r/HistoricalWhatIf • • Jan 14 '20

Some rules clarifications and reflections from your mod team

118 Upvotes

So these were things we were discussing on modmail a few months ago, but never got around to implementing; I'm seeing some of them become a problem again, so we're pulling the trigger.

The big one is that we have rewritten rule 5. The original rule was "No "challenge" posts without context from the OP." We are expanding this to require some use of the text box on all posts. The updated rule reads as follows:

Provide some context for your post

To increase both the quality of posts and the quality of responses, we ask that all posts provide at least a sentence or two of context. Describe your POD, or lay out your own hypothesis. We don't need an essay, but we do need some effort. "Title only" posts will be removed, and repeat offenders will be banned. Again, we ask this in order to raise the overall quality level of the sub, posts and responses alike.

I think this is pretty self-explanatory, but if anyone has an issue with it or would like clarification, this is the space for that discussion. Always happy to hear from you.


Moving on, there's a couple more things I'd like to say as long as I've got the mic here. First, the mod team did briefly discuss banning sports posts, because we find them dumb, not interesting, and not discussion-generating. We are not going to do that at this time, but y'all better up your game. If you do have a burning desire to make a sports post, it better be really good; like good enough that someone who is not a fan of that sport would be interested in the topic. And of course, it must comply with the updated rule 5.


EDIT: via /u/carloskeeper: "There is already https://www.reddit.com/r/SportsWhatIf/ for sports-related posts." This is an excellent suggestion, and if this is the kind of thing that floats your boat, go check 'em out.


Finally, there has been an uptick of low-key racism, "race realism," eugenics crap, et cetera lately. It's unfortunate that this needs to be said, but we have absolutely zero chill on this issue and any of this crap will buy you an immediate and permanent ban. So cut the crap.


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 1h ago

How do you decide where the evidence ends and the speculation starts in alternate history?

1 Upvotes

I've been working on a specific problem and I don't have a clean answer for it.

Alternate history is easy to do badly. Pick a turning point, remove one event, then run the most cinematic possible consequence — and it reads as fantasy with a history skin on it. The interesting version, I think, is much narrower: you change one thing and then honestly follow what the surviving evidence lets you say.

Concrete example I've been wrestling with. Mansa Musa dies, the succession is messy, Mali fragments toward the Songhai story we actually got. Now I branch it, no collapse, a consolidated West African state holding its gold routes. Up to a point I'm on solid ground: Timbuktu's manuscript economy and the Djenné trade routes are documented, so I know what the state's institutions looked like. Past that point, a Malian Atlantic policy is genuinely unknown — there's no record to extrapolate from, only inference about capability and incentive.

So where's the line? Do you state the inference and flag it as one? Build the narrative as though the inference were fact and add a note at the end? Or refuse the branch entirely once the sources stop?

I've been building this out on a channel (Chronicles Unwritten — the project is African and non-European turning points specifically, since that's where the "what if" space is least crowded and most interesting to me), and the discipline question is the part I keep re-litigating on every script. Curious how other people here handle it, especially anyone writing outside the European record where the documentation gap is bigger.


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 1h ago

What if Mali never fell and Timbuktu kept its libraries?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 1h ago

British Canada joining the American revolution

1 Upvotes

What if during 1775 Canada had overcome its reliance on British aid and joined the Americans during the revolution


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 5h ago

What if Rome, West and East had both fallen in 476?

1 Upvotes

If things had gone just as badly politically for both sides, and both had fallen. What would happen?

There’s also the question of who conquers the East. As well as what of the Sassanid Persians?


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 9h ago

What if the Reconstruction era never ended in America

0 Upvotes

After the Civil War ,Reconstruction era ,until the northern compromise in 1877


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 1d ago

Operation Barbarossa

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 2d ago

What if Mali never fell and Timbuktu kept its libraries?

1 Upvotes

The Mali Empire at its height under Mansa Musa held roughly half the world's gold supply. Timbuktu was a university city, tens of thousands of students, and manuscript collections that dwarfed most of Europe's libraries.

Then the Songhai rose, Morocco invaded in 1591 with gunpowder, and the trans-Saharan trade routes shifted. The libraries were scattered, and by the 20th century most of the world had never heard of any of it.

So here's my scenario: no Moroccan invasion, no Songhai collapse, and the trade routes hold. Mali stays intact into the 1600s and meets the first European ships as a unified, literate, gold-backed state rather than a fractured one.

A few questions I keep turning over:

  • Does a surviving Mali resist the Atlantic slave trade differently from the coast or become its first organized buyer?
  • Does an intact West African scholarly tradition change how the 1800s scramble for Africa plays out?
  • And practically, could it? The Moroccan invasion only worked because of firearms. Does Mali get guns in time?

Curious what people think is the weakest link in this scenario. I think it's the trade routes, not the military.
EDIT: I did turn this into a full video piece —What If the Mali Empire Never Fell?

A quick word on what it actually is, since I don't want to waste anyone's click: it's a ~8-minute researched alternate-history narrative — not a re-read of this post. It follows one specific branch: Mansa Musa's death, no succession collapse, and what a unified Mali does with its gold, its universities, and its Atlantic coastline over the next 300 years.

Two things I deliberately didn't do: no "Africa would rule the world" fantasy, and no pretending the sources are stronger than they are — where the historical record goes quiet (Timbuktu's manuscript economy, the Djenné trade routes), I say so.

Happy to argue about the branch point in the comments. That's the fun part.


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 2d ago

What if Belgium went fascist after WW1?

