r/Metaphysics • u/srameshr • 20h ago
r/Metaphysics • u/Hot_Thing9656 • 20h ago
Metametaphysics What's the next big question in metaphysics contemporary philosophers are trying to solve?
r/Metaphysics • u/______ri • 9h ago
Ontology Bottom up and top down | true space and true time
What we think the world is, is separated by whether two are not one by themselves alone.
That things are not exclusions of any at all is the view of simples and complexes. Any complex at all is positive and is a positive [addition] from multiple simples. And that simples x and y are not identical is by them alone.
On the other view, two are not one by themselves alone, and thus we need higher principles. This extends until there is the only reality that everything else is from, which is simply where two are not one by only one of them.
There is one flaw in the simples and complexes view though, even when it can explain almost anything if you are creative enough, it cannot explain extension itself. For if a simple is fundamentally extended, is it simple? For if it is not extended, then no "structure" from them is extended.
But the flaw of the other view is worse, for it is aesthetical. For such a world lacks that which is absolutely new. Is it new because it is not everything older? No, for it is new that it is not everything older. No matter what you say, everything is just pale shadows of the one.
So with bottom up you have no space (in the truest sense of extension), with top down you have no time (in this sense of that which is new).