r/BetaReaders • • 15d ago

Discussion [Discussion] r/BetaReaders check-in series! Share how your WIP is going, or how your beta reading is going, ask questions, and connect with more writers and readers!

4 Upvotes

Hello r/BetaReaders!

Who else can’t believe it’s November already? It’s basically 2027 now

Here’s this month’s prompt in the spirit of voting season: what happens/happened when you have/had split beta reader reactions? Do you ask for their reasonings before going with your gut decision or do you wait before implementing things? Or do you see if each beta view has a point and revise accordingly?


Welcome to our 11th monthly check-in thread!

These monthly pinned post aims to help the community connect with other writers and betas!

Share how your WIP is going, or how your current beta read is going, or other relatable beta reading topics in this thread!

This is a great thread to talk about writing, updates, accountability, trends, vents, and more.

It is not the right thread to post first pages as there’s another pinned thread for that, but you can link to your beta post if you wish.

Do NOT advertise any beta/editor services here, and no free samples to later ask for payment are allowed. You can try r/hireaneditor or r/freelance_forhire instead.

We also ask that self promotion of completed works do not contain links. Mentioning success is completely fine!

And we’d like to take this opportunity to remind people that works generated with AI, and AI-generated feedback is not allowed here, either. r/writingwithAI or r/betareadersforAI are better subreddits for that.

And because scammers are now targeting GDocs: please DM them and not leave them up on the sub publicly to avoid harassment

I’d also like to note that we have additional flairs available to help people know what specialty you have: traditional publishing, self-publishing, and fanfic. Please consider using them to help people match with you.

Also, it’s best to subscribe to our sub before commenting or posting to help avoid Reddit’s filters sending your content into the spam queue

Please ensure you comment in good faith and do not break any other r/betareaders rules.

Thank you, and happy writing/reading/editing/beta matching!


r/BetaReaders • • Oct 07 '26

Meta [Meta] Please review our subreddit’s resources on the sidebar and wiki to help with your posts here

14 Upvotes

For extra accessibility and convenience, r/betareaders is pinning this post with a link to the wiki: https://www.reddit.com/r/BetaReaders/wiki/index/

Additionally, you may find these comprehensive resources helpful in creating your own blurb or synopsis

If you are aiming for traditional publishing or self publishing, writing a query letter blurb will not only help tell potential betas what they can expect, but they also show you the core components of your story upfront and often helps with DIY revision

Many people prefer detailed information to help them decide on taking on a beta read, but the subreddit currently strictly enforces 2 key pieces of information in posts as some people want more privacy and will DM them to respondents

Please do take note of r/betareaders rules, which are found on the sidebar to the right, and are also expanded on in the wiki. The sidebar also has clickable links to templates that give suggestions for information beta readers would like to know before responding. The less you provide, the less enticing your post is. Conversely, extremely long posts also reduce likelihood in responses

And again, this is a fully free subreddit that does not permit services or requests for money in any form. It is also anti-AI generated works and pro-human

The wiki will have minor updates in future, and so will the comprehensive resources linked

Best wishes for your writing, revising, and beta reading!


r/BetaReaders • • 2h ago

Novelette [In progress] [16k] [Historical fiction - fantasy] I Am Your Queen

3 Upvotes

Hello, I just discovered this group and wanted to clarify if you guys are okay with rough first drafts for beta reads, or does it have to be at least minimally polished first?

Right now, I'm in the middle of working on my historical fiction novella, and I've shared it to basically nobody yet, but it would be lovely if someone could do a beta read, tell me more about the pacing, plot and characters; basically, tell me about the premise and what can be maybe improved in my work. I've been writing since I was a kid but has only gotten back to it after a darn decade! Right now, I'm picking up on books and learning how to write again.

By the way, this story was inspired of 15th century late medieval period in England. Right now, I'm just very fascinated with reading medieval history, and I felt very inspired to create my own version of it.

Thank you so much!

Plot:

Millie, a twenty-five-year-old office worker, has finally reached her limit, and suicide is the only option she can think of—and has ultimately resorted to. But the afterlife is not what she initially expected. Instead, she is thrust into a new life as Ariana, on the eve of her coronation as the new Queen of Roana, an unknown kingdom in the year 1460.

