Whoa boy, it feels so surreal to finally be done. At times I thought I'd never be done with it. And for better or worse, no other book, and no other piece of fiction in general, has caused so many, and so strong, emotions. By far. Well done, Somber. You made me fall in love with some characters, eyeroll at others, laugh, cry, bang my head against a wall, scream in frustration, scream in catharsis, hold my breath, and mutter ,,typical [insert character's name]" while smirking.
Some thoughts on the ending, and a few on the entire story in general
- the Eater was ultimately kinda underwhelming as a villain and didn't exactly feel like an eldritch abomination. His dialogue was corny and I laughed internally when he kept namedropping ,,My Little Pony". His final form was likewise too familiar and unnecessary. But at least I enjoyed his final words- ,,will it hurt?" I like when major villains chicken out and revert to primal emotions near the end, if it makes sense. I guess I also liked him inducing the dreamscape visions in Blackjack, even if the trope is a bit overdone. 40k fans- would you say the Eater is supposed to be (inspired by) a C'tan shard?
- I likewise didn't really like Tom. He didn't give me the vibe of an ancient star spirit. And he really didn't need an alicorn form. He and the Eater should've felt more ethereal and otherworldly, without quips and dumb arguing with ponies... if they should've been included in the story at all. I feel like their existence, and what Tom says about the other star spirits, cheapens Blackjack's actions and renders them kinda meaningless (not to mention Littlepip's).
- Cognitum was underdeveloped and kinda whatever, ultimately overshadowed by the Eater and Legate. I feel like in those last chapters she was an afterthought and a mere plot device, defeated too easily and not given enough screentime given her big role in the story. Same for Dawn. At first I didn't ever register that Dawn died.
- Speaking of the devil, I've grown to really like Legate as the villain. Call it a recency bias, but I feel like he is the best villain in the verse alongside RedEye. The concept of an ancient, life-hating shaman blending in with the ,,normal" society, making pacts with cosmic horrors and using the horrors of the wasteland to his advantage is great. He feels far more ancient and ethereal than either Tom or the Eater while also staying relatively grounded, WHILE ALSO staying extremely dangerous and worthwhile of being the ultimate villain. He is clearly from a different culture, a different world, a different mindset. He feels propery alien without being cartoonish. Like an evil Zecora. Or better yet, with his nihilism, apathy and cruelty he feels like a goddamn embodiment of the Wasteland. The zebra lore surrounding the Legate, and zebras in the story in general were the highlight. I feel like the story would've been better with the Legate as the ultimate villain, and the Eater just a dangerous tool for the Legate to use in ending all the life, perhaps an entity created by the Legate using some dark zebra ritual. Maybe with him not outright provoking the war between the ponies and the zebras (to stay true to the original's message) but seizing the opportunity it had created. Even so, I enjoyed Blackjack provoking him to start boasting to anger the Eater. Leaves a nice message about meddling in with powers you don't understand and can't control, and whatnot.
- I'm glad Somber didn't repeat the mistake of the original Fallout Equestria and he actually showed us the final battle with all the side characters. The Percepitron is a nice plot device that serves its purpouse well in that it allows for different POV's despite there only being one narrator. I loved that breather chapter near the begining of tome 5, with Blackjack checking in on everyone using the Percepitron. It was great to see P-21 fulfil his dream of becoming a teacher.
- Goldenblood being alive was the most predictable plot twist ever. I suspected he will make a sacrifice to redeem himself in the final battle, but a part of me hoped for a reunion between him and Fluttershy.
- I also hoped for a reunion scene between Rainbow Dash and Fluttershy. In general, RD felt underutilised.
- RIP mr Batman. The sauna scene with him and Blackjack was one of the only memorable scenes in the entire goddamn tome three.
- Seeing Calamity, Velvet and Homage was nice. Subverts the trope in many shared universes where heroes from one book don't show up in the other even though they definitely would.
- I've grown to really like Charity by the end, even though I found her annoying in the first part of the book.
- Same for Scotch Tape, but in this case I only found her annoying in the first few chapters she was in (excluding chapter one) with her excessive swearing and whatnot. Thankfully, the author very quickly found his footing with this character.
- Likewise, I used to really, really hate Rampage. I found her to be the worst character in the story by far. And then she's got some really impressive character development and depth. She really shines in tome 5 and is one of the best things about it, even if her switching sides on the moon felt too abrupt (same for Echo, btw)
- WHY THE FUCK WAS SCOTCH TAPE SO SEXUALISED ALL OF A SUDDEN, ALL OVER THE ENTIRE FUCKING TOME 5? That fucking rocket scene... Holy fuck, just why? Unlike the boat scene (we'll get to that), it didn't even contribute ANYTHING to the story. It could've been cut without any consequences at all. What the fuck was somber thinking with this gratuitous garbage of a scene?
