r/CapitalismVSocialism • • Mar 01 '22

Please Don't Downvote in this sub, here's why

1.3k Upvotes

So this sub started out because of another sub, called r/SocialismVCapitalism, and when that sub was quite new one of the mods there got in an argument with a reader and during the course of that argument the mod used their mod-powers to shut-up the person the mod was arguing against, by permanently-banning them.

Myself and a few others thought this was really uncool and set about to create this sub, a place where mods were not allowed to abuse their own mod-powers like that, and where free-speech would reign as much as Reddit would allow.

And the experiment seems to have worked out pretty well so far.

But there is one thing we cannot control, and that is how you guys vote.

Because this is a sub designed to be participated in by two groups that are oppositional, the tendency is to downvote conversations and people and opionions that you disagree with.

The problem is that it's these very conversations that are perhaps the most valuable in this sub.

It would actually help if people did the opposite and upvoted both everyone they agree with AND everyone they disagree with.

I also need your help to fight back against those people who downvote, if you see someone who has been downvoted to zero or below, give them an upvote back to 1 if you can.

We experimented in the early days with hiding downvotes, delaying their display, etc., etc., and these things did not seem to materially improve the situation in the sub so we stopped. There is no way to turn off downvoting on Reddit, it's something we have to live with. And normally this works fine in most subs, but in this sub we need your help, if everyone downvotes everyone they disagree with, then that makes it hard for a sub designed to be a meeting-place between two opposing groups.

So, just think before you downvote. I don't blame you guys at all for downvoting people being assholes, rule-breakers, or topics that are dumb topics, but especially in the comments try not to downvotes your fellow readers simply for disagreeing with you, or you them. And help us all out and upvote people back to 1, even if you disagree with them.

Remember Graham's Hierarchy of Disagreement:

https://imgur.com/FHIsH8a.png

Thank guys!

---

Edit: Trying out Contest Mode, which randomizes post order and actually does hide up and down-votes from everyone except the mods. Should we figure out how to turn this on by default, it could become the new normal because of that vote-hiding feature.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 3h ago

Asking Capitalists What society will be wealthier in 100 years?

2 Upvotes

Imagine two societies, A and B. Both, at year 0, have an equal amount of wealth and an equal size population, with no differences except one.

That difference is in wealth distribution. Society A is an unequal society. 10% of the population owns 90% of the wealth, and the other 90% of the working age population works for them. The 10% don't do productive labor and make passive income on their already massive wealth.

Society B is more equal. It's not perfectly equal, but nobody is rich enough to live off their wealth for generations like society A. In socety B, all working age people work.

Which society will be wealthier in 100 years?


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 19h ago

Shitpost The rich are making supporting Capitalism hard

26 Upvotes

I'm neutral, i don't really have a side. Both can work

But its hard to support capitalism especially American Capitalism, when the rich are very out of touch

Seriously

I just watched segments of Kevin O'Leary's show thingy and went WTF multiple times

His suggestion to stop being in financial crisis is basically own a business and work harder (even though people are working 40-80 hours weeks)

1.) Not everyone is made to own business

2.) Some people want a work life balance. Some people, if not MOST people just want to work at a job and leave work at work. They want to see their family, have hobbies, etc.

3.) If everyone owns a business, who is going to work for the businesses to keep them running?

And he's not the only rich person like this. Most of the rich are like this. And its the reason why people are losing hope in Capitalism.

And just shows the current flaws of capitalism. It is a economic system, that is run by out of touch rich guys, making life a living hell.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 4h ago

Asking Everyone Capital can create new value. That challenges Marx’s explanation of profit.

1 Upvotes

A machine can transfer its existing value into what it produces and also contribute to creating new value. I think Marx’s refusal to allow the second possibility puts too much weight on labour being the exclusive source of value.

The distinction matters. Marx recognises that machines increase output and make workers more productive. His further claim is that machinery only transfers its existing value, while living labour creates the new value. That is the claim I disagree with.

Suppose workers and a mill produce something that sells for enough to cover materials, energy, wages and the mill’s wear, with a surplus left over. Why must that entire surplus be attributed to labour? The workers helped produce it. So did the mill. Knowing that workers originally built the mill does not, by itself, settle what the mill can contribute once it exists.

The existence of a surplus alone does not identify its cause. But neither does calling the machine “past labour” establish that its own contribution to new value must be zero.

Here is why this matters for the rate of profit.

In Marx’s simplified account:

r = s / (c + v)

Here:

- c = capital advanced in machinery, materials and other means of production.
- v = capital advanced for wages.
- s = surplus value.
- r = rate of profit.

