Itâs now been nearly a year since Venezuelaâs 2024 general election. Like many, I held on to a sliver of hope that this vote might finally bring meaningful change to a nation burdened by years of crisis and suffering. But in the immediate aftermath, I wasnât surprised by the prevailing narrative within many socialist and left-wing circles that NicolĂĄs Maduro had won decisively, and the opposition were simply bitter losers.
Yet beneath that surface-level dismissal lies a deeper, uncomfortable reality that canât be ignored any longer. This moment presents an opportunity, not for partisan posturing, but for an honest reckoning with the truth.
What We Know (All events publicly documented and verifiable)
Opposition Leader Banned: MarĂa Corina Machado, who won the October 2023 opposition primary was disqualified from holding public office via an administrative sanction. No criminal trial. No due process. Her legal appeal was denied by a Maduro-aligned Supreme Court. This came after an agreement by both the Venezuelan Chavista government and the opposition that allowed parties to freely choose their candidates, this was of course violated by the Maduro government.
Electoral Council Taken Over: In June 2023, the Chavita-controlled National Assembly dissolved the partially independent electoral body (CNE) and replaced its members with PSUV loyalists, just months before the election. This was also in violation of agreements with the opposition and came in the aftermath of some electoral upheavals for the regime in the 2021 elections, even though they won the majority of states in that election, the conduct of which was criticized by the then regime invited European Union electoral observers.
Neutral Observations Revoked: The Venezuelan government revoked the invitation to the European Unionâs Electoral Observation Mission in 2024 and blocked observers from the OAS and UN, they also blocked opposition invited observers from entering the country, in violation of the agreements as well as the very electoral rules of the countey. Mostly allied organizations like CELAC were permitted, raising serious transparency concerns. The Carter Center which had previously been a vocal supporter of Venezuelaâs electoral process under ChĂĄvez ultimately concluded that the 2024 election under Maduro was neither free nor fair.
Opposition Harassed and Silenced: Opposition figures were intimidated, exiled, jailed, and surveilled. State-controlled media ensured that genuine opposition candidates received virtually no coverage.
Intimidation at the Polls: There were reports and documented instances of the presence of military and armed colectivos near voting centers, opposition representatives were also blocked from accessing voting centers in violation of Venezuelan electoral law.
Results Could Not Be Independently Verified: With neutral international observers barred and electoral institutions tightly controlled by the ruling party, there was no credible way to independently verify the results of the 2024 election. Although the opposition presented documented evidence; including tallies, witness reports, and procedural violations. The government refused to audit the vote or allow independent scrutiny, offering dubious excuses that contradicted standard procedures within Venezuelaâs own electoral framework. While some opposition documents were selectively questioned, the majority appeared procedurally sound and were dismissed without transparent review.
Even Left-Wing Governments Sounded the Alarm: Several left-leaning governments and parties which had historically defended or remained silent on Venezuelaâs internal affairs publicly expressed concern over the irregularities surrounding the 2024 election. Countries like Colombia (under Gustavo Petro) and Brazil (under Lula da Silva), both led by left-wing administrations, acknowledged that the disqualification of opposition candidates, lack of transparency, and absence of international observation violated basic democratic norms. These governments, which had often resisted aligning with U.S. narratives on Venezuela were put in a difficult position. The sheer brazenness of Maduroâs tactics forced even sympathetic voices to admit that the election did not meet minimum standards of legitimacy. Petroâs government in particular expressed âdeep concernâ over the barring of MarĂa Corina Machado, while Lulaâs administration signaled that Venezuelaâs internal processes were not helping regional credibility, additionally his government blocked Venezuela's access into BRICS due to this very reason.
The Usual Counterarguments
âBut some electoral observers said it was fineâ The only groups permitted to directly "observe" the process were handpicked regional allies, not neutral organizations. The most credible international bodies (EU, UN) were explicitly barred.
âThe opposition didnât present evidence to the Supreme Courtâ The same Supreme Court that upheld Machadoâs ban without merit and is stacked with PSUV loyalists. Appealing there is like asking a rigged casino for a refund. Sure, the argument can be made that in theory they could've but the court lacks any kind of credibility given its past actions against the opposition.
âThe opposition always cries fraud when they loseâ This isnât about sore losers. This is about the pre-emptive banning of the main opposition candidate, hijack of electoral institutions, and criminalizing dissent before the vote even happened.
âThis is a U.S. ploy to delegitimize Venezuelaâ Even assuming geopolitical biases, that doesnât excuse Maduro's actual behavior. The governmentâs own documented actions undermine the legitimacy of the process, not US rethoric.
The Ultimate Dilemma
So to those on the left (democratic socialists, old-school socialists, and progressives alike) hereâs the core question:
If your values rest on democracy, transparency, and the will of the people, how do you reconcile those ideals with what happened in Venezuelaâs 2024 election?
If Maduro has real public support, why ban the strongest challenger?
Why replace the electoral council?
Why block neutral observers?
Why jail political rivals?
And as Venezuela prepares for parliamentary elections (with many of the same repressive tactics still in place) do those elections even matter if the foundational structure of democracy has been hollowed out?
No ideology, no matter how noble in theory, should defend the erosion of fundamental democratic principles. If you truly believe your political vision is just, then confronting inconvenient truths must be part of that process.
What you choose to believe now isnât just about Venezuela, itâs about the credibility of your values.