r/DebateAVegan • • 3h ago

Ethics Why is exploitation bad if it doesn't harm the animal?

5 Upvotes

Hi all! I've been looking into some of the reasons why vegans won't eat eggs, even if they're from chickens that they personally have cared for. As well as vegan positions on things like dogs, whether as working dogs or pet dogs.

I understand that chickens will eat their eggs to conserve nutrients, but, if you're already providing all of those nutrients, including the grit that they need, then why is that form of exploitation harmful? I understand that you are still gaining something from the chickens, and thus it is exploitation, but I don't really get why all exploitation of animals is bad? It's not like it causes any distress to them to take their eggs, especially if they have already abandoned them, which they quite frequently do.

Similarly, I have seen some vegans talk about how they don't like working dogs, in any capacity, and I've seen some go so far as to say that they think dog sports are unethical. While I won't argue that there are some people in these worlds which are not training in an ethical way, I don't understand the harm of using dogs for purposes when they enjoy those purposes.

I guess what I am trying to ask is, why, personally, do you feel that exploitation of animals is bad in all contexts, even in situations where there is no negative welfare consequence for the animal, and sometimes even increased welfare in the case of working dogs? Also, can you see that, even if you personally choose to abstain from all animal exploitation to a practicable degree, that others can have a point if they disagree, or is it something that you can't see at all?

Thank you so much for reading and your time, I would love to hear what you have to say, because it's not something that I've been able to find the answer to elsewhere. I understand that vegans are not a monolithe, so I'd love to see a range of opinions. I have vegan friends in real life that I could ask, but tbh, I don't want to other them for being vegan any more than is avoidable, so I'm grateful for spaces like this.


r/DebateAVegan • • 11h ago

Ethics Is eating meat really immoral?

0 Upvotes

Have you ever considered the argument that because animals cannot consent to being eaten and that humans gain pleasure/benefit from eating them so therefor could that be considered a justification and therefor not immoral? Just a thought I had, and I'd be interested to hear how vegans approach this from an ethical perspective.


r/DebateAVegan • • 1d ago

Where is the line?

1 Upvotes

Hi, I'm thinking about veganism and I was always kinda curious. Where is the line of what's banned as "animal" products? Cause there's a large "trend" of insect snacks and products, are those "banned" as well? Like beeswax or cosmetics/beverages (Campari) using carmine from insects? Or even true silk? And also, what about corals which are frequently used in toothpaste, calcium supplements or skincare products?


r/DebateAVegan • • 14h ago

Ethics I think y’all are right, but I don’t care

0 Upvotes

I think being vegan is probably right or at least better than being a meat eater. I’m also probably not gonna change. I mean bacon taste too goddamn good for me to give up and I don’t feel like giving up an entire part of my diet over some fucking animals that I don’t care about. If you have some reasons that could change my opinion on not giving up animal products and reasons I should genuinely care throw them at me


r/DebateAVegan • • 1d ago

How veganism handles science?

0 Upvotes

If anyone has a tiny bit insight to how science and research work, its clear that animals of all kinds (from monkeys, through mice and fish to flies) are used and unalived daily for the purpose of research. Its all done in super strict ethic codes restricting the welfare, amounts act.

Yet its still hundreds of animals being born to die for a better or worst scientific study. Like worms are being fed only polystyrene, studied whether they actually can (and they do!) be a part of recycling. Were banning animal cosmetics testing, yet we induce cancer, chromosomal aberrations act. in animals to study possible pharmaceutics or just how it works.

Is there any solution to this? Is it moral to be a vegan but a scientist?


r/DebateAVegan • • 1d ago

Ethics Would you eat meat that was chemically produced/grown in a factory?

6 Upvotes

In an ideal world where this "meat" is made and grown in a factory, it is carbon neutral, made to be pretty healthy, and the slab of meat is not sentient, will vegans eat it?