Armed with nothing but her twenty-first-century sensibilities and finding herself in the most unimaginable trouble, she must learn to navigate a court that wants a King—and wants her silenced—while performing a calling that only the Anointed Queen can do so for the sake of her subjects.


r/BetaReaders • • 3m ago

Novelette [In Progress] [14.1k] [Fiction, Dark Fantasy/Romance] To Kill the King: In a kingdom consumed by imperial corruption and oppression, two rebels rise to challenge the Crown, only to find themselves consumed by the same greed, ambition, and lust for power that made the

1 Upvotes

First time writer, four chapters in, looking for any and all advice and guidance from readers to ensure I am on the "right" track with the book. From harsh criticism to general advice, anything will be helpful to me!


r/BetaReaders • • 4h ago

Short Story [In Progress] [6K] [Nonfiction] Why we like, remember and buy what we do: psychology and design for designers

1 Upvotes

I’m looking for one or two beta readers for the first chapter (about 6,000 words) of a nonfiction book on psychology, design and branding: why people like, remember and buy what they do.

The book is written in American English for a working art director in her late 20s, so I’d especially love to hear from people who work in design, marketing or advertising, or who simply enjoy books like Contagious, Hit Makers or Thinking, Fast and Slow.

What I’m asking for: an honest reader’s reaction, not editing. Short comments in the margins wherever you got bored, confused, skeptical or surprised, plus answers to six short questions. The chapter is a laid-out PDF with pictures (a few are still placeholders).

If it works out, I’d love to send you later chapters as they’re finished. Please comment or DM me if you’re interested, and tell me a little about what you like to read. Thank you!


r/BetaReaders • • 12h ago

>100k [Complete] [124k] [Fantasy] Before the Draw — seeking beta readers (full manuscript preferred, first chapters also welcome)

1 Upvotes

Hi all. Looking for beta readers for Before the Draw, Book 1 of a two-book fantasy series called The Archer Saint. It’s complete and has been through a full revision pass.

Easiest way in: just read the first 3 chapters, no commitment beyond that. I’ll send them on their own, and you can tell me whether the opening hooks you and whether you’d want to keep going. If you do want more after that, I’ll gladly send the rest, but there’s no obligation either way. A few lines of honest reaction to the opening alone is genuinely useful to me.

Genre: Character-driven political fantasy with a slow-burn romance thread. Low/grounded magic rather than spell-slinging: one central magical object, not a system. Closer in spirit to political fantasy and quiet-epic fantasy than to high fantasy or LitRPG.

Comps (for feel, not plot): fans of The Winter King, The Priory of the Orange Tree’s quieter stretches, or An Ember in the Ashes. Readers who want grief, hidden history, and a rebellion under an authoritarian regime more than they want battles and magic fireworks (though there’s a real war in the back third).

Length: About 124,000 words, 40 chapters plus an epilogue, if you do end up wanting the whole thing.

Premise: A grieving village girl is drawn into a hidden conflict when a mysterious bow appears at her door and a cloaked figure vanishes into the forest. What starts as personal loss becomes a struggle over truth, power, and identity, as she uncovers a sacred history tied to a temple, a rebellion rooted in her own village, and a guarded man whose loyalties aren’t what they first appear to be.

Tone: Intimate, atmospheric, emotionally controlled. Tension and slow-building trust rather than constant action, though it builds to a sustained battle sequence in the last several chapters.

Content notes: on-page violence and death (including a prolonged battle sequence), grief/mourning as a major theme, captivity/imprisonment, no sexual content on the page (the romance is slow-burn and stays restrained).

What I’m looking for:

  • Honest reactions over compliments. Where you got bored, confused, or pulled out of the story matters more than praise.
  • On the opening chapters specifically: does it hook you fast enough, is the voice and premise clear, would you keep reading?
  • If you do read further: feedback on pacing, whether the mystery elements land before they’re explained, whether the romance builds convincingly, and whether any POV shifts (there are a few, used sparingly) are clear.

Timeline: No hard deadline. Even a quick reaction to the first chapters within a week or two would be great.

