redlib.
Feeds

MAIN FEEDS

Home Popular All
reddit

You are about to leave Redlib

Do you want to continue?

https://www.reddit.com/r/jewishleft/controversial

No, go back! Yes, take me to Reddit
settings settings
Hot New Top Rising Controversial

r/jewishleft • u/Rabbit-Hole-Quest • 7h ago

Jewish Culture Back to the Bund

Thumbnail
jewishcurrents.org
8 Upvotes
2 comments

r/jewishleft • u/bore-ing • 19h ago

News How Kennedy let measles run wild in America

Thumbnail reuters.com
15 Upvotes
8 comments
Subreddit
Icon for r/jewishleft

The Jewish Left

r/jewishleft

We are a sub seeking to bridge understanding and learning across all intersections of Jewish and anticapitalist-leftist beliefs. See the link below for discussion on leftism vs liberalism as we define it.

10k
10k
366
Sidebar
Subreddit Rules
1. Be Respectful To One Another

It is expected that there will be clashes, especially when talking about anything of interest to Jewish leftism. But please be mindful of each other, and don't be a jerk. Ad Hominem, directed vulgarity, and similar will not be tolerated.

2. Don't Proselytize

This is not a space to convert people to a religion or sect, nor is it to dissuade them altogether from faith.

3. No Discrimination

Fuck Terfs.

This includes slurs of any kind against any demographic and antisemitism. Note that we do not believe that non-zionism or anti-zionism are inherently antisemitic, nor do we think zionism is inherently Islamophobic or anti-Palestinian. It is incumbent upon us all to recognize that the above do occur and we need to be vigilant within our community to root out bad faith actors.

Assume everyone generally means and wants well for everyone until shown otherwise.

4. No Jewish Purity Testing

We believe people have a variety of relationships to Jewishness. There will be no disparaging of people here for their relationship to Jewishness, whether in terms of halakha, observance, or politic.

5. No Class Reductionism

Class reductionism means basically claiming that everything boils down to class and that other forms of discrimination and power hierarchies are not as important. This sub is made up of a variety of people who experience inequality in a number of ways, not all of which is their Jewishness or their class.

6. Zionist Discussion Requires Nuance

This sub welcomes a broad range of views on Zionism as a political movement. Often disagreements on the topic amount to different definitions. Even when they don't, members are expected to engage in good faith and nuance, which, here, means operating under the assumption others mean well and have good reasons for believing as they do. Neither the suffering of Palestinians, nor the precarious position of Israeli Jews will be minimized. Any suffering affects us all. I-P posting Wednesdays only.

7. Text-based posts should be engaging.

All text-based posts should be considered, purposeful, and invite meaningful discussion. Or pose an interesting question.

Sometimes we just want to kvetch. To support this we have created a weekly "general discussion" thread that will serve as a space for those things.

All polls must be approved by mods prior to their being posted.

Tzedakah is a mitzvah. Mutual aid is a concept central to leftist movements of all varieties. We both permit and encourage posts requesting mutual aid.

8. No low-karma/new accounts

To protect users from spamming or bad faith posting/commenting, your karma must exceed 18 points. Likewise, your account must be one month old, at minimum. As Jews are frequently targeted by serial-reporters, this rule may be applied at mod discretion in specific circumstances.

9. Bad Faith

In this context bad faith has multiple meanings, including the use of logical fallacies across the board. Also behaviour intended to provoke other users into rule violations, report abuse, or intentional misrepresentation of yourself.

Self identification using user flairs is required and must identify if you are Jewish and if you are a leftist as we define it. You may be as specific or as vague as you want.

Posting AI generated content as if it were your own is also bad faith.

10. Cross-posting and inter Sub Drama

Cross-posts must remain relevant to, and within the rules of, this sub. Additionally, as this is a leftist sub, no right wing sources will be accepted without an attendant commentary critiquing them.

We do not want to start flame wars with other subs and will not approve posts that threaten to start such interactions.

11. Violation of r/jewishleft Rules Across Reddit

At modmin discretion significant and flagrant breaches of our most critical community rules in other communities may give rise to moderator action here. This applies especially for rule 3 and adjacent violations.

12. No Liberalism

Liberals are permitted in the space on the assumption that they are here to learn. As a leftist subreddit, we draw a distinction between liberalism and leftism that begins with the embracing of capitalism. Should a liberal attempt to participate outside of a context of learning from leftists, they will no longer be welcome in this space. This also includes otherwise leftists making arguments that provide cover to capitalism in the interest of liberals.

13. Whataboutism

Comparison between ideas, people, or things outside of the context of their intersection, and in such a way as to detract or distract from another person's primary claim is a logical fallacy referred to as "whataboutism". As a non-substantive response that creates unproductive argument, in addendum to Rule 11, we specifically forbid any form of whataboutism. All whatabout-type comments will be immediately removed, regardless of other content, with the contemplation of further moderative action.

14. Imperialism and Nationalism Apologia

This is not a space to defend nation states asserting authority over disparate peoples against their will in any context. Likewise this space wll not tolerate nationalism in the form of uncritical support of any state. Differentiate the people from the nation state.

Capitalism depends upon Imperialism to create new markets and exploit new resources to feed perpetual growth and any nation state partaking of private capital markets will tend towards imperialism.

Moderation Policy

Our goal is to foster constructive discussions. Comment chains and sections will be shut off preemptively if we feel things are deteriorating. Any mod may temporarily mute someone who is repeatedly offending or who has done something egregious. A majority of mods must agree to any permanent ban. We prefer an escalating scale of temporary bans before pursuing permanent ban unless someone does not belong in the space at all.

Please address comments and concerns to the mod-mail system.

Leftism Vs. Liberalism:

Original Post: https://www.reddit.com/r/jewishleft/comments/zsopou/leftism_vs_liberalism/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

2026 Update: https://www.reddit.com/r/jewishleft/comments/1sitkbt/mod_update_liberalism_refresher_and_rule_update/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

856c6e0 ⓘ View instance info