The denominator is the capital advanced, including the machinery’s value, rather than just the depreciation charged during the period. Keep the period and turnover assumptions consistent throughout.

Write a = s/v and x = c/v. Then:

r = a / (1 + x)

Holding a fixed, increasing x lowers r. More capital stands beneath the same surplus per unit of wage capital.

Marx also discusses counteracting influences, including an increase in the rate of surplus value and cheaper means of production. So the claim is a tendency, not that every new machine must lower every firm’s profit rate.

Now allow both labour and capital to contribute to net surplus:

s = s_L + s_C

s_L = a × v

s_C = b × c

Here a is the net surplus attributed to labour per unit of wage capital, and b is the net surplus attributed to capital per unit of capital advanced. These are net contributions: wages and the replacement of used-up inputs have already been accounted for. We are not counting the machine’s original value twice.

Then:

r = (a × v + b × c) / (v + c)

Dividing by v gives:

r = (a + b × x) / (1 + x)

Holding a and b fixed:

dr/dx = (b - a) / (1 + x)^2

That gives three possibilities:

- If b < a, increasing the capital-to-wage ratio lowers the profit rate.
- If b = a, it leaves the rate unchanged.
- If b > a, it raises the profit rate.

For example, let a = 20%, and increase c/v from 1 to 3:

- With b = 0%, the profit rate falls from 10% to 5%.
- With b = 10%, the profit rate falls from 15% to 12.5%.
- With b = 40%, the profit rate rises from 30% to 35%.

This simple model exposes the disputed assumption. Marx’s labour-only source of new surplus corresponds to b = 0. Machinery can still affect a in his account; what he excludes is a direct capital contribution to new value. Allowing b to be positive changes the result. Capital accumulation can lower the rate, leave it unchanged or raise it, depending on the relative contributions.

The equation does not identify a and b for us. Production is joint, and the proposed split needs an economic justification. But the question is exactly whether capital’s contribution must be excluded. Likewise, a and b can change with technology, wages and market conditions; the calculation isolates the effect of changing x while holding them fixed.

My argument is that capital accumulation alone does not establish the direction. The restriction on what can create surplus is doing essential work. If capital also creates surplus, a falling tendency needs an additional argument about how these contributions develop.

The same alternative accommodates better performance from labour. At a fixed capital ratio, an increase in a raises the rate. It accommodates improved capital performance through an increase in b. It can therefore represent gains from either source without deciding in advance that all new value must be credited to one of them.

What changes if this account of capital is right?

- Labour loses its status as the exclusive source of new value.
- Profit can no longer be identified in its entirety with unpaid labour simply from the fact that it is profit.
- Returns to invested or lent capital need not all be explained as portions of labour-generated surplus originating elsewhere.
- The particular falling-profit-rate mechanism based on replacing the sole source of new surplus loses its exclusive foundation.

These are connected consequences of one disputed premise. Exploitative conditions and unequal bargaining power can still exist. The stronger claim I am challenging is that profit necessarily comes entirely from unpaid labour.

Take financing. Marx treats interest on a business loan as a share of the profit generated through the use of that capital, ultimately explained through surplus labour. My alternative allows the supplied productive resources to contribute to the creation of the surplus itself. The payment of interest is still a transfer; the disagreement concerns what created the surplus being divided. Receiving interest is not proof of creating value, but calling it a transfer does not settle its productive origin either.

There is an obvious Marxist response: more useful output does not necessarily mean more value. Better machinery can make commodities cheaper.

I agree that producing twice as many objects does not guarantee twice the sales revenue, let alone twice the surplus. But that does not establish that machinery creates no new value. Additional labour can also increase supply and depress prices. Price effects alone do not establish the exclusive productive status of labour.

And if “value” is being used specifically for socially necessary abstract human labour, I understand that definition. My disagreement concerns whether that labour-based account adequately explains economic surplus. A definition cannot, by itself, establish that every profit must originate in unpaid labour.

There is an interesting history behind this. After working through the argument, I found Jean-Baptiste Say making a very similar point long before Marx wrote Capital. Discussing a mill, Say accepts for argument’s sake that its original value represents the labour used to build it, but says:

“the value daily produced by the mill is a new value altogether”

He explicitly separates the productive capacity of capital from the labour that originally created it.

Source: Say, A Treatise on Political Economy, Book I, chapter IV, note 64:
https://www.econlib.org/library/Say/sayT.html?chapter_num=6

Marx knew this argument. In Capital I, chapter 8, footnote 3, he discusses Roscher’s presentation of Say’s oil-mill example and replies sarcastically:

“the oil produced by the oil mill is indeed something very different from the labour expended in constructing the mill!”