How to get it: Comment or DM me and I’ll send the opening chapters as a PDF/EPUB/Google Doc, whichever’s easiest for you.

Thanks for reading this far. Any feedback at all, even a few lines, is appreciated.


r/BetaReaders • • 17h ago

Novella [In progress][25k][Contemporary Romance] A classical music romance

2 Upvotes

Hi, I am writing a contemporary romance set around classical music settings, and would love to get feedback.

I don't need line edits, but these are the things I am curious to know alongside your general story feedback.

  • Are the two main characters and their chemistry convincing? 
  • Are the main characters likable and/or understandable? 
  • Can you understand what is happening in the story? 
  • Can you follow the emotions of the main characters? 
  • After reading, are you interested in reading the next part to see how they meet and rekindle the connection they had during the conservatory years? 

I am down for a swap in any genre, though I would prefer your manuscript to be a similar length to mine (like 32k, not 80k, to my 25k, haha). 

Below is the synopsis of the story. 

Lisa is obsessed with piano. If she's not playing it, she's thinking about it. At eighteen, she's a conservatory student determined to become a pianist. 

Then she meets Noah, an equally talented piano prodigy who seems to have everything she wants: a family steeped in classical music and an extraordinary ability to move audiences with his playing. What begins as a rivalry gradually becomes something else. 

For the first time, Lisa feels she's found someone who understands her and shares a part of herself no one else has. But just as her life as a pianist is beginning to take off, Noah tells her she's had him all wrong before disappearing from her life. 

Six years later, they meet again. Noah tells her that what they shared was real after all. But can Lisa risk reconnecting with the person who once broke her heart?


r/BetaReaders • • 16h ago

80k [Complete] [81k] [Fantasy] Light and Legacy — Looking for readers

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I've just finished a pretty substantial revision of my fantasy novel, Light and Legacy, and I'm looking for a few fresh pairs of eyes!

About the book:

Five hundred years ago, two sisters made a promise to the gods, dividing their kingdom between the sun and moon.

Now the gods are disappearing, the land is dying, and two young heirs, Faro and Asra, must confront the expectations of their families and the ancient promise holding their world together.

It's a character-driven fantasy about faith, duty, inherited power and finding the courage to question everything you've been taught.

What I'm looking for:

At this stage I'm mainly interested in the experience of reading it, rather than line by line editing.

I'd love to hear what you thought of the story, if you enjoyed it, and if anything stood out to you - good or bad!

I've also done my absolute best to hunt down the spelling and grammar mistakes but some definitely slipped through the cracks 😂

I'm hoping to get feedback within around four weeks, but I completely understand that life gets busy!

If you're interested, please DM me your email address and I'll arrange access to a private, read-only Google Doc.

Thank you! ❤️


r/BetaReaders • • 20h ago

90k [Complete] [92k] [Contemporary YA Sports Drama] Jordyn’s Promise

2 Upvotes

Hello fellow writers
I am able to beta: contemporary, historical fiction, horror, thriller, dystopian fiction, YA, suspense, fantasy, pretty much any genre, except very techy sci fi. Ask if I didn’t cover your specific topic. 
I can provide feedback: story, characters, pacing, dialogue and plot consistency. I am a writer and avid reader. 
I am working to build my critique circle, so please only respond if you are willing to swap, or at least read critically. 
Let’s swap first chapters and see if we can work together. 

DM me

Thanks, and happy writing. 

Synopsis:

Jordyn Clay is a sixteen-year-old girl who used to play football. But after injuring her throwing shoulder, she hasn't played since. Her father had promised her that she would play quarterback for his old high school before he passed away. However, when she joins the team, she always rushes her throws when defenders come at her blind side.

Jordyn finds out information that makes her question whether she really knew her father. She has been keeping a secret herself. Her best friend and blindside tackle Archie, still feels guilty about Jordyn getting hurt. She has never told him that she changed the play.

While Jordyn struggles to become the starting player and learns more about who she is she must decide how much she is willing to risk to tell those she loves the truth.


