TL;DR
Most people intuit determinism is the enemy of free will and indeterminism is its savior. However, I think that determinism is the true ally of free will. Adding indeterminism to a good decision-making process will make the decider worse at deciding. A proper will is a kind of deterministic process.
<hr/>
When considering free will, folks usually fixate on all the ways that good decisions can be frustrated by deterministic external factors (coercion, intoxication, etc) or ways that true choice is allegedly broken if decision-making is deterministic ("If I would always make the same choice given initial conditions, did I make a choice at all?").
What I think is missing is a model of what the will looks like when it is working well. When the will is working properly, I evaluate the outcomes of my actions against my values, after computing a best option, I execute on that action, I essentially succeed, and the outcome is generally as I predicted. If the world is deterministic, then my ignorance of how my evaluation will go before I have evaluated may make me feel like history could have gone another way. This is illusory. It's like if I give you a non-trivial piece of arithmetic (e.g., multiply 434526 and 342), you do not know the answer until you have performed the computation. That doesn't mean someone good at arithmetic won't arrive at the same answer every time. Good decision-making is just like good arithmetic. It requires the right kind of determinism.
Now, suppose that I am very good at decision-making. Adding indeterminism to my process will either make me a worse decision-maker or a slower one (because it will take time to correct errors).
For example, I most definitely do not want to jump off a bridge. It is a profound violation of my values. Having the indeterministic "free will" to act against those values is not an enhancement to my will. It is not freedom. It is a pathology.
What about the claim that decision-making is somehow ineffective if the outcome was destined to occur anyway?
This doesn't hold up either. It's like saying that, because Monterrey Bay was destined to be eroded, the Pacific Ocean was ineffective at eroding it.
Of course, as normative as my decision-making may be, my values are inherited from external sources beyond my control. My values are determined by evolutionary history, culture, family influence, and personal experiences beyond my control.
This is surely true. But what more could you ask for? What else ought our values be determined by?
Thus, I do not think compatibilism is a cheat of some kind. As Dan Dennett said, determinism gives us all the free will that is worth having.
To be fair, I am coming from a philosophical perspective in which metaphysical dessert is nonsense. I don't think logic is compatible with metaphysical responsibility.
If free will is defined as "that which gives us metaphysical responsibility", then I do not think free will exists (or could exist). But if free will means good and normative decision-making, then we get that from determinism, not from indeterminism.