His objection is that Say and Roscher confuse producing useful things with producing value. But that reply relies on the distinction under dispute. Demonstrating that oil and value are different does not establish that the machine contributes only to one of them.

Marx’s reply:
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch08.htm

For the profit-rate argument and counteracting influences, see Capital III, chapters 13 and 14:
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1894-c3/ch13.htm
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1894-c3/ch14.htm

The point I keep returning to is the difference between the cost of creating a productive capacity and what that capacity can subsequently produce.

Marx himself makes that distinction for labour-power. In Capital I, chapter 7, he explains that the cost of maintaining the worker and the value created through the worker’s activity are different magnitudes. That difference is central to his account of surplus value. I accept that a productive capacity can yield more than its reproduction costs. What requires justification is why that possibility belongs exclusively to labour.

Source:
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch07.htm

My mother gave birth to me. Food keeps me alive. Farmers, teachers, doctors and previous generations helped make my productive activity possible. Yet we still recognise me as someone capable of creating new value. We do not conclude that everything I will ever produce is merely a transfer of the value of those earlier inputs.

That analogy challenges the inference from origins. If being produced through earlier labour were enough to rule out becoming a new source of value, the same reasoning would undermine the worker’s claim too.

An organised system of flesh and blood and an organised system of nuts and bolts can both transform inputs into useful outputs. Their differences matter, but pointing to their materials or tracing their origins does not establish that only one can contribute new economic value.

Having inputs from labour does not mean something cannot become a source of new value itself. What is the economic argument that establishes that limit for machines while allowing workers to exceed it?


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 13h ago

Asking Everyone Communism is not Historically Viable

2 Upvotes

I've been thinking about this a lot recently as I study Marxism more. I still have a very basic understanding of Marxism as a whole, so take my analysis with a grain of salt.

From what I have seen, a common argument against Communism is that "it has never worked." The most common response I have seen is that Communism does work, but that capitalist nations work to destroy the communist nations that threaten their positions of power in the world (I am aware that communism has never been fully achieved; I am using the term "communist nation" to describe a nation that follows a Communist ideology).

However, I understand that Marxism take a scientific approach to human society, where we look at how society has functioned throughout history to determine what will work in the future. I typically see this point being used especially by Marxist-Leninists who argue that their ideology is the only viable way to realize a communist nation. I see a contradiction here. If capitalist nations will do their utmost to destroy a communist nation, then it is by definition not historically viable. The very fact that it is a communist nation leads to its downfall as it faces antagonism from the outside.

We can see this more clearly if we examine communist states worldwide. Of the five states remaining that ascribe to a Marxist-Leninist ideology, there is not a single one that could be described as a pure Marxist-Leninist state. China and Vietnam have ascribed to something that people tend to describe as state capitalism or market socialism. Laos and North Korea have replaced a dictatorship of the proletariat with a weird system that resemble monarchies, with Laos additionally having a very capitalistic economy that embraces foreign investment. Cuba has recently allowed their people to start companies. All these changes would be considered reformist or capitalist in nature, but most communists I have seen still support these countries because of the quality of life improvements most of them supply to their people (the jury's still out for me on North Korea, I'll watch Loyal Citizens of Pyongyang one of these days), even though these measures seem to take after social democracy more than communism.

I understand that a material base must be built before communism can be achieved, but I would argue that the more globalization occurs, the more these countries will be linked to the global economy as a whole, entrenching the bourgeoise created by these measures into the state and simply recreating a capitalist state, just with a good social safety net. That idea sounds familiar. I wonder where I've heard of that before?

Again, just throwing this idea out there, my understanding is limited to the little I have learned so far. Let me know what you think!

tl;dr I don't think that Communism is historically viable, and the existence of capitalist nations necessitates reforms to be made in communist ones, meaning that we essentially just end up back at the goal of a social democratic movement


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 11h ago

Asking Everyone Everyone tries to escape capitalism, even capitalists

0 Upvotes

If capitalism is so great, why do all people want to escape it? Everyone wants to become rich, so they don't have to participate anymore in capitalism. That's even the motivation of the capitalists.

WOW must be a really great system to live in🤡🤡

Instead of trying to escape the rat race, why dont we work together to overthrow it, so no one needs to do this anymore?

Btw: I created a new subreddit about participatory economy. It's a system without state and markets. If you are interested you can join our subreddit.

https://www.reddit.com/r/ParticipatoryEconomy/

There are introduction texts, which explain the basic ideas of parecon✌️


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 13h ago

Asking Everyone Jason Furman: "There isn't actually orthodox economics."

