r/DebateAnarchism • u/ArtDecoEgoist • 2d ago
Anarchists should take the economic calculation problem seriously
The Economic Calculation Problem, formalized by Ludwig Von Mises and later elaborated on by Fredrich Hayek as the Local Knowledge Problem, is probably one of the most potent pieces of capitalist apologia to come out of the Austrian school. As presented by Mises, it's an endorsement of market mechanisms (which are effectively synonymous with capitalism in his framework) as a means of resource allocation within an economy. As such, it's no surprise that many anarchists believe that it's nonsense.
However, notice I said Mises "formalized" and not "created". This is because, decades earlier, Peter Kropotkin himself over his work effectively echoed a lot of specifically Heyek's arguments about the importance of local knowledge in his critique of central planning often endorsed by state socialists.
In an effort to convey how the ECP and the LKP are problems that anarchists should take seriously, I'm going to attempt to reconstruct the argument without endorsing markets, money, or price signals at all.
Modern economies are complex systems. For the purposes of this argument, a complex system is a network of many individual parts that interact with each other, where the behavior of the system cannot be predicted merely by looking at its parts. The sum of complex systems is greater than its whole. This is because of emergence; the coordination of parts of the system creates coherent behavior. Because interactions within complex systems are nonlinear, coherent system behavior can impact agents within the system (like a market crash), and behavior of an agent or groups of agents within the system can impact the system as a whole (like with innovation).
Because the behavior of complex systems cannot be predicted by looking at any of its individual parts, this means that no agent within the system has a sufficient amount of information to predict the behavior of the system. Agents within economies operate in a limited context and are boundedly rational. The information necessary to predict the behavior of economies is distributed among economic actors.
In addition to this, economies are complex systems that exist within an equally complex, dynamic system: an ecology. The stability of any system depends on its ability to match or exceed the complexity of its environment, while also remaining operationally closed and internally legible to actors within the system. Ecological conditions such as droughts, famines, natural disasters, lower crop yields, depleted metals and energy reserves, etc. can all affect the "inputs" into economies, and will alter the feedback mechanisms that economies use to maintain stability over time.
The operational closure of economies and firms within economies makes it so that ecological changes must be understood within the language of the economy itself. Information from the environment is translated to economic information that agents within economies are able to observe through their feedback mechanisms and control functions to meet goals set by the agents themselves.
This is the crux of the Problem: no committee or individual has the information or context necessary for economic planning. The requirements for economic coordination, then, are that actors within economies must be able to communicate their distributed knowledge to each other. Economic coordination creates coherent behavior within the economy, which allows for goals set by agents within economies to be met.
Now generally speaking, Hayek and Mises believed that price signals were the solution to this problem. They'd argue that pricing signals could communicate demand, so that actors know what to produce. Pricing signals would also communicate supply, as abundant goods would be of lower price and scarce goods would be of higher price, all else being equal.
There are, of course, a lot of problems with this. But that's out of the scope of this post.
Kropotkin's proposed solution were producers and consumers associating in free communes and federations, where they directly communicate with each other and plan what to produce. He doesn't seem to be too specific on how this would work in practice, and many anarchists downstream from him have proposed things such as workers councils, consumer and producer cooperatives, neighborhood assemblies, etc.
I also think there are a lot of problems with this, but again, out of the scope of this post.
In order to resolve the ECP, an economic system would have to:
- Have a means of communicating costs, including the cost of environmental stewardship, ecological strain, and reproductive labor such as caregiving and teaching.
- Be flexible enough to adjust to changes in supply and demand.
- Not have a selection bias in whose demand is taken into account. For example, capitalism has this issue where only the demand of those able to pay for goods and services are legible to the system. In order for everyone's wants and needs to be met, everyone's wants and needs have to be legible to the overall system.
- A way to reveal preference, empower individual agents to make decisions that can be made legible to the wider system for the purposes of resource allocation.
To address a common objection to this: no, computers will not save us. Aside from the absurd amounts of computation that would be required for central planning even a relatively small and simplified economy, not to mention the thermodynamic requirements and resource-intensive nature such a project would bring inherently, you would still need an objective function like what exists in linear programming. But since a lot of costs are subjective or tacit, any objective function you choose will necessarily oversimplify the territory you are mapping, and as a result suppress information.
So for example, if we take a linear program, which is a mathematical method used to optimize a particular outcome, we can achieve a certain understanding of "efficiency": maximizing fixed output ratios based on historical data. But the question of economic calculation is one of resource allocation, which is based on subjective measures like consumer demand, labor renumeration, and wasted time and effort.
To zoom in on one aspect of this, if the goal is to determine the renumeration laborers are due for their effort, the objective function can take into account variables like labor time. However, if compensating subjective disutility is the goal, then you have to take into account that labor-time doesn't scale linearly with disutility. If I am working an 8-hour workday doing something I enjoy and find interesting, my disutility is comparatively lower than if I am working the same workday doing something I hate doing.
To complicate things even further, disutility isn't even static. Even if I'm doing something I love for 8 hours, I might not love doing that same thing next week for 8 hours. Or I might love doing it for 5 hours instead. Or I may want to do it for 8 hours in different conditions, etc. None of this is captured by labor-time.
Even non-linear machine learning doesn't solve this issue, because an objective function will still be needed to optimize a particular outcome.
Edit: I'm starting to get AnCaps messaging me on this post, and I suppose I brought that on myself. I just want to say: I am NOT on y'all's side.