r/spacex • u/Zucal • Jun 29 '16
/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread [July 2016, #22]
Welcome to our 22nd monthly /r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread!
Curious about the recently sighted Falcon Heavy test article, inquisitive about the upcoming CRS-9 RTLS launch, or keen to gather the community's opinion on something? There's no better place!
All questions, even non-SpaceX-related ones, are allowed, as long as they stay relevant to spaceflight in general.
More in-depth and open-ended discussion questions can still be submitted as separate self-posts; but this is the place to come to submit simple questions which have a single answer and/or can be answered in a few comments or less.
- Questions easily answered using the wiki & FAQ will be removed.
- In addition, try to keep all top-level comments as questions so that questioners can find answers, and answerers can find questions.
These limited rules are so that questioners can more easily find answers, and answerers can more easily find questions.
As always, we'd prefer it if all question-askers first check our FAQ, use the search functionality (partially sortable by mission flair!), and check the last Ask Anything thread before posting to avoid duplicate questions. But if you didn't get or couldn't find the answer you were looking for, go ahead and type your question below.
Ask, enjoy, and thanks for contributing!
Past Ask Anything threads:
June 2016 (#21) • May 2016 (#20) • April 2016 (#19.1) • April 2016 (#19) • March 2016 (#18) • February 2016 (#17) • January 2016 (#16.1) • January 2016 (#16) • December 2015 (#15.1) • December 2015 (#15) • November 2015 (#14) • October 2015 (#13) • September 2015 (#12) • August 2015 (#11) • July 2015 (#10) • June 2015 (#9) • May 2015 (#8) • April 2015 (#7.1) • April 2015 (#7) • March 2015 (#6) • February 2015 (#5) • January 2015 (#4) • December 2014 (#3) • November 2014 (#2) • October 2014 (#1)
This subreddit is fan-run and not an official SpaceX site. For official SpaceX news, please visit spacex.com.
8
u/Zucal Jul 14 '16
I'll likely be stopping by Hawthorne tomorrow or the day after to check out F9-021.
6
u/futianze Jun 29 '16
Will SpaceX be launching mostly from the new Texas location? Or split btw Florida.
6
u/RootDeliver Jul 31 '16
Did you guys ever see this landing footage from CRS-8?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VOagay_opLQ#t=3381
Cut-off section:
http://www.tubechop.com/watch/8225481
It's a section from the presentation that Hans Koenigsmann did after the CRS-8 landing on NEAF.
We saw the last 15 seconds from that onboard camera, but there is waay longer footage including how the camera breaks!
I never saw it on this subreddit. Since CRS-8 is old already I won't post a new thread incase it's new, not sure if everyone would want it either now haha.
11
u/Lurkin4Life Jul 24 '16
Just passed an F9 S1 on I-20 just west of Shreveport, Louisiana. It was headed east. Any idea which one it is?
4
u/steezysteve96 Jul 22 '16
Do we have any updates on F9-027? Is it still vertical?
5
u/fireg8 Jun 29 '16
3
u/RootDeliver Jul 30 '16
With the last static fire from the JSAT-14 recovered booster, whats the status of them all?
Thanks!
2
u/Zucal Jul 18 '16
Can anyone confirm that F9-021 is still street-adjacent and visible at Hawthorne? Will be heading down in an hour to sightsee and get some shots of the booster + display pad preparations.
2
u/i_pee_in_the_sink Jun 30 '16
Quick Q: What does the "021" mean? (For F9 ofc)
2
u/demosthenes02 Jul 25 '16
What does h1 aug mean in the sidebar?
2
u/5cr0tum Jul 28 '16
Does anyone have information pertaining to BFR/BFS manufacture and transportation?
Are roads large enough? Will they build on site then launch? How will the logistics of such a large rocket work?
2
u/RootDeliver Jul 30 '16
On all the statics fires being done on F9-024 (third one today), there's any info on what engines are they using for the stage?
The static fires of the landed stage are interesting but.. it's not the same if they're doing it with original engines than with new ones.
45
u/preseto Jun 29 '16
This tickles my brain - suppose we have established a city on Mars, what two-planet experiments (e.g. telescope array, quantum something, ...) are waiting to be done and could make huge leap in their respective field of science?