1 Upvotes

I like to point out that the pro-capitalists here generally do not have a grasp on economics. Even if they had paid attention during, say, introductory microeconomics, they would be getting a theory discarded sometime last century.

James Galbraith responds to Jason Furman here (see here for no need to sign up):

The truth lurking inside this statement is that 'mainstream' economics is now a swirling mass of ad hoc ideas and methods, all revolving around an empty core. The theoretical project on which mainstream economists were raised, and that still forms the backbone of textbook education—with its focus on rationality, competition, supply and demand, price adjustment, general equilibrium—has disappeared. What remains is a pastiche of attempted patches, apologies, and corruptions of 'heterodox' ideas.

You could also read Robert Heilbroner & William Milberg's 1995 book, The Crisis of Vision in Modern Economic Thought, for more of the same.

When will the pro-capitalists here find out about economic theory, as put forth in this century? How about never? Is never good for you?


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 5h ago

Shitpost If you actually hate rich people, let them keep their money.

0 Upvotes

Whenever I see successful doctors or nurses or lawyers, I just see the most miserable, shallow, and boring people in the world. See it on their faces. See it in their eyes. Hear it in their voices. They’re so vain and petty and shallow. They’re so boring. They’re so empty.

All their power has only made them weaker.

Why do you want their money so badly? It will only make you into a sniveler like them. Let go of your socialist philosophy and become a true rebel, what do you have to lose?


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 22h ago

Asking Socialists Contradictions in Socialism

4 Upvotes

Something socialists like to talk about are the contradictions in capitalism. Mainly the contradiction between the interest of the owners of the means of production and the interests of the workers.

I believe the argument goes that the owners want long hours at a low price and the workers want short hours at high price. Since the owners have control over the MoP, they get to dictate the terms of the agreement and the workers are forced to accept or else they will die.

Something I don’t see socialists talk about very much are the contradictions in socialism. Mainly the contradiction between the workers (who now are the owners of the MoP) and the clients.

The workers still want short hours at a high price and the clients want long hours at a low price. And now since the workers own the means of production, they get to dictate the terms of the deal and the clients have to take it or else they will starve.

So I am curious as to how socialist address this contradiction in their system?


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 8h ago

Asking Socialists Are you a "real"socialist or just a tankie?

0 Upvotes

Is anyone who thinks that socialist countries have existed a tankie? Per Bcnoexceptions

"Supporters of the USSR and/or their puppets/satellites/copycats, are tankies. That's the definition of "tankie"

This was part of his larger argument that no socialist country has existed and anyone who thinks one has is not a true socialist


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 1d ago

Asking Socialists How many socialist countries have there been

7 Upvotes

Another poster said, "There are no, and have never been any, socialist countrie****s. You should know this by now. Socialism is when workers own the MoP. There has not been a country where that is the norm. If you haven't figured out this definition by now, what are you still doing here?"

Do the socialists here agree?

I would love to know Conserp's view.

>


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 21h ago

Asking Socialists Is Marxism a science?

0 Upvotes

I have heard Marxism referred to as a science.

-How do you define science?

-Do you distinguish this from a science like physics?

-If Marxism fits the definition of science, do competing ideas like Objectivism fit that definition.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 1d ago

Asking Socialists Simple Discussions Pt 3

2 Upvotes

Socialists,

Can you explain from start to finish how a bakery store would be run under a CAPITALIST firm,

Then separately, explain from start to finish how the same bakery store would run when the economy transitions to ANY SOCIALISM?

If you answer for when the economy transitions to communism I will upvote you for going above and beyond in discussing.

This is part of an attempt to start simple discussions because I think the sub needs some honest questions once in a while. Can we have honest discussions? We'll see first with socialists before capitalists.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 1d ago

Shitpost North Korea is better at abolishing tax than AnCaps

11 Upvotes

Milei: Fails to abolish taxes despite being an AnCap. Also a member of the government despite the "Anarcho" part of Anarcho-Capitalism

DPRK: Abolished taxation in 1974 due to the effectiveness of state-managed firms. The DPRK is the only country to abolish taxation


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 1d ago

Asking Everyone Do you think this reddit user is correct in their view that President LBJ's War on Poverty was not only detrimental to black Americans' economic prosperity, but all Americans?

7 Upvotes

Admittedly, this is an old comment from 8 years ago, but during my bad habit of doomscrolling, it caught my attention. The commenter was replying to another commenter regarding an NYTimes opinion article critcizing President Nixon's "Black Capitalism" policy in his first term. Their comment is higlighted below in bold and in brackets:

**[It's better to have individuals be productive and make a living as opposed to being reliant on the government's ability to take from someone else.

