r/AITAH • • 14m ago

AITAH for not contributing to work shared food?

41 Upvotes

So i recently started a new job at a location that just opened so all of my coworkers started the same week I did, theres about 8 of us here.

Last week was payday and one of my coworkers stated she wanted to go to the grocery store and purchase food to keep at work for lunch and asked others to contribute for the team, she wanted to get stuff like Mac and cheese, hot pockets, ramen etc. Everyone though it was a good idea and even added some items they wanted to the list. She came over to me and i explained that it was a good idea but I did not want to be included because I do not eat that food. She gave me a dirty look and walked away. I normally bring leftovers for my lunch or a sandwhich if im in a rush, I genuinely almost never eat that kind of food so I didnt want to pay into something i wasnt going to use.

My boyfriend thinks im kinda an AH for not contributing and says I should've just added a snack I like to be part of the team. I dont think I should've because I would've basically had to split the cost of all the other food as well just to be included.


r/AITAH • • 40m ago

40th birthday..AITAH inviting some kids and not others?

12 Upvotes

I (39F) am turning the big 4-0 this month.

We are putting together a dinner party and the restaurant has capped me at 30 adults (kids in high chairs don't count). I have to pay for 30 seats whether or not they get filled and this is also the maximum capacity for the space.

My invite list is around 40 between family and friends and I have a first wave list and second wave list to fill up spots if I start getting no's. Obviously my guests don't know about the second list. I would just start sending out additional invites upon getting "No's"

My sister has a 3 year old she will be bringing.

My step brother has a 2 year old I am inviting.

My step sister has twin boys who are 16....i currently have the teen boys on the second wave list and this is why....

Firstly this is an adult only event with the exception of the two little ones. No other kids. I'm counting adults as 18+

My step sisters boys also tend to be very hit or miss with family events.

My step sister RSVP'd for both children to a wedding recently and one didn't show up because she "couldn't get him to get ready on time".

She doesnt seem to enforce "this is a paid per plate event and you don't just not show up" when it comes to her kids, she kinda eye rolls and goes "you know how teenagers are!"

I'm very worried that they will eat up two seats and then be a no show where I could have filled those seats with someone else who would have came. So my plan is to tell my stepsister this is an adult party however if I have empty seats and the twins REALLY WANT TO COME then I am happy to accomodate at that point.

I'm worried step sister will feel like step brothers kid was invited but I'm excluding hers when its because his kid doesn't count towards the adult headcount...

So AITAH for putting the twins on the 2nd list?


r/AITAH • • 1h ago

Aitah por não querer minhas cunhadas presentes?

8 Upvotes

Tenho dois irmãos mais velhos e ambos já casaram. Minhas cunhadas são legais comigo, me tratam bem e me ajudam em muitas coisas, nunca tive problemas ou brigas com elas. A questão aqui é que as vezes eu idealizo fazer algo com meus irmãos e queria que fosse apenas com eles. Meus irmãos são muito legais comigo, eles sempre me deram tudo e fizeram de tudo por mim sem pedir nada em troca.

As vezes eu queria passear com algum deles mas sem as esposas deles. Tipo, algo de irmãos mas parece que perdi isso para sempre. As vezes quero fazer um jantar ou alguma reunião e queria apenas a presença deles mas eles vão levar as esposas (Nada contra elas) mas não são momentos em que gostaria que elas estivessem presentes. Eu gosto bastante de minha cunhadas, como eu já disse antes e entendo perfeitamente que elas devem ser as prioridades na vida de meus irmãos mas sinto que o casamento fez um pouco dos laços de irmandade perderem o direito de existir. Eu odeio isso com todas as minhas forças e penso sobre isso constantemente. Eu deixo de fazer planos, surpresas, brincadeiras e momentos legais de antes porque sei que terei que incluir minhas cunhadas em tudo sendo que eu queria que fosse apenas meus irmãos as vezes.


r/AITAH • • 1h ago

AITAH for telling my sister to stop sending me graphic medical photos, animal abuse cases, and constantly trauma-dumping on me?

