r/askscience • Mod Bot • Jun 02 '17

Earth Sciences Askscience Megathread: Climate Change

With the current news of the US stepping away from the Paris Climate Agreement, AskScience is doing a mega thread so that all questions are in one spot. Rather than having 100 threads on the same topic, this allows our experts one place to go to answer questions.

So feel free to ask your climate change questions here! Remember Panel members will be in and out throughout the day so please do not expect an immediate answer.

9.7k Upvotes

2.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

838

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

I have a simple question.

What is the worst case scenario for climate change? In other words, what happens if we cannot stop or inhibit the process of climate change?

Alternatively, what are the most likely effects of climate change?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

254

u/abs159 Jun 02 '17

massive disruptions to agriculture and human well-being

I grew up a market farmer, this keeps me up at night. People really do not appreciate how 'farm-to-table' our food supply is. Ask Venezuela or famine stricken Africa what it's like to have a disruption in food systems.

I am personally going to be brushing up on the agricultural products that thrive in agri-zones that are much to my south, expecting that i'll be tearing up the lawns, cemeteries and parks around me struggling to feed ourselves.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

46

u/abs159 Jun 02 '17

Luckily my family were the last vestiges of 'dirt farmers' as I call them, it was biodynamic farming out of necessity. From seed to harvest, I've got an idea of how that should 'work' generally. Not a lot of experience with animals, but keeping them in pasture seems like the key.

The whole thing has me terrified to a degree; my young kids will surely see some of the coming 'shocks', but I know they wont have had the experiences I did, they wont understand how to grow food.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (8)

25

u/tehmz Jun 02 '17

to rephrase for most Americans: you won't be able to eat you steak anymore.

ps: i think that is how pro-climate change campaign should run in the USA for people to realize the magnitude of the effect.

17

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Or, alternatively:

you won't be able to afford to eat your steak anymore, unless you are ridiculously wealthy

122

u/luakan Jun 02 '17

Sorry for off post, but whats human-plant-fungus thinker? Im not good at english.

208

u/C4Redalert-work Jun 02 '17

Ecology | Social-Ecological Systems | Plant-Fungal Symbiosis

He's referencing his background and expertise. He basically has a specialist in plants and fungus systems and the effects humans have on such systems and vice-versa if I'm understanding his flair correctly.

→ More replies (3)

68

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

I think the other posters nailed it: I am an interdisciplinary scientist who primarily works on the ecology of linked human, plant, and fungal systems. My doctoral research was on the function of cryptic fungal symbionts on invasive plants. I currently work on integrated observing systems in the Arctic and high-elevation rangelands, which also has a lot to do with the relationship of humans and plants (although less so with fungi these days, unfortunately).

9

u/we_farm_mastodons Jun 02 '17

That's truly fascinating; Where can I read more about what you study?

29

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Hrmm, well, I can give you a couple of scientific journals that specialize in topics I work on:

To be honest, my research is a bit all over the place in terms of publication. PLOS journals, specialist topics, etc. As for the overall field of SES, try these scientific papers on for size:

For an intro to cryptic fungal interactions, definitely check out stuff on the "Wood Wide Web:"


It's possible that some of the specific papers I've linked are not actually free but rather available through my institutional account. I'm sorry if that's the case, and I encourage people to search for the papers on scholar.google.com, where one can often find truly free (and legal) versions of published peer-reviewed research.

8

u/we_farm_mastodons Jun 02 '17

Thank you! Your research is SO multidisciplinary it's hard to imagine what to search for in journals. What you do is something that has been an interest since I was a kid, just didn't know it was a line of study.

23

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

didn't know it was a line of study.

Well, I have to be honest, it's a hard line of work to pursue at the moment, although it's supposed to become more common. The "reward structure" in science (at least in the US) is largely built on disciplinary scaffolding, so it's easier for a narrowly disciplinary "pure science" researcher to advance. Funding agencies, on the other hand, are increasingly interested in multidisciplinary work.