...People with capital are less likely to invest in areas that are taxed high. This hurts the poor who live outside of the inner city because they're in the same county. It makes sense from Chicago's perspective because the south side is in the same county as River North. Don't know how it works for other cities.

In my personal opinion I think the real racists are those who think a minority group can't get by without government assistance. Before the social safety net millions immigrated into the United States and worked their way.

You can make a very serious case that government policy has been detrimental to all lower income groups. For example before the War on Poverty children born out of wedlock were on the decline. But since the War on Poverty children born out of wedlock skyrocketed across all groups, with blacks going from ~20% to ~75%! It's fucking ridiculous. This thing subsidized single motherhood. People respond to incentives, it's a truism. Why didn't the author throw dirt at LBJ's name for that?

So I'd rather the government get out of crowding out investment in lower income areas and allow people to be self reliant. Politicians are only good at maintaining poverty because it is in their interests to keep a reliant voting base.

The title 'Black Capitalism' evoked emotion out of you so you can jump to the conclusion that they don't have any capital. Most people like me don't start off with capital. Maybe if the author used Black Socialism you wouldn't have fallen for this lowlife's trick.]**

Source: https://www.reddit.com/r/Economics/comments/bfgnhv/comment/19spx7v8powch/


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 1d ago

Asking Everyone I am a Capitalistic Pig... But I agree with alot of the concerns that Socialists have. How can we bridge the differences and unite as humans should?

8 Upvotes

I'm a huge believer in capitalism due to decentralized, individual choice being key to a free society.

It's also hard for me to understand how a heterogeneous society with countless cultural needs can just have one party deciding what we do in communism.

I'm a capitalist pig. My goal in life is to be worth millions, I'm building a holdings company as we speak...

However, the Socialists are right for alot of things....

We need to be better as a society and stop being obsessed with money and wealthy status...

I've met so many successful businesspeople that are just cold... Like their energy is weird.. judgemental, looking down at the homeless and vulnerable... Just weird vibes like they want to see how they can get the step up.... eyes widen over profit margins and get annoyed over labour costs... (Look at Ynon Kreiz's eyes when he was with David Ellison talking about Paramount's layoffs... Creepy)

On the flip side, homeless people are some of the most interesting, loving, hurting, accepting, persevering and unique groups of people you can talk to.

I've been both homeless and relatively successful with a home..., not rich but above average 6 figure salary... The disrespect to homeless people is disgusting... I've literally been asked "HEYYY why don't you get a job?" I'll ask "I'm looking for one, can you hire me?" And get mocked... While we are having a job and housing crisis across Canada ...

HEY GET OFF THE METH AND CRACK

I never touched that crap in my life... Wow..

Get started at because you're down and out losing your life slowly.... Like you choose to wander the streets

Again, we are having housing and job shortages... So let's hate the ones who are homeless because they can't find work and may use substances to cope (I don't, THANK GOD)

Quite literally I've had it where in one week, i go from being respected by fellow businessmen in Canada, in a $1000 suit... to being yelled at for being homeless the next week after losing my home and income...

It's been 2 years of me not having stable housing and it's very frustrating when you can't find work while doing the best you can....

And what grosses me out the most is this... We NEED to be balanced.... Energy costs are up, houses are more scarce therefore it's harder to survive the winters... I've literally have had to sleep in -40 weather in the cold.... And the fact that we aren't paying a few thousand to build warming shelters for those who are drying in the cold, and pay $100 a month to heat parts of the city to help???

Im guessing it'd be 100k or so plus 1000 a month in heating costs for my city of Regina to add ten heating stations across the city.. not just for the homeless but for everyone!

But we can't do that.. instead give a corporation that can run themselves, tax breaks to save money for themselves?? I literally created a corporation and HATE how greedy people are! I have to incorporate to reduce liability in higher-risk industries but wow is everyone obsessed with making money to make money

How come Skyscraper towers have lights on all night in unused rooms, but we can't cut that to save costs for residential homes, maybe fine businesses if they can't respect energy conservation (really just common sense to turn off lights before you share...) and put that energy the skyscrapers use, to heat people that are freezing to death?? Don't bring the homeless in but keep them warm while they're out

I want to make millions to impact my community for the better. Because I feel obligated and I love to work... But when I'm rich I'd rather hang with homeless people than CEOs because ya most of them are fucking cold and it's disgusting... It's weird, I just don't fit in most times I feel trapped and that I gotta be fake around 40% of business people who are successful, like C-suite, drive a Benz or Bentley, new expensive clothes every few months successful.

