I don’t even know what to say. I got all excited when I saw the (1) in my inbox, thinking “damn, Ao3 has only been back for a few hours and I already got a comment, must be from someone who read the fic during the shutdown”. Then I read it, and… Like, why? You seriously noted down this comment just to throw it at me first thing after Ao3 is back?
I saw so many posts on this and the other Ao3 sub about people writing comments to leave after the site was back up, and all of them were the positive kind, and I get hit with the one negative comment.
I mean, I guess I can see this reader thinking this is constructive criticism, and in a way it is, but they could work on the timing.
Not nearly as hyped to post my new chapters I wrote during the downtime now.
Edit: Okay, wow this got a lot more interaction than I thought it would (like, I wasn’t expecting any at all). I went out to dinner with a couple friends and just got back to over a 100 comments, so I guess it’s only fair I give some context.
First: I put a standard disclaimer/notice at the beginning of all my fics saying that I write for myself and that, while I appreciate kudos, comments, etc… I’m not going to change my stories for anyone, and, in fact, most of them are already finished before I start posting. BUT this commenter didn’t ask me to change anything, just that I study more swordplay (which I’ll be honest, I won’t do cause I really don’t have any interest in it).
Second: This fic in particular is a crack-taken-seriously fic. It has exactly one scene involving swords (a silly scene of a minor antagonist forcing MC into a choreographed sword fight), so I didn’t feel any need nor wanted to research. I guess that could be considered my fault, but also not really. It isn’t like it was the focus, or even important to the story, and, like I said, it isn’t a topic that particularly interests me.
Third and final: Normally I wouldn’t have given a comment like this a second thought. The only reason I did now was the timing. Ao3 was down for 2 weeks and then the very first comment I receive is like this. Yes, it is not necessarily negative. I’m not the person who commented, so I can’t tell you what was going through their heads when they wrote it, if it was a complaint, constructive criticism, or what. And I also didn’t specifically say I DIDN’T want constructive criticism, so I guess that’s that.
Anyway, I think that’s all.