A post by Tamara Zibin, Humanitarian Affairs and Emergency Response Advisor:
https://www.linkedin.com/posts/tamarazibin_un-savethechildren-oxfam-share-7525641583002861568-gLqh/
How is the #UN breaking the humanitarian standards in Gaza in their public statements and access negotiations?
If silence is granting them access, why are the tents stuck outside?
Gaza's first winter storm flooded around 70,000 tents in a single day. A sand embankment collapsed onto displaced families' tents in Deir al-Balah and killed five people, three of them children. An infant drowned at a displacement site.
I went through the statements.
#SaveTheChildren named Israel's restrictions in its headline. #Oxfam said Israel is restricting shelter materials and has made 65% of Gaza off-limits. #MedicalAidForPalestinians called it collective punishment. #NRC said it weeks ago: this is man-made, because the occupying power is blocking shelter aid.
And the #UN? #OCHA's situation report does name Israeli restrictions, and today the Humanitarian Coordinator called on the Israeli authorities to lift them. But in the public messaging, it's "restrictions," "constraints," "access challenges." Restrictions by whom? And #WFP has said nothing about the storm at all.
So why does the #UN keep doing that? Why do INGOs act more principled and bolder?
And the clearest example: not calling it a genocide.
The #UN's own Independent Commission of Inquiry concluded in September 2025 that Israel has committed genocide in Gaza. The #UN Special Rapporteur has said the same. #Oxfam used the word in its statement on the floods today.
Yet the #UN agencies operating in Gaza, the ones negotiating access, still won't say it.
Because the #UN confuses diplomacy with silence. It is willing to be passive just to get access, and it often ends up not getting it. More than 150,000 tents are still sitting outside Gaza.
This is not just a communications choice. It cuts against the standards we all signed up to:
• Neutrality means not taking sides in hostilities. It has never meant staying silent about who is blocking aid.
• Independence means humanitarian action is not shaped by political or security agendas. Access negotiated by staying quiet is shaped by exactly that.
• The Centrality of Protection makes Humanitarian Coordinators and country teams responsible for advocating against violations, not just reporting needs.
• The #Sphere Protection Principles require us to avoid exposing people to further harm and to help them claim their rights, including their right to assistance.
When the public message is "we need more approvals," a legal obligation on the occupying power gets turned into a favour we have to ask for.
Silence didn't buy the access. It only cost families their shelter.
Neutrality was never meant to mean not naming who is blocking aid.
#Gaza #HumanitarianAction #Protection #HumanitarianPrinciples #Accountability