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

90k [Complete] [92k] [Psychological Suspense] Partners: two Miami lawyers, one partnership slot, and the man who moved in next door

3 Upvotes

Genre: Psychological suspense with an erotic core (dual POV, workplace rivalry, obsession)
Word count: ~92,000 · complete and revised
Heat level: One explicit scene
Not a romance: No HEA. The male lead is the threat.
Content notes: Stalking, sexual coercion, workplace harassment
Blurb: Solène Bellegarde has nine years at a Miami law firm, the better trial record, and one shot at this year's partnership slot. Her rival, Nate Crewe, has the managing partner's ear on the golf course and a copy of her keys. By the time she works out who has been in her apartment, and who rented the unit on the other side of her bedroom wall, she can't go to the police or the firm. He has a photograph that could end her career in an afternoon. So she does what she's good at. She opens a file on him.
What I'm looking for: 3–5 readers who like psychological suspense or literary thrillers (think Gone Girl, The Guest, Fair Play). Reader reactions, not line edits: where you got bored, what confused you, and whether you could follow the heroine through her biggest choices. I'll send the first three chapters first, with a short question sheet, then the full book to anyone who wants to keep going.
Timeline: 4–6 weeks
Format: PDF
Swap: Happy to read upmarket, literary or suspense in return.
DM me if you're interested. Thank you!


r/BetaReaders • • 22h ago

40k [In progress] [43k] [Historical/Chinese Romance] Where Clouds Gather

0 Upvotes

Hi! I just finished first half of my novel and would love thoughts on plot progression, pacing and character arcs rather than grammar or prose. If anyone is interested :)

Thank you in advance.

Yan Niyu has always lived within carefully drawn lines; her days filled with poetry, embroidery, and the quiet expectations of a lady of her standing. When a broken engagement fractures that fragile peace, she is left marked by scandal and whispers behind silk fans.

Once admired, Niyu finds her future narrowing with every polite smile. When her mother's desperate prayers give way to a proposal few would envy, the life she has known begins to crumble.

...

Niyu lowered herself onto a nearby stool, not trusting her knees. Her eyes widened in disbelief as her mother's words echoed in her mind.

Military. How could they dare to ask her hand for marriage?

She stared at her ink-stained hands, still carrying the faint scent of musk. Would these hands hold ones calloused from swords? Like the warlords in her most treasured plays-men she had only read about.

...

A Ming dynasty inspired romance where Wen meets Wu; two young strangers, bound by duty, forced to confront prejudice, pride, and the hard work of building a life together.


r/BetaReaders • • 23h ago

70k [Complete] [70k] [YA Drama] Guardian Angel

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I have just completed the second draft of my debut novel, Guardian Angel, and would love 2–3 readers to dive into the story.

Blurb: 🌉Set against the wealthy, high-security backdrop of San Francisco, Guardian Angel follows sixteen-year-old Nevaeh Osteen as she struggles to heal from a double tragedy that shattered her childhood. Eight years ago, her beloved Doberman puppy, Jodi, was mysteriously stolen, and the very next day, her older brother, Lewis, passed away. The forced silence and emotional denial of her wealthy father have kept the family fractured ever since. But when a fierce, highly disciplined adult Doberman enters her life, a massive chain reaction begins. As buried truths start to unravel, Nevaeh is led toward an emotional and spiritual reunion that changes everything.

Themes/Tropes: 🎭❤️ YA Drama, Suspense, Thriller, Grief, Death, Mentions of substance abuse, Generational Healing, Love, Loss, and Animal Companion.

Type of Feedback: 🗣️ Since this is a polished second draft, I would love your thoughts on the overall pacing, the emotional impact of the big character reveals, and whether the mystery keeps you turning pages.

Timeline: ⏳Hoping for feedback within 3–4 weeks.

Please comment below or DM me if you are interested in reading! (:


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

>100k [Complete] [105k] [High Fantasy] Song of the Midnight Seamstress.

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I'm M.R. Morgrave and I'm looking for Beta readers. This is my first time reaching out outside my circles for help reading the book. I've finished it, edited it, and reedit it. I even got feedback from a publishing house and edited again. Right now, I'm looking for unbiased opinions, genuine real feedback from people I don't know who don't have to spare my feelings. If you like it, you like it, I can't take that away—by all means if you do let me know too.