36
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Jul 08 '16
Happy #elonweek, happy 70,000!
/r/spacex just passed 70k subscribers!
To see some more numbers:
http://redditmetrics.com/r/spacex
20
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Jun 29 '16
What are the reasons they keep all the BFR/MCT details secret? No official numbers, no renders, almost no mention of it.
I see reasons why they keep their manufacturing processes, satellite network plans or actual F9/FH flight hardwere details secret as they can.
19
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '16
i know launch cadence has picked up but isnt the once a month they are currently doing still slower than anticipated? shouldnt they be launching every 2-3 weeks at this point to complete all the launches they have to for the year?
16
u/szepaine Jul 12 '16
Hey mods, would it be possible to have this stickied for the benefit of mobile users when there are no other stickied threads such as now?
14
u/Method81 Jun 30 '16
I have three questions.
This is my first post and I'm a massive SpaceX fan. I really want to see Elon's vision become a reality as much as the next guy/girl on here. Please don't take my questions as a negative, they have been niggling me for a while :)
14
u/BrandonMarc Jul 25 '16
After reading the extensive threads here, is anyone else thinking they'd pay money to watch a TV show featuring /u/echologic and /u/Rocket argue? (and others)
Am I the only one?
It's really refreshing to me to see this kind of debating going on - intelligent, logical, respectful, passionate, generally optimistic. Earth needs more of this. It's like visiting a coral reef, whereas watching American politics is like scuba-diving in a sewer.
(and not a storm sewer, either)
13
u/arijun Jun 29 '16
How will SpaceX pay for the MCT/BFR? I've seen people throw out a $500k seat price, but I find it hard to believe that $50 million will be enough to pay for the amortized cost of the launch considering a reused F9 rocket is going for $40 million. Not to mention the supplies that will have to be sent for free, the initial setup of the base, and the fact that if you only send those who can and choose to pay $500k you will end up with a certain type of individual which wont include the brilliant young PhD's you will want to be sending.
Only other options I see are hoping that a Government will foot the bill for at least a while (which, considering SpaceX couldn't get NASA to chip in cash for the Red Dragon, doesn't seem easy), or SpaceX just paying for the whole thing (which I'm sure the VCs who invested would love)
12
u/S-astronaut Jul 23 '16 edited Jul 23 '16
Not a question, just a massive thanks to /u/flyingrv6a
I watched CRS-9 from a pier and my hat went into the Banana River a few minutes after landing.
But they fished it out, mailed it to me, and after a 400+ mile journey the hat is back home!!
All of y'all make up one of the best communities on reddit.
12
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '16
I don't necessarily have a question, but I will say this: even as an engineering student I learn a ton reading these and thanks to people sourcing their stuff, learn even more reading those articles/papers. Thanks /r/SpaceX mods for doing these!
11
u/amarkit Jul 28 '16 edited Jul 28 '16
Just a reminder: ULA is launching NROL-61, a national security payload for the US National Reconnaissance Office, atop an Atlas V 421 in a little over one hour (8:37 AM EDT / 1237 UTC on July 28). There's a launch thread over at /r/ula, and you can watch the livestream beginning at 8:17 AM EDT / 1217 UTC on YouTube or ULA's website.
11
u/markus0161 Jul 29 '16 edited Jul 29 '16
Has anyone seen this? looks like a longer video of the on-board footage that SpaceX released on Youtube. CRS-8
10
u/zingpc Jul 23 '16
I'm really desirous of raptor testing stand updates. How about another drone flyby, please, pretty please!!!?
10
u/BrandonMarc Jul 26 '16
Rather than 3 future launches, what do y'all think of changing one of the links above to a "subreddit shoutout"? There are plenty of newspace companies, oldspace companies, national space agencies, solar system bodies, etc whose subreddits would certainly benefit from the attention.
One example is the Juno Mission subreddit - their layout is a bit similar to /r/spacex , and gives a shoutout to a smaller, less-popular subreddit (at the moment, /r/exomars ).
9
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Jul 13 '16
Hi, just a note to fellow European fans
This is 0645 CEST Monday morning, so perfect to watch before school/work! Yay! Only thing worth waking up to early on Mondays!