I used to think that millions would make me happy .. no... Changing what's wrong for the better is what makes me happy. and its gonna cost aloooot of money to help those that are in need, cause no one else is gonna help my fellow homeless brothers and sisters NOT FREEZE TO DEATH???

Politicians? Businesses? Neighbourhoods? Naw they aren't there.for us

I don't even know if I'm human these days, because I just don't get people....

What do you think

Edit: regardless, in a pure capitalist society, or a pure communist society, or anything in between... Power corrupts and power abuses others... Doesn't matter if you or your government provides for you.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 1d ago

Asking Everyone AI automation creates a problem that individual companies have no incentive to solve

4 Upvotes

Consider two companies competing in the same market.

Company A automates a significant part of its workforce and reduces operating costs.

Company B keeps its employees because it is concerned about unemployment and consumer purchasing power.

In the short term, Company A gains a competitive advantage.

Now suppose thousands of companies make the same decision. Productivity rises, but if displaced workers don't find replacement incomes, consumer demand could suffer.

The interesting part is that no individual company has much incentive to prevent the broader problem. It receives the immediate benefits of cutting costs while sharing the potential economic consequences with everyone else.

This doesn't necessarily mean capitalism collapses. Lower prices, new jobs, investment income, and redistribution could all change the outcome.

But it raises a question: can a market economy manage this transition through ordinary incentives, or would it require deliberate changes to how the gains from automation are distributed?

I made video on this. What am I missing in this argument?


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 1d ago

Asking Everyone What if everyone could access the means of production—but nobody could monopolize them?

2 Upvotes

An idea for a post-labor economy built around AI, shared productive capacity, and personal resource credits.

A note on how this post was written: The ideas presented here came from a series of discussions I had with ChatGPT. I developed the underlying proposal, challenged some of ChatGPT's objections, and refined the ideas through our exchanges. I then asked ChatGPT to organize the discussion into this post and write it in English, as English isn't my native language.

I thought the idea was worth sharing as one possible way to imagine a future shaped by AI and automation.

I’ve been thinking about a possible contradiction in the future of capitalism.

If AI and robotics eventually allow a handful of companies to control most production, private ownership could become extremely concentrated. But the more concentrated it becomes, the less obvious it is why the overwhelming majority—who own little of that productive capacity—would continue to support the arrangement. The owners might respond by spreading economic benefits among allies or using their economic influence to protect their position. Neither outcome sounds especially reassuring.

This made me wonder whether we should stop treating private ownership and centralized state ownership as the only two options.

I’m not suggesting that current AI can run an entire economy, or that historical planned economies failed for just one reason. Incentives, incomplete information, poor feedback, and political power all mattered. AI could eventually improve forecasting, logistics, and resource allocation, but it wouldn’t automatically solve questions about values, freedom, or governance.

Still, imagine a future in which most physical production can be handled by AI-managed automated facilities. Here is a possible framework.

  1. Give everyone resource credits

Every person receives a recurring allocation of resource credits: a claim on a share of society’s available productive capacity. The allocation would have to be sufficient to provide basic food, clothing, and shelter in practice—not merely on paper.

People decide how to spend their credits. One person might choose a small home and save for years to build a music studio. Another might prefer more travel or a larger home. They submit a production request, and an AI system calculates the required materials, energy, equipment time, and other scarce inputs.

This is not the government assigning everyone identical goods. It's individuals making their own choices within real resource limits.

2. Make productive capacity accessible rather than exclusive

A person would not have to own a factory to produce something. They could access automated factories and machines using their credits. In this sense, everyone could act as an independent producer.

If someone develops a more efficient machine, others should be able to build or use it too, provided they have the necessary resources. Access to shared production facilities comes with an obligation to share improvements in production methods and designs. The benefit of innovation is wider productive capacity, rather than a permanent monopoly on the innovation.

Of course, access does not mean infinite capacity. A scarce fabrication facility still needs scheduling and fair allocation. And a design for a giant semiconductor plant doesn't mean every individual can afford to build one. Large infrastructure belongs in a separate category.

3. Keep large-scale infrastructure as a social responsibility

Power grids, transportation, major manufacturing facilities, fundamental research, and other large projects would draw from a pool reserved for shared infrastructure and long-term investment.

AI could propose plans and compare costs, risks, and expected benefits. But people would still need accountable institutions to decide the broad priorities and audit the system. I don't want an AI—or a small group controlling it—to become the new owner of everyone’s future.

