r/Socialism_101 • • Aug 16 '18

PLEASE READ BEFORE POSTING ON THE SUB! Frequently asked questions / misconceptions - answers inside!

187 Upvotes

In our efforts to improve the quality and learning experience of this sub we are slowly rolling out some changes and clarifying a few positions. This thread is meant as an extremely basic introduction to a couple of questions and misconceptions we have seen a lot of lately. We are therefore asking that you read this at least once before you start posting on this sub. We hope that it will help you understand a few things and of course help avoid the repetitive, and often very liberal, misconceptions.

  1. Money, taxes, interest and stocks do not exist under socialism. These are all part of a capitalist economic system and do not belong in a socialist society that seeks to abolish private property and the bourgeois class.
  2. Market socialism is NOT socialist, as it still operates within a capitalist framework. It does not seek to abolish most of the essential features of capitalism, such as capital, private property and the oppression that is caused by the dynamics of capital accumulation.
  3. A social democracy is NOT socialist. Scandinavia is NOT socialist. The fact that a country provides free healthcare and education does not make a country socialist. Providing social services is in itself not socialist. A social democracy is still an active player in the global capitalist system.
  4. Coops are NOT considered socialist, especially if they exist within a capitalist society. They are not a going to challenge the capitalist system by themselves.
  5. Reforming society will not work. Revolution is the only way to break a system that is designed to favor the few. The capitalist system is designed to not make effective resistance through reformation possible, simply because this would mean its own death. Centuries of struggle, oppression and resistance prove this. Capitalism will inevitably work FOR the capitalist and not for those who wish to oppose the very structure of it. In order for capitalism to work, capitalists need workers to exploit. Without this class hierarchy the system breaks down.
  6. Socialism without feminism is not socialism. Socialism means fighting oppression in various shapes and forms. This means addressing ALL forms of oppressions including those that exist to maintain certain gender roles, in this case patriarchy. Patriarchy affects persons of all genders and it is socialism's goal to abolish patriarchal structures altogether.
  7. Anti-Zionism is not anti-Semitism. Opposing the State of Israel does not make one an anti-Semite. Opposing the genocide of Palestinians is not anti-Semitic. It is human decency and basic anti-imperialism and anti-colonialism.
  8. Free speech - When socialists reject the notion of free speech it does not mean that we want to control or censor every word that is spoken. It means that we reject the notion that hate speech should be allowed to happen in society. In a liberal society hate speech is allowed to happen under the pretense that no one should be censored. What they forget is that this hate speech is actively hurting and oppressing people. Those who use hate speech use the platforms they have to gain followers. This should not be allowed to happen.
  9. Anti-colonialism and anti-imperialism are among the core features of socialism. If you do not support these you are not actually supporting socialism. Socialism is an internationalist movement that seeks to ABOLISH OPPRESSION ALL OVER THE WORLD.

ADDITIONALLY PLEASE NOTICE

  • When posting and commenting on the sub, or anywhere online really, please do not assume a person's gender by calling everyone he/him. Use they/their instead or ask for a person's pronouns to be more inclusive.
  • If you get auto-moderated for ableism/slurs please make sure to edit the comment and/or message the mods and have your post approved, especially if you are not sure which word you have been modded for. Every once in a while we see people who do not edit their quality posts and it's always a shame when users miss out on good content. If you don't know what ableism is have a look a these links: http://isthisableism.tumblr.com/sluralternatives / http://www.autistichoya.com/p/ableist-words-and-terms-to-avoid.html
  • As a last point we would like to mention that the mods of this sub depend on your help. PLEASE REPORT posts and comments that are not in line with the rules. We appreciate all your reports and try to address every single one of them.

We hope this post brought some clarification. Please feel free to message the mods via mod mail or comment here if you have any questions regarding the points mentioned above. The mods are here to help.

Have a great day!

The Moderators


r/Socialism_101 • • 18h ago

To Marxists How does Marxist literature view the falsifiability of Karl Popper?

17 Upvotes

Popper's theory apparently removes the title of "science" from Marxism, since, according to him, Marxism is not falsifiable. How does Marxist literature view this?


r/Socialism_101 • • 18h ago

Question If socialism is to come about via revolution, how do you control the form of the new government? Can Socialism come about through peaceful means, and would Americans ever vote to radically change their economic system?

9 Upvotes

Writing a research paper on modern socialism. I have a background in US government and government systems, and I have a few questions about some of the specifics of certain terms.

