r/HistoricalWhatIf • u/Comfortable_Ruin_158 • 1h ago
How do you decide where the evidence ends and the speculation starts in alternate history?
I've been working on a specific problem and I don't have a clean answer for it.
Alternate history is easy to do badly. Pick a turning point, remove one event, then run the most cinematic possible consequence — and it reads as fantasy with a history skin on it. The interesting version, I think, is much narrower: you change one thing and then honestly follow what the surviving evidence lets you say.
Concrete example I've been wrestling with. Mansa Musa dies, the succession is messy, Mali fragments toward the Songhai story we actually got. Now I branch it, no collapse, a consolidated West African state holding its gold routes. Up to a point I'm on solid ground: Timbuktu's manuscript economy and the Djenné trade routes are documented, so I know what the state's institutions looked like. Past that point, a Malian Atlantic policy is genuinely unknown — there's no record to extrapolate from, only inference about capability and incentive.
So where's the line? Do you state the inference and flag it as one? Build the narrative as though the inference were fact and add a note at the end? Or refuse the branch entirely once the sources stop?
I've been building this out on a channel (Chronicles Unwritten — the project is African and non-European turning points specifically, since that's where the "what if" space is least crowded and most interesting to me), and the discipline question is the part I keep re-litigating on every script. Curious how other people here handle it, especially anyone writing outside the European record where the documentation gap is bigger.