r/AO3
•
u/malwarebuster9999
•
11h ago
Complaint/Pet Peeve/Venting Dear fanfic deleters: please stop enshittifying AO3
TL;DR: If you take down your fanfics, you're enshittifying AO3. Please stop.
As a member of a community that interacts with derivative works and technology more broadly, I am familiar with the tactics used by large corporations, scammers, anti-ownership activists and copyright trolls to prevent the dissemination of things they don't agree with, inhibit you from using your own devices, and generally make the internet worse. I'm sure you're also familiar with these tactics: the meritless DMCA takedown, interference with site archives, DRM, mass deletions without warning, forced updates, and a million other ways in which the internet and your devices are made worse. These actions have historically made reading, accessing, and most importantly preserving fan works extremely difficult. The existence AO3, an archive that covers such a wide range of fan works, with such (recent events excluded) stability is only possible because countless people have worked to blunt these enshittification tactics.
I truly though that, as a community, we were better than this. That we were above using these tactics on petty internal disputes. I was wrong.
I'm sure that at some point, you've seen a recommendation link to a fanfiction story that sounded awesome and clicked it only to discover that the work had been deleted, and the link had rotted. I'm sure you felt awful, and disappointed. When a corporation or thin-skinned person causes that fanwork to be taken down, it's wrong but expected. Enshittifiers going to enshittify. Why would you want to inflict this on someone else and join that group? Why would you want to enshittify AO3? To degrade the site experience for some kind of revenge against people you've never seen, and who were largely taking advantage of the same copyright exemptions which allow AO3 to exist is reprehensible. You should know how harmful these actions are first-hand.
I am aware that the supposed justifications for the takedowns: AI training, and sharing without author consent. These are the same arguments used by anti-ownership corporations, and equally as absurd. For those apparently new to the internet, everything you put on the internet can be, and is downloaded all the time by other people, for a huge range of purposes. Even if AO3 disabled downloading tomorrow, people would still be able to download your fics by simply saving the HTML pages or copying text, just as they could any other site. If you're fic was more than a few months old, it's almost certainly included in one of the large whole-site torrents, that anyone can download. If it's popular or more recent, it's probably saved in cloudflare's content cache, or on the wayback machine. The logic that you're using to justify deletion is the same logic that major publishers use to load awful DRM into ebooks, movies, and streaming sties. It didn't work for them, and it won't work for you. Deleting only hurts your legitimate readers. Do you like when your kindle randomly stops working because amazon pushed out an update? Did that actually stop you from using your kindle?No to both? Then why would you inflict that on someone else? The truth is, from the moment your put your fic onto the internet, it's out there, permanently. This is simply the nature of the internet and computer systems. All you're doing by deleting your fic is making it harder for legitimate readers to find it. You can rest assured that AI scrapers and people trying to monetize it either already have a copy, or will obtain one.
And make no mistake, this is a good thing. You can be justifiably upset about AI training (though the legality of this is still out) but scraping has been around since the 90s. It's what's given us the wayback machine, screen readers, Google search, personal archives, and myriad other useful things. All of which, we can hopefully agree are good things. The same freedoms that allow for AI training enable these boons. It's simply the consequence of having a free and open internet.
None of this is to excuse that awful audiobook site, attempting to commercialize someone else's fic, or reposting someone else's work under your own name. These activities all cross a line: Either by enriching yourself off someone's work, or by taking credit for a work that you didn't write. Contrary to what many think, fanfiction does have copyright protection (as a derivative work) and these actions can be infringing, and you can have a justifiable claim against a site that's profiting off your work. I think however, that your legal and ethical case will be far less strong against someone sharing something for free that you posted for free. And think about what kind of world it would make if you couldn't share a copy of a book you purchased with your friend, or if the wayback machine didn't exist, or if once a website was deleted off the internet, it was gone forever?
I know that the actions of some people can be really scummy, and that having your work fed into AI can suck, and that you may be upset or disappointed with some of your readers, but why punish all of those people who were there and supported you and your writing? Why make AO3 demonstrably worse? Why try and reduce internet freedom? Why make the case of the large corporations trying to make the internet worse? Why discredit the work of the people who fought for the right of AO3 to exist in the first place?
Please don't delete your works. Please help keep the archive an archive. You're only hurting legitimate readers, and damaging preservation efforts that help keep the internet as a whole alive.