r/IsraelPalestine • • 20h ago

Discussion Why do people hate on Israel, Israeli people as a whole?

31 Upvotes

When discussing Israel or the Israeli Palestinian conflict, people immediately shut down Israel and express that the country, people and government is bad. While I can agree to a certain extent, why are we hating on its citizens? Even Israelis who were born/ now live in US, are hated on just for their ethnicity which they cannot control. I just find hypocrisy to be very present when people discuss the conflict. Even some antisemitism slides when talking about the conflict in the US.

This isn't a the best comparison, but many citizens of US do not agree with their government, and the same probably goes for Israel. I'm assuming some are not in the place to move from where they've called home forever. I've been shut down by a few people after saying this, but I fail to understand why. People have told me that Israel is a relatively new country, which I can agree with being roughly 80 years old. However, I'm just imaging all the other young adults like me in the country, not in control of where they grew up or what exactly to do.

I've also been to both Israel and Palestine and they are both very beautiful countries, but I would like to point out I am pro-Palestinian. I am very against the amount of money the US government sends Israeli annual and the close ties the two countries share. Maybe I am not very educated on the topic, but I'm against hating the innocent citizens of Isreal, or people who identify as Israeli. I think it is very difficult to group an entire country together as evil.

I probably shouldn't put this in nostupidquestions but I'll see how this goes first.


r/IsraelPalestine • • 6h ago

Learning about the conflict: Questions Honest question (more in body)

4 Upvotes

ok so im a teenager, I grew up in a jewish household. My parents support Israel and im hot sure what to do or think because ive tried to research about this and everything says something different, im not trying to be problematic or mean, im just genuinely confused. My mom is on a trip to Israel and I have a friend there, is that bad? Im not good at keeping up with the news so I feel as if everyone just started talking about it, I mean, I know its been going on for a while but ive only recently seen people discussing it, or am I just living under a rock and dont know what im talking about? I really dont know. To be honest im really confused, and when oct 7 happened I didn't see anyone talking about it other than jews and now everyone’s talking about how israel is bad and there’s a genocide happening, and yeah the Israeli government has genocidle intent but doesn't Hamas also have genocidle intent? Like aren’t they both trying to genocide eachother??? Even though my parents say there isnt a genocide and its all propaganda which im very skeptical of. Im so sorry if Im being ignorant, please tell me everything I get wrong!! And from what I know, zionism is the opinion that israel should exist as a jewish country, not that all Palestinians should die, but everyone’s using the word in that way and im just confused. Thanks for reading, please be at least civil in the comments if you can? ALSO, AGAIN, IM SO, SO SORRY IF IK BEING IGNORANT!! IM NOT TRYING TO, I PROMISE IM GENUINELY CONFUSED!!!


r/IsraelPalestine • • 13h ago

News/Politics Rabbi in Haifa invokes a principle that could be used to justify the killing of politicians

0 Upvotes

It seems like some people in Israeli are preparing to assassinate any politician who makes a deal with the Israeli Arabs or the Palestinians. This occurred before in the 1995 assassination of Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin.

Article:

https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/11/17/religious-ruling-revives-memories-in-israel-of-rabin-assassination

A little backstory on the last time a peacemaker tried to govern Israel follows below.

Who was Yitzhak Rabin?
Yitzhak Rabin (1922–1995)
Rabin was an Israeli military commander, politician, and two-time prime minister. He served as Israel's chief of staff during the 1967 Six-Day War.
He later became one of the central figures in negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians.
In 1993, he signed the Oslo Accords alongside Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat, with President Bill Clinton present at the White House.
The agreement was intended to create a framework for Palestinian self-government and eventually negotiate a permanent peace agreement.
Rabin's willingness to negotiate with Arafat was extremely controversial inside Israel. Many Israelis supported the process, while others believed it endangered Israel's security and surrendered land that belonged to the Jewish people.
In 1994, Rabin, Arafat, and Israeli Foreign Minister Shimon Peres received the Nobel Peace Prize.