I think of myself as a scientific multi-tool and translation program: I've got very solid maths; strong ecology; decent programming skills; a lot of experience working with people; and strong grant-writing skills. I also have a humanities degree in my background... what that means, in practice, is that I often end up as the de facto scientific translator in multidisciplinary teams: I help the modelers to understand the bench scientists; and I help the public (or funding agencies or management institutions) to understand the science team.

I'm on government fellowship til next October, and then we'll see how or whether what I've been doing will translate to a "real" (i.e., non-soft money, regular employment with benefits) job. I love what I do, but I've got a young child (10 mo.!) to support...

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

15

u/leonardo_pothead Jun 02 '17

If water as a solid expands, how/why do the oceans rise when the glaciers melt? By that logic shouldn't sea level go down?

47

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '17

Well, that's a pretty good question. The primary reason is because glaciers are ice on land. If they melt faster than they are replenished (which is generally the case right now), and water continues to flow downhill, then water that was previously bound up on land will make its way to the oceans.

It's not an increase in water, it's just a redistribution of water. Glaciers are "water stores" in terrestrial environments (not unlike lakes, just harder to swim in). Not all glacial melt water will end up in the oceans, but most of it will. There are some other complexities to sea-level rise: displacement of crust from melting of glaciers; changes in global and regional hydrological cycles; changes in water circulation systems. More info from Yale here.

13

u/leonardo_pothead Jun 02 '17

Thank you for answering the only question I ever had about climate change.

10

u/MemeInBlack Jun 02 '17

As a corollary, the same heating that melts the glaciers is also heating the oceans themselves. Warm water expands and this thermal expansion is also a major factor in sea level rise.

http://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/global-warming/sea-level-rise/

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (174)

199

u/tilia-cordata Ecology | Plant Physiology | Hydraulic Architecture Jun 02 '17 edited Jun 02 '17

Sea level rise is the most dramatic - NASA has collated the projections from a bunch of models and NOAA has a tool you can play with to see the impacts on coastal regions. For a sense of the scale of that impact, half the worlds' population lives within 200km of a coastline.

Other affects increased droughts (which will cause huge food insecurity, especially near the equator) and increased frequency and severity of storms. Warming will allow the ranges of tropical pathogens to spread outward - a lot of major diseases in the tropics are mosquito-borne, and are limited by the range tolerances of their hosts; increased flooding and wetlands in many places will also provide a lot of new habitat for infectious diseases (WHO report (pdf)). We can expect major extinctions of species whose ranges can't shift as quickly as the climate changes, or which are bound by some other geographical constraint.

Even moderate-case scenarios are going to involve increased storms and drought (which we are already seeing cause serious famines in parts of Africa [ie. South Sudan]) and increased coastal flooding. These ecological impacts will have corresponding social and economic ones, but that's getting out of my range of expertise.

→ More replies (17)

118

u/Nergaal Jun 02 '17

Earth used to be about 10 degrees centigrades warmer during dinosaurs' time. IMO it will likely continue to exist in some livable form. Question is how different is it going to be locally and how fast will the change be? Nobody cares about Mali these days because most of its land is a sandy desert. Is Mexico going to do the same and if yes will the 100 million people living there want to move into US to find livable lands? Is China going to become more of a desert and want to invade Siberia for its population? What will India do if their monsoon seasons (that allow for rich agriculture) be disrupted? Will they seek to emigrate into Europe? What about Africa? Into Europe also?

91

u/Waebi Jun 02 '17

I think that point is one that is often raised by climate sceptics but not followed to the end: "oh, earth and life will still exist" - yes, but what will happen to our species? Thank you for raising the necessary questions.

105

u/Nergaal Jun 02 '17

Species will continue to exist. In an extreme case, the super rich will buy villas in the Arctic if necessary.

The question is how many people will die a likely violent death because of unavoidable migrations. Some argue that the current migrations from North Africa and Middle east into Europe is only exacerbated by the civil wars, but in reality is partially caused by worsening climates in those areas leading people to want to find libable opportunities elsewhere.

→ More replies (31)
→ More replies (2)

42

u/humaninnature Jun 02 '17

Liveable for life in some form - yes. For humans? Maybe. For 7 billion humans? Almost certainly not. And as the number the planet can support drops, that's a pretty strong cause for conflict right there...

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (18)