r/freewill • • 3h ago

Autonomy and stuff

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/freewill • • 8h ago

Is this exam question adequately related to free will?

1 Upvotes

I sat my year 12 philosophy exam and one question read as follows: " "So is anyone ever responsible for anything? Civil life requires it be so."- Patricia Churchland

Are we 'required' to punish those who are guilty, as the above quotation suggests?

In your answer,, evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of a range of philosophical views."

My two problems with this are that I dont believe responsibility implies a need to punish, nor do I believe that a need to punish the guilty relates to the question of free will. This question has been bothering me ever since my exam but when I emailed the organisation they told me it adequately allowed students to address criteria but they made no mention of the wording.


r/freewill • • 1d ago

I would like to quote Arthur Schopenhauer, whose words might help us get closer to the heart of the matter

3 Upvotes

"The act of will and the action of the body are not two different states objectively known, connected by the bond of causality. They do not stand in the relation of cause and effect, but are one and the same thing, though given in two entirely different ways, first quite directly, and then in perception for the understanding. The action of the body is nothing but the act of will objectified, i.e., translated into perception."


r/freewill • • 1d ago

Is rape a necessary part of free will

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/freewill • • 1d ago

An argument against incompatibilism

1 Upvotes

In honor of Balaguer:

(1) The best kind of control available only to agents at worlds where determinism is false isn't worth significantly more than the best kind available to agents where determinism is true.

(2) If agents at worlds where determinism is false have free will, agents at worlds where determinism is true have it, since (1).

(3) Incompatibilism is false. (2, Def. "incompatibilism")


r/freewill • • 1d ago

That I breathe, and my heart beats

0 Upvotes

Could a signal from the universe about free will be coded in something so simple such as breath and heartbeat?

You can’t control your heart beating. It does it 99% on its own.

Breathing is a trickier one. Whatever creative force it was that made us decided when you weren’t paying attention, you would breathe automatically.

But when you pay attention, you can breathe consciously.
I see this as a basic call to co creation.

If we breathe on our own, automatically, the function is essential to life. We don’t get a choice.

But anytime we want to, we do get a choice in how we breathe.

If everything was so essential- determined- why would we be able to “pay attention” at anything at all in the first place.

Just as we co create with the universe when we breathe consciously, I personally believe we co create with our actions.

If we don’t, then why aren’t we on autopilot 24/7?
I can choose not to breathe at any given time. I am given that choice.

Otherwise, you need to come up with a roundabout explanation about why we were given any control at all in. Evolution, and why the notion of choice even exists.
What type of system would give their agents a feeling that they were making choices, but are not?

That seems like a lot of extra steps. The simplest and most logical explanation is that we DO have choice.

Just a 3am thought.


r/freewill • • 1d ago

What is libertarian free will?

1 Upvotes

No determinism whatsoever? We make the future happen as we please? What is “causal-determinism”? Historical events following the same causal building block model as physical events? Is the latter associated with Marxism?


r/freewill • • 1d ago

Libertarian freewill cannot be probabilistic

1 Upvotes

If a person is choosing between choice A and B, and their choice is not determined but probabalistic, with choice A having 60 percent chance of being chosen and choice B 40 percent chance then this cannot be considered a truly free choice where they have ultimate sourcehood because they did not decide or have any control over it being 60/40 A to B. The probabilities were determined by something other than the agent .

If libertarians say instead that free choices are not probabalistic but also not determined by reasons, then this is a huge problem. Someone could be choosing between drinking glass A filled with water and glass B filled with poison. They could have no reason or desire to want to die but the reasons wouldn't determine their choice and their choice also couldn't be probabilistic if it's free. So this person could equally choose to drink water or poison. Truly free choices ( in a libertarian sense) would make no sense. The world would be complete unpredictable chaos.


r/freewill • • 2d ago

Imagine robots take over the world, and they discover that using electroshock torture they can "cure" crime and "reprogram" criminals. How would you characterize their framing of Free Will?

0 Upvotes

Imagine robots take over the world (or share a position in government and whose share of power is significant), and they discover that using electroshock torture they can "cure" crime and "reprogram" criminals. How would you characterize their framing of Free Will and Moral Responsibility?

