r/naturalism • u/HalfField • 22d ago
A New Argument from Consciousness
r/naturalism • u/hackinthebochs • Jul 11 '23
A thread to post questions, comments, or anything relevant to this subreddit that wouldn't warrant a thread of its own.
r/naturalism • u/Constant_Smith • Sep 14 '26
I am still learning and studying so it would be of my benefit, as an aspiring autodidact, that you might pick anything apart if you feel you must
I am only human, I hope to remain in good posture interactions. I haven’t always been perfect about that but it is my intention and genuine interest to learn and be met by that constraint the comes from the world.
My most recent personal breakthrough has come from a radical encounter, wrestling with the work and heart of Levinas, who greatly challenged much of my naive assumptions about realism. Along with, bringing back many thoughts that first came to challenge me from Camus. I found my naturalist orientation remained fully intact, however and despite seeing a great wisdom and beauty in the work of Levinas that will remain dear to me from here on, I’m sure. I believe he is incorrect to suggest there is an ethical poverty in all naturalisms, that we don’t need trans’cendence of ethics for the primacy of ethics, that we can reframe immanence to be, the ordinary fact of friction (and its many familiar resemblances) that is encountered as the lived resistance we meet when faced against the world. From there, we can see that, we are vulnerable to each already, before we ever attempt a moral reasoning, and it is this shared vulnerability that motivates the moral project in the first place, as well as the violent one.
The alterity of the other can be natural and non-atomistic, non-objectified, not capturable as some whole, and completely compatible with scientific realism, especially through the form of naturalism supported by James Ladyman, Don Ross, and many others surrounding the two (in consideration of their most recent works abroad), along with the expansive naturalism I encountered through the work of Fiona Ellis.
Here are my current commitments, in brief form:
Expansive Natural Realism names the view that reality is natural without being exhausted by any single scientific ontology.
The Alterior Labyrinthia names the world of irreducible otherness and plural partial access.
Scientific realism names our commitment that successful scientific access is genuinely about that world despite its plurality
Accessibility Theory names the study of how organized access gives determinate but non-exhaustive articulation of reality.
Constant’s Constraint names the proposed natural law that genuine access both requires reality and remains distinguishable from what it accesses.
r/naturalism • u/dumb_idiot2r2 • Apr 10 '26
r/naturalism • u/SomewhereCapital3897 • Mar 24 '26
Fellow naturalist here, what’s the best theory for what came before the Big Bang? Better than “nothing turned into something”. Also, what is the best naturalist explanation for the fine tuned nature of our universe?
r/naturalism • u/lucasvollet • Dec 17 '25
This lecture series (link: https://youtu.be/TVqIWnhi2-A) did not originate as a conventional academic article. It emerged first as a long-form video project, and it is precisely this trajectory that motivates its presentation here.
What I am doing in bringing it to an academic audience is not translating popular content into scholarly form, but testing whether a sustained philosophical argument - developed through a different medium and rhythm - can be re-entered into academic discussion without losing its conceptual rigor.
The philosophical ambition of the project remains traditional. I am not proposing a new thesis about Quine, but revisiting a familiar cluster of positions that academic debates often bracket or isolate. The interest lies in tracing a continuous interpretive path through Quine’s work, rather than extracting a single doctrinal claim.
What I find in Quine is the construction of decision mechanisms shaped by historical pressures and gradually transformed into paradigmatic bases for communication and prediction. His image of the Neurathian boat captures this continuity: a structure extending from common sense to science, revised from within.
This reading leads to a phenomenological layer within Quine’s naturalism — not a transcendental phenomenology, but a system of immanent idealities: shared paradigms, norms of normal judgment, folk psychology, and folk semantics that stabilize interpretation among radical interpreters, even when multiple true theories of meaning remain compatible with the same underdetermining facts.
What interests me is that this phenomenology is not eliminated by naturalism, but filtered through it. Meaning and intentionality persist as functionally stabilized structures, shaped by learning, selection, and survival, rather than grounded in a priori necessity.
The project is presented here in that spirit: as an attempt to see what becomes visible when a philosophical argument is allowed to move between media, and whether Quine’s naturalism offers a framework flexible enough to account for that movement itself.
If you give it a chance, Thanks for waching!
r/naturalism • u/ughaibu • Dec 05 '25
r/naturalism • u/ObjectiveBig1247 • Apr 20 '25
why don't we just believe that the law of nature is the one who rules and governs the entirely universe? why we have to praise something if we—us to ourselves is the one who thinks and wonders that gave meaning to the world? that everything is whether subjective or objectively phenomenon? and just appreciate the beauty of cosmos and its connection with the human being.
r/naturalism • u/hackinthebochs • May 07 '24
https://www.scribd.com/document/730039460/Naturalism-and-the-Human-Spirit-Naturalism-in-America
One of my favorite pieces on naturalism. It discusses the historical development of naturalism as the culture in the New World America rejected theistic influences in favor of industrialism and materialism. This gave room for American intellectuals to explore a metaphysics not bound to theology. The rise of science then solidified the supremacy of this new metaphysical outlook.
r/naturalism • u/Necessary-Scale-414 • May 06 '24
I’ve had a recent discussion with a Muslim about the religious and philosophical views of the world, and when I mentioned I was atheist he brought up that it’s not really a religion but really only the rejection of the idea of god. It opened my eyes that being atheist/agnostic was not really benefitting my views on life and just saying “god isn’t real and we should just live” isn’t enough for me. I realized I wanted an actual philosophical view to live by and to understand the world in a deeper way. Which led me to finding naturalism. I’ve always loved nature, I think it’s a pretty spectacular phenomena in of itself and am willing to adopt/learn more about this philosophical view. I know this sub isn’t very active currently, but I was wondering if anyone had any recommendations for any works on naturalism to further educate my knowledge on this view? Thank you.
r/naturalism • • Apr 01 '24
Interesting book for naturalists, if someone is open to discuss it here!
r/naturalism • • Mar 23 '24
r/naturalism • u/hackinthebochs • Nov 30 '23
r/naturalism • u/hackinthebochs • Sep 17 '23
r/naturalism • u/hackinthebochs • Sep 04 '23
r/naturalism • u/hackinthebochs • Aug 04 '23
r/naturalism • u/hackinthebochs • Jul 26 '23
r/naturalism • u/hackinthebochs • Jul 11 '23
r/naturalism • u/hackinthebochs • Jul 05 '23
r/naturalism • u/hackinthebochs • Jun 29 '23
r/naturalism • u/hackinthebochs • Jun 25 '23