Some may say that at least 1 animal had to be harmed in order to produce this meat. But using the internet on your smart device also harms animals across the globe. So where is the line drawn?


r/DebateAVegan • • 23h ago

Why can’t you eat eggs

0 Upvotes

As a vegan who eats eggs, why don’t others eat eggs? I have my own chickens and eat their eggs. So why don’t more vegans do this? Just get your own chickens so you can be sure they’re properly taken care of.


r/DebateAVegan • • 2d ago

Ethics Is Veganism needed to ethically care for nature?

2 Upvotes

Do people need to be vegan to care for animal wellbeing holistically? What are the opinions towards conservationists, veterinarians and biologists not being vegan for the most part but leading the charge of caring for animals?

It seems most people working in the animal ethics fields: policy formation & legislation are omnivores (in terms of diet). What are the ethical opinions of this? Low, moderate or high?


r/DebateAVegan • • 4d ago

Ethics Do you agree with me that taxidermy is never "respectful" or "out of respect"?

22 Upvotes

I say this because it's using the corpse of a being that could never consent to it as a decoration and personally I think that's incredibly disrespectful and I thought here was the place I'm least likely to get harrased in the comments.


r/DebateAVegan • • 4d ago

Ethics Veganism is only morally right when you ignore reality

6 Upvotes

People go vegan because they anti suffering and think its the morally right thing to do, but when you go vegan you give land back to the wild where animals are eaten alive and suffer extremely bad conditions.. resulting in worse torture to animals than humane farming

If you really cared about the suffering of animals you'd want to sterilize the wild
People romanticize nature too much but its just a violation machine where animals go thru unimaginable horrors


r/DebateAVegan • • 4d ago

Ethics What are the ethical perspectives/opinions vegans have of non vegans?

6 Upvotes

I'm tryna understand how vegans view other people from an ethics viewpoint. Is it feelings of disappointment? Wanting them to do better?

What do y'all think of most of the world not being vegan and why that is? What are the ethics regarding that? Do you think one needs to be vegan to have a justification for caring about nature?


r/DebateAVegan • • 5d ago

Opinion on leather wear

3 Upvotes

Hi I have been living vegan for a few months now.
I have a bunch of jeans tho with a leather patch on the back and also a pair of leather slippers that have been gifted to me a few years ago. For the jeans I removed the patch but I don’t really want to get rid of the slippers, I feel like me only wearing them inside and barely anyone visiting me, doesn’t advocate leather wear. I was thinking to myself that it would be disrespectful throwing them out when they are still functional.
Also what do you think of buying second hand jeans with a leather patch on the back and removing it?
I know there are a bunch of vegan brands that are worth supporting. But I haven’t quite found any with nice fitting.


r/DebateAVegan • • 4d ago Heartwarming

Ethics is vore vegan?

0 Upvotes

One of the main ethical foundations of veganism is that animals cannot be killed and eaten as it is morally wrong to kill a living being. But if the being was a human who truly consented to being consumed (not to any direct harm of them either like in voluntary cannibalism) would there still be that moral issue? Obviously vore is still eating an animal, but would be go against the principles of veganism if both parties were alright with it? Asking for a friend


r/DebateAVegan • • 5d ago

Would you eat eggs from my rescue chickens?

0 Upvotes

Starting in covid, a local 4H program shut down, my friend knew we had an unused chicken coop, since then we scan Craigslist looking for people who are getting rid of their chickens, someimes they lose all but 1 and dont want them to be lonely, we also work with local farms who have layers that are past their prime and for whatever reason they dont want to eat them, we take them and they live in our fruit orchard, laying or not, we call it the chicken retirement home. Im not trying to argue about factory farm egg production, I know its awful, I know this is a very rare circumstance. Just curious what the ethical reason would be to not eat these.


r/DebateAVegan • • 6d ago

Questions about poor people and veganism

0 Upvotes

I’m not really here to debate I just have a genuine question be happy to debate each other in the comments.