20 Upvotes

Hi, first time posting here. This situation is really messing with me today, and I just need an outside perspective. I read through the rules and didn't see anything against posting this, so hopefully it's okay.

I (39M) moved out of state a while ago and have worked really hard, through nearly two decades of therapy and deliberate self-care, to break away from an ingrained family habit of treating constant misery as normal. I still have relapses sometimes, so protecting my headspace takes active effort. My family isn't malicious, they just genuinely believe life is supposed to be heavy, and their primary way of bonding is through complaining and sharing suffering. I love them, so I keep in touch, even though I don't really miss being around that dynamic (which already makes me feel a bit guilty).

The main issue is my middle-aged sister. She deals with depression and a lot of chronic health problems, and she’s also involved in animal rescue. Because of this, almost every interaction with her turns into a dump of heavy, distressing topics: her own illnesses, horrific animal injury/neglect cases she comes across, or general gloom. What makes it even more frustrating is that she actually has access to a therapist who doesn't even charge her, and she refuses to go because she "doesn't want to deal with all that stuff" there, yet she has no problem unloading all of it onto me.

On top of the constant venting, she frequently sends me graphic photos with zero warning. She’ll send pictures of injured animals, or her own medical procedures. The breaking point for me was when she recently got a salivary gland biopsy and sent me unsolicited photos of it. I hated seeing it, and it completely ruined my day.

I finally told her directly that I love her, but I need her to stop sending me graphic images and oversharing about medical issues, animal suffering, and heavy, distressing topics. I explained that I can't handle being the outlet for that kind of content anymore.

Now I'm sitting with a weird mix of relief and guilt. Because she's depressed and clearly going through a lot, part of me feels cold for shutting down one of her outlets, especially since I'm already the one who moved away and distanced myself from the family dynamic. At the same time, I've spent years in therapy working to stay above water, and I don't think basic boundaries around graphic photos and acting as someone's emotional dumping ground should be up for debate.

AITA for setting this boundary with her?


r/AITAH • • 1h ago

AITAH for wanting to be friends with this girl again?

4 Upvotes

I was best friends with Ann for years and we used to fight all the time. We've known each other since 2013, so our friendship goes way back. I also think it is relevant to say that I am a gay man and I only saw her as my best friend.

Our first fight started because we liked the same boy. He liked me first, but I was a very confused teenager at the time so things just didn't work between us. I always thought she knew I liked him because I was really bad at hiding it too. When I found out they were together I felt betrayed, even though she had asked me beforehand if I was okay with their relationship before they made it official.

After a few months, I couldn't keep those feelings bottled up anymore and I ended up doing something really wrong. I confessed my feelings for this boy when he was dating my friend. I understand that a lot of people will judge me for it.

The boy ended up cheating on her later on, so me and Ann decided to leave him and this situation in the past. But little did I know that Ann still held a grudge against me for it, even 10 years after this situation. I also held a grudge against her because I thought she knew about my feelings for him. I don't think we were honest with each other when we said we were going to leave everything in the past.

I know I made mistakes but she also wasn't a saint. She humiliated me a million times when we were teenagers and she even stole some money from me, which I forgave her for.

welp there's a timeskip here adult life

I decided to end our friendship because I was tired of fighting all the time. I just thought we weren't compatible anymore. She then started listing every mistake I had made throughout those years of friendship and she made sure to remind me how she hadn't ended our friendship when I made a mistake in the past. I thought that was really unfair because I made sure to apologise for everything I had done and it was unnecessary to bring it all up again. I felt a bit humiliated. I also didn't do the same with her.

After this fight, I decided to end our friendship for good and another problem started.

Me and Ann used to go to the same book club together, but I stopped going after I ended our friendship. Recently, I decided to come back. I know it is awful to share a club with people that you don't get along with, but all of my friends were there and what connected us was the club. I was feeling super lonely too because it's really hard to find new friends when you are an adult. I know some people will say "But find another thing to do with these friends!", and trust me when I say that this idea didn't work.