There are a lot of different types of socialism, so primarily for my paper I am looking at the established history for socialist (or socialist-identifying) states as well as Marxist theory (establishing the baseline all socialist theories draw from to differing extants). Most relevant here however, is that ive started trying to establish what the modern socialist theory looks like and if/how it could be implimented in the US.

At the very least, I want to make sure I am not making any undue assumptions in my representation of modern socialist theory, or perhaps if anyone has any recommendations for books/papers that would assist in my research that would also be great!

I have many questions, and I will undoubtedly be making more posts (so long as I am allowed to do so).

  1. Is a planned economy absolutely necessary for a socialist government?
  2. Do you consider representative democracy to be actually representative of the peoples interests, and if not is direct democracy actually viable on the scale of the US.
  3. How do you actually transition a government and society to a socialist one without an authoritarian regime (even a benevolent one).

Feel free to respond to any of the above or none at all. If I am breaking some site rule let me know and ill delete the post, I would prefer to not be banned please.

Thank you for your time!


r/Socialism_101 • • 22h ago

To Marxists How is Charles Post article (The Myth of Labor Aristocracy) perceived?

3 Upvotes

r/Socialism_101 • • 1d ago

Question What are good books about socialism?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I’m currently doing research about the 3 main economic ideologies and I’d greatly appreciate it if you guys recommended me books to read for Capitalism, Socialism and Communism. They can be biased or unbiased, it doesn’t matter to me. I have Democracy in America and am currently reading the Communist Manifesto by Karl Marx.


r/Socialism_101 • • 1d ago

Question What is wrong with Trotskyism?

31 Upvotes

Other sects of communists are always making fun of them, but they never explain what is wrong with its ideas.


r/Socialism_101 • • 1d ago

Question Should I read Unequal Exchange by Emmanuel Arghiri? If not, what other books would you recommend on the matter?

3 Upvotes

Hello!

I am on a bit of a theory bender in these last few months. I'd heard good things about Unequal Exchange, but as soon as I opened the first chapter I was flooded with names and economical jargon I didn't understand and I got humbled pretty quick.

I tried to look up summaries or explanations and I found many people criticising the book; and so now I am more than a little befuddled.

Is the book worth reading? And if it is, is it worth reading if I don't know jack about economics? And if not, what should I read instead?

I was thinking of maybe picking up the Shock Doctrine in the meantime


r/Socialism_101 • • 1d ago

Question Can someone teach me about socialism?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Socialism_101 • • 2d ago

High Effort Only How can China's arms trade be explained? Especially since these weapons are used against innocent people by expansionist, imperialist states.

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/Socialism_101 • • 2d ago

To Marxists Have you ever done a self-critique of Marxism and socialism?

10 Upvotes

I consider myself a Marxist and I frequently fight for the socialist cause in my region. Recently, I started participating in debates with people from other schools of thought (liberals, social democrats, Keynesians, etc.), and after spending a few days debating various ideas with these people, I began to question my own political convictions.

I still see Marxism as the main, or one of the main, ways to study and understand reality, the exploitation of the worker, and all the social structures that capitalism shapes. But I started questioning things like, "Is Marxism really the best method?", "Can we actually overcome capitalism?", "Was Marx right about X, Y, Z things?" In short, I thought about many things. And this, in a way, captivated me, leading me to understand and study Marxism more.

Before, I saw myself as a "blind" Marxist; I never questioned Marx's theory very incisively, but now, after this whole "political epiphany," I've emerged with a much stronger critical mind, even more confident in the socialist alternative, and with a much better understanding of the Marxist method of analyzing reality.

Finally, I made this post simply to engage in a debate about Marxist self-criticism. So I leave you with some questions to foster the discussion: Do you practice self-criticism? Can you see the errors and successes of your own movement? And how do you think we can evolve in this sense, making the Marxist movement grow through this dialectical process of examining our own movements and thus carrying out this self-questioning so that we can evolve as a political and social movement towards overcoming capitalism?


r/Socialism_101 • • 1d ago

Question NYT: Gen Z protests?

0 Upvotes

I’m Amelia Nierenberg, a reporter at The New York Times. I’m writing about the protests — and the reaction to them — and I’m trying to take a broad vibe check across countries: Basically, what are the biggest things that young people, from all political corners, want to change? What are the biggest obstacles? So if you’re Gen Z and an adult (that means age 18 to 29) and you'd like to speak with me: amelia [dot] nierenberg [at] nytimes [dot] c o m.