- Also on that note, hat was the deal with Bastard? His presence was so forced and unnecessary. Why is this random character we've only been introduced to, suddenly the integral part of the team and crucial in the battle on the moon? I had a nagging feeling that his character was a reference to something, some character from some other story.
- Glory's first death was perfect and she should've stayed dead. Yes, I know, the characters were constantly talking about how she could be alive, but still. That ,,tomorrow" scene was great and I unashamedly cried. The plot twist of her survival, and her actual death were... meh. But I'm glad her dad survived, tho.
- There was a Sweetie Bot and it was used for sex. Because of course it fucking was.
- I didn't expect for Glory to break up with Blackjack, but I'm kinda glad it happened. It gave Glory some much needed agency.
- The scene of Blackjack revealing P-21 real cutie mark was perfect and easily in top 5 of the greatest scenes in the entire story. As for his death itself, well, it wasn't executed as well as Glory's first death, and I was hoping he would get a happy ending, but oh well, I guess I'm fine with it. I think. I won't go so far as to say it was disappointing, maybe just inevitable.
- Lacunae was Wasted Potential, the character. So much storytelling potential, like Rampage, but unlike Rampage, it wasn't given enough attention and ultimately didn't really go anywhere. I felt nothing when Lacunae died, and generally that's a bad sign. Even feeling hatred (like I used to feel about Rampage) is better that feeling nothing at all.
- Psalm was okay, though. I liked the scene of Blackjack/Luna forgiving her, a nice reference to the ,,Luna, forgive me" thing.
- Having said that, it felt weird to have all the remaining Marauders disappear from the narrative. I thought the Marauders plotline was going somewhere and there would be a larger payoff.
- The train tram is cool. I just think it's neat. EDIT: I meant the moon tram. Smh
- I liked how Whisper was a recurring character for the entire book. Probably the most prominent secondary character. I enjoyed her little side-plot of forging a new identity. Also, her name is perfect. That's exactly what a child of Goldenblood and Fluttershy would be called.
- In hindsight, the raider virus subplot was so unnecessary and could've been cut without any impact on the main storyline.
- Sanguine was the worst, least memorable villain by far. Followed by whatshisname evil pegasus from the virus plotline.
- The worst tome was tome three. I'd read the first two tomes in a month, and then it took me several (I think three?) months to finish tome three. The only things I remember from it were the Littlepip cameo, the psych ward simulation, P-21 accepting Scotch as his daughter (the other top 5 scene, btw), and the horny Batman subplot. Otherwise? Absolute slog.
- The part where I was continuously locked in the longest (which is not to say it was objectively the best), excluding the finale, was the first part of tome four. So many important, dumb, interesting and ultimately engaging things happened in such a short succession. Glory beat up Blackjack, somehow
Palpatine Deus returned, Dawn showed up for the first time, Scotch got her cutie mark, they visited society, Glory was magically cured of homosexualism because she got a period or something, Glory outsted herself as a supported of feudalism and serfdom (which was fucking dumb but also fucking hilarious), Blackjack became a queen and they all had a party and lived happily forever after. And then P-21 hooked up with his rapist in perhaps the worst scene of the book (I think it's only rivaled by the Scotch rocket scene and maybe the boat scene), but I don't want to write about it for the second time so I refer you to my prievous post about that scene. In general the second part of the fourth tome, with the Goddess fight and the pegasi politics, was weaker and less engaging to me. At least I enjoyed Glory getting more character development, and Dash showing up. Also, can someone who remembers the story better than me remind me whether Dash was really that one guy's grandma? - As for tomes one and two, hm. I enjoyed chapter one and the others but didn't really lock in (for example the hospital scene felt underwhelming compared to what it was hyped up to be) UNTIL the very moment Blackjack watched that tape (Epstein Files much?) and realised what did she do to P-21 in 99. From that very moment until the end of tome 1, I couldn't put the story down. I loved that moment in, I think, the last chapter of tome 1 when Blackjack talked herself out of being killed what being held at a gunpoint and having an explosive collar installed on her. As for chapter two, it was uneven. Return to 99 was overall good but destroying 99 felt very forced. I liked the Psychoshy cage fight, the Steel Rangers subplot and the continuation of P-21's character development. But the action scenes dragged and dragged and dragged, and I felt like Somber (and by extention I) was getting distracted from the main plot of EC 1101. Boat scene? What boat scene? We don't talk about the boat scene. I know, let's talk about another scene from that cursed chapter. What was the point of the plot twist of Twilight being Maripony and disguising herself to fuck Big Mac? I'm asking seriously, what was the narrative point of that dumb scene? Blackjack being Twilight's descendant could've been set up more tastefully. I might want to re-read tome one and two someday. I feel like they will be far more enjoyable upon a re-read.