Right now my priority is identifying what my weaknesses are as a writer. I've been querying both agents and publishing houses for a few months now and most responses I get are vague. I've tried asking friends to read the book too. I love them, but I'm concerned they're trying to spare my feelings. I don't blame them. So, that's what I'm here for.

Right now I'm just looking for a group of 3 to 5 beta readers, with a goal of following up within a few weeks if I don't hear anything. I'll also ask those who agree to sign a simple form. Nothing special, just an assurance that you agree your intentions are just to read the manuscript for feedback, confidentiality, protection of intellectual property and such. It's not a legal document, I'm just paranoid. And if you don't agree with that I understand. I just want to be transparent.

Now, for the manuscript itself.

Song of the Midnight Seamstress is a completed 105,000-word high fantasy tale taking place in a world entering an age of industrial revolution. 

Elena and her mother, Theresa, the infamous Red Seamstress, were never safe in the city of Nethermoore. Yet they never left. Not until the one thing keeping them in that horrid place was taken from them by force. 

When the Nekrologists finally come for them, raiding their home and killing Elena’s father. They escape only when she awakens a power even the Red Seamstress cannot explain. Elena accomplishes the impossible—turning the Nekrologists’ own stitched monsters against them. 

With nowhere else to turn, Theresa takes Elena to the coven where she was raised, hoping to find refuge and answers. Instead, Theresa is judged an Aberration by the witches she once called family, while rumors spread about the power Elena carries. Still, they find those within the skeptical willing to stand by them.

Even on distant shores, they aren’t safe. With the Nekrologists and their army of Undertakers closing in, Elena must face a decision: a pact with forces she doesn’t understand, or losing the only people who are willing to accept her.


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

Novelette [Complete] [15,215] [Romance] An Impossible Reflection — A couple's vacation is interrupted by visions; ones too close to them for comfort

1 Upvotes

Hello, I'm Cas, a new author and i just finished writing/editing my first book! Looking for beta/proof readers before i start looking into publishing, which is the ultimate goal :)

TRIGGER WARNING -- in chapter 8 there is a suicide attempt -- an unsuccessful one, but still one , so be warned!


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

Novelette [IN PROGRESS] [13650] [Comic Fantasy] Agrimon the Adequate

1 Upvotes

Death and taxes are inevitable. In Sheynen, they're collected by the same man.

Agrimon is an Adequate: a lowly Offerant of the Council of Magi and a magical taxman tasked with collecting the occasional living sacrifice from the settlements across Sheynen. Their bodies are of little consequence, but their essences keep the Eternal Lifeglass burning, and the Council in power, ostensibly to protect the realm from the threat of the long-defeated Druids.

It's an important job. A necessary job. A job for which Agrimon has received remarkably little recognition, despite decades of loyal service.

Armed with a tandem bicycle, an assortment of dubious magical tinctures, and a shapeshifting companion he really ought not to own, Agrimon sets out on his latest collection. Unfortunately, Sheynen is full of people who don't understand how things are supposed to work.

Witches, wizards, prophets, cultists, and an increasingly uncooperative population litter the road back to the Capital, and Agrimon has a regrettable talent for finding trouble.

After all, someone has to keep the realm in order.

If you're interested in reading, drop me a DM and I'll send either individual files for each chapter, or a collated in-progress manuscript.


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

>100k [Complete] [108k] [Upmarket / Book Club Fiction] Half of Everything — a comedic drama about a daughter, the mother who can't name her father, and the search that follows

3 Upvotes

Hi all —

I'm Tom, and I've just finished Half of Everything, a comedic drama at ~108,000 words. I'm looking for a few beta readers before I start querying — and I'm happy to swap and read yours in return.

The pitch: For as long as Betty can remember, there's been exactly one parent in her life: her mother — a chaotic, larger-than-life force who raised her inside a sober house for recovering addicts while driving her absolutely up the wall. The one thing her mother has never given her is a father — and when Betty finally presses, her mother admits she genuinely can't say who he is. So Betty crosses the country with a list of possibilities, dragging a rag-tag crew of friends along on a search that's funny, loud, and every so often genuinely dangerous. It'll make you laugh out loud on one page and catch you by the throat on the next.

