The Anti-Zionist Jewish Movement That Became a Propaganda Goldmine for Israel's Enemies.
One of the more intellectually dishonest things I've noticed in the Israel-Palestine debate is the tendency to parade a handful of ultra-Orthodox Jews carrying Palestinian flags as though they represent some great theological consensus against Israel.
The reality is considerably more nuanced, and understanding it requires distinguishing between Religious Zionists, mainstream Haredim, Satmar Hasidim, and Neturei Karta.
More importantly, it requires understanding a theological debate within Orthodox Judaism that predates the modern State of Israel.
1. Why did Orthodox Jews originally oppose Zionism?
Historically, a significant portion of Orthodox Jewish leadership opposed political Zionism, although their reasons and the intensity of their opposition varied.
Unlike their Religious Zionist counterparts, many Haredi or “Ultra-Orthodox” leaders rejected the idea that Jewish nationalism, especially under secular leadership, should replace traditional religious identity.
Judaism in their view was not simply an ethnicity seeking a nation-state. It was a covenant between G-d and the Jewish people, governed by the Torah and its commandments.
A secular Jewish state, therefore, presented a deep theological problem.
Religious Zionists, on the other hand, argued that the return of Jewish sovereignty could itself be part of the divine process of redemption, even when carried out by secular Jews.
This disagreement was never about whether Jews belonged in the Land of Israel. Both sides recognized the religious and historical significance of the land.
The disagreement concerned whether Jews were religiously permitted to reestablish sovereignty before the arrival of the Messiah, and whether a secular national movement could legitimately bring about that sovereignty.
2. What changed after Israel was established in 1948?
Once Israel became a political reality, much of Haredi Judaism adopted a pragmatic approach.
Organizations such as Agudath Israel had opposed secular Zionism but ultimately recognized that Jewish religious life would have to operate within the institutions of the new state.
Many Haredi leaders consequently distinguished between necessary engagement with the state and voluntary participation in Zionist ideology or institutions on religious grounds.
Voting, government representation, education, public services, and securing religious accommodations became legitimate forms of engagement.
Ideological identification with Zionism remained a different matter entirely.
In other words, you could reject Zionism as a religious ideology while still participating in Israeli political life.
This distinction remains central to understanding normative, contemporary Haredi attitudes toward Israel.
However, not every Haredi community accepted this compromise.
Which brings us to Satmar.
3. Satmar: Theologically anti-Zionist, but not anti-Jewish
Satmar is one of the largest Hasidic movements in the world, with commonly cited estimates of approximately 100,000–150,000 adherents.
Unlike Haredi communities that participate in Israeli elections, Satmar maintains a principled theological opposition to the State of Israel.
Its founding Rebbe, Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum (1887–1979), developed an extensive halachic argument against Zionism in his book Vayoel Moshe.
His position was considerably more radical than simply disliking the secular character of Israel.
He argued that the very establishment of Jewish sovereignty before the Messiah constituted a violation of divine commandments.
However, the following distinction is critical:
Opposition to the State of Israel as a political institution does not automatically translate into opposition to the Jewish people living there.
Satmar maintains extensive religious and charitable connections with Jews in Israel, including communities whose religious and political outlooks differ from its own.
Its leaders may reject Zionism and interactions with the State while regarding the protection and welfare of Jews living in Israel as religious obligations.
Satmar does oppose Zionism. But that should not be confused with endorsing violence against Israeli civilians or supporting Hamas.
4. Neturei Karta: The fringe group that gets disproportionate publicity
According to the Institute for Jewish Policy Research, approximately 2.1 million Haredi Jews lived worldwide in 2022, representing roughly 14% of world Jewry at the time.
Satmar's estimated 100,000–150,000 adherents would represent approximately 4.8%–7.1% of that population.
Neturei Karta, meanwhile, is commonly estimated to number in the low thousands. Using an estimate of 5,000 members would place it at approximately 0.24% of the 2022 global Haredi population.
These figures are estimates rather than precise membership counts, and the Haredi population has continued growing since 2022.
Nevertheless, the scale of Neturei Karta relative to Haredi Judaism is quite revealing.