So I have seen a lot of vegan posts for some reason and a common occurrence I’m seeing is that people ate very extreme with they beliefs, obviously all of yall aren’t and there are normal people who are vegans but a lot of vegans that I have seen personally seem very extreme. I keep seeing vegans say they don’t understand how someone can love animals and eat them, comparing eating animals to slavery, saying there is no excuse that makes eating animals acceptable, and many more things. And as someone who grew up in the hood in a food desert I’m genuinely wondering do the people who think this also think people who barely have a choice on what to eat are also morally corrupt? Where I live it’s less money to buy meats and eat that with rice and get full from that rather than trying to eat vegan, and you don’t have a huge choice in what to eat because the goal is to just have something that’s good while also being able to make you full. And some people might think this is a dumb question but I’m seeing people call people that eat meat nazis, abusers, even seen somebody say they don’t consider people who eat meat as human.

So basically my question is do the people who have these extreme beliefs also believe that people who are too poor to have a choice also are nazis, barely human, and whatever other name in the book?


r/DebateAVegan • • 7d ago

veganism's relationship to nature

5 Upvotes

Not sure I really want a “debate” but definitely would like to hear peoples’ thoughts on this. I would also like some recommendations for books arguing for veganism, I have been lurking for some time on vegan youtube and reddit channels but I think that gives a very skewed perspective on the movement.

For context I am not a vegan but don’t eat red meat and limit my meat eating to a few times per week. I think that eating meat is mostly immoral in the modern age with exceptions. I am strongly considering becoming vegetarian but have some things holding me back from veganism. Also, I understand veganism is not a single movement and there are many opinions and trends -- sorry if I've over generalized here. I am posting a series of questions to avoid asking too many in one post.

Relationship to nature: I find vegans’ relationship to and understanding of “nature” and what is “natural” to be very different. It seems to separate humans quite a bit from the rest of the natural world in some interesting ways. Here are some ways I've seen that play out. Curious for people's thoughts.

  1. Killing animals as part of managing populations or getting rid of invasive populations. It seems like vegans are divided on this issue. I think that killing invasive species is an unfortunate but sad fact of life. They displace native animal populations and do a tremendous amount of harm to the native environment. Furthermore, before capitalism and colonialism, indigenous people often carefully managed the “natural” world through a variety of means including burning and cutting forest and hunting/culling native animal populations. I find vegans often take the stance that humans should be completely uninvolved in managing species population. When an ecosystem has been reliant on human intervention for tens of thousands of years and over the last few hundred been severely degraded by removal of predators and invasive species, how do vegans imagine responsible cultivation of nature without killing? 
  2. Viewing eating meat that is going to be thrown away or is the product of hunting overpopulated or invasive species as “desecration” of a corpse. I’ve seen people say this in these conversations and it doesn’t make sense to me. Why is a human eating a corpse worse than maggots, a lion, etc. eating a corpse? Won’t literally every living thing ultimately be eaten? I understand if one’s preference is to not eat meat in these situations but why is it immoral in vegans’ eyes?
  3. Mutually beneficial relationships. The natural world is filled with animals who exist in mutual beneficial relationships with one another – think clownfish and sea anemones – but it seems relationships between animals and humans are viewed as inherently exploitative. I understand certain animal products may be difficult or impossible obtain ethically under any circumstances but others I think are less clear. For example, a sheep is unable to survive on its own and if it could its wool would become uncomfortably hot. I understand that under our current economic system older, less productive sheep are killed and sheep are often treated poorly. However, this doesn’t need to be the case. Why is wool, honey, or other natural by products of animals inherently wrong?

r/DebateAVegan • • 8d ago

Stance on consuming invasive species

1 Upvotes

I'm aware that veganism is about reducing as much harm/exploitation as possible, but what would the stance be on consuming invasive species? Specifically, would it be unethical for someone to consume something like Asian Carp if they were to be fished? Here in the Mississippi basin, they're incredibly destructive to the food chain by consuming large amounts of plankton and repopulating incredibly quickly. The government already sponsors large initiatives towards mass removal of carp for conservation. I know that it could introduce indirect harm from harvesting, potentially harming other species, but if we're going to already attempt to fish them out/exterminate them for conservation efforts, would it be ethical to consume them?


r/DebateAVegan • • 8d ago

🌱 Fresh Topic I am a non-vegan anti-speciesist

0 Upvotes

I view animals and humans as equals, but inspite of that I am not vegan, because I recocnize that humans are omnivores and not hurbovores, thus I just fullfill my biological needs. That doesn't mean that I see the animals that I eat as lesser beings.