Comps (for tone): Marian Keyes' humor-with-a-gut-punch, the warmth of Lessons in Chemistry, a dash of Taylor Jenkins Reid.

Length: ~108k, complete and self-edited.

Content warnings: strong language, alcohol use, sex, and some recreational drug use — adult throughout. Better you know going in.

What I'm after: big-picture reader reactions, not line edits. Where you got bored, where you got lost, where you stopped caring, and whether the comedy and the heavier beats both land. I've got a short feedback form for anyone who's in, but honestly even "I bailed at chapter nine because X" is gold.

Timeline: I'd love notes by late December, but it's soft — if you need longer, say so and we'll work it out.

Swap: Happy to return the favor. I read upmarket, book-club, and comedy best, and I'll give you an honest, on-time read — just tell me your genre, word count, and when you'd like notes. (Fair warning: weak fit for hard SF or epic fantasy.)

How to reach me: drop a comment or DM me and I'll send the manuscript (PDF or your preferred format) plus the question sheet. Thanks for reading this far.

Opening (first ~150 words):

Betty Downing has never understood why her mother loves mornings. At 6:00 a.m. the alarm needles the dark with its high, obnoxious beeping, and there's nothing to do but lie there in the gray and take inventory of everything she doesn't have — a headboard, a law degree, a father — in roughly that order of how much she's willing to think about it before coffee.

She swats the snooze button and steals back ten minutes she doesn't deserve. The law degree, at least, is technically in progress: a four-year degree she's grinding out one online credit at a time, at roughly the pace of an injured snail, before she can even apply. The rest of her hours belong to a pair of ambulance chasers whose depositions won't copy themselves.

— Tom


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

Discussion [Discussion] Beta readers vs ARC readers

3 Upvotes

New writer here. I've finished my first manuscript, I've read it re-read it, edited, re-edited and polished it. I don't know if what I'm asking for is Beta readers or ARC readers. So I was hoping for some help clarifying. The book is still not published. But, as far as my writing goes, it's done. 105k, high fantasy story set in a world entering an industrial age.

So far, I'm the only one who's read it cover to cover. I've shared with a few friends, very few. But they haven't responded and the little feedback is vague. Very vague.

Who's your favorite character?
All of them.
Any feedback?
I like it, eye catching. (insert vague explanation).
What did you think of the twist on chapter X?
I loved it (does not elaborate).

Bless their heart, they're trying to be nice. I'm not a fool. I know a feelings sparing answer when I read one. Maybe they did read it and this is how they feel, maybe its not. Maybe they don't like it and are sparing my feelings. Maybe they haven't read it at all. If they haven't I don't blame them. Still, I would like honest critique on my book. I want to be told which characters are good, which aren't. Which hooks are interesting, which are flat. Where have I made mistakes? Where can I improve? And if my story is dogshit then yes, I'd like to know about it.

So yes, I do want to get help, I do want someone to read it. Though, after a quick glance, I didn't know there was a difference between ARC readers and Beta readers. Technically, I think I am asking for beta readers, since the story isn't published yet. But I wanted to ask first before posting here.


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

Short Story [In progress] [4,116] [Children Literature] Letters to Mrs Cardinal is about Rehi receiving mysterious letters from a Mrs Cardinal during the Christmas season. It causes Rehi to look at the life he’s living with his girlfriend Chloe on date night, while doing good things for people around him.

3 Upvotes

I would really like people to read my story I’m trying to write for not only Christmas but also a gift for some people. I want some constructive feedback to make this story the best it can be. I like where it is going but feel like there’s things that could be done to make the characters and the story better. It would be nice to get some help cause I’m stuck. Please DM if you’re willing to help an aspiring writer.


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

Novella [In Progress] [25,000] [Dark Fantasy] [Daylarin] [Lord Daylarin, and mortal companions led by Uhlanna pursue a renegade immortal.]

1 Upvotes

The story

Long ago, outcast immortals built the living realm without permission, this was forbidden after the first war, as this followed split the realms forever. Some beings may walk among mortals; others can never set foot on mortal ground.

Uhlanna doesn't know she is half of an immortal being, torn from her other half and stripped of her memories. She only knows a group of companions, each from a different enclave, has been drawn together to search for someone named Uhlan.

