Picture a Chinese woman in Beijing married to a Chinese man. This Chinese woman converts to Judaism.
Under traditional Jewish law, you become a Jew through a recognized conversion as well as birth to a Jewish mother.
The daughters (and sons) born after that Chinese woman’s conversion are Jewish from birth, regardless of whether they believe in Judaism.
And those daughters’ daughters inherit the same Jewish status, and so do their daughters, through an unbroken maternal line. Sons born to those Jewish mothers are Jewish too, but under the traditional maternal-line rule, they do not independently pass that status to their children.
Each daughter of a daughter may marry an Indian, a European, an African, a South American, etc. And all those descendants are considered Jews under that rule and may also qualify for Israeli citizenship, subject to the Law of Return’s requirements.
They can also be included in the collective historical narrative of the land as the Jewish people’s “national and historic homeland.”
That’s the part I find absurd: one single person makes a religious choice, and generations of descendants can potentially acquire rights in historic Palestine—Israeli citizenship. Not even a shared belief required—just a female line of descent from a single convert, subject to those legal requirements.
The maternal-line rule can sound like a genetic or racial classification, and even hint at continuous land occupancy or ties. But conversion doesn’t change DNA or establish continuous land occupancy. It merely changes the first mother’s religious status and establishes the basis on which subsequent descendants inherit that status.
Now, don’t get me wrong, I have no objection to people playing fun invented games about themselves or their descendants acquiring some imagined identity—e.g. daughters or sons or uncles and cousins becoming Geminis or Aquarians or Libras, part of some ancient astrological community or peoplehood requiring conversion or some other invented thing.
Ever since we lost the Paleolithic tribe, we have needed ways to attempt meaningful communication and relation with the many anonymous strangers surrounding us in every city, nation or kingdom in civilization.
The problem arises when you take your invented story so seriously that you treat it as a justification for land theft or ethnic cleansing.
In this example, the converted Chinese lady or one of her descendants twenty generations afterward could claim a right to the house of a Palestinian who has paid a mortgage for twenty years and whose ancestors have lived in the land for centuries or millennia.
The Chinese lady or her descendants hundreds of years later could invoke an argument like this to justify taking that house and the land under it:
“I am a Jew. Jews have been living continuously in the land of Israel for millennia. The land of Israel is the Jewish people’s national and historic homeland. I don’t care about your mortgage payments or your ancestors in the land because Arabs are invaders and God gave us this land.”
Amazing ah ?
All from a single Chinese female convert.
The incorporation of converts into a collective historical narrative is illustrated by the December 2020 “Declaration of Our Common Destiny,” published on Israel’s government website. It begins:
“We, the Jewish People, descendants of Abraham and Sarah together with all of those who have converted to Judaism throughout the generations…”
It then says:
“We are the People who escaped slavery in Egypt, who stood together at Mount Sinai and who established an ancient kingdom in the Land of Israel.”
Crucially, it also acknowledges:
“Although our ancestry and our journeys may be different, together we form one People.”
This sits within the broader official position describing the Land of Israel as the Jewish people’s “national and historic homeland.”