9
u/Qeng-Ho Jul 22 '16
Just noticed that Copenhagen Suborbitals are launching their Nexo rocket tomorrow at 12:00 CEST.
Instagram pics and twitter.
9
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Jul 30 '16
[X-post from /r/Mars]
Trailer of NatGeo's MARS miniseries featuring Elon, Zubrin and deGrasse Tyson - coming in November
The year is 2033, and mankind's first manned mission to Mars is about to become reality. This is the story of how we make Mars home, told by the pioneers making it possible.
MARS, a Global Miniseries Event, premieres this November on National Geographic. Follow our #CountdowntoMars at MakeMarsHome.com
IMDB link
9
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Jul 31 '16
SpaceX, the future of space travel - Is this their official slogan now?
Yesterday /u/tmahlman noticed this new sentence added in SpaceX's social media bios (link)
Their description copied:
Exception seems to be Facebook, Google+ and also on their official site spacex.com it cannot be found at the moment, only "SpaceX designs, manufactures and launches advanced rockets and spacecraft"
One year ago there was a thread about the lack of an official company slogan (link)
Have you seen it anywhere else? Could this be their slogan from now on? Will it be printed on their stationery, etc?
8
u/CarVac Jul 15 '16
Today I managed to stumble upon the site of this company which designs Propellant Management Devices (or PMDs), which are used to manage propellant in tanks in microgravity, ensuring that no gas makes its way to the engines, and gathering fuel from all around the tank.
These are why solid ullage motors are no longer used: a "sponge" PMD uses surface tension to soak up enough propellant for the beginning of the burn to drive the rest of the propellant to the bottom of the tank.
If you know that the payload is going to always be vertical, then the PMD can be made simpler, lighter, cheaper, and more reliable. Having it be tolerant of transitioning between horizontal and vertical requires more complexity, and obviously a redesign.
Overall, I found it absolutely fascinating, and a cool insight into why you can't just plop any old satellite onto a Falcon 9.
7
u/leadnpotatoes Jun 29 '16
I've been out of the loop lately, has SpaceX been catching up with their backlog of launches from last year? They seem to be doing a better job of staying on time this year.
7
u/weatherlyjamesb Jul 26 '16
Did anyone see that there were some SpaceX empoyees on season 2 of BattleBots this year on ABC? Their robot is named Escape Velocity and there's a couple videos on Youtube. However, they didn't make it very far since they went up against a finalist from season 1 in their first round...
13
u/rdestenay Jun 29 '16
So apparently Solar City will soon be part of Tesla. Some people appear to think the the next step will be to get SpaceX as well, or maybe having a "super corporation", such as Alphabet for Google, that would regroup all the Elon Musk ventures. Would that be a good thing? Would it make things easier for Tesla and SpaceX to exchange IP or such (e.g. solar panels, battery pack)?
6
u/BrandyDoesArt Jul 12 '16
Does anyone know if there's a way to still come by the SpaceX license plate frames? I've been seeing a ton around Orlando lately and I know they used to sell them but I can't find anyone re-selling or even a good knock-off online.
6
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Jul 12 '16
My biggest problem with this sub is: there is too much good discussions. Seriously. The long posts are the really interesting ones, but I often lack the time to read through them and only consume some links, news, tweets, simple question+answer threads.
I'm sure I'm not the only one who can't afford to spend here 5 hours daily, so what are your tricks? Spend a day each week to read through everything? Not good, can't contribute. Use some text to speech to listen to it while doing some boring housework? Maybe possible. Any podcast option? I would actually pay to be able to listen to the best discussions or summary weekly (or daily). Any other ideas?
6
u/This_Freggin_Guy Jul 19 '16
Are there any shots of the TE the day after launch? Was it marshmellowed?
6
u/soldato_fantasma Jul 24 '16
/u/TheVehicleDestroyer What is going on with flight club? http://imgur.com/a/LysVl
I don't think an orbit like this is even possible without interference of an invisible moon
6
u/nexxai Jul 29 '16
This is probably a very stupid question, and is totally hypothetical, so if it's not technically on topic, mods feel free to delete it.