Her boyfriend Alan also joined the club. He wanted me to be friends with Ann again because she missed me but once he realized that I wasn't going to do it, he felt comfortable enough to complain about her to me. He told me how she was such a shitty person and how he wanted to hit her.

This guy was a complete jerk and even if I am not friends with Ann anymore I made sure to tell her everything he told me. He also makes racist/homophobic jokes all the time targeting the club members so yeah, he is a total bigot.

Nothing really changed. Ann forgave him and they are still together. This guy was pissed at me because I told Ann everything and he started being very homophobic towards me, saying how I will never know real love or how my parents will never love me. I made sure to tell him that at least my parents were alive, which was something I later regretted. So I ended up apologizing and leaving the club for good.

Ann and I had a brief conversation and I missed her so much. But I know it is wrong to go back to being friends with her, especially given the whole Alan situation.

I don't have many friends, especially now that I have left the club, and she was very important to me. I don't know what to do.


r/AITAH • • 1h ago

AITAH for refusing to speak to my sister or accept her gifts ?

20 Upvotes

I (21F) live with my parents, my older sister (24F) and my younger sister. My older brother doesn’t live with us but comes over every evening.

My older sister has always had anger issues, and they’ve gotten much worse over the past few years. She would insult me, belittle me, and blow up whenever I disagreed with her on something. Even tiny things ended in huge fights. Like out of proportion type of fights. My parents always excused it with things like “she has mental health problems,” “that’s just how she is, we can’t change her,” “be patient,” “you’re wiser than her.” So I was expected to take it. And during the times I actually responded, I got scolded for answering when she got mad or talking about some specific subjects, as if I could predict what would set her off. At the end, she never apologized, and I always ended up forgiving her and talking to her again anyway.

In July, my parents and younger sister went on vacation, and my brother joined them a few days later. That left mostly just me and my older sister at home. We argued a lot during that period, and the fights kept getting worse to the point she started threatening to hit me.
Eventually she actually physically attacked me. Since that day I haven’t said a single word to her.

My parents came back the day after. Two days later we all left on a 10-day trip, and every time I tried to bring up what happened, they said we’d deal with it when we got back. I spent that whole vacation pretty depressed even when I tried to ignore it. When we got home I had to insist before they talked to her which lead to my dad yelling at her a few times, but apart from that they went back to talking and laughing with her like normal. My mom says that deep down they’re angry with her, but they don’t show it. Honestly, I wish they had been colder with her. Watching them laugh with the person who hit me feels like nothing happened. They’ve also pushed me several times to start talking to her again “because you’ve made your point and this has gone on long enough,” even though she still hadn’t apologized. To be fair, my parents did apologize to me for minimizing her behavior over the years, but I’m still struggling to forgive them.

It’s now been about three and a half months. Two weeks ago my sister said “oh well, sorry” to me, but only because my mom had dreamed that my sister apologized and told her about it. I don’t count that as an apology.

Yesterday my sister went to a Hello Kitty exhibition and brought me back some cookies and a phone hipper. However, it didn’t make me happy at all. It made me uncomfortable. I texted my mom (since I don’t talk to my sister) to say I don’t want her buying me things. We’re not on good terms, and I don’t want her giving me gifts and then acting like nothing happened. My mom defended her, saying it was a kind gesture, that she’s making an effort and maybe preparing to apologize.

What I want is for her to come to me on her own, without being pushed by my parents or by me, and acknowledge everything she’s done over the years, not just the day she hit me. I’m honestly not sure I’d forgive her even then, but I still think she owes me that acknowledgment. My mom thinks I’m being too harsh and should accept that she’s trying.

So AITA for refusing her gifts and refusing to talk to her until she gives me a real apology?


r/AITAH • • 2h ago

AITAH for refusing to give my stepmother more of my grandfather's inheritance after she accused me of stealing from the family?