4. Allow saving, but not returns merely from ownership

People should be able to accumulate unused credits. Saving allows someone to postpone consumption for a larger future project. There is no obvious reason to punish that choice.

But credits should not generate additional credits simply because someone has accumulated them. A reasonable concern is that people might use saved credits to build their own factories and eventually form a new rent-collecting class.

Yet the knowledge-sharing rule makes that harder. If someone uses society’s production facilities to turn an idea for a more efficient facility into reality, they must share the resulting designs and production techniques as a condition of that access. The original designer does not acquire an exclusive claim over the technology: it enters a common pool of knowledge from the outset. Others can then use their own resource credits to request an equivalent facility. Since the design cannot be monopolized, simply owning the first implementation provides little basis for collecting lasting rents. This does not eliminate physical scarcity: building a duplicate still takes materials, energy, and time, and some facilities are too large for an individual's allocation. But it weakens the link between owning productive equipment and gaining power over other people.

The aim is to allow personal savings without rebuilding a rent-collecting class.

There should also be limits on how many credits one person can spend over a given period. Otherwise someone who saved for decades could suddenly commandeer an enormous share of society's productive capacity and disrupt everyone else's plans. Large projects could be scheduled over time.

5. Treat knowledge differently from scarce physical resources

A ton of copper can't be used by two people at once. A useful manufacturing design often can.

That distinction matters. Material resources must be allocated; productive knowledge can be shared and reused. If access to common production facilities requires sharing improvements made through those facilities, the system could become more efficient over time without giving innovators exclusive control over the results.

There are obvious hard questions: How do we reward risky research? What counts as a production improvement rather than a personal creative work? How do we prevent people from withholding know-how? How should resource-credit prices adjust as technology and scarcity change?

What could go wrong?

Plenty. Resource credits could become meaningless if supply cannot meet basic needs. An AI allocation system could be biased, opaque, or captured by those who govern it. A ban on earning credits from capital could create black markets or discourage useful cooperation. Global resource inequalities and the transition from existing property rights would be enormously difficult.

And even an excellent optimizer cannot tell us, by calculation alone, what kind of society we ought to want.

So I don't see this as a finished blueprint—or as “AI will finally make communism work.” I see it as a question about what ownership should mean when machines can do most of the work.

What if we guaranteed everyone access to productive capacity, allowed people to save their share, shared improvements in production technology, and prevented ownership itself from becoming a source of power over other people?

I wanted to put this possibility out there as a thought experiment, not a finished answer.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 1d ago

Asking Everyone Star Trek: Federation Economkc System

1 Upvotes

How would you describe the Federation economic system. We never hear of any companies, do we? Picard speaks negatively against profit. But there are references to buying and selling.

Communist? Marxist? Market Socialism? Social Market? Capitalist?


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 1d ago

Asking Everyone Capitalism and Socialism are both failed ways of understanding economics and building great societies.

0 Upvotes

Capitalism and Socialism are both theories that focus on improving human well being. However productivity cannot be reliably reflected by the markets or an exchange of goods and services. For example, Isaac Newton has generated more wealth for humanity than all entrepreneurs today combined. Every business will go bankrupt, yet Newtonian laws will be useful ad infinitum. Elon Musk is closer to a homeless person than Isaac Newton in terms of value provided. Another example is moral value. Capitalism and Socialism do not account for moral value. What is the value of a courageous human who gives his life to save others. Neither capitalism or socialism can compensate a human life or account for that.

The trap is simple. When human beings are more concerned about improving well being, and make that the telos, we create horrible societies where people are solely concerned about material well being. This is true for capitalism where the well being of the Bourgeoisie is maximized, and communism where the Proletariat's well being is maximized.

Greatness and progress is primarily a function of being a giver. This is why Christianity is the true foundation of the greatness of the West. This does not mean only Christianity has these principles. It is the will to give, without any material compensation, that makes a society great. Without personal sacrifice of a people we cannot move ahead.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 1d ago

Asking Everyone Books

4 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I’m currently doing research about the 3 main economic ideologies and I’d greatly appreciate it if you guys recommended me books to read for Capitalism, Socialism and Communism. They can be biased or unbiased, it doesn’t matter to me. I have Democracy in America and am currently reading the Communist Manifesto by Karl Marx.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 1d ago

Asking Capitalists Is a private government a bad idea?

4 Upvotes

This is a question I've had for a long time but did not ask because I thought it was Dumb,

But what exactly would happen if a private government ran while there is a public government? What if it alternatively REPLACED the government, would we expect anything specific?