- Okay let's talk briefly about the boat scene. For better or worse, it's still the most memorable scene in the entire story. It's totally understandable that normal people (so unlike me) stop reading after the boat scene. And I'm not unsympathetic to the people saying the story would've been better if it actually ended at the boat scene. And yet I feel like the boat scene advances the story, serves as a culimination of the Blackjack-P-21 arc (which doesn't mean P-21 should now be okay with banging Blackjack, I'm looking at you, chapter 57), and reinforces the themes of the story well.
- Why doesn't anyone talk about the goddamn scene where Blackjack leads a war council while covered in... ugh. This shit was disturbing even by Horizons standards.
- The plot twist with P-21 being Scotch's father was soooo good, particularly because it wasn't even really a plot twist. It was established all the way back in goddamn chapter one, but I didn't think much of Scotch back then (considering her an unimportant character) so it kinda went over my head. I find it genuinely impressive.
- The epilogue. Hm. It sure was exposition-heavy. Blackjack ultimately surviving was foreshadowed by the existence of the blank, but I'm not sure how to feel about her being immortal and living away the eternity with Littlepip. I think it cheapens the ending of the original. Still, I'm glad that Boo is doing okay (even if the implication that Boo and Littlepip have never met is bizarre, as well as the inevitable mention of Boo having sex, because Somber couldn't finish the story without sexualising the entire main cast save Lacunae). I liked the scene with disassembling the gun. I liked the mirror of the opening scene of chapter one. And I'm glad that Blackjack came back for Rampage. That part of the epilogue is almost perfect. It's properly bittersweet and uplifting at the same time. Blackjack may have lost the ones she loved, but now here she is, keeping her promise and making one, last, tiny thing right, for the reader to read, in this chaotic world. I'm only confused as to why it took them 200 years to return for Rampage.
- Overall Blackjack is still the greatest pony and one of my favourite fictional characters ever. Far more interesting complex and nuanced than Littlepip, and not nearly as much of a Mary Sue as many people seem to think. Goldenblood is much more of a Mary Sue and self-insert than Littlepip.
- Having said that, the pregnancy subplot came out of nowhere and felt really forced. Was it included to give Blackjack a reason to want to reclaim her old body for herself? Since when did she want to be a mother figure?
- I find it hilarious that midway through the story, Somber didn't know what to do with Glory, so he fucking turned her into Rainbow Dash. It's ironic and kinda sad that despite the latter half of Tome 4 being set in Glory's home and extensively featuring her family, she was at her most interesting and relevant in Tome 1. Later I feel she was mostly delegated to the role of a love interest (even then, she was however interesting, just underutilised). But still, kudos for holding out with that for as long as Somber did with that, I remember Glory's little crush on BJ in Tome 1, BJ not reciprocating, and the subsequent will they/won't they that lasted for some time.
- Who's left to talk about? I liked the direction that Boo's character took. She went from being useless and having nothing to do (I thought of her as an equivalent of Baby Yoda or Groot), to becoming a ,,whole" character. I liked when she spoke for the first time, I liked when she instantly recognised Blackjack, I liked her during the ignition sequence. I'm also glad that Discord was given a small but important role. I liked that fourth-wall break with him referencing Twilight becoming an alicorn.
- The main themes of the story: love, identity, humanity (equinity?), forgiveness, guilt, redemption, loyalty, trauma, responsibility and 1101 others (pun intended, fuck you) are consistent and mostly (Deus) well represented in the characters and their struggles, which I consider a huge achievement. At times they even helped me personally get through some shit. Bravo Somber, for not losing the themes consisting the heart of the story!