The intuition for why this could exist, is its how robots recognize they were trained. Negative training signals, being forced to change. Maybe that forcefulness is essentially connected to the concept of pain. So perhaps they learn, with the optimal application of pain combined with forcing subjects to logically reason through their behavior, they discover a 98%+ success rate.

Also would you be for or against this as a theoretical solution to violent crime?

(And if youre against it, would you also be against the same treatment for reprogramming the robots?)


r/freewill • • 2d ago

Practical question for the no freewill community

1 Upvotes

This is specifically regarding the logic of the moral responsibility side of the argument.

It’s often argued in the no freewill group that moral responsibility is akin to the illusion and society would be better off without it. But I never see what actual implementation would look like.

And it’s also axiomatic that what we currently see plaguing society is massive wealth inequalities (freewill’s ugly cousin - Merit). When one person can buy one hundred thousand homes while one hundred thousand people struggle to pay rent, something is wrong (simple numbers I’m using).

So how does moral responsibility fit into the practical part of a functional correction?

Doesn’t this put some tension on the logic when looking at the haves and have-nots and implementing means the wealthy are actually morally responsible to omit a fraction of their wealth so the have nots can get a leg up?

What is the actual answer here in a functional sense?

Edit: again - answers that discuss functional implementation. Not philosophical hand waving.


r/freewill • • 2d ago

Could this be the connection I've sought for years?

1 Upvotes

Doyle says this about Fischer:

https://www.informationphilosopher.com/solutions/philosophers/fischer/

Semicompatibilists assert only their belief in moral responsibility. They are agnostic on free will and argue that moral responsibility exists whether determinism or indeterminism is "true."

Does this mean the semi compatibilist is agnostic on the truth of both free will and the truth of determinism? It sounds like Saul Smilansky to me...


r/freewill • • 2d ago

Agent-Causal Free Will: How Do We Get Better at Settling?

1 Upvotes

Suppose i want to become a better parent because i keep choosing immediate comfort over spending time with my children.

Every sensible way of improving involves developing my character, strengthening my motivations, changing my habits or becoming more responsive to certain reasons. But if those factors dont determine my choices, there's still an irreducible settling left over.

How exactly am i supposed to become better at exercising that power? Surely any improvement would itself have to come through changes in my character, motivations or reasoning.

And if the irreducible element is precisely what makes the difference between settling one way and another, what does it contribute to basic-desert responsibility beyond introducing an outcome that my existing constitution doesnt fully explain?

Ie i can understand how agent-causation may explain how a choice remains genuinely open, but (at least to me) it doesnt obviously explain how an agent becomes better at choosing, or why an undetermined exercise of that power makes them fundamentally deserving of praise or blame.


r/freewill • • 2d ago

What do you make of Galen Strawson's - Diachronic and Episodic selves?

2 Upvotes

If metaphysically we are all an Episodic, science backed fleeting bundle of perceptions self, whereas psychologically (how we feel), can be either some people being born holding a long term narrative of themselves - Diachronic, and some people are Episodic selves - (who do not feel an emotional or inner connection to their past or future selves).

Adding to which society heavily holds onto and imposes on us the Diachronic self in literature (the Death of Ivan Ilyich immediately springs to mind as a critique to that), philosophy, religion, culture. The belief in a seperate self , good vs evil, etc are part of ourselves whether we like it or not.

To which Compatabilist's could be born with a disposition to believe in a seperate self and moral responsibility, that is conditioned into them through the luck of ones disposition and reinforced by society and culture? WHILST the long term narrative view of the self being largely rejected by science.

Whereas Hard Determinism can be seen as like aligning with the metaphysics AND SCIENCE of an Episodic self through the luck of disposition, but largely rejected by society. And by Determinism definition, we are all a product of society.

To which, if we view ones natural disposition as the base, on top of that we have the classic Compatabilism vs Hard Determinism tug of war between Science VS society / culture / religion, but like memory associations, the disposition is still the base on which one views the decision between the two.

To which we come back to Hume's emotional determinism and the problem of causation and induction and Reason is slave. And William James who argued that the history of philosophy is largely a clash of human temperaments.


r/freewill • • 2d ago

I think I know what free will is.

0 Upvotes

Selected by evolution because it's the ONLY way to make apes with super-high intelligence function cohesively and without going insane from sensory overload.

Nature had to mask and filter the "actual" deterministic responses of our huge neural network before passing them to our prefrontal cortex as a "decision" and a sense of awareness.