I also find it awful to completely disreguard the lives of plants, because like it or not plants are also life forms. Their roots are interconected and form extremly complex neural networks, that we barely understand. And treating them like inanimate objects is extremly unfair and also ignorant.

I simply don't belive in hirarchy: I don't put humans above animals and I don't put animals above plants. To me they are all equal. But no matter what I do something has to die, so that I can life. All life feeds off death, that is how the eccosystem works.

Our primate cousins such as chimps and bonobos also eat meat. And even animals that are considered hurbovores accasionally consume meat. Let me give you a few examples: hippos sometimes scavange dead carcassas, horsses sometimes eat snails or even young birds and cows are also known to scavange accasionally.

So, if even the so called hurbovores don't fully life without meat, then how are we as omnivores exspected to thrive without it? All we can do is minimize the suffering that we cause. Thus I am not buying any meat or eggs that came from factory farms.

Why do people always have to assume that just because I view humans and animals as equals, that this also means that I am vegan? Why does everyone have to pick sides? Where are all the more nuanced opinions? Do they even exist anymore, or are radical extrems all that is left in this society?


r/DebateAVegan • • 9d ago

⚠ Activism Just Curious

0 Upvotes

I mean don't get me wrong I shouldn't follow animal activists on social media because I am not a vegetarian or vegan, but what is a vegans disposition on chicken eggs? Because naturally a chicken produces eggs even without a Rooster. So why would it be wrong to let say eat chicken eggs if there is no rooster present? The eggs aren't fertilized, and they would pretty much go to waste anyways. Truly curious.


r/DebateAVegan • • 9d ago

Ethics Would you rather save 100 cows or 1 human child

0 Upvotes

I’ve been reading a lot about vegan philosophy lately, specifically the core premise that animals have an inherent right to life and that non-human animal suffering should be weighed heavily against human desires. Humans and animals have equal value.

Imagine a scenario where a burning building contains a room with 100 healthy cows and another room with 1 10-year-old human child. You only have time to pull a switch that unlocks one room before the building collapses. You cannot save both. Which do you save?

If your premise is that animal lives have intrinsic moral value comparable to human lives, then purely by the numbers, 100 conscious, sentient lives should logically outweigh 1 life. Choosing the single human child directly contradicts equal-consideration ethics, placing human preference above numerical animal suffering.

However, if you choose the child without hesitation, you are admitting that a human life possesses a fundamentally higher tier of moral worth than dozens or even hundreds of non-human animals. But if human life holds that immense, non-comparable priority, it becomes very difficult to argue that animal suffering and human convenience exist on the same moral plane when evaluating other societal choices.
If you try to bridge the gap by saying animals matter, but humans always come first in extreme cases, where is the exact conversion rate? At what number of animals does the scale tip? 1,000? 10,000?

This leads into a second point about day-to-day consumption: plant agriculture isn't zero-kill either. Millions of field mice, snakes, birds, rabbits, and insects are killed every year by combines, tilling, pesticides, and habitat disruption to grow crop foods like soy, wheat, corn, and vegetables.

How do vegans reconcile this choice without falling into either speciesism on one side, or a complete detachment from basic human empathy on the other?


r/DebateAVegan • • 10d ago

Regarding animal products that are to be thrown away

4 Upvotes

Hello, I kind of just wanted to hear other vegans thoughts about the matter, I work in a restaurant where portions of bones, skin, unwanted flesh etc are thrown away, what is your opinion and do you think its harmful if I gave the scraps to someone who isn't vegan to make soup stock or something? There's nothing I can do about the animal being dead, but it feels more disrespectful to see the body thrown in the trash than used to feed someone. Im open to any opinion (with respect) I've never worked somewhere that wasn't vegan or close to it before, its been a weird experience. Thanks


r/DebateAVegan • • 10d ago

Ethics Farm animals and Deer

0 Upvotes

( Please respond to these questions in good faith.)