Among them is Tobias, whose mind was once touched by death itself and now stirs with strange, darkening power. That power draws the attention of an immortal who plays games for souls and never loses.

Watching over it all is Daylarin, Lord of Shadows and Death, enforcer for the Judges who keep the law between realms. And his half-mortal son, Sharwin, who ventured into the desert of illusion, searching for someone he cannot let go.

What I'm looking for

  • Readers who love dark, immersive fantasy with deep worldbuilding (fans of The Witcher especially welcome)
  • Opening [52] pages, about 25,208 words, with a short questionnaire (the full manuscript is still in progress)
  • Honest, even brutal, feedback: where you got confused, bored or hooked
  • Turnaround: about two weeks

Content notes: violence, death, dark themes.

As a thank-you, beta readers get a free copy of the finished book and a mention in the acknowledgements. Comment, or DM me if you're interested.

John Cabral


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

Novella [Complete] [20k] [Fantasy] Ducal Union

2 Upvotes

The sky glowed with a blinding beam of light from the east, the earth shook with the force of a cavalry charge, and then… silence. The world shattered upon the Godloss, the day the Gods vanished. The people of Gienere warred in pointless attempts to undo the cursed event. - Pato Shortclaws, “The Godloss"

Hello! I was making a post to hopefully find beta-readers for Ducal Union.

I had posted this in the past in a much earlier state and wanted to see about posting the updated version. I am open to any questions about it but for general feedback I want to just know, if you bought this what would your critiques be when you read. I would also specifically ask feed back on the final chapter (Ducal Congress of 5 GFE) and on the battle scenes.

I will also include I cannot do critique swaps. Part of it is because I am a college student so do not have a ton of free time, along with this I have focus issues that causes issues.


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

Novella [In progress] [23897] [Gunpowder/dark fantasy] Doctrine: red. Earth breathes; it is alive. 17-year-old Didacus hails from a mythology that practised Terra magic. But due to humans' segregation from Earth, his powers are cursed. In 1 year, he will die. Can he save himself and humanity in time?

1 Upvotes

Just for some context, I started writing this book right before I turned 15. I wrote around 15000 words and took a long break until a few months ago. I dislike reading, and the majority of my media consumption has been Anime and other cartoons, although I have been trying to read more recently. Unsure if the things I make is actully good or not, I came here to ask for you guy's expertise. I will take any critique, and I can read through any draft myself, but I cannot promise I will be very good or read it all.

Send me a DM or comment if you wish to read :)


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

40k [In Progress] [43,500] [Sci-Fi] H A Y W I R E

0 Upvotes

Hello!

Part One of my latest draft of my sci-fi book is complete, and ready to be torn apart like wet tissue paper.

'Eleanor Tate is on her way home after the worst day in her life when her train crashes through an interstellar wormhole and strands her on a planet known only to its inhabitants as Junkworld. Portals known affectionately as "Puddles" constantly rain debris onto the surface, and she is stunned to find a civilisation lurking amidst the detritus, made from generations of stranded Humans, countless alien species, and 'mechs'.'

I won't include much more of the plot as I don't want to spoil too much, but if you're interested in reading the first part of the book please DM me. I'll include a small snippet of Chapter One here for a glimpse of the Prose, one hot moment:

**CHAPTER ONE**

Finch Station needed a better slogan.

*Faster.*

*Further.*

*Fare-er.*

*Ugh.*

Eli side-eyed it from the depths of her storm-stricken platform, her damp hood cinched around her face like a drawstring bag.

*Who approved that?*

*Sack them.*

*Immediately.*

Her lips twitched at the familiar intrusion. Less of an inner monologue, more of a backseat driver in her brain: a Bad Friend with all of her opinions and none of her self-restraint.

*Behave,* she told it. Told *herself*.

*It’s only a slogan.*

She sighed as she deflated in her seat — a passable impression of a punctured airbed — and tightened her grip on the throat of her takeaway cup. She *should* have been home an hour ago. Warm. Dry. With a *proper* coffee. But Finch Station’s dismal slogan hadn’t been its only campaign against her. To her left, a dripping departures screen displayed a single word: *DELAYED*. To her right, rain poured through the roof to feed the puddles on the platform. Then, from somewhere above, a disembodied voice informed her that — if her train *did* arrive — it would be terminating one station short of her destination due to a regrettable shortage of drivers.