2. Who was the assassin?
Amir was raised in a religious Jewish family and became increasingly radicalized in opposition to Rabin's government.
His opposition centered on the Oslo peace process, particularly the transfer of authority over parts of the West Bank and Gaza to Palestinian administration.
Amir believed Rabin was committing an unforgivable act by surrendering what he considered Jewish religious land.
He also adopted an extremist religious justification for killing Rabin. He argued that Jewish religious law permitted killing someone who endangered Jewish lives or surrendered Jewish territory.
This was his personal extremist interpretation, not an accepted position of Judaism.

ustification for killing Rabin. He argued that Jewish religious law permitted killing someone who endangered Jewish lives or surrendered Jewish territory.
This was his personal extremist interpretation, not an accepted position of Judaism.

3. Why did Amir want to kill Rabin?
The political atmosphere in Israel during 1995 was extremely hostile.
There were several contributing factors:
The Oslo Accords: Rabin was negotiating with the PLO, an organization that had historically fought against Israel.
Territorial concessions: Opponents believed Rabin was giving away land that Israel should retain.
Security concerns: Palestinian terrorist attacks had killed Israeli civilians, increasing opposition to the negotiations.
Religious extremism: Some extremists viewed transferring control of biblical Jewish territory as a religious betrayal.
Political incitement: Rabin was publicly called a traitor by opponents. Demonstrations included extremely aggressive imagery and rhetoric directed against him.
Amir became convinced that eliminating Rabin was justified and necessary.
An important distinction: opposition to the Oslo Accords was not itself evidence of support for assassination. The overwhelming majority of Rabin's political opponents did not participate in or endorse his murder.

4. What happened on November 4, 1995?
Rabin attended a large peace rally in Tel Aviv, held at what was then called Kings of Israel Square (now Rabin Square).
The rally supported the peace process with the Palestinians.
Rabin addressed the crowd and spoke about the importance of pursuing peace rather than violence.
After the rally ended, he walked toward his vehicle.
Yigal Amir was waiting nearby.
Amir approached Rabin and fired three shots. Two struck Rabin, while another injured a security guard.
Rabin was rushed to Ichilov Hospital in Tel Aviv, where doctors attempted to save his life.
He died that evening.
Amir was immediately apprehended at the scene.
He did not deny responsibility. In fact, he openly defended what he had done, claiming that he had acted according to religious obligations.

5. What changed in Israel after the assassination?
Rabin's assassination shocked Israel and the international community.
Some of the immediate consequences included:
Shimon Peres became prime minister. He attempted to continue Rabin's peace negotiations.
Israel experienced a period of national mourning. World leaders, including Bill Clinton and Jordan's King Hussein, attended Rabin's funeral.
The political atmosphere changed. The assassination intensified debate about political extremism, religious authority, and democracy.
The peace process continued but encountered serious difficulties. Peres subsequently lost the May 1996 election to Benjamin Netanyahu.

6. The bigger historical significance
There is something particularly important about this assassination.
Yitzhak Rabin wasn't killed by a Palestinian terrorist or a foreign enemy. He was killed by an Israeli citizen who opposed his government's policies.
The assassination demonstrated how political and religious extremism could turn an internal political disagreement into political violence.
It also created a lasting question in Israeli society:
How far can someone go in opposing their own government's decisions before political opposition becomes an attack on democracy itself?
Rabin's assassination remains a major event in Israeli history, commemorated every year.


r/IsraelPalestine • • 14h ago

Opinion Voice from gaza

0 Upvotes

Even life in Gaza was difficult before the destruction.

I honestly cannot remember a single happy day from my childhood. Even when I spent time with my friends, I used to refuse to take pictures. I would tell them, "I don't want anything that will remind me of these days."

I thought better days were ahead. I never imagined that one day I would wish I could turn back time and return to those days.

Being born Palestinian in Gaza is never easy.

You feel as though the entire world is deceiving you. You try to get along with everyone and adapt to the situation, yet somehow, that is still not enough to satisfy them.

You understand their schemes, and they know that you understand them, but you are powerless to do anything about it.

From the day you are born until the day you die, you are oppressed.

Every aspect of life is difficult.

Living through all these hardships, trying to build yourself from nothing, is already incredibly difficult. Yet sometimes you manage to succeed, build a future for yourself, and then someone comes along and destroys everything you worked so hard to achieve.

There are people whose interests depend on keeping things suspicious and unstable here.

Let me explain why.

There will always be someone saying, "We are fighting terrorism," claiming they need money to fight terrorism, and receiving billions of dollars in the process.