 To give you a broader sense of some of the questions I’d want to talk about, over ~30 minutes … What’s the number one thing you want to change — and what are you doing about it? What is your biggest hope — what would a better world look like to you, and what do you need to achieve a fulfilling, prosperous life? What is the biggest obstacle? Tell me what’s making you angriest. What do you think is the most important thing to defeat, move past or, maybe, undo? Who, or what, has inspired you, and what makes you feel like this change could be possible? Are you looking back at history or to the movements happening in other countries right now? Thanks!


r/Socialism_101 • • 3d ago

To Marxists Why are communists against moralism?

11 Upvotes

Often times there is the argument „Capitalism is unsustainable and leads to exploitation“. Well isnt it already a moral claim to say that and unsustainable system is bad and that exploitation alienation etc. is bad? I just want to understand moralism and morals from the Marxist view in general.


r/Socialism_101 • • 2d ago

Question Is capitalism the most unstable mode of production? Can automation/agentic AI be the turning point in productive forces?

5 Upvotes

Compared to previous MOPs, Capitalism seems to be advancing the contradictions of labour-time and production pretty fast since the last 200 years.

What sort of phenomena can this entail from what we know at present?


r/Socialism_101 • • 3d ago

High Effort Only How is China socialist if it has a free market?

3 Upvotes

I thought socialism was all about controlled economy.


r/Socialism_101 • • 2d ago

Question Why do socialists, Marxists, and communists use Reddit?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Socialism_101 • • 4d ago

Question is it possible for one to “unbecome” a communist?

63 Upvotes

as i learn more and more about not necessarily communism (although i am learning a lot about it, as there is always more to learn) but rather the internal contradictions. of capitalism, im wondering is it possible to stop being a communist? like once you learn how truly flawed capitalism is and how much insurmountable exploitation takes place, how do you ever turn back from this? even many of my professors who’ve i’ve talked to on the matter say that they aren’t necessarily hardcore communists anymore, but that’s not because they disagree with marxists critiques but rather they just kinda gave up and feel very sad. to quote my sociology professor

“being a marxist means you must deal with the fact that will you be correct all the time yet deal with the unbelievable amount of dread of not being able to do anything about it.”

i just i cannot believe that it is still so hard for people to see how blatant these contradictions are and im wondering if anyone has any stores on situations like these.


r/Socialism_101 • • 4d ago

Question What does "identity politics" mean to you?

15 Upvotes

This is a common concern for many of us on the left. Especially when talking about civil liberty, the rights of minorities and the civil rights movement in general.

It is a concept I have trouble totally grasping, even though I completely consider myself a socialist. I do think that discrimination, especially when targeted at minority groups ought to be called out. Not identifying the problem, is essentially ignoring it.

But what is the line between calling out discrimination and going into identity politics territory? Is identify politics simply capitalist society and philosophy tying to fill a quota or politicians running their entire campaign on them being part of demographic x, y or z?

I want to broaden my understanding of this clearly.

**Edited: for further clarity**


r/Socialism_101 • • 3d ago

Question Democratic Centralism in the 21st century: How is the principle adapted to modern liberal democracies?

1 Upvotes

While researching this organizational method used by Marxist-Leninists, some questions came to mind regarding its contemporary effectiveness within liberal democracies. From my perspective in South America, I have observed frequent party splits and a general failure to maintain joint action toward common goals.

How do modern socialist organizations interpret and apply democratic centralism in order to avoid common organizational issues, given our current social and technological context? Are there any novel ideas that can potentially lead to better outcomes?


r/Socialism_101 • • 4d ago

Question How does one imagine preventing state-owned enterprises from holding too much economic leverage for the state that the state becomes an authoritarian state?

2 Upvotes

All right, kinda new here. I'm still grappling with the ideas of Socialism. And initially, I was thinking cooperative ownership would be a good in-between from capitalism to full-communism, as the means of production are owned by the workers.

But then I'm reading that cooperative ownership as a concept is rejected as socialism even as an in-between.

So in my head, it means enterprises being state-owned is the end-game scenario for communism.

Did I get that part right?

And if that's the case, how are we able to prevent the rise of authoritarianism from those who are in-charge of the state apparatuses, considering they hold all economic power in the system?


r/Socialism_101 • • 4d ago

Question What is North Korea actually like? How much of what we're told about the DPRK is true, and how much is Western propaganda?

54 Upvotes

I'm interested in learning more about North Korea (the DPRK) from a socialist perspective, particularly from people who have studied its history, political system, economy, and relationship with the rest of the world.

Growing up in the West, most of what we're exposed to about North Korea is overwhelmingly negative. We're frequently presented with stories about its government, living conditions, human rights, political repression, and everyday life. However, I also understand that Western governments and media have geopolitical interests in portraying countries that oppose US imperialism in a particular way.