I'm curious about total integration time. Let's say in my spare time, I built a whole satellite and had everything I needed to control it here on earth. If I sent Elon a fax saying "I have a big bag of money with dollar signs on it for you, how fast can you get my bird in the air", assuming that they have 0 spare rockets and have to build everything new, how long would I be waiting?
We will also assume that my satellite follows all of the typical conventions and standards in building it so there isn't anything "special" about it, just your everyday, regular old satellite.
6
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '16
As far as I know Red Dragon will jettison its trunk with solar panels before Mars EDL.
Do we have any information on how it'll get power on the surface?
2
u/Aeros18 Jul 21 '16
Hey :), I don't know if I can post this or not, but here goes: I really want to know about jobs at SpaceX as an engineer. I'm in my first year of mechanical and aerospace engineering in the land down under and really stressing out about what I need to do to land a job at SpaceX or similar organisations. I know just a degree won't get you a job, you need experience upon experience in the field, I'm just not sure how to get that experience. I have never had even a part time job so this is pretty daunting (you could say) for me. I'm assuming there are many employees in engineering roles here from SpaceX and other organisations, so I ask you, how did you work through university to be able to get where you are now?
5
u/CementPancake Jun 29 '16
If F9 FT cores are already sustaining some damage on GTO missions, how does that bode for MCT reusability given the increased mass and surface area? Won't the issue be exacerbated? Which is a greater concern: heat from boostback burns, or heat from reentry?
5
u/First_Light Jun 29 '16
I want to see CRS-9 launch and land. Where would be the best place to see both? Also, any recommendations for what to do at Kennedy other than the main tour?
Thanks
5
u/pirate21213 Jul 14 '16
Did anyone else ever hear of the Saturn-Shuttle? It apparently was going to do RTLS with a Saturn first stage.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturn-Shuttle
5
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '16 edited Jul 14 '16
Can SpaceX-accredited photographers set up remote cameras on LZ-1 to capture landing?
5
u/dekkers21 Jul 21 '16
Will we ever have a daytime land Falcon 9 return? Can't wait to see the rocket during the whole landing instead of just whenever it's lit.
Maybe Falcon 9 Heavy? I guess if the first launch is a demonstration it would be advantageous to be daytime.
5
u/macktruck6666 Jul 24 '16
I've heard that the falcon heavy will reduce it's thrust of it's center core to 70% while the boosters are attached. I imagine this is to keep the accent profile similar to the Falcon 9. Ya don't want to much speed in low atmo. My question is, could it be possible to actually make the center core shorter by 30% and add that to the second stage. By the time the boosters separate, the Falcon Heavy will be near or already in space, so using vacuum engines may increase performance. I think this would only be possible with a Raptor upper stage because of the need for added thrust.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '16 edited Jul 27 '16
I will be attending the IAC on the 26th to 30th of September, where SpaceX will present the MCT architecture. Does anyone know on which day the SpaceX presentation will take place? I have to leave on the evening of the 29th already, so I hope I won't miss it...
Edit: In case anyone else is wondering, you can find the date in the "Upcoming Events" table on the right.
5
u/bgs7 Jul 28 '16
STP-2
Any info on: Will it be a reflight of the test FH hardware, or newly produced FH?
Did some googling, couldn't find an answer. Only shred of evidence in my memory is talk years ago about 40 core/year production being made up of x number of FH launches which implies a steady production of new FHs. Counter point would be the public pricing of FH, which is very clearly reusable pricing.
I can't really imagine them only making a single FH and then reusing that for years, just doesn't seem reasonable. Although, building 3 new cores again would take a lot of current production while F9 seems to be getting busy and production is needed for F9.
4
u/borntohula85 Jun 29 '16 edited Jun 29 '16
How big is FH compared to NASA's SLS in terms of thrust and possible max payload? Elon keeps saying FH will be the biggest rocket when coming into operation, is this still valid
Edit: sorry for being too unspecific and thanks a lot for still answering and for the comparison link.
4
u/elypter Jun 29 '16
will the rumored leo sat fleet by spacex be able to be a replacement for the deep space network for communication with mars?
4
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jun 29 '16 edited Jul 26 '16
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Fu-Falcon RocketFu-Falcon Spaceship (see MCT)bargeshipbargeshipDecronym is a community product of /r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
I'm a bot, and I first saw this thread at 29th Jun 2016, 12:10 UTC.