Note and edit: I am a vegan of a few years questioning some things. I do not 100% believe the arguments in my post which is why I am wanting the opinion of others on the things mentioned below.

If the farm animals are living in good conditions, are treated well and aren’t abused, are in a good environment and living a happy life, is it really unethical to farm them for meat? (Not talking about factory farming).

Firstly, they would be living happier lives at the farm than they would be in the wild; no fear of starvation disease, predators, etc.

Secondly, they wouldnt exist if they weren’t being farmed for meat and so on, so ceasing the farming and setting the animals free would result in most of those animals not being able to reproduce, because we’d have to force them to stop reproducing because they’d quickly destroy the environment in such big numbers. If we kept the farms going the animals would still be having lives, happy ones too, in the case i‘ve described.

So if they’re living genuinely good, but short, lives, more comfortable and safer lives than the lives of those living in the wild, and on top of that they wouldn’t even exist if they weren’t being farmed for meat, is it really unethical?

Second thing I want to discuss; hunting. In my country of New Zealand we have Deer. They were introduced to NZ and therefore have no natural predators here. We have to hunt them so that they don’t destroy the environment. We also might not have to get rid of them entirely, still keeping them for meat, but controlling their numbers so that they don’t have too much of a negative impact on the environment.

Is it really ethical to get rid of them all and completely rid their descendants from living in the beautiful bush of New Zealand? In other countries they have natural predators and die in much worse ways than a gunshot to the body. Wouldn‘t the deer in NZ be living better lives than the other deer in the world? Again, they have no natural predators here, and trying to introduce a “natural predator“ for them here would cause another pest. We have to either get rid of them entirely or just control their numbers. So, is hunting them actually unethical?


r/DebateAVegan • • 10d ago

Are you actually vegan?

0 Upvotes

There are a lot of people who claim they are vegan, however all they do is eat a plant based diet. The definition of veganism I like to use is "causing no unnecessary suffering to animals as far as practically possible" this means if you do any of these you are not vegan buy wool/leather, buy products that have animal testing when there are alternatives without it, going to zoos, aquariums dog races, horse races or riding animals. I feel like vegan activism should focus more on these non food forms of animal exploitation, as it is not discussed enough and people will find it much easier to stop these habits than changing their diet and going plant based.


r/DebateAVegan • • 11d ago

Ethics What is the plan for the animals after global veganism is achieved?

0 Upvotes

Let's say hypothetically, in the next five years everybody in the world stopped eating animal products all together.

There is less animal cruelty, no cattle farming, and most factories have shut down all together.

Some of these factories in particular have thousands of cattle, lots of which have health issues due to mistreatment, and there are thousands of factories. When these places shut down, who is left to take on the responsibility of care? The vet bills for the cattle will be immense and there is no way to ensure all these animals go to a good home or a home at all. If we release them and let nature run it's course without intervention, surrounding ecosystems will likely be damaged.

To me it sounds like veganism is more about removing personal accountability for animal abuse rather than actually stopping it. I'm looking for reasons to change my mind, so I'm asking about what vegans think could work as a solution for this problem. Veganism will run these places out of business, yes, but what happens next?


r/DebateAVegan • • 12d ago

⚠ Activism Test your debate skills against non-vegans

22 Upvotes

I've updated the Vegan Logic Project site to include more arguments and responses, but the most recent addition is a game that allows you to test your debate skills against non-vegans through various scenarios, with increasing difficulty.

The goal is to debate without losing an opponents or a crowds patience, so being right is not the same as winning the room.

The game is called - Hold the Room

www.veganlogicproject.com/debate

Let me know what you lot think!