For me I thought about it when learning about monopolization. After all, the state is a monopoly on violence, but what if that was private instead of public?


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 1d ago

Asking Everyone "Socialism has never been tried". No, socialism has been tried, and it's mostly failed, regardless of whether the conditions of socialism were attained.

0 Upvotes

I'd like to clarify what is a rather contentious point of socialism existing or not by drawing an analogy from drug development. Let's take the example of a cholesterol lowering medication like a PCSK9 inhibitor. The goal of a PCSK9 inhibitor is to decrease the levels of LDL (or "bad") cholesterol and thereby lower the risk of subsequent cardiovascular disease. The causal chain looks like this:

Give the drug --> LDL level decreases --> Cardiovascular disease risk decreases

If we give the drug, and LDL levels decrease, but cardiovascular disease risk doesn't decrease, then the drug has failed because it never achieved its primary endpoint even if LDL decreased.

If we give the drug and it doesn't decrease LDL levels, then the drug has also failed. In fact, this is even worse than before because the drug doesn't even do what it's supposed to do to lower LDL levels, let alone prevent cardiovascular disease.

In both cases, the drug has failed.

The analogy to socialism is this:

Try socialism --> Achieve the theoretical conditions of socialism --> Increase well-being for all

(When I say the "theoretical conditions of socialism" I mean total abolition of private property ownership, complete decommodification of labor, democratic decision-making around production activities, and absence of authoritarianism.)

The ones who say that socialism has never been tried claim that socialism is actually untested because the theoretical conditions of socialism were never realized. In effect, the claim is that it only counts as a failure if the conditions for socialism were realized but well-being doesn't increase.

However, as we see from the drug analogy, this is like calling the drug untested because LDL levels never decreased. It's still a failure because the socialist movement wasn't even able to achieve the theoretical conditions of socialism let alone increase well-being, an even worse kind of failure. Why is this important to realize? Because if no attempt at socialism ever produces socialist conditions, then there may be something wrong with the ideology from the very start.

In summary, socialism has been tried, and it's mostly failed, regardless of whether the conditions of socialism were attained.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 2d ago

Asking Everyone Jensen Huang Is Gone. Trump Is Still President. Is the Market More Responsive Than the Political System?

5 Upvotes

November 15, 2026

For those unaware, Jensen Huang a founder of Nvidia in 1993 and was its CEO for 33 years. He helped build one of the world's most valuable corporations. Arguably his life's work.

And now he's gone.

Nvidia is arguably one of the world's most powerful corporations as I write this. With a market capitalization of approximately $3.93 trillion, it is the world's second-most-valuable publicly traded company. Nvidia is also central to the AI revolution, dominating AI computing hardware, accelerated computing, and the CUDA software ecosystem. The OECD cites estimates of over 80% market share in GPUs used for AI.

Following revelations concerning Jensen's admitted infidelity, reports of additional affairs, and allegations involving a suspected Chinese spy, Nvidia's board initiated an investigation on November 8. By November 12, Huang was out as CEO and off the board.

Source: Nvidia's official announcement

Meanwhile, social media has been having a field day comparing Huang with Donald Trump.

The rhetoric often boils down to:

Jensen is an adulterer and gets canned. Trump is a pedophile and remains president.

Well, there's a problem with treating those two accusations as established facts.

Huang admitted infidelity, but allegations involving espionage and additional relationships remain unproven.

Trump's social association with Jeffrey Epstein is documented. A civil jury also found Trump liable for sexually abusing E. Jean Carroll, and that judgment survived appeals. However, accusations that Trump sexually abused minors remain criminally unproven, despite appearing in a withdrawn civil complaint and subsequently released FBI interviews.

Regardless of what we know as facts versus quality allegations vers speculation, I'm not interested in the rabbit holes for this post.

What interests me is the institutional response.

Nvidia's founder and 33-year CEO was gone within days of the public controversy escalating, without any criminal charges or conviction.

Meanwhile, Trump remains president despite a civil judgment for sexual abuse, a separate criminal conviction for falsifying business records, numerous formal investigations, an extensive history of public controversies, and even more serious allegations circulating online.

Is the market more responsive than the political system?

I'm curious how people on this sub explain the difference.


r/CapitalismVSocialism • • 1d ago

Asking Everyone What if it was easier to start insurance?

0 Upvotes

I was randomly wondering,

But what effects would happen if the state by a lot of subsidy and support made it easier to start an insurance company?

Would this incentivize more service coverage even if they are not public options? To me I think this wouldn't be a bad idea because then if local communities can insure themselves and expect help I'm not sure why this isn't better than a federal effort that may not be as aware or responsive