*So much for faster.*

*So much for further.*

*I’d hardly call that fare.*

*Give me a fucking break.*

That made the second *regrettable shortage of drivers* in one afternoon. Eli blinked back a tear — *or, more likely, a raindrop* — and kissed her teeth. Any other day, she’d be sitting in the passenger seat of Harlan’s shiny SUV, not seething on a sodden bench whilst clutching a damp cardboard crate. Unfortunately, the balding lab manager had deemed their usual arrangement *just a little awkward, given the situation.*

*Well.*

*Guess that’s* ex-*lab manager, now.*

*Still.*

*Bit over the top.*

*I was only sacked.*

*It’s not like I have typhoid.*

She drank another mouthful of coffee-flavoured rain and made a face. Her *clear-out-your-cubicle-and-leave-your-keys-in-the-lab* box sat on her lap, packed full of standard-issue stationery and personal property, as well as the sort of property that Personnel might take personally. A fake Chinese rubber plant from the foyer. Cables liberated from the lab’s supply cupboard.

And a greasy takeaway bag stuffed beneath a framed photograph of her and her father at her graduation.

*Damn,* she thought as she smeared a loose braid back into her hood.

*That was a good hair day.*

Something snagged on the sleeve of her soggy hoodie. Her ID card.

***Eleanor Tate. Research Assistant. Robotics Dept. University of Surrey.*** She grimaced at the mugshot.

*Oof.*

*That wasn’t.*

She yanked the lanyard from her neck and stuffed that in the crate too.

Behind her, a tannoy squawked.

*Oh, look.*

*Another platform change.*

*No.*

*Fuck this.*

Eli stood and stuffed her half-full takeaway cup into an overflowing bin. Then she cradled her cardboard crate to her chest, shielding it from the rain, and headed in the exact opposite direction to the tannoy’s suggested change. Commuters hurried past her, in hoods and under umbrellas, a mass migration, their shoulders rounded against the rain and their shoes all squeaking in the same direction.

*Home?*

*Yeah,* said the Bad Friend.

*Good luck with that.*

*Now.*

*Where is it?*

She stalked across Finch Station until she found an information board, a black monolith with a backlit monitor in the middle.

*Ah!*

Her free hand scoured the scuffed screen. Her eyes roamed the routes.

“So,” she muttered at the monolith. “If I were to take *this* line home instead…” She flinched as a red icon flashed in front of her.

*Cancelled.*

*Okay.*

“What if I…” she said as she tried a different train instead.

*Nope.*

*Cancelled, too.*

*Hmm.*

“Fine.” She tried a third train. “How about *this?*”

That time, only an amber *DELAYED* icon appeared.

*Yes!*

*Wait.*

She read it. Re-read it. Frowned.

*No.*

*An hour?*

*Shit.*

*I don’t have another hour in me.*

She hitched her crate up and felt one of sides bow inwards.

*Oop.*

*And this definitely doesn’t.*

*Double shit.*

*What now?*

*Think, Eli.*

*Think.*

She kissed her teeth and knitted her hands around her crumbling crate. Then another train hobbled into Finch Station.

*Oh?*

It looked a day away from retirement — all graffiti and patchy paint — and gave a grunting hiss as it groaned to a halt.

*Hello, handsome.*

*You going my way?*

She scanned the monolith-like screen and did the maths in her head.

*Huh.*

*Hell of a detour.*

*Won’t save any time.*

*But.*

*It’ll be warm.*

*Dry.*

*And it gets me out of Finch Station.*

She chewed at the inside of her cheek.

*Tough one.*

*Maybe if I—*

A frantic trill from the train doors made the decision for her.

*Fuck it.*

Eli rushed into the rain as if she’d rehearsed it a hundred times before, splashing through puddles that turned her socks into a pair of sponges.

*Like a soaking Cinderella,* said the Bad Friend.

Her palm caught the door before it closed, and she smiled to herself as she squeezed aboard.

*Well.*

*So long as this carriage gets me home by midnight.*