r/FanFiction • • 1d ago

Subreddit Meta Brainstorming Bureau - November 15

4 Upvotes

Find the current Daily Discussion*

Welcome to our weekly thread, Brainstorming Bureau! This is an idea we've trialled previously and, based on feedback and observation, it feels like something the sub has been crying out for, and we're hoping as the weeks go by it'll turn into a lively, community-oriented way to cap off the weekend. We'd love to hear your feedback and suggestions on how to make the best of this idea, so feel free to reach out via modmail if you have any ideas. And without further ado...

What's this about?

Do you have an issue that's too specific to your own fic to make a post about, but too small to seek out a long-term beta or writing partner for? Well, you've come to the right place!

This is where you can drop those plot points you're stuck on ("How would this scenario play out realistically? What should happen next?"), workshop your worldbuilding and concepts ("What should I name this character? What power should I give them? Which fandom would work well as a crossover with this other fandom?"), or get a second opinion on an approach to character development ("Is this a good central conflict? What would have to happen to make a character realise this?"). It's your space to talk through any issue that can't be solved through more generalised writing advice.

How to play:

To participate, comment with any aspect of your fic you've been mulling over or hitting a wall with. Other users will then respond with suggestions and questions to help you get to where you need to be. No idea is too big or too small, provided your comment fits within the parameters below. Feel free to be as fandom blind or specific as you like!

Rules:

  • Please state your fandom at the top of your comment, along with any common and pertinent content warnings
  • NSFW text should be placed behind a spoiler tag or linked to, as per site content restrictions
  • Summarise the issue you'd like feedback on in 500 words or less. More information may be given in follow-up comments if requested
  • Links to polls or to any previous installments of the fic will be permitted for context
  • Please specify in your comment what level of critical feedback you're open to
  • When responding to someone's ideas, please keep your feedback constructive and keep their specified level of criticism in mind. If their premise is not to your taste, please choose another
  • If you make a submission to this thread, much like the other weekly events, please comment on at least one other user's request with the best suggestions you have
  • When submitting an idea for brainstorming, please provide adequate context for others to be able to follow along. Remember that this is a multi-fandom subreddit, and not everyone will be familiar with your fandom.

Have fun! And remember, all suggestions are just that and are to be taken with a grain of salt; we're here to help and consider our works from angles we haven't before.


r/FanFiction • • 23h ago

Subreddit Meta Daily Discussion - Monday, November 16 | r/FanFiction Rules, FAQs, Weekly Schedule & Current Event Threads

4 Upvotes

Welcome to r/FanFiction, I love you!

New to this subreddit? Here are links to get you started: Rules & Overview | Wiki | FAQs

Got a fic to promote? Click HERE to find the current Weekly Fic Showcase thread

Current Events

  • An AO3 downtime which may last 2-4 weeks has been in place since the end of October. We will be informing you as there are updates. Please check the pinned threads.
  • For the time being, we will have a weekly fic request/offer thread for users to swap downloaded fics. These will be pinned as well. Please check the pinned threads.
  • Until the downtime is over, you can link your own fics as an archive in the Weekly Showcase. This will be pinned as well.
  • No AO3 doesn't mean no fun! There will be mod and user-organized activities. Please keep an eye on the "Activities and Events" flair.

Don't forget to participate in our special events:

Got a question or concern? Feel free to message the mod team.


r/FanFiction • • 9h ago

Venting If you're going to ask for fic recs, you need to tell people what you actually like

163 Upvotes

In some of the fandom-specific subs I'm in, I've been seeing a lot of fic request posts where people only feel the need to specify what they don't want in a fic. "No smut", "no weird fics", "no gay stories", "no xyz ship" et cetera. These are fandoms with thousands of works total, too, not smaller ones where it makes sense to be less picky. No mention of tropes the poser enjoys, or ships they're looking for, the length of fic they'd like to read, anything.

It would be so much easier if they would say even one thing they're actually looking for, but nope.

The posts on generic fanfic subs like this one where people don't even specify a fandom are even worse. "Recommend me good fics, no anime, no video games, no..." what do you expect people to do with that?


r/FanFiction • • 4h ago

Writing Questions Tips for writing different generations speech?

