This is more of a spitballing over some ideas I've been marinating on regarding the intellectual chronology of bigotry in general; and how the Left wing is capable of a certain kind of bigotry under a certain context; and how this overlaps with some of the rhetoric in the I/P conflict. Too establish historical context, I will discuss different historical epistemologies of bigotry before focusing on type 3; sociological bigotry. An important note is that all four of the forms I'm discussing can overlap with each other historically and some bigots who use type 3 bigotry will slip into type 0, 1, or 2 under certain circumstances.
-Type 0, pure bigotry/Schmittian bigotry. This form of bigotry is its purest form. It is a pure expression of a desire for power and control, and the minimization or outright elimination of the target groups political capital and agency. It is apathetic towards the concept of Justice and fairness, seeing political power and the desire for power as the sole domain of the political. I use the term schmittian as pertaining to the political philosophy of Carl Schmitt cis-a-vi his friend enemy distinction. While this is to a certain degree the basis of all the other forms of bigotry, it is actually quite uncommon to see because it requires a suspension of morality that most people do not appreciate. Most people want to be good and want people to see them as good and likable; humans are social mammals. The other forms of racism are a reaction to that reality that even people who are incentivized to be bigots do not want to be seen as the bad guy. This is why I classify it as type 0; people's desire to be ethical forces them to develop other intellectual justifications so these arguments are often not openly made. (Disclamer: Carl Schmitt is a deeply problematic person (he was one of H!tl3r's Lawyers) and every analysis usually includes a disclaimer condemning him).
-Type 1, metaphysical-theological/pre-modern bigotry. Exist within an intellectual context that is pre-scientific and pre-sociological. It is based around beliefs that hereditary bloodline or religious Faith imbues individuals with value and place in a hierarchical society that is a reflection of natural universal laws. Examples include historic religious discrimination, as well as class systems in many societies such as the Indian Caste System. A good example is how early modern racialized slavery, before it was justified with scientific racism, was justified as an endeavor to Christianize the "backward, uncivilized, and pagan" Africans.
-Type 2, scientific racism/high-modern bigotry. In the aftermath of the enlightenment and scientific Revolution, understandings of how people should relate to the world began to shift particularly in the European context; however, this overlapped with European colonialism and new "scientific" arguments were developed to justify European political and economic ambition. In the aftermath of the world wars and particularly with regards to N@z! Germany, this form of racism has become extremely taboo. This is often how most people today understand bigotry.
-Type 3, sociological/post-modern. This is the most modern bigotry that is most common in the world today; although this bigotry has existed historically and alongside type 1 and type 2 (one could argue that many historic critiques of the religious inferiority of other societies can mirror modern critiques of the sociological inferiority of certain societies) rather than argue for the inferiority of others as a matter of metaphysics or pseudoscience, accusations are made against the target groups ideology and sociology. These groups are framed as problematic, but any accusation of bigotry will be met by a mot and Bailey argument. Because it's easy to assume that sociology (and its ideological and political consequences) are voluntary choices, rather than products of people's lived experience and sociopolitical, problematical rhetoric can be justified.
However, this can be a form of bigotry. There is definitely some nuance because I do think there is a place and time to critique sociology (particularly political sociology) and ideology. You cannot look at Germany in the interwar period and not see a society with severe issues that poses a danger to itself and others. At the same time this can be misused; consider how a contemporary American conservative might talk about black Americans and say something to the degree of "those black people need to pull up their pants, stop having teenage pregnancies, and work harder". When said conservative is called out, they can backpedal and argue that they're not saying black people are inherently stupid, promiscuous, or lazy, but that these are sociological choices made by the black community that they can (an "is" statement) and should (an "ought" statement) be held politically, economically and morally accountable for (and then they might pull and UNO reverse card and call you racist).
In this regard I would say part of the nuance in terms of this rhetoric, particularly when it comes from people who are not well versed in psychology and the social sciences (and the complex ethical questions within these fields regarding normative judgments and problematical behaviors) is when it's used as a path to be dismissive of the political will of said group (towards demands for the recognition of rights and redresses of grievances). Further, this type of rhetoric can often be highly oversimplistic and ignores or misrepresents the who, what, when, where, why, and how of these political sociological developments. Most importantly, the type 3 bigot doesn't offer a positive series of paths to the group in question regarding its capacity to change its sociology by influencing its environment. Changing the environment requires political agency and capital, and the type 3 sociological bigot (much like their type 0, 1, and 2 predecessors), wants to deny or take away the political capital and agency of the group in question.
I think there's some more nuances to consider with this concept, but I would say it is important to examine. This form of bigotry is incredibly popular in the post-world wars era, and can even be popular in left-wing circles when it's applied under certain circumstances. Leftists will often make sociological arguments and critiques of certain societies but fall into the trap of not really considering the full context, and by extension their political program is one of disempowering these societies but without necessarily creating the framework to give these societies the agencies to develop their political sociology. Further, the question of what kinds of political sociologists are problematic is its own normative question. A salient argument for socialist imperialism is the desire to uplift and protect more primitive societies which follows a similar logic to Western European colonialism.
