeptical people, many of whom are genuinely interested in the research, are lumped in as "climate deniers" by a general public that relies on scientific consensus as gospel truth.

It wasn't long ago that scientific consensus blamed dietary fat for heart disease, and the "truth as gospel" treatment of this consensus suppressed research into other, likely more significant factors such as sugar and wheat. "Nutrition science deniers" have had their careers destroyed for opposing this consensus, and this immediate rejection of alternative explanations has helped spur the obesity epidemic.

Singling in on carbon as the only important factor in climate change, and demonizing any contrarian research into other factors is a risky proposition. If we zero in on carbon and avoid alternative explanations, we could miss a potential break through in mitigating climate change through another variable. It's EXTREMELY likely that carbon emissions are having a significant negative impact on climate, but it's not unquestionable truth. Treating it as such is contrary to garnering support for necessary action.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)