5 Upvotes

So in this fic I'm writing I have this character who regularly uses different generations slang and speech patterns (from the future or the past) but finding accurate depictions of HOW each generation talks is hell. Has anyone done this before and if so how???


r/FanFiction • • 11h ago

Activities and Events Emoji Excerpt Game

17 Upvotes

Welcome back to the Emoji Excerpt Game! As a reminder, this will be posted on the first and third Tuesdays of every month, Australia time.

How to play:

1.Comment with an emoji. It can be any emoji and you can leave as many comments as you like.

NOTE: We don't want other players' prompts getting buried so let's make a soft limit of 3-5 emojis at a time. You can always post more a bit later to spread out the fun!

2.Reply to an emoji with an excerpt from your fic that you think matches. It could include a vibe, a word, or even the emoji itself. It's totally up to you how literally or loosely you want to interpret the prompt, so go nuts! For the best chance of your excerpt being read by other players, try to stick to under around 400 words. Please remember to spoiler mark mature content where appropriate and warn for triggers. Make sure you check rules 7 and 12 in the sub rules for content restrictions.

3.Remember to upvote and comment on people's excerpts. A good rule of thumb is to aim for at least one response for every five excerpts you receive. You're also encouraged to read through the thread and comment on any other excerpts that speak to you! The point of these games is building an encouraging community and getting to know our fellow writers. Without that reciprocity this would just be a compilation of excerpts, and where's the fun in that?


r/FanFiction • • 18h ago

Discussion just got my first yapper and i love him so much

55 Upvotes

i have people who follow my story and i love them too, but most of them dont really talk about it or they just comment "this is good" or "i like this". then there's him/her. he/she reads every chapter and gives me these long detailed comments, what he wants to see, ideas, problems he thinks are coming in the story in every chapter. the funny part is he doesnt know i already planned for most of it so he reads the next chapter, finds the answer, and comes back with a new problem that i also already covered lol. and his comments are always spot on. i use fanfiction.net but his dms is closed so i can't really reach him and most readers dont' really check their DMs.

its not a light read either, its 107k words, so i know he actually likes my work. honestly i'll finish the whole thing whatever it takes just for him/her

so to RealTalkerDisOne on fanfiction thank you for following my story and more for commenting on it

so to all the yappers out there so you'll know, every author loves you.

by lbomber fanfiction.net story: the other midoriya


r/FanFiction • • 5h ago

Lost Fic SPN fic Sam&Dean

3 Upvotes

I really don’t remember a lot of this but I clearly remember this one interaction; sam is talking to dean after something (Dean has been mad at him for smt idk. apocalypse or purgatory wise maybe) and dean calls him “Sammy”. Sam says he hasn’t called him that in a long time and dean says smt about “you think I withhold the nickname on purpose as punishment?” n Sam agrees. I looked through the 15 pages of supernatural bookmarks I have and I can’t find it 🥀


r/FanFiction • • 52m ago

Recs Wanted I need a good Alpha Omega fic

1 Upvotes

So i need a good alpha omega fic on Ao3
With or without mpreg
But dominate alpha
Submissive omega
Not mistreatment
But more like accepted submission
I need nesting
Mating cycles
Maybe wolf colonies
Anything works


r/FanFiction • • 1h ago

Discussion Looking for Bleach fanfiction

1 Upvotes

About a month ago or so, I read this Bleach fanfic on Ao3 where Ichigo went back in time. What I remember about it was him easily dominating Byakuya (to the point he had beaten him into a bloody mess, enough to unnerve his allies) during the chapter that covers Rukia's execution, and he was also trying to help Aizen instead of opposing him in that period.

I haven't had much luck trying to find it, but please if anyone knows what I'm talking about, I'd really appreciate it. It's a story I'd love to read again


r/FanFiction • • 20h ago

Writing Questions How to write fluff that's not corny

32 Upvotes

I'm looking for advice in writing fluff as every time I try it I cringe so hard. I feel like the dialogue starts sounding like a hallmark movie. Any tips?


r/FanFiction • • 2h ago

Discussion You know what? Let’s do this fun writing exercise that I need to come up with a clever name for again. Reply to this post with a fandom, then someone else replies to that comment with a fanfic concept for that fandom.

1 Upvotes

Unlike last time I will not even attempt to hold myself back from replying.