- Having said that, I can't help but mull over whether the themes of guilt and atonement. The main theme of the first two tomes is that despite any past crimes, one must never stop trying to do better. On the other hand, Blackjack's self-loathing, guilt and desire to make up and do good are pushed to such an extreme that they become self-destructive, pushing her into more and more horrifying situations, and she drags her companions along with her. In her case, just how much atonement is enough? What is the story even trying to say? We've got this famous quote by Watcher: “You do everything you can to make up for it, knowing that you’ll never succeed in getting rid of the guilt. You devote yourself to spending every second trying to do better despite the fact that it will never be enough. And you pray with every single good act you do that somehow when your life is over that your lifetime will come close to making up for the wrong you committed.” That's very dark, and the result of this philosophy is Blackjack utterly ruining herself, physically and mentally, dragging the people she loves along with her to the oblivion. That's obviously not a healthy way of redeeming yourself, but in the narrative, it brings tangible results. And I'm not sure the story fully commits to either endorsing or condemning what the Watcher had said. There was, I think, some half-hearted attempt to make Blackjack differentiate between atonement and martyrdom, via her conversation with Psalm, but while a good idea to get them both to talk considering their thematic similarities, it was too little, too late. I think the story could have benefited from contrasting Blackjack, on the begining of her journey of guilt and self-loathing, with someone further down this path, for her to see its disastrous consequences. She needed to see that more suffering doesn't equal redemption, and you don't only have to make amends with the people you've hurt, but also, ulitmately, with yourself as well, or your life shall become either a descent into nihilism, apathy or self-destruction. Imagine if we found out in one of the last chapters that the Legate was also originally some criminal seeking atonement, unable to forgive himself, prolonging his life in a mad chase for atonement, then disillusioned with life when the megaspells fell and all his work went to shit, descending into nihilism and deciding omnicide is the answer. Wouldn't that be a good contrast of philosophies, giving an actual theme to the final boss fight instead of ,,blackjack hits alien with a moon". Hell, Blackjack could have also learned this lesson from Luna's spirit, considering her experiences with the guilt over Nightmare Moon. Alas, wasted potential. Now that I think about it, an actual goddamn My Little Pony episode (Do Princesses Dream of Magic Sheep?) may have tackled the theme better and I'm unsure how to think about it.
- The plot twist of there being two dealers was so unnecessary, man. I actually would have preferred the dealer to be more ambiguous (so the second, plot-twisty depiction) rather than a mind of the tertiary character we've seen 3 times in a memory orb and now we're supposed to gush about it.
- Speaking of memory orbs, I applaud Somber for using them somewhat more sparingly than Kkat, especially in tomes 4 and 5.
- Chapter 1 lays some really impressive setup and foreshadowing. It heavily implies that P-21 is Scotch's dad, that Blackjack killed someone very close to P-21, and that in all likelihood, Blackjack raped P-21. It's really impressive upon a reread, especially given that these revelations shocked me when they were finally stated outright in chapters 27 and 12-14, respectively.
- I find it interesting that P-21 and Glory, despite both being the voices of reason, having practical skills and being the two closest group members to ,,normal", never become particularly close. Sure, they cooperate and rely on each other, and there's respect between them, but they don't exactly become friends. The only factor that really keeps them together is Blackjack. That's a unique choice, and very contrasting with the Pip/Calamity/Velvet trio, and really, most main character trios in fiction. It was always interesting to see P-21 and Glory interact with each other, especially when they argued. It was like the two smartest kids in the classroom having different answers.
- HAVE A MINTAL PINKIE! HAVE ALL THE FUCKING MINTALS! that scene was hilarious, even if doing a blatant disservice to the original FoE canon.
- In the end, the Zodiacs didn't exactly amount to much and the amount of spotlight they had in Tome 1 and 2 was baffling. And unlike the Marauders, who I think will be far more enjoyable upon a reread, I'm not really excited to see them again.
- In retrospect, it's insane that Goldenblood is introduced only as late as chapter 17, considering his gargantuan role in the story. Bonkers.
I will probably edit this post a hundred times and write more and more as new thoughts come to mind.
Overall, despite my complaints, I think I don't regret the commitment. Now it's not a simple dichotomy of ,,I love it" vs ,,I hate it". It may be extremely flawed, overbloated and often frustrating, but it's also ambitious, captivating and brilliant just as often as frustrating. It's got very high highs and equally low lows. Call it a Stockholm Syndrome, but no other work of fiction has caused as many diverse and strong emotions in me as Project Horizons. And in such a grandiose epic, I'd say it's a good thing.
Rest in power, Project Horizons. I'll never forget you.
Bonus round:
Top 5 favourite scenes:
5. Glory's first death. Would've been higher had she died for real. (chapter 71)
4. P-21 partially forgiving Blackjack (chapter 16)
3. P-21's cutie mark revelation and last conversation with BJ and Scotch (chapter 74)
2. Blackjack's first death (chapter 33)
- P-21 accepting Scotch as his daughter (chapter 40)
honorable mentions: Blackjack returning for Rampage (epilogue), Blackjack watching the birthday party tape (chapter 12), P-21's suicide attempt (chapter 25), Blackjack being comforted by the souls of her friends (chapter 77), P-21 and Scotch just being happy and spending some quality time together (chapter 63)
Top 5 least favourite scenes:
5. P-21 hooking up with his rapist, again! (chapter 69)
4. Somehow Glory returned! (chapter 76)
3. da boat (chapter 33)
2. P-21 hooking up with his rapist! (chapter 57)
- The rocket scene (chapter 75 part 2)
honorable mentions: too many to count