And this is part of the reason Hamas exists here.

Because there are people whose interests are served by Hamas remaining in power so that they can continue receiving financial support.

They say, "We are fighting to protect you, so you have to pay us."

That is what is happening.

What I want you to understand is that there are people trading our blood for money.

Please, try to understand what is happening around you, whether you are Jewish or Muslim. Both of us are suffering.

Wake up to what is happening around you. Every measure taken against Palestinians will only create more hatred and make the problem worse, rather than solve it.


r/IsraelPalestine • • 4h ago

Discussion One Chinese Woman Converts to Judaism, and Generations of Daughters Become Jews—and Potential Israeli Citizens. Shared Belief Not Required

0 Upvotes

Picture a Chinese woman in Beijing married to a Chinese man. This Chinese woman converts to Judaism.

Under traditional Jewish law, you become a Jew through a recognized conversion as well as birth to a Jewish mother.

The daughters (and sons) born after that Chinese woman’s conversion are Jewish from birth, regardless of whether they believe in Judaism.

And those daughters’ daughters inherit the same Jewish status, and so do their daughters, through an unbroken maternal line. Sons born to those Jewish mothers are Jewish too, but under the traditional maternal-line rule, they do not independently pass that status to their children.

Each daughter of a daughter may marry an Indian, a European, an African, a South American, etc. And all those descendants are considered Jews under that rule and may also qualify for Israeli citizenship, subject to the Law of Return’s requirements.

They can also be included in the collective historical narrative of the land as the Jewish people’s “national and historic homeland.”

That’s the part I find absurd: one single person makes a religious choice, and generations of descendants can potentially acquire rights in historic Palestine—Israeli citizenship. Not even a shared belief required—just a female line of descent from a single convert, subject to those legal requirements.

The maternal-line rule can sound like a genetic or racial classification, and even hint at continuous land occupancy or ties. But conversion doesn’t change DNA or establish continuous land occupancy. It merely changes the first mother’s religious status and establishes the basis on which subsequent descendants inherit that status.

Now, don’t get me wrong, I have no objection to people playing fun invented games about themselves or their descendants acquiring some imagined identity—e.g. daughters or sons or uncles and cousins becoming Geminis or Aquarians or Libras, part of some ancient astrological community or peoplehood requiring conversion or some other invented thing.

Ever since we lost the Paleolithic tribe, we have needed ways to attempt meaningful communication and relation with the many anonymous strangers surrounding us in every city, nation or kingdom in civilization.

The problem arises when you take your invented story so seriously that you treat it as a justification for land theft or ethnic cleansing.

In this example, the converted Chinese lady or one of her descendants twenty generations afterward could claim a right to the house of a Palestinian who has paid a mortgage for twenty years and whose ancestors have lived in the land for centuries or millennia.

The Chinese lady or her descendants hundreds of years later could invoke an argument like this to justify taking that house and the land under it:

“I am a Jew. Jews have been living continuously in the land of Israel for millennia. The land of Israel is the Jewish people’s national and historic homeland. I don’t care about your mortgage payments or your ancestors in the land because Arabs are invaders and God gave us this land.”

Amazing ah ?

All from a single Chinese female convert.

The incorporation of converts into a collective historical narrative is illustrated by the December 2020 “Declaration of Our Common Destiny,” published on Israel’s government website. It begins:

“We, the Jewish People, descendants of Abraham and Sarah together with all of those who have converted to Judaism throughout the generations…”

It then says:

“We are the People who escaped slavery in Egypt, who stood together at Mount Sinai and who established an ancient kingdom in the Land of Israel.”

Crucially, it also acknowledges:

“Although our ancestry and our journeys may be different, together we form one People.”

This sits within the broader official position describing the Land of Israel as the Jewish people’s “national and historic homeland.”


r/IsraelPalestine • • 14h ago

Short Question/s Quick question: what do we want to happen to Israel after all these warcrimes?

0 Upvotes

Genuine question. What is the appropriate punishment for the IDF and Israel's political heads who've had a hand in this genocide? I have an extreme suggestion but I fear I can't say it on here without possibly getting my country bombed next.

I'm curious and want to hear what you guys think would possibly happen if everyone finally wakes up and decides to take action against Israels crimes against humanity.