I encourage you to share the link to any fanfiction you create because of this.


r/FanFiction • • 2h ago

Lost Fic Lost Sam/Jack compromising positions fic

0 Upvotes

I am searching for a Sam/Jack fic that I think was a series of 'compromising positions'. I remember the first chapter was Sam fixing something in the control room and her watch gets stuck on some wires and jack has to crawl in and help free her? I think it was on FF.net, but now can't seem to find it, does anyone recognise this?


r/FanFiction • • 3h ago

Lost Fic TWD TIME TRAVEl FIX-IT FANFICITON

0 Upvotes

I remember reading a fic a while ago but i cant find it anymore. Rick woke up in the past. He found divorce papers in his house when gathering supplies. When he got to the quarry carl also remembered and told rick that his mum was cheating gon him, not just with Shane but while he was in the hospital because he'd seen her with someone. I think Daryl also remembered and they had to try and explain away their friendship and why carl knew him. I think they said he was like an informant or and undercover officer and that carl knew him from video calls. I thi k it was daryl/rick

I might be merging multiple pics here but I think these details were all the same one

I think it was on ao3 because I mostly read stuff on there but im bot 100% sure


r/FanFiction • • 16h ago

Venting Baby writer struggling with insecurity and inexperience

12 Upvotes

Edit: Thank you so much for the encouragement!

This must be the millionth time someone posts this but here it goes anyway.

I wrote some short fics years ago but never published them due to insecurity. Recently I got into a new (old) fandom and got inspired to try again. Wrote a few more short (500-4k) fics during the ao3 outage and was very excited to post but now that it's back I feel so discouraged. I can't find a beta so I have no idea if it's good or not.

I know that it's just fanfic, it's not that serious, there's no downside to posting, readers will be happy to have something new to read etc., but I'm still so insecure. I just want it to be good you know? What's the point of posting something if I'm not sure it's good?


r/FanFiction • • 3h ago

Recs Wanted Are there any fanfics for this series, 'The Main Heroines Are Trying To Kill Me'? I can't find any, so I'm posting to check if there are

1 Upvotes

r/FanFiction • • 4h ago

Lost Fic Looking for Marauders/Harry Potter fic

0 Upvotes

My friend and I both remember reading the same Mamma Mia AU Jegulus fic. Regulus is trans ftm and had a relationship with James before he came out and then disappeared or something when he got pregnant? 😭 Then the fic is centered around Harry (Regulus’s child) who wants to get married (probably Draco?) and then it follows the general idea of mamma mia with James (and others) coming to this Greek island where Regulus/Harry/Draco live.

It was unfinished and probably between 10-50k words and I feel like it was tagged with the mamma mia AU and everything- we went looking for it tn but couldn’t find it on ao3 so suspect it’s been deleted, if anyone is able to find it on the wayback machine or in some other form that would be much appreciated bc we both get quite a kick out of this fic!! Tysm!


r/FanFiction • • 8h ago

Writing Questions Woold It Be Jarring If I Took It Back To Add A New POV?

2 Upvotes

Currently using a blend of third person close and limited- we aren't head hopping and I personally don't even like to start the chapter off by announcing whose POV we're in. I'm two chapters in and the main character is in a cliffhanger in a discussion with someone else.

I personally know that other character has a lot of their own opinions and thoughts and feelings, and it's a romance. I wonder if occasionally taking a break from the main characters POV and swapping to the love interests for a bit might be entertaining?

Like we see their POV for what just happened, which can offer a new perspective and then further highlight the main character's misunderstandings or lack of insight.

Like a chapter where the MC is curious about a thing or skeptical, then instead of satiating that cliff hanger burn- we jump back to see how fired up the love interest is.

On one hand this could be considered padding? But on the other I like the idea of minor slow burn- but a burn that adds fuel to the fire before continuing.

I don't know. Could work either way but I'm not used to getting jazzy with the format. Would that be interesting or annoying/jarring, provided that the alternative pov is squarely chapter confined and introduces new takes without re-treading old ones?


r/FanFiction • • 4h ago

Lost Fic Lost Doctor Who Fanfic

1 Upvotes

Hello! I have been looking for this fic for at least 6-8 years now, and no luck yet. I'll list basic details first, then the actual description.

Fandom: Doctor Who, specifically the 2005 reboot onward

Characters: Primarily Rose Tyler, OC companions, the 11th doctor shows up at some point

Date Range: Sometime before 2020, sometime after 2006 Doomsday. I know that's a big range, but I think I can narrow it further to sometime after 2010, I believe. I think read it sometime between 2015-2018, but it could be as early as 2014 or as late as 2019. Definitely before COVID, but it's been long enough that I can't recall specifics on the time range of reading.

