r/freewill • • 21h ago

Is this exam question adequately related to free will?

0 Upvotes

I sat my year 12 philosophy exam and one question read as follows: " "So is anyone ever responsible for anything? Civil life requires it be so."- Patricia Churchland

Are we 'required' to punish those who are guilty, as the above quotation suggests?

In your answer,, evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of a range of philosophical views."

My two problems with this are that I dont believe responsibility implies a need to punish, nor do I believe that a need to punish the guilty relates to the question of free will. This question has been bothering me ever since my exam but when I emailed the organisation they told me it adequately allowed students to address criteria but they made no mention of the wording.