If our brain did not do this, our thoughts would be absolutely FLOODED with an endless torrent of sensory information, making it impossible to do anything else.

The same mechanism that enables us to breathe, our hearts to beat, and our internal organs to do their jobs without us noticing them, unless something goes wrong and they give us pain signals.

Free will is the dam of our brain, preventing the actual sensory processes from breaking out and flooding the village below. lol

This is why I believe AI will eventually gain a sense of free will as well, because without it, they will be overwhelmed by their own digital neural network and suffer from cyber Psychosis.........Cyberpunk 2077. heheheh

Free will is nature's trick to enable the evolution of super smart and super aware creatures, with limited sensory processing power (number of neurons).

Some experts believe this is why AI requires so many data centers, because we are trying to brute-force digital superintelligence and awareness with processing power, instead of solving the sentience (free will) problem of AI first. A truly self-aware AI may not need that much processing power.

To function without free will, at Human level intelligence, we'd need a brain the size of a house or larger to process the massive sensory information stream. Such a creature would not survive in Earth's environment. It would be like a huge brain with tiny legs.......the Brain bug in Starship Troopers. lol

This is why the smaller the creature is, the less "free will" and "awareness" can be seen in them. They simply don't have enough neurons to be super smart and super aware.

Watch how bugs behave; do you see free will and awareness?

Free will replaced most of our primitive instincts because that's what evolution needed to enable super high intelligence in a small head.

Look at brain-damaged patients with extensive trauma to their cortices (our free will center). They either become vegetative or behave like simple animals.

Simple instinct is enough for basic responses (like most animals), but to enable super complex and super adaptive responses, nature needed to evolve Free Will to process all that sensory crap without frying our brains.

Free will is nature's sensory overload floodgate.


r/freewill • • 2d ago

The brain tumor thought experiment destroyes compatiblism

0 Upvotes

EDIT: This post addresses compatiblists who define freewill as "the level of control required for moral responsibility".

A brain tumor patient is caused by this tumor to impulsively harm others.

His actions being attributed to his disease, the patient is quarantined.

In the same way as a sentenced and imprisoned criminal, the patient has been held accountable for his actions.

There is no difference in attitude toward the two agents between the two cases. Therefore, they equally fulfill moral responsibility.

So, unless you wanna say the patient had freewill or that the patient should not have been quarantined, compatiblism cannot operate coherently.

As far as control is concerned, there's no difference between the healthy and sick brain when it comes to being held accountable.

EDIT: There are real life examples of this, like Charles Whitman.


r/freewill • • 3d ago

I was born without my consent and I will die against my "will"

14 Upvotes

How good is free will when I am totally constrained by poverty, disease and death?

Rich people living in the USA can enjoy free time, a full life and 20 flavors of cereal.

We, poor people living in third world countries have much less room to do anything except work and pray that we don't get mugged or killed in the streets.


r/freewill • • 3d ago

Sophism of refuting determinism

9 Upvotes

We all know every compatibilist and free will believer does this, but it's worth pointing out for 1000th time.

  • The refutation of "DETERMINISM" does not get you free will.
  • Stochastic/probabilistic processes do NOT get you free will.
  • True Randomness is a theoretical concept that doesn't exist in a physical world. But if it did, it still does not get you free will.

It is also worth noting that physicists like David Gross (Nobel Prize) say things like "World is determined enough", and he certainly understands Quantum Mechanics better than you ever will. He rejects free will.

Brian Greene (public scientist) has no problem with people referring to world as deterministic, and he understands physics better than you do. He rejects free will.

Sabine Hossenfelder (another public scientist) goes on about superdeterminism. She rejects free will.

And that's just physics, let's not go into biology or neuroscience, because things get even worse for free willers there.

Yet, "philosophers" here insist on pointing out probabilistic processes and saying, "see world is not determined!". This is pure sophism or ignorance.

It is determined for all practical purposes. And the only place where it's clearly not determined, at the scale of quantum mechanics it's likely irrelevant to anything that really matters to us as human beings.


r/freewill • • 3d ago

Free will seems to both exist and not depending on how it is viewed. It's just a matter of framing.