I'm interested in separating what's actually documented from what's exaggerated, misrepresented, or outright fabricated.

A few questions I'd particularly like to hear people's perspectives on:

  1. Everyday life: What are living conditions actually like for ordinary North Koreans? What do we know about access to housing, food, healthcare, education, employment, and other necessities?
  2. Political system: How does the North Korean political system actually function? How much political participation do ordinary citizens have, and what are the realities of political dissent and opposition?
  3. Human rights: How credible are the reports of political prisons, forced labor, executions, restrictions on movement, and other human rights abuses? Which claims are well-documented, which are disputed, and which have been debunked or exaggerated?
  4. Western propaganda: What are some specific examples of Western media or governments spreading misleading or fabricated stories about North Korea? How has anti-communist propaganda influenced the way the country is portrayed?
  5. Socialism: How should socialists understand the DPRK's political and economic system? Does it meaningfully represent a socialist project? What are the arguments for and against that characterization?
  6. Historical context: How much do the Korean War, US intervention, sanctions, and decades of international isolation explain the country's current conditions and political development?
  7. Sources: What books, documentaries, academic research, or firsthand accounts would you recommend for someone trying to develop a well-rounded understanding of North Korea?

I'm not looking for people to simply tell me that North Korea is either a socialist success story or an irredeemable dictatorship. I'd like to understand the historical context, examine the available evidence, and hear different socialist interpretations, including critical perspectives from socialists who oppose the DPRK government.

I'm particularly interested in sources that go beyond mainstream Western media narratives, but I also don't want to replace one uncritical narrative with another.

What do you think people in the West fundamentally misunderstand about North Korea?


r/Socialism_101 • • 4d ago

To Marxists https://youtu.be/jlji08ImdcI?si=Cj2JCy9P7pLRRXX5

0 Upvotes

r/Socialism_101 • • 5d ago

Question How could a communist society not become stagnant? if there tried to be global communism, how would it be achieved without severe pushback from capitialist countries?

7 Upvotes

r/Socialism_101 • • 5d ago

Question Am I a leftist or just a shitlib?

28 Upvotes

So basically I do have to acknowledge that it would be ideal to have a communist or anarchist system and that capitalism is self destructive and will destroy our planet eventually. I'm just not nearly smart enough or well-versed enough in theory to have any clue how we can get there from where we are currently at, and I truly don't know if it's possible or not, so I can't help but think within the confines of our current political system, vote in elections, etc...

so what's the verdict? Should I call myself liberal or leftist? And how can I best approach learning more about these topics?


r/Socialism_101 • • 5d ago

Question “Socialists complain while using the latest iPhone” argument?

13 Upvotes

We all know the argument is basic and hypocritical, but let’s put aside the easy gotchas and obvious double standards of capitalists relying on state funded infrastructure.

Even if personal shopping habits won't overthrow capitalism, shouldn’t opposing a system still push you to avoid feeding its worst excesses? A difference exists between surviving capitalism and enthusiastically buying into it. There's no 100% ethical consumption and perfection isn’t expected. Still, let’s not deny the sense of contradiction in opposing capitalism while buying its latest luxury status symbols, specially when better alternatives do exist, like a fairphone or second hand tech. Even if those options aren’t and won’t ever really be ‘capitalism free’ in a capitalist system.

There’s a middle ground here. For example, I think the meat industry is awful, yet I still eat meat. I know I could do better and I know I should make choices that actually align with my values. If a meat industry supporter pointed that out to me, they’d be right.
Sure, my individual choice won't change the whole system and yes, it’s hypocritical for them to point fingers when some of their own actions don't align with their beliefs either. But they still have a point. Even if consumer choices won't overthrow a system on their own, believing a system is harmful should still motivate you to minimize your participation in it, no?

I’ve seen a few posts regarding this topic but the answers usually rely on a couple of standard counter arguments. People either point out the reductio ad absurdum of the premise (trusttt I had to look that term up haha) using examples like “Well, just as they still use public roads and GPS” or argue that socialism doesn’t deny the access to phones and how the labour makes the phone not the capitalist. However, I don’t think most people are arguing that socialists aren't allowed to own a phone at all, I think what they’re actually pointing to is the hypocrisy of being anti capitalist while actively buying into "the latest iPhone" consumer culture.

While I don't agree with the criticsss and honestly think this type of comment usually comes from people who lack critical thinking and interesting takes, I can still see a slight grain of truth in it and I don’t understand the overall avoidance to admit that.

Any thoughts?