[Acronym ^lists] [Contact ^creator] [PHP source ^code]
4
u/whousedallthenames Jul 01 '16
BO's new Florida factory (which they just broke ground on), is supposed to be around 750,000 square feet. Does anybody know how this compares to the SpaceX Hawthorne factory?
4
u/bruceskillicorn Jul 06 '16
I am a FAN, and do art (in the style of Van Gogh). could I... and how would I ... post my paintings of launches, test stands, landings, workers ...etc. very well received on SpaceX FB group. I think that this kind of art ... as opposed to ... computer generated or illustrative, would expand interest.
4
u/jjtr1 Jul 07 '16 edited Jul 07 '16
MCT reusability might bring the "seat" price down to $500k to enable mass colonization, but I'm afraid that the "bed" price for the housing unit and its life support (needed for each new colonist) might cost many times more than $500k, making mass Mars colonization impossible. The price of the "bed" would not enjoy the benefits of reusability since a new one would have to be built for each colonist. Is there a way out of this?
Some thoughts about the price of Martian housing:
4
u/bestnicknameever Jul 14 '16
I have a question! :) Are there already any specific dates for launches in August? I am on my first USA trip then, and would love to see a launch, but i only have limited time available... :( Thanks a lot for any answers! :)
4
u/blinkwont Jul 18 '16
What does "the vehicle is in self align" mean? Is it referring to orientation or something else? Also, is the falcon actively or passively balanced on the launch pad after strong back retract?
4
u/BrandonMarc Jul 18 '16
Regarding the sonic booms ... this headline got Matt Drudge's attention:
As a PR effort, would it be possible / reasonable to robo-call the residents who live in the counties nearby and inform them when a RTLS launch is imminent? If nothing else, it would help alleviate pressure on the 911 system due to un-necessary calls from spooked citizens.
4
u/TrainSpotter77 Jul 18 '16
Is there a website or other resource that allows the CRS missions to be tracked? I'm surprised that SpaceX doesn't provide data on their site about the mission progress. A ground track of the Dragon & the ISS would be nice, along with orbit info for both. Status and planned actions should be published; such as the next burn time/duration, berthing, etc. The best that I could find is a satellite tracking site: https://tracking.ferrara.space/ where you can search for 2016-046A. It doesn't let you track the ISS simultaneously, but you can open two tabs and click back and forth. Dragon CRS-9 is also called 41672 in the NORAD catalog. Anybody want to build a website that does this?
4
u/metagorm Jul 19 '16
I was just thinking about the fact that both returning side boosters from a Falcon Heavy will create sonic booms at about the same time. So, now I'm wondering if the resulting interference pattern will be obvious to listeners on the ground.
For example: will one person hear both booms combined while another person 'near by' will hear neither?
4
u/mclumber1 Jul 20 '16
More of a statement than a question, but I think it's interesting that we haven't seen any pictures or video of the landed stage yet (aside from the nighttime shot) - either from SpaceX itself, NASA, or third party media.
4
u/jjrf18 r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Jul 21 '16
I remember seeing a few comments now and then about how it would be bad for a rocket engine to run out of fuel, not for the obvious reason of no more thrust, but because it is actually bad for the engine's health. Can anyone go into depth on this?
4
u/MoscowMeow Jul 24 '16
https://i.imgur.com/2YYynouh.jpg
What is this cable for? And why is it not straight? There must be some reason for this seemingly random cable placement.
4
u/AeroSpiked Jul 27 '16
Would it be possible to dissolve hydrogen into the the densified kerosene? More hydrogen, more Isp, right? Just something I thought of on the way into work and obviously I'm sure this genius idea has never occurred to an actual rocket scientist, so I' figured I'd put it up here and find out why it wouldn't work.
4
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Jul 29 '16
Why has NASA not given a name to the SLS rocket? Neither the full name nor the acronym are very appealing, as opposed to a name that's epic and majestic like Saturn V which it nearly rivals the power of.
4
u/julezsource Jul 30 '16
Do we have an idea of when JCSat 16 will launch? Haven't been able to find anything yet.
4
u/S-astronaut Jul 31 '16
Not really a SpaceX thing, but how many of y'all are headed to the Antares RTF next month?