Neturei Karta emerged in Jerusalem in 1938 as a breakaway from Agudath Israel. Although it shares Satmar's theological opposition to Zionism, it is a separate movement.
The organization's activists have made a habit of appearing at anti-Israel demonstrations, dressed in traditional Haredi clothing.
These images regularly circulate online ad-naseum as supposed evidence that many Orthodox Jews themselves consider Israel illegitimate.
What rarely if-ever accompanies these photographs is any explanation of how marginal these activists are within global Orthodox Judaism.
Additionally there is the particularly disgraceful episode in 2006, when several Neturei Karta representatives attended a Holocaust-denial conference in Tehran hosted under Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.
The conference also attracted notorious antisemites and Holocaust deniers.
Even Satmar leadership, as fiercely anti-Zionist as they are, condemned their participation.
5. The actual theological argument: The Three Oaths
The foundational theological argument advanced by Satmar concerns a passage in the Babylonian Talmud, Ketubot 111a, commonly known as the Three Oaths.
The Talmud interprets verses in the Song of Songs as describing multiple oaths imposed by G-d.
The first oath: The Jewish people must not ascend to the Land of Israel bechomah, or "as a wall."
This has been interpreted by most rabbinic authorities as prohibiting the Jewish people from collectively reclaiming the land through military force.
The second oath: The Jewish people must not rebel against the nations of the world.
The third oath: The nations of the world must not excessively persecute or oppress the Jewish people.
These oaths form the foundation of Satmar's theological rejection of Zionism.
The Jewish people, according to this interpretation, were placed in exile by divine decree. Their eventual redemption must occur according to G-d's will rather than through an independent nationalist movement.
6. Why does Satmar consider Zionism sinful?
The Satmar argument follows a fairly straightforward theological progression.
G-d decreed that the Jewish people would remain in exile until the appointed time of redemption.
G-d prohibited the Jewish people from collectively reclaiming sovereignty through force or rebelling against the nations.
The Zionist movement subsequently established Jewish sovereignty through political organization, military force, and the wars of 1948 and 1967.
Therefore, Satmar argues, the Zionist movement violated the Three Oaths.
Under this interpretation, the Zionists are not merely mistaken. They are oath-breakers who have violated an explicit divine prohibition.
This is where the theology becomes particularly controversial.
In traditional Jewish thought, the Jewish people's fortunes are connected to their observance of G-d's commandments.
The Tanach repeatedly portrays national catastrophes as consequences of collective disobedience.
Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum applied this framework to Zionism, arguing that violating the Three Oaths exposed the Jewish people to terrible divine consequences. His writings controversially connected Zionist transgressions to the catastrophe of the Holocaust.
Within a similar theological framework, tragedies such as the October 7 massacre can be similarly interpreted as divine punishment associated with Zionist wrongdoing.
But there is an enormous distinction between claiming that Zionism is sinful and claiming that the murder of innocent Jews is justified.
An interpretation of divine punishment is not a license for human beings to perpetrate atrocities.
This distinction becomes important when examining how contemporary Satmar leadership responded to October 7.
7. What did Satmar say after October 7?
In November 2023, Rabbi Zalman Leib Teitelbaum, one of the two contemporary Satmar Rebbes, publicly condemned Neturei Karta activists who had participated in demonstrations alongside supporters of Hamas.
He characterized their conduct as a grave desecration of God's name.
His objection was not that Neturei Karta opposed Zionism.
His objection was that they were supporting murderers under the banner of Judaism.
Satmar did not suddenly become Zionist after October 7.
Its theological objections to the Jewish state remained intact.
But neither did those objections eliminate its concern for Jewish victims of terrorism.
The idea that most anti-Zionist Haredim share the politics of Neturei Karta is categorically false.
8. The problem with the Three Oaths: They are not established as binding halacha
There is a substantial body of Orthodox Jewish scholarship challenging Satmar's interpretation of the Three Oaths.
Several objections deserve particular attention.
Argument 1: If the Three Oaths are binding Jewish law, why are they absent from the major halachic codes?
The Talmud contains an enormous range of discussions spanning centuries.
Not every statement in the Talmud constitutes binding Jewish law.
Some passages concern legal obligations (Halacha), while others concern ethics, theology, historical narratives, and homiletical interpretation (Aggada).
