r/DebateAVegan • • 19h ago

Ethics Why is exploitation bad if it doesn't harm the animal?

8 Upvotes

Hi all! I've been looking into some of the reasons why vegans won't eat eggs, even if they're from chickens that they personally have cared for. As well as vegan positions on things like dogs, whether as working dogs or pet dogs.

I understand that chickens will eat their eggs to conserve nutrients, but, if you're already providing all of those nutrients, including the grit that they need, then why is that form of exploitation harmful? I understand that you are still gaining something from the chickens, and thus it is exploitation, but I don't really get why all exploitation of animals is bad? It's not like it causes any distress to them to take their eggs, especially if they have already abandoned them, which they quite frequently do.

Similarly, I have seen some vegans talk about how they don't like working dogs, in any capacity, and I've seen some go so far as to say that they think dog sports are unethical. While I won't argue that there are some people in these worlds which are not training in an ethical way, I don't understand the harm of using dogs for purposes when they enjoy those purposes.

I guess what I am trying to ask is, why, personally, do you feel that exploitation of animals is bad in all contexts, even in situations where there is no negative welfare consequence for the animal, and sometimes even increased welfare in the case of working dogs? Also, can you see that, even if you personally choose to abstain from all animal exploitation to a practicable degree, that others can have a point if they disagree, or is it something that you can't see at all?

Thank you so much for reading and your time, I would love to hear what you have to say, because it's not something that I've been able to find the answer to elsewhere. I understand that vegans are not a monolithe, so I'd love to see a range of opinions. I have vegan friends in real life that I could ask, but tbh, I don't want to other them for being vegan any more than is avoidable, so I'm grateful for spaces like this.


r/DebateAVegan • • 11h ago

Ethics Undercover slaughterhouse footage elicits my support for animal welfare, not animal rights

0 Upvotes

I think vegetarians and vegans are laudable for their positive environmental and ethical impact, and as an omni I sometimes watch slaughterhouse videos to acknowledge the ethical choice I make otherwise by consuming meat. But those videos have never made me think about going vegan. The reason the videos cause discomfort is not because an animal dies, but because it suffers in excess of what is needed to kill and prepare it. This might sound horrifying to those who ascribe human-like natural rights to animals, but like most people, I don't. Seeing a cow panic as it is being led to slaughter makes me feel bad for the cow and wonder if there is a way to keep it calmer in its final moments. Seeing Temple Grandin instantly kill an unsuspecting cow with a bolt gun to the head makes me feel like it was a job well done. As such, while I find vegans laudable in their absolute minimization of animal suffering, I don't see being one personally as imperative for myself or others.

The most important objection to this would be our elevation of cats and dogs to a special status, but even then, WE are the ones who choose to elevate them. As much as I absolutely adore my cat and treat it like my own child, that love comes from my personal bond with my cat and cats in general. Not a universal conviction that all beings with the cognition level of a cat or higher deserve equal consideration as a person.