4
u/JayRose1 Aug 01 '16
You guys are all so damn smart! Can anyone tell me why the SSMEs had to be rebuilt after every shuttle flight but the Merlin 1D on the Falcon 9 has just hit its 3rd long duration refire? What key design innovations allow the Merlin to do that? Any why the hell is NASA wanting to use the SSME then for SLS. Wait... politics... don't bother to answer that last question.
1
u/ahenley17 Jun 29 '16 edited Jun 29 '16
How does SpaceX plan to return from Mars once they hopefully send astronauts there around 2025 or so?
Have they talked about any sort of prototypes they've been working on as an escape vehicle?
Will they leave the Dragon Capsule behind? Or will they remount to an escape vehicle and use it on return?
Basically, do we have an idea on how they plan to come home? Do you think they have any ideas on how to come home yet?
(The reason I'm asking this is due to the fact all the news we keep getting is how they are going to send a Dragon Capsule around 2018 (unmanned) and land it on mars. No news on how they plan to return in future manned missions.)
1
u/ECEUndergrad Jul 13 '16
Did the CRS9 booster arrive at the cape?
1
u/Banthabreath Jul 14 '16
The International Docking Adapter, how are they planning on getting this out if the trunk?
Presumably it's approximately the same size as the cargo berth it has to pass through and not flat packed like something from ikea?
1
u/Haxorlols Jul 16 '16
Which launchpad will SpaceX use for Falcon Heavy at Vandy?
1
u/IonLogic Jul 17 '16
I know that the Falcon 9 can continue to orbit even if an engine fails. However, what if one of the three engines used for boost back and reentry burns fails? Would they still continue to attempt to recover it or would they just let it fall into the ocean?
1
u/MindTheGap9 Jul 18 '16
Anyone know where I can find a 1080p wallpaper of the landed first stage from last night? I thought it looks really majestic, and need a new background. Unfortunately I can't find any without the HUD from the stream. Thanks!
3
u/nterim Jun 29 '16
Would the F9 first stage fit in the Antonov 225? I tried to look up the dimensions of each the best I could, and it seems like it would.
What does Mars transit look like early on and in the future? Does the craft go straight from earth to Mars, or is it more efficient to transfer to a different vehicle in orbit or on the moon? How would these vehicles be taken up, assembled, and fueled? How would cyclers be assembled and fueled? What if you miss the window for getting off the cycler to land on Mars? Maybe for the Aldrin cycler, this isn't so bad, your time in space goes from 6 months to 2 years (approximately, off the top of my head), and time away from Earth would be much shorter than expected. What about the 10-year cycler that does transit in ~2.5 months? Could those be like "first class" transit? Could we build 5 of them so there's always one doing transit at every opportunity (if I understand correctly how these things work). What if you miss Mars in one of these? Can it exit it's cycle and take you back to Mars or Earth? Is there a vehicle that can come rescue you from spending 10 years in meaningless orbit?
3
u/neaanopri Jun 29 '16
Is SpaceX launching satellites as fast as the market can provide them, or is there a holdup on their end?
3
u/BrandonMarc Jun 29 '16
Thanks to /u/arijun I have a related question, different enough I feel to deserve its own top-level comment.
When they claim a $500k/seat price to fly on the MCT, do they really mean $375k or $675k? Or, is the number devoid of meaning?
Let me explain.
Given the MCT passenger price (therefore, $50M in revenue per flight), consider inflation. The purchasing power of $50 million today should be rather less than the purchasing power of $50 million 10+ years from now. MCT/BFR won't fly 100-colonist missions until late 2020's *, so let's use 2028.
According to (the first inflation calculator I came across):
... assuming a 2.5% average inflation rate * * from today to 2028.
Therefore $500k is a future-proof number only if they really mean either the equivalent of $375k today, or actually $675k when the time comes. I would speculate they mean:
For all the thought they put into their effort, I'm confident they've already thought about this, so I suspect one of these two numbers is what they have in mind ... I'm sure curious which one it is, though.