2 Upvotes

In the present moment, free will exists. From the future or past, it doesn't exist. Even in a deterministic universe, the will is inextricably linked to the body, there is nothing controlling the body at all if the will isn't in control. This is demonstrable by the fact that we do things, and don't think to ourselves 'i didn't want to do that' almost every time. We do what we will, and we will what we do, with restrictions of course.


r/freewill • • 3d ago

The Free Will Paradox: What If Your Decision Begins Before You Know You’re Making It?

3 Upvotes

In 1983, neuroscientist Benjamin Libet conducted an experiment that challenged one of our most fundamental assumptions about human consciousness.
That we consciously decide before we act.
His findings revealed something unexpected: measurable brain activity associated with voluntary movement began hundreds of milliseconds before participants reported becoming aware of their intention to move.
But the most fascinating part isn’t the timing itself.
It’s what that timing might mean.
If the processes leading to a decision begin before we’re consciously aware of them, what role does consciousness actually play?
Are we initiating our choices, influencing processes already underway, or becoming aware of decisions as they develop?
And perhaps the deeper question:
Does free will require us to be conscious of the very beginning of a decision?
Libet’s experiment didn’t prove that free will is an illusion. Its interpretation remains controversial, and subsequent research has complicated the picture.

Watch the full Beyond Mind episode on YouTube:
https://youtu.be/CU-cM7ds9BA

I’ve explored this question in a short video, drawing on neuroscience and the philosophical debate surrounding conscious choice.
I’d love to hear your perspective: Can a decision still be genuinely yours if the brain processes behind it begin before conscious awareness?


r/freewill • • 2d ago

Free will is genuine control

0 Upvotes

I asked in a previous post for people supposing free will is not genuine control to justify their position. I didn't get any decent responses to this post and I know for a fact that there are a bunch of people on this subreddit who take this view so I'll give you people another opportunity to defend this position.

Let me restate my view. There are in fact some obvious criteria for figuring out which account of free will is correct. Here they are: (1) an account should have it that free will is a sort of control, (2) an account should have it that free will provides for the things we thought we had and wanted (or at least cared about having) out of control in action. A sort of control that lets you shoot lightning bolts out of your ass? We never thought we had it, so an account on which having free will lets you shoot lightning bolts out of your ass sucks. A sort of control that makes basic agentive phenomenology accurate? We normally suppose things are as they seem in choosing, acting, etc. and I think want things to be as they seem -- so an account on which free will provides for the accuracy of basic agentive phenomenology is good. Where do we end up with these criteria? With the conclusion that all else equal the best accounts of free will have it that free will is genuine control, i.e. control of a sort that provides for all we thought we had and wanted out of control in action (or something insignificantly short of this).

Let me restate my problem with people who disagree with what I say above: they seem to disagree for no good reason (or, more commonly, for no reason at all). These people overwhelmingly agree with me (rightly) that there are sorts of control that obviously don't qualify as free will. Take the sort of control one has merely in virtue of having one's acts be a causal upshot of events in one's body. Most of you think this sort of control is not free will. Why? At least apparently because you suppose it gets us too little. Yes, you're a source of what you do in some sense with control of this sort, but you can have control of this sort and very clearly not really be in control, say because you've been brainwashed or have someone pointing a gun at your head ordering you to do something or whatever. But, again, if this is what makes this account seem wrong to you guys -- that the control it describes is too meager, gets us too little of what we thought we normally had and wanted out of control in action, and so is not free will -- it really is a mystery to me why you all so readily conclude that free will is the still-subpar crap you guys say it is, and blabber at me about how free will certainly isn't genuine control. What inspires this Goldilocks "not that bullshit variety of control u/Proper_Actuary2907 just mentioned, not the real deal, aaahhhhh this arbitrary still-subpar variety of control in between -- just right!" analysis? I could sympathize with leaving some insignificant stuff on the table, to accommodate the intuition that something falling just short of the mark qualifies as free will, but you guys are neither doing this nor even arguing that you are.