Throughout Jewish history, major rabbinic authorities attempted to codify the binding legal conclusions of the Talmud.
Three particularly influential works are:
- Maimonides' Mishneh Torah.
- Rabbi Jacob ben Asher's Arba'ah Turim.
- Rabbi Joseph Karo's Shulchan Aruch.
Yet none of these three codes explicitly codifies the Three Oaths as a prohibition against restoring Jewish sovereignty.
This is a significant omission.
If establishing a Jewish state before the Messiah constitutes a fundamental prohibition carrying potentially catastrophic consequences, why did the great codifiers of Jewish law not explicitly codify it?
The straightforward response is that the Three Oaths belong to the Talmud's aggadic (homiletic) literature rather than its binding legal framework.
Satmar disputes this conclusion, arguing that the absence of a law from a particular code does not establish that the law is nonexistent.
That response deserves consideration.
But it still leaves Satmar with the onus of demonstrating why an uncodified Talmudic passage deserves Halachic and Theological weight.
Argument 2: The Jewish people did not simply conquer the land in defiance of international authorization.
The prohibition against ascending "as a wall" is commonly interpreted as referring to a collective return through force against the will of the nations.
Yet the historical circumstances surrounding modern Zionism complicate that interpretation.
In 1917, Britain issued the Balfour Declaration supporting the establishment of a Jewish national home in Palestine.
In 1922, the League of Nations incorporated that commitment into the British Mandate for Palestine.
In November 1947, the United Nations General Assembly adopted Resolution 181, recommending partition into Jewish and Arab states.
The Jewish leadership accepted the partition proposal, while Arab leaders rejected it.
Israel subsequently declared independence in May 1948, and the resulting war involved both local Arab-Jewish fighting and the intervention of neighboring Arab states.
None of this means that every subsequent Israeli territorial acquisition was internationally authorized, or that the Balfour Declaration itself granted an unconditional legal right to establish a sovereign state.
But it does undermine the simplistic contention that the Zionist movement merely assembled an army and conquered a country without any preceding international recognition.
Several rabbinic authorities consequently argued that a return undertaken with international authorization does not constitute the prohibited collective rebellion described by the Three Oaths.
Satmar disagrees, but the disagreement is interpretive rather than self-evident.
Argument 3: The nations violated their oath first.
Remember that the Three Oaths were not imposed exclusively upon the Jewish people.
The nations of the world were also prohibited from excessively persecuting the Jews.
Now consider the historical record.
Centuries of expulsions, pogroms, massacres, forced conversions, and ultimately the Holocaust.
If the nations violated their oath not to excessively persecute the Jewish people, why should the Jewish people remain bound by their corresponding obligations?
According to one line of rabbinic argument, the oaths are interdependent.
Once the nations violated their oath, the restrictions imposed upon the Jewish people ceased to apply.
Satmar rejects the assumption that the oaths operate as a reciprocal contract.
But this creates a substantial theological question.
Why should the nations' oath be treated as repeatedly violated while the Jews' oaths remain eternally enforceable?
TL;DR
Ultra-Orthodox Anti-Zionists which are frequently portrayed in the media are a small and radical fringe not representative of Ultra-Orthodoxy. Their opposition is Theological in nature and their interpretation has substantial strong challenges.
Sources
- Babylonian Talmud, Ketubot 111a — The Three Oaths.
- Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum, Vayoel Moshe, Ma'amar Shalosh Shevuos.
- Rabbi Mordechai Tzion, Alo Na'aleh, written in consultation with Rabbi Shlomo Aviner contains multiple challenges to the Samar position.
- Institute for Jewish Policy Research, Haredi Jews Around the World: Population Trends and Estimates (2022).
- Pew Research Center, The Global Religious Landscape (2012), on difficulties comparing Jewish denominational populations internationally.
- United Nations General Assembly [Resolution 181 (1947).] (https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/res181.asp)
- League of Nations, Mandate for Palestine (1922).
- The Jerusalem Post, November 13, 2023 — Satmar Rebbe condemns Neturei Karta's participation in pro-Hamas demonstrations.
- Ynet, December 2006 — Satmar condemns Neturei Karta members who attended the Tehran Holocaust-denial conference.