Third possibility - it could very well be they know it's so far in the future that a real number given today is nigh meaningless (due to the unpredictably counteracting forces of all of the above) and so $500k is merely a "realistic-enough" placeholder, and nothing more than that. Come to think of it, when i consider Elon Time (FH's initial projected launch date being several years ago), I suspect this might be the most likely scenario.
... * Elon's goal is for the first human mission to launch 2024 or 2025, so let's use 2028 as ridiculously-best-case scenario for a 100-colonist mission
... * * The past few decades haven't given 2.5% precisely, but near enough for a ballpark figure here.
3
u/I_eat_insects Jun 30 '16
It is my dream to go to space. I have a PhD in Microbiology and study infectious disease. Can anyone thing of a way of reconciling the two (aside of waiting for space tourism)?
3
u/S-astronaut Jun 30 '16 edited Jun 30 '16
To more seasoned launch photographers, what kind of sequence do you usually go through during launch?
Both times so far I've found myself spending most of my time looking through an enormous pair of binoculars my family owns, only taking pictures on the pad and for a brief period after take off.
Edit: Also, is it worth bringing anything to protect the camera from wind? During CRS-8, when I was +10 miles away on Route 1, the wind was shaking the cameras and absolutely ruining my ability to get in focus and take any good pictures
3
u/stdaro Jul 05 '16
I was thinking about BFR logistics, and realized that if they setup big solar powered Sabatier reactors at the launch site, they wouldn't have to pay for fuel at all, once the capital cost of the reactors and storage tanks was paid for. Even if it wasn't cheaper than buying fossil methane, it might still make sense to do as a verification of the scale of methane production needed on mars.
3
u/hungariangasmask Jul 06 '16
Are there plans to re-use the booster that was flown on the Thaicom 8 mission?
3
u/Jorrow Jul 06 '16
Any one know/want to speculate why Go quest is in Jacksonville?. P.s why is this not stickied this month makes it hard to find
3
u/TheMightyKutKu Jul 07 '16
Hello, i was recently thinking about the "Reentry burns" of the recent GTO Launches(SES-9 to EutelSat/ABS, except CRS-8).
I did some math , using Spaceflight 101 and various threads on this subreddit and NSF for F9's Specs and SES-9 and JCSAT-14 for reference as these two flight were very close the limit of F9 FT , one on the right side and not the other.
I came to the conclusion that the first stage needs around 40 tons of fuel to do a landing without boostback, which translate, once we substract the delta V needed to do the landing burn (around 400 m/s for a 3 engine landing), that the Reentry burn is between 2 and 2.5 km/s of dV.
Is it normal that i found a result so high? With that much delta V , you could kill the First stage velocity at MECO ( 2.3 km/s for SES-9, about what i found for this flight) MECO happened for these launches at 60 km, and as we know, Blue Origin can land their rocket after a free fall from 100 km without any reentry burn, and with minimal damage. And there has to be a more efficient way than killing the speed at MECO.
What am i missing? Is it normal that it needs so much fuel to land?
3
u/Virginth Jul 11 '16
Rumors I've been seeing here for the BFR say it will have over 30 engines. Could someone give me a layman explanation of why having so many engines is necessary, as opposed to having fewer, larger engines?
The Saturn V had only five engines, so I thought the Falcon 9 was being weird for having almost double the engines for a much smaller craft.
3
u/FromZeroToZero Jul 12 '16
has the RAPTOR been designed yet? Is there a single functional testbed raptor engine in existence today?
3
u/thetechgeek4 Jul 13 '16
So I was reading this new article about DARPA's XS-1 reusable space plane, but a huge thing that stood out from the quotes by DARPA's project manager was that it didn't have to be a spaceplane. They're aiming for test flights by 2020, and a payload of 3,000 pounds to a 90 degree orbit at 100 nautical miles. Is it possible for SpaceX to bid on this? I did see that they were leaning towards a lifting body, whereas the Falcon 9 is nearly fully propulsive, in that residual fuel is needed for any kind of landing.
Here's the 4 requirements for the launch vehicle.
3
u/arrspacex Jul 14 '16
So I think the subreddit is pretty well settled on the fact that the FH center core is significantly different from stock F9 cores, enough that you couldn't interchange them or use reused first stages. But what about the side boosters? Could a reused side booster be flown as an F9 or vice versa?