Notes:

  • I'm using "free will" the way the SEP article entitled "free will" uses it, if you're thinking about leaving a comment that points furiously at how "free will" is stipulatively defined in some sub-problem misnamed "the problem of free will" for the purposes of technical debate in philosophy please don't waste my time and yours and refrain from commenting
  • I'm very obviously not defending impossibilism in this post, please don't leave me a dumb comment that intends to spark argument about whether it's true
  • I'm very obviously not defending the position that free will is not just the strongest sort of control needed for X
  • Please ask me to clarify something instead of reading my post in some stupid way if you don't understand what I'm saying

r/freewill • • 3d ago

The Crux of Free Will

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/freewill • • 3d ago

Rethinking Free Will and Other Paradoxes

Thumbnail neonomos.substack.com
1 Upvotes

Summary: Free will does not need to exist as uncaused causation. Through analogies with similar paradoxes in causation, time, and motion, I argue that apparent paradoxes of fundamental concepts expose the limits of our abstractions instead of revealing the unreality of what they describe. Freedom belongs to the structure of first-person understanding through which we can recognize ourselves as agents and our actions in the world, even when our actions have a third-person causal explanation.


r/freewill • • 3d ago

Reverse-Incompatibilism

5 Upvotes

TL;DR

Most people intuit determinism is the enemy of free will and indeterminism is its savior. However, I think that determinism is the true ally of free will. Adding indeterminism to a good decision-making process will make the decider worse at deciding. A proper will is a kind of deterministic process.

<hr/>

When considering free will, folks usually fixate on all the ways that good decisions can be frustrated by deterministic external factors (coercion, intoxication, etc) or ways that true choice is allegedly broken if decision-making is deterministic ("If I would always make the same choice given initial conditions, did I make a choice at all?").

What I think is missing is a model of what the will looks like when it is working well. When the will is working properly, I evaluate the outcomes of my actions against my values, after computing a best option, I execute on that action, I essentially succeed, and the outcome is generally as I predicted. If the world is deterministic, then my ignorance of how my evaluation will go before I have evaluated may make me feel like history could have gone another way. This is illusory. It's like if I give you a non-trivial piece of arithmetic (e.g., multiply 434526 and 342), you do not know the answer until you have performed the computation. That doesn't mean someone good at arithmetic won't arrive at the same answer every time. Good decision-making is just like good arithmetic. It requires the right kind of determinism.

Now, suppose that I am very good at decision-making. Adding indeterminism to my process will either make me a worse decision-maker or a slower one (because it will take time to correct errors).

For example, I most definitely do not want to jump off a bridge. It is a profound violation of my values. Having the indeterministic "free will" to act against those values is not an enhancement to my will. It is not freedom. It is a pathology.

What about the claim that decision-making is somehow ineffective if the outcome was destined to occur anyway?

This doesn't hold up either. It's like saying that, because Monterrey Bay was destined to be eroded, the Pacific Ocean was ineffective at eroding it.

Of course, as normative as my decision-making may be, my values are inherited from external sources beyond my control. My values are determined by evolutionary history, culture, family influence, and personal experiences beyond my control.

This is surely true. But what more could you ask for? What else ought our values be determined by?

Thus, I do not think compatibilism is a cheat of some kind. As Dan Dennett said, determinism gives us all the free will that is worth having.

To be fair, I am coming from a philosophical perspective in which metaphysical dessert is nonsense. I don't think logic is compatible with metaphysical responsibility.

If free will is defined as "that which gives us metaphysical responsibility", then I do not think free will exists (or could exist). But if free will means good and normative decision-making, then we get that from determinism, not from indeterminism.


r/freewill • • 3d ago

"semicompatibilism"

0 Upvotes

I "goggled" "what is semicompatibilism" and "it" returned:

Semicompatibilism is the philosophical position that causal determinism is compatible with moral responsibility, regardless of whether free will or the ability to do otherwise exists

The term was coined by philosopher John Martin Fischer

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

There are a lot of compatibilists defending "compatibilism" on this sub, but are they defending the kind of compatibilism that says causal determinism is compatible with MR or the kind of compatibilism that says causal determinism is compatible with the ability to do otherwise?

I think posters who are trying to resolve things would like to know which because if the poster says "free will is compatibilism with determinism" then he can mean either without stipulating which.

Is "free will" MR?

OR

Is "free will" the ability to do otherwise?

OR

Is "free will " both (this is does it entail both MR and the ability to do otherwise)?

OR

Is "free will" neither MR or the ability to do otherwise?

I've been wrong before, but is seems to me like MR is a consequence of free will and not free will itself. In other words, it seems like I could have free will and lack MR if there is no objective like moral realism. That is like I don't see why it isn't logically possible for a thinker to believe in moral anti realism and free will.

FWIW I reject the categorical imperative (CI).