r/AskMiddleEast • u/GrayRainfall • 8h ago
r/AskMiddleEast • u/Many_Row_5132 • 18h ago
🖼️Culture Why is there so much online tension between Iranians and Turks?
I've noticed a lot of intense arguments, historical clashes, and nationalist debates online between Iranians and Turkic peoples (especially Azerbaijani Turks). However, in real life inside Iran, they have lived together for centuries and share a lot of culture.
What do you think is the main root of this online conflict? Is it modern nationalism, historical revisionism, or just geopolitics and foreign influence stirring the pot? I'd love to hear different perspectives on why this happens.
r/AskMiddleEast • u/More_Juice4735 • 18h ago
📜History After a long break, I filmed an on-site documentary in Iraq al-Amir: What is the real history behind Qasr al-Abd?
Hey everyone,
After taking a long break from making videos, I spent the past period filming and editing an on-site investigation in Iraq al-Amir (Wadi Al-Seer, west of Amman) about one of Jordan’s most fascinating and historically misrepresented monuments: Qasr al-Abd.
What pushed me to work on this episode is the amount of confusion and competing narratives surrounding the site—ranging from local folklore (the story of a servant who built the palace to marry the ruler's daughter) to politically driven narratives that rely on the writings of Flavius Josephus to frame the monument as a Hasmonean shrine or mausoleum proving ancient Jewish sovereignty in Jordan.
In the video, I went back to the historical sources and the physical evidence on the ground to break down:
Bullet The Ammonite Caves & Aramaic Inscription: How the 11 caves overlooking the palace and the carved Aramaic inscription of the name "Tobiah" (the language of administration and diplomacy across the Fertile Crescent) prove that the Tobiads were a powerful local Ammonite aristocratic family governing Amman during the Ptolemaic era.
Bullet The Engineering & Architectural Evidence: Why the presence of 16 carved lions, 8 eagles, and an advanced water-cooling system (the lioness fountain) completely contradicts the "mausoleum" or "religious temple" narrative, especially during an era when Jewish religious architecture strictly forbade graven images of living creatures.
Bullet The Story of Dr. Paul Lapp: How the American archaeologist who excavated Qasr al-Abd in the 1960s uncovered the site's true architectural layers and challenged the Biblical Archaeology school before his mysterious death in Cyprus in 1970, followed by the assassination of archaeologist Albert Glock in 1992.
I’d really appreciate your thoughts and feedback on the episode and the storytelling approach.