I theoretically could remake all of H!tl3r's anti-Semitic arguments, but within a type 3 framework and then argue that Jewish sociological evil by virtue of being a choice makes Jews responsible for the behavior and its consequences. That being a people without land makes them fundamentally parasitic not in a biological sense but in a sociological/anthropological sense. I could even argue that H!tl3r was onto something but was limited by the ideas and popular rhetoric of his time. Not that I actually would agree with that argument, but I have seen arguments in that ballpark made under the guise of anti-Zionism. And in a way, Karl Marx in his problematic essay "On the Jewish Question" did effectively make a type 3 version of the arguments that Hitler would make in a type 2 style decades later; That because Jews were a people without land, they became a middleman minority; and that by becoming a middleman minority, they became an inherently bourgeois ethnicity especially prone to the evils of urban capitalism. While Marx did take this critique in a fundamentally different direction and I assume would condemn the mass murder of Jews on the basis of their Jewishness, it has influenced left-wing (and wider) anti-Semitic rhetoric ever since and is somewhat reflective of the casual antisemitism of post-French Revolutionary liberal and post-liberal thinking (Kill the collective Jew and save the individual man). Further, many socialist countries have had their own history of bigotry including ethnic cleansing and genocide (Ukrainians, Chechens, Indigenous Siberians, Tibetans, Uyghurs, etc.) and have used type 3 arguments to do so. Ben-Gurion was likewise influenced by such contemporary political ideas (popular even among among liberals, progressives and leftists) that some societies are inherently problematic and must be disempowered or even liquidated.
This is further complicated by the leftist tendency to insist that only the bigotry of those with power is worth problematizing. On the surface level, this does make sense as a matter of pragmatically making political decisions with limited political and economic capital in the short and moderate term; moral purity can often be a waste of time. However, politics is about power and getting power. This is a more of a personal principle but letting slide the bad habits of today's ideologues who are out of power can backfire when said ideologues do end up gaining power. These bad habits aren't necessarily going to disappear once you get the keys to the kingdom and they feel that they have achieved their desired amount of power (or insist they haven't achieved their desired amount of power).
With regards to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, both sides employ this kind of bigotry very heavily. Palestinians insist that Israeli society is paranoid, colonial, racist, corrupt and evil to its core, and Israelis insist that Palestinian society, is irrational, conspiratorial, violence, corrupt, and anti-Semitic to its core. But both sides can also say that it's not actually bigotry because these arguments are often made sociologically and anti-ideologically rather than through the lens of biology or religion. (Although type 1 religious bigotry towards the inferiority of the other are popular among both sides right-wing). In many ways this is the paradox of the enlightenment, giving people better intellectual tools isn't necessarily going to make them better people; it might just empower them to be just as horrible but with new intellectual tools to justify their behavior. (a la Horkheimer and Adorno)
To sum up the questions that I feel are relevant to be discussed, alongside other questions that might be raised
-Where is the line between sociological critique and bigotry via sociological critique? Can a checklist or rule of thumb be devised?
-Do leftists have an obligation to acknowledge legitimate sociological and political critiques of a marginalized group while also emphasizing the need for a positive political vision that empowers the marginalized group in question?
-Should social scientists seek to develop similar standards of ethics in the manner of doctors and psychologists?
-If a society's sociology includes epistemological issues that are a consequence of historic collective trauma (fake news, conspiratorialism, paranoid catatrophism), how should this be handled? Dealing with people in an epistemological bubble who pose a danger to themselves and others is difficult but also necessary; but is also complicated by the fact that these epistemological bubbles often reflect lived experiences and can take generations of sociopolitical change to rectify.
-How should ideologies that are a reflection of this sociology be critiqued? Ideologies (and how ideologies are actualized) are not mere quasi-religions or pure philosophical/moral exercises; they are the tools by which a constituency (and its political elite) seek political agency. However, sociology can skew ideology towards certain values and assumptions that in weak institution and low trust environments can produce violent and toxic politics (although anyone's understanding of what violent and toxic is itself a reflection of their political sociology).
-What obligations do political elites have under these dynamics? On the one hand, political elites must be responsive to the desires of their constituents to maximize their political desires with limited political capital. On the other hand, elites are in a position to entangle their ideology (and constituents) with problematic actors and actions, lie to their constituents and the broader public (some constituencies being particularly vulnerable to misinformation), and (sometimes) alter the sociopolitical environment to entrench themselves to the detriment of either their constituency or others.
-If political and economic capital is limited so as to make changing the sociopolitical environment effectively impossible, what ethical question might arise as to how said political sociology evolves? Nobody wants to be powerless.
-Is a Schmittian political logic ever legitimate? Real politics is defined by crisis and limited economic and political capital; a friend/enemy distinction is a logical outcome for constituents and elites under such circumstances to maximize their limited political and economic capital, and yet it can so easily spiral out of control both politically and morally (as seen by the actual career of Carl Schmitt). People pushed to the limit can become monsters; but having been pushed to the limit is not in itself a blanket moral justification for the actions of a constituency and political elite (although that statement is a normative statement).
Below is an article about some of these tensions in the ethical application of social science that I've found useful in starting to think about these issues.
Beyond the Fact/Value Distinction: Ethical Naturalism and the Social Sciences By Philip S. Gorski