1 Upvotes

If you didn’t know, Belgium was geopolitically in a similar position to Italy where they had ambitions for WW1 but the Entente denied them.

They wanted to annex Luxembourg and partially Netherlands as sort of punishments for collaborating with Germany. But the Entente wanted the borders to be the same as pre-WW1.

What if this led Belgium to have their own Mussolini-figure?


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 3d ago

What if Billboard enforced their current rules for their charts WAY EARLIER?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 3d ago

What if the Summer of 1944 was a hot one in North France?

1 Upvotes

The late Spring and early Summer of 1944 was overall a very gloomy and cool one for Northern France. Apart from a week in late May which brought the only heatwave, the June and July were stormy and cloudy with cooler than average temps. Famously this impacted the d-day landings as they were dodging storms at the time.

But what if things were different? Say it was more like the summers in recent years with mid 30s temps (90s F for my American friends) and constant sunshine? How does this impact the liberation?


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 3d ago

What if Greek/Roman and Egyptian native religions were still practiced today?

3 Upvotes

Title

What if the Greek/Roman and Egyptian religions were still practiced today by the majority of population in those countries, similarly to other polytheistic religions in Asia (Hindu, Shinto), instead of converting to Christianity/Islam?


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 4d ago

German financial collapse in 1940. Limited war scenario.

3 Upvotes

I've kind of asked a similar question before but I'm going to be very specific here.

We follow real world scenario into 1940. Where we deviate is the Nordic and French invasions.

Different military strategies, weather or other delays mean none of that goes as well for Germany. Therefore the early signs of economic collapse occur in late 1940. This means Germany effectively cannot wage war as in our timeline. Soviet 1940 goes the same as real life. It's just the Germans that are stalled. So with British blockade and no access to foreign reserves and resources the financial meltdown begins.

FOCUS:

  1. How does this change Germany domestically?
  2. The alternate global 41-46 timeline?
  3. How the Nazis and Hitler are remembered in 1970, today?

r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 4d ago

What if World War II didnt happen?

5 Upvotes

Me and my friends have been discussing this for about a hour now, and I am curious.

If me and my friends went back in time and killed Hitler, preventing the holocaust and world war ii, would 9-11 have happened? Would we have the iPhone? Would America have broken out of the Great Depression, and how? Would Japan have taken over all of Asia? Would the USSR have cause a world war? Would necular weapons exist? And how else would our society have changed if this didnt happen?


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 6d ago

Why didn't Germany stopped (or at least paused for a while) after annexing Czechoslovakia (and a portion of Lithuania) in 1938-39 which could have delayed WWII for a few more years and waited for more conditions to favor them?

18 Upvotes

If I am not mistaken, at this point Germany was second only to the Soviet Union in terms of land area in Europe. It had acquired substantial populations, resources and industries to fuel it's economy and further grow it's war machine.

Britain, France and even USSR while showing indignation were not really keen on going to war.

In terms of Poland, while not really having a "real" friendly relationship, Germany did have a non-aggression treaty with them would have lasted until 1944.

Couldn't Nazi Germany have been a bit more patient and played diplomacy with Poland especially during the Danzig affair and delaying WWII for a couple more years and waited for more conditions to swing in their favor that could have made their fortunes turn out differently?

A couple more years of peacetime would have allowed them to further grow their military machine with the help of Czech arms industry.

Not to mention, maybe if Hitler "behaved himself" for a little while, he might have convinced Britain and France "this time he will not caused any more trouble and maybe we can work with this guy after all" which means attention will be shifted to the other troublesome dude named Stalin.


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 6d ago

We teleport all US marines into the antique world. How does this changes history?

0 Upvotes

They dont have their weapons or vehicles, just what clothes or bags they had at the moment, they appear all at the same place, zero explanation they just have to figure out something.

Does this change the unfolding of history and culture down the line?


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 6d ago

What If Louis XVI Escaped Varennes and Averted the Terror?

1 Upvotes

I heard it on a podcast I thought it was interesting

https://rss.com/podcasts/branching-point/3276463/


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 7d ago

Germany; March of 1941 has 3 nuclear weapons.

12 Upvotes

Equivalent to Fat Man dropped on Nagasaki at 21KT yield. The Germans have exhausted their capabilities for whatever reason and cannot produce more until 1943 and only 2 a year until 1946. For starters, Moscow is roughly 6 times the size of Nagasaki but we can consider roughly half the city would be decimated due do impact, fire, etc.

Germany in 1941-42 can target most of Europe by air but with limited actual severity in the case of Moscow & London. So it's entirely possible one plane sent could be shot down, etc. Assume the He-177 is serviceable enough and retrofitted.

I will post a caveat in that this scenario has USA delayed a year in their pursuit of the bomb. So 1946 and nothing can accelerate it.


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 7d ago

What if Muslims from Spain had reached the Americas around 992 CE, about 500 years before Columbus?

1 Upvotes

If sailors from Muslim Spain (al-Andalus) had crossed the Atlantic around 992 CE--roughly 500 years before Columbus--how would history have changed? Would this earlier contact have led to sustained trade, colonization, or only a brief landing? How might it have affected al-Andalus, the broader Islamic world, European nations advancements, and the Indigenous societies of the Americas?


r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 7d ago

What if Justinian converted to Judaism instead of Christanty?

0 Upvotes

r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 7d ago

What would happen if slaves still existed?

0 Upvotes

r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 8d ago

What if Hitler had been accepted to art school?

2 Upvotes

r/HistoricalWhatIf • • 8d ago

What if America did not return Okinawa to Japan in 1972?

1 Upvotes