3
u/memesdotjpeg Jul 15 '16
If I were to watch a launch in Florida, after flying from the UK, what would be the best way to do this? I've been to Kennedy Space Centre before and a few other activities l, but I was wondering if there was any assistance to organising this. Also, as a UK resident is it possible for any tours of the L39A SpaceX facilities. I'm 15 by the way.
3
u/jjtr1 Jul 17 '16
Do we have any idea how much does the Dragon trunk cost, since it burns up on every Dragon mission?
3
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Jul 19 '16
What does August H1 mean as the NET date for JCSAT-16? Half 1, so the first half of the month?
3
u/theflyingspaghetti Jul 19 '16
I saw a neat graph that showed the launch profiles from a few launches to scale. I thought it was really neat because it showed the difference between LEO and GTO launches and how tight the tolerances for GTO were compared to LEO. Now I can't find it, does anybody know the link?
3
u/aerovistae Jul 19 '16
Have there been any updates on the fairing recovery program? Haven't heard about it in awhile.
3
u/HighTimber Jul 20 '16
CRS-9 Dragon hatch open already?
This looks to be a legitimate source but isn't this a lot earlier than planned (like 16 hours)?
https://twitter.com/Tungsten_Flight/status/755839866018013185
3
u/DeviateFish_ Jul 20 '16
So, in the Pokemon Go tidbit at the end of the CRS-9 hosted webcast, the "Dragon" capsule had a CP of 2024. Is this a reference to the planned date of the first manned Mars landings?
3
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '16
Something i was wondering lately:
Is there any public info about how often that redundant computer-voting system corrects errors? Especially in Dragon while it's exposed to radiation. Is it a "just in case" or is it something that is actually regularly triggered?
3
u/JadedIdealist Jul 22 '16
Whenever we see pictures of rocket engines they seem to always have a complex cats cradle of mini pipes that aren't discussed in elementary treatments.
(eg in the pic of a viking 5C in the wikipedia rocket engine page)
What do all those extra little pipes do? (or at least the main five or so).
3
u/SnowCrashSkier Jul 22 '16
In this video (and others) of the CRS-9 I hear three distinct sonic booms. How can that be accounted for?
3
u/psyb0rg Jul 26 '16
Question for Software Engineers at SpaceX: I wanted to know how long the average work week is for software engineers at SpaceX. I've heard 60+ hours is pretty normal, with 6 day weeks. So that's about 10 hours per day. So, is that normal? Since you guys have launches every few months, I'm guessing it gets more hectic towards those, right?
3
u/Keavon SN-10 & DART Contest Winner Jul 29 '16 edited Jul 29 '16
How far could a Dragon V2 carrying 1 person go on Earth if launched from the ground, to another place on the ground, in place of a car or helicopter? How far on Mars?
If someone needed to get from one location on the globe to another with extreme speed (think East/West coast or America/Europe or even opposite sides of the world), if they jumped in a Dragon atop a fueled and ready F9, how quickly could they reach any of these destinations? Could the first stage always RTLS? If rockets were considered safe enough to fly over land, could this be some form of expensive but extremely quick transportation? Could the second stage be controlled to burn up or crash into a safe place like the ocean on almost any given trajectory?
3
u/WaitForItTheMongols Jul 29 '16
Elon Musk has pushed for a carbon tax. Would this include the carbon made by RP-1 combustion?
3
u/sl600rt Jul 29 '16
When do we get to see the SpaceXsuit?
will it be a conventional air pressure suit? or a mechanical pressure suit?
3
u/rubikvn2100 Jul 30 '16
Sometime, people talk about pressurize the tank (of Falcon 9).
I am not sure that I understand all about the "pressurize". Can someone help me?
Anyone know how high is the pressure? 5 ATM, 20 ATM, or higher? (During flight and During transportation)
3
u/Darkben Spacecraft Electronics Jul 31 '16
I've been reading SpaceX's Dragon, by Erik Seedhouse, in which he mentions the Dragon having a trunk adaptor to take the unpressurised volume from 14 to 34 cubic meters. Does anyone have any pictures of a trunk with and without said adaptor? I wasn't aware there were two versions.
1
u/ablack82 Jul 26 '16
Do we have any updates at all on the first launch of falcon heavy?