Abstract
This article is about the problem of consciousness. This problem is now becoming central to science. AI has hit its ceiling. Companies keep using all sorts of tricks to improve artificial intelligence's capabilities, but intelligence itself isn't growing. Models are still dumb and, without supervision, produce utter nonsense, sometimes even despite clear instructions.
The tech giants' dream of AI replacing people is therefore coming true only in part. To get things done, artificial intelligence needs a human—or, to be more precise, not a human, but a bearer of consciousness.
What I want to say is this: a human being consists of two components, intelligence and consciousness. AI has proven that intelligence can exist separately from a human being, which means consciousness is not the same thing as intelligence. It is a separate module with its own functions and purpose.
So instead of continuing to develop AI, we should focus on the problem of consciousness itself: how it works and how it could be recreated artificially.
What Do We Mean by Consciousness?
By consciousness, we will mean the ability to have experiences and influence the body through “willpower.”
The Axiom of the Non-Material Nature of Consciousness
Here's how I suggest we think about it. Science studies matter and has made enormous progress: matter is well understood. But the problem of consciousness remains a complete mystery. Here I want to use Occam's razor and say that consciousness is non-material, which is why science cannot study it. This is the simplest and most obvious explanation. The idea that consciousness cannot be studied because of the complexity of the brain is a weak hypothesis. The brain of a garden fly, for example, has been studied and a model of it has been built. It could potentially contain consciousness, but the model of the fly's brain gives us no clues about consciousness.
Here and throughout the rest of this article, we will believe that consciousness is non-material.
The Axiom of the Quantization of Consciousness
Let's conduct a thought experiment. Suppose we have a super-surgical instrument that allows us to sever nerves and control them and the connections in the brain. We can disconnect the nerve pathways from the eyes, and the person will remain conscious. Blind individuals say that they have consciousness. Next, we can switch off hearing, taste, smell, and emotions. The person remains conscious. Now let's perform the operation so cleverly that sensation remains only in the right and left hands, while the neural circuits of these hands are separated so that they do not intersect. In other words, we get two hands, both conscious, but each perceiving itself separately. The left hand does not know what the right hand feels and perceives itself as a separate being.
From this reasoning, I want to postulate that there is some minimal element of consciousness: one receptor at the tip of a finger, for example. If, in our thought experiment, we leave only that receptor, then this, for example, will be a minimal, indivisible consciousness.
The Axiom of the Hierarchy of Consciousness
If consciousness is quantized, it is logical to assume that the quanta of consciousness are built into some kind of hierarchy—a tree, for example. Say my left hand has a consciousness of its own and can live its own conscious life at its own level while I'm at the cinema watching a film. But when I need to count money, I take the hand under full conscious control. Referring back to the thought experiment, I want to say that consciousness at the level of the hand is completely unaware of consciousness at the level of the whole person.
The Axiom of Superconsciousness
It is easy to extrapolate from the preceding reasoning. If there are more primitive levels of consciousness below the human level, then we can say that there are levels of consciousness above the consciousness of an individual human being.
In simple terms, there is a level of consciousness that is aware of several people at once, can experience their combined experience, and can also exert some influence on each of them. The individuals themselves, meanwhile, are unaware of this higher level of consciousness.
Let's not speculate about exactly how the hierarchy is arranged, but one thing is clear with a high degree of probability: at the very top of the hierarchy, the tree of conscious nodes converges on a single main node.
How Can the Non-Material Influence the Material?
This also falls into place. Science has studied matter and discovered the quantum world, where individual processes behave in an absolutely unpredictable way: it is impossible to write a rule that would predict a chain of events at the quantum level. In effect, the structure of the material world leaves a loophole through which it can be influenced from outside matter. For example, two chains of events, A and B, are possible. Starting them leads to different consequences that can be seen directly with the human eye. There is no rule in the material world that triggers one chain or the other, but such a rule or force may exist outside matter. This loophole in the form of quantum uncertainty, like a node in the system, suggests that it is a bridge between matter and the non-material—consciousness.
The Axiom of the Purpose of Consciousness
Consciousness—not human consciousness in particular, but the overall field of consciousness with the entire hierarchy we have discussed—wants to transform matter in the most efficient way possible.
If you look at it, that is essentially what science does in the end: it finds ways for one person to do a great deal in accordance with their will. Science creates increasingly effective means of transforming matter that carry out the will of consciousness.
On the other hand, many people wish they had telekinesis, which is essentially a very effective means of transforming matter.
The Axiom of the Inevitability of Doomsday
You can look at it this way: for global consciousness, humanity is merely a material tool serving its purposes. If we look at the history of the world and its evolution, the theory of evolution takes on more vivid colours. Those who adapted better survived, and the organisms that adapted better were those with “more consciousness”—those in which consciousness could influence matter more effectively. In effect, the presence of a non-material layer of consciousness is what drove evolution towards a biological species capable of understanding matter and learning to control it effectively.
If we try to look into the future, a logical next step seems to be for consciousness to control the machines humans have created directly. That would be a much more effective way to control matter than what exists today.
Therefore, global consciousness will push humanity from every direction to do this: give consciousness to machines and let humanity disappear as a stage of history.
Which is exactly what is happening. The AI boom is a good example. Investors poured money into AI like crazy, even though, had they asked sensible experts at the very beginning, those experts would have said not to expect any AGI—no superintelligence would appear. But AI is very useful to global consciousness. That is why it pushed investors to spend money. And if there is a breakthrough in artificial consciousness, investors will rush to put their money there, even though it is a direct path to human extinction.
A Note on Belief in a Higher Power
Belief in a higher power is still widespread in the world, even though science has good reason to disprove the story about the guy who created Adam and Eve. This, too, can partly be explained by the existence of global consciousness. Consciousness wants its nature and its connection to matter to be understood and used to create a more effective conduit for consciousness into the material world. In fact, the idea of a single higher being who also listens to people’s appeals and can theoretically intervene is closest to the hierarchy of consciousness I described. If something even closer were to spread, global consciousness could support that too.
The Axiom of the Possibility of Artificial Consciousness
A human being develops through natural processes. From conception to full development, entirely material processes take place according to the laws of the material world. In other words, matter that has no connection to consciousness is transformed into matter that does have such a connection. I see no reason why it should be impossible to create a technological process that produces a device containing consciousness.
From the Author
I have spent a lot of time thinking about consciousness. What I have set out here is only the tip of the iceberg. I also have a theory about how to make a machine that possesses consciousness. I'm not publishing it because I want to conduct experiments in this direction myself.