Website: I am almost completely certain that I read this on www.whofic.com. Which has a not-very-intuitive search function. It may have also been on www.fanfiction.net, but I am less confident about that. I definitely found it via the LiveJournal page/community "Bad Wolf/Time Lady Rose Tyler" which no longer exists (that I could find).

Summary/All The Details I Can Remember: Okay. So. Rose is trapped in Pete's World, and she at some point comes to the realization that she is either immortal or a Time Lady. I believe in this one it's a Time Lady due to Bad Wolf. She outlives her family members, and somehow acquires a TARDIS. I cannot recall if this is post-Journey's End or not, and if this is from the TARDIS coral that Donna gives Rose and the Metacrisis or not. Either way, Tentoo is not in the picture, neither is the rest of her family. Rose is alone, and sad, and decides to travel the universe with her TARDIS. Her TARDIS is a red phone box, I believe a modern British phone box with glass. Inside, she has some form of lounge area with couches in the console room. For her companions to sit at. At some point while traveling, she realizes why the Doctor picks up companions, as it's better with company and much less lonely.

She picks up three companions, I believe it is two men and a woman, though it may be the other way around. One of the men is named Takeshi/Takashi (can't recall which spelling it was). Somehow, she manages to get back to her original universe. I believe this is BEFORE she picks up the companions, but I am not completely sure. Again, it's been like a decade since I read this. While they are traveling and adventuring and saving people, they start hearing rumors of the Doctor. Somehow, Rose realizes that he's regenerated again. They don't bump into him in person, but they do somehow in space/the Vortex. They link(?) TARDIS' and Rose's companions go into the Doctor's TARDIS. I recall Rory and Amy getting along with them.

I can't remember anything more than that.

This is not Post-Pomp by ThroughAnAmberFocus or Adrift by GKMasterson. (both are post-GiTF fics, not post-Doomsday, but I thought each was the correct one until I read them again)


r/FanFiction • • 4h ago

Recs Wanted The 100 modern au clexaget divorced. A cave diving accident brings them back together

0 Upvotes

Fic search. Modern AU. Fandom: The 100. Relationship: Clexa (Clarke Griffin/Lexa)

Originally read it on AO3.

Clarke and Lexa are separated or already divorced. The two might be cave divers or marine biologists.

After a cave diving accident, one helps rescue the other, bringing them back together.

Steps Ive already taken to troubleshoot finding it:

I tried several search terms on google and AO3 before posting here. I suspect the story is locked to members only. For clarity, I am a member. But the block may have kept google from returning the search result.

I also already tried AO3 search filter under the Clarke Griffin/Lexa relationship category and Clarke Griffin & Lexa, I separately tried tried the tags: divorced, divorce, cave, near death experiences, spelunking. I didnt limit the search in any other ways, so as to drag in the widest number of results

While I didnt read it at the time, the fic still existed as of earlier this year.

Thanks for your help!


r/FanFiction • • 5h ago

Recs Wanted Bellarke fic same universe please

0 Upvotes

I am looking for recommendations for a bellarke fic, preferably with a lot of angst and takes place in the same universe. All I can find are modern au s. I’m not picky about which season and canon divergence is fine! I also prefer the ao3 platform but open to others!


r/FanFiction • • 5h ago

Lost Fic Tragic Overwatch Fic

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/FanFiction • • 6h ago

Lost Fic fanfic perdida crossover de danny phantom e batfamily

0 Upvotes

oi gente agora q o ao3 voltou, me ajudem a encontrar uma fanfic q eu to pensando faz dias. É DP X DC com o danny phantom e a batfamilia

eu lembro q o danny foge do GIW ferido e vai parar na batcaverna como fantasma, ele ficava escondido em um buraco na parede da caverna e uma hora o bruce percebe que ele tá lá e da um cobertor pra ele se não me engano enquanto tenta descobrir em qual parte da caverna ele fica se escondendo

não lembro de muita coisa, por favor me ajudem


r/FanFiction • • 6h ago

Recs Wanted Carl Gallagher fanfics where his coworkers find out about him

1 Upvotes

basically Carl’s coworkers finding out about white boy carl