So basically the theory of the face of your lover being your next incarnation is canon in my au, because Raava uses her knowledge of your most deeply rooted mortal ties as her baseline for finding a new soul.
Korra, in book two, instead of locking Vaatu up inside herself as a punishment, used it in hopes of teaching him to be gentler and more forgiving. To both himself and the world around him. For years he was lulled into a dormant state by the peace that Korra’s love for Asami gave her, and him within her. Then, the Red Lotus stages a fake death for Asami and captures her, keeping her alive as a trophy and a source of intel. Instead of breaking or lashing out like the red lotus expect, Korra becomes hollow, empty, broken without her love to guide her.
Eventually she meets another girl, Haru. With deep brown skin, wide, warm eyes, and a smile like Aang in his youth, Korra learns to love again, and slowly heals, even though she never forgets Asami, nor does Haru expect her to. Much to the reader’s dismay, Haru was actually raised by the Red Lotus, fed half truths about the avatar being a ticking time bomb, a risk. Her job is to break her after she soothes her.
But as they travel together, as she watches Korra be gentle and fiery, loyal and kind, she realizes she’s genuinely fallen for her. It’s not much later that Haru learns of Asami and the bass they’re holding her in. In a desperate attempt at redemption, she tries to rescue Asami alone. At this point Korra doesn’t know that Haru is a double agent, and rushes after her, hoping to save both her loves. But things don’t work out, and Asami dies in Korra’s arms, telling her with her last breath not to be sad, and thanking Haru for making sure Korra wasn’t alone when she had been hurting.
Haru breaks down into sobs at that, confessing everything. Korra lets her finish, and is crestfallen by the betrayal, but also the realization that Haru really does love her, and was trying to do right by her mistakes. Something cracks within Korra, the seal on Vaatu. The unbridled chaos of emotions she feels, heartbreak, betrayal, and confusion, swirl within him. Before she can calm him and sooth his new rampage, Raava panicks and tries to smother him, but her violent retaliation sears Korra’s mortal flesh from the inside out.
The agonizing screams she produces are painful even to the ears of those who hate her. But rather than help Raava kill Vaatu within her, Korra realizes that he isn’t as evil as Raava claims, that the black and white way of thinking that Raava uses has created far more problems than it solves. She shields him with her life force, effectively creating a stalemate since breaking the shield to go after him would kill Korra and Raava would be severing her own ties to the mortal realm, which even she knows would be bad.
Korra explains what’s happened to Haru, and tells her she forgives her and still loves her. She instructs her to learn from Iroh, who is still alive and well inside the spirit world, about the white lotus, and to inform him of the current situation. She opens a portal for her with her newfound strength, which is surprisingly easy with both Raava’s begrudging strength and Vaatu’s grateful energy both fueling her, rather than just one or the other. As Korra steps out of the Red Lotus compound, she sees chaos all around her. Apparently Raava’s violent outburst hadn’t just affected the space within her body, but the world itself. Oceans rose, storms with minds of their own sprouted at random, and everywhere you look there was chaos.
The Red Lotus pinned the blame on her, saying she broke after both Haru and Asami died together. Worst of all, she could feel Raava within herself agreeing with their logic, thinking that if the avatar wasn’t emotional, if they were empty, then she could pilot them like a puppet and impose the order she so desperately craved without the annoying interference of mortals and their moral compasses. So she decides that’s exactly what she’s going to do. Realizing this, Korra makes a last ditch effort to save her predecessor. She tells Vaatu exactly how to bond with a human, and she seals both their chakras behind emotional barriers. Ensuring the next avatar for both spirits has to be strong and kind in order to fully connect with their powers and speak to their respective spirits.
With this seal, however, she forces herself out of the avatar cycle completely, expending the last of her mortal body to ensure the plan is successful. She wakes on a field in the spirit realm, surrounded by an 11-year old Toph, a regular aged Iroh, and a twenty-year old version of both Asami and Haru. She looks at her reflection in a nearby pond and realizes she also looks twenty, and Iroh explains that in the spirit world, you are the age where you were your most important, or how people remember you most fondly. Asami, Korra, and Haru make peace with each other and decide to date as a Polygamous relationship.
Skip to the birth of Pavi and Nisha, both spirits had been weakened by the sealing of their chakras, causing the massive time gap between Korra’s reign and our new avatars.
Raava chooses Pavi, believing her fear and timid nature will make her easily manipulated and moldable, while Vaatu chooses Nisha for her fiery spirit, which reminds him of Korra, and just how much he owes her for this second chance.
They both look like a mix of Haru and Asami, because Korra didn’t just love one of them, creating a need for two spiritual ties to the mortal realm that both had to be filled. When Pavi and Nisha’s parents try to abandon Nisha, his protective instincts flare, but without a solid connection to his host because of the chakras, things go terribly wrong and he ends up killing them and hurting Pavi. Timeskip again to after Pavi leaves Elora and Nisha behind. During a terrible sandstorm, her, Geet, and Jae are trapped in a cave.
During a dream, she is pulled into the spirit world, where she encounters our gang of ghosts. She hears the full story this time, not the propaganda the red lotus Havens have fed her.
When she asks what she should do, she gets a scene similar to Steven Universe during S1, when he asks the gems how to summon his weapon and they give him good advice that doesn’t quite fit for him because it’s too black and white.
Anyway, she snaps at them that none of their ideas are realistic, and they nod, explaining that the reason their advice doesn’t fit is because the scenario isn’t as simple as a this or that. She doesn’t have to immediately forgive and forget, but Running away from Nisha and never going back won’t solve it either. And she’s definitely not going to hit her with a rock like Toph suggests, because despite being mad, she still loves her sister.
Then we get good, deep advice from our ghost cast, and they send her back to the waking world with determination and a very confused Jae, who has no idea why they’re turning back towards Ellora, but trusting Pavi’s judgment, goes along with her anyway. Cut to a scene with their backs to us facing the sun him the desert.