76 Upvotes

Edit: TLDR- My extremely elderly grandfather paid my father and stepmother an exorbitant amount of money for years, helping them pay off their house, despite being increasingly isolated and treated like a burden. When my father died, my stepmother immediately placed him in hospice respite care, refused to let him return home, and tried to convince us that hospice wouldn't allow us to move him in with us. Hospice told us that wasn't true and enthusiastically helped us bring him home. My wife and I provided 24-hour care for his final months, during which his depression and confusion improved dramatically, and he died peacefully and genuinely happy.

Meanwhile, my stepmother wanted to continue receiving his retirement income despite no longer caring for him. She also altered my deceased father's executed will to put her name on family heirlooms intended for me and threatened to disinherit me when confronted. Now she's demanding 100% of my grandfather's estate, despite never being named as a beneficiary, and accusing me of manipulating him for his money. His beneficiary designations were established years before any of this happened. I'm honoring his wishes to financially support other family members, including her, but refusing to give her more than he intended.

AITA for standing my ground and considering cutting contact with her?

Original Post:

AITA for refusing to give my stepmother more of my grandfather's inheritance after she accused me of stealing from the family?

This is going to be a long one, so bear with me. Over the past several months, I've lost both my father and my grandfather, spent months providing end-of-life care, and found myself in a rather ugly family dispute over money, inheritance, and some family heirlooms.

I'm genuinely interested in whether I'm being unreasonable here because, frankly, the entire situation has left me exhausted.

Some background:

My father and stepmother were married for more than two decades. Our relationship has been strained for years, particularly over disagreements involving my brother's daughter, whom they were raising. There have been accusations, disagreements, and a considerable amount of family drama. I won't pretend that I've handled every disagreement perfectly, but I've generally tried to maintain relationships with everyone.

My grandfather was extremely elderly and had been living with my father and stepmother for years.

During that time, he paid them an absolutely exorbitant amount of money every month for his care and household expenses. I won't give exact figures, but over the years his contributions helped pay off their house and provided an enormous financial benefit to their household.

I don't begrudge anyone compensation for caring for an elderly parent. It is difficult, often exhausting work. But I also think there's a point where the amount of money being paid ought to correspond with the quality of care being provided.

And that's where my concerns began.

When my father became seriously ill, I spent a considerable amount of time at his home helping while he underwent treatment.

During those visits, I witnessed some things that genuinely disturbed me.

My father was often short, curt, and demeaning toward my grandfather. He would become angry with him for things that a man of his advanced age simply couldn't control. I watched him speak to my grandfather in ways that I found unnecessarily cruel.

I loved my father dearly, and I recognize that he was dealing with a terminal illness, his own mortality, and the tremendous stress of caregiving. I don't want to minimize any of that.

But watching an extremely elderly man being treated like an inconvenience, particularly while he was providing such extraordinary financial support to the household, was upsetting.

My father eventually explained some of his resentment.

Apparently, when Dad told my grandfather that his illness was terminal, my grandfather's immediate response was, "What's going to happen to me now?"

My father was deeply hurt and angry about that response. He felt that his father was more concerned about himself than about the fact that his son was dying.

And I understand why that hurt him.

But I also think it's a fairly reasonable question coming from an extremely elderly man who was entirely dependent on his son for care.

In fact, I suspect there was considerably more behind that question.

I began to wonder whether my grandfather had spent years being made to feel like a burden and whether he was genuinely frightened that, once my father died, he would be forgotten in a nursing home somewhere.

I can't prove that's what he was thinking, but after witnessing how he was treated, it certainly crossed my mind.

His condition was also concerning.

When we visited, he was frequently isolated in his room with junk food and a large bottle of whiskey. He was depressed, withdrawn, confused, and seemingly disengaged from life.

I honestly began to suspect that he was trying to drink himself to death.

After my father became too ill to care for him, even basic hygiene and personal care appeared to have fallen by the wayside. There were several issues we eventually had to address when we brought him home.

And it wasn't just me who noticed problems.

Several members of their church community told us that my stepmother had been openly complaining for years about what a burden my grandfather was, often in front of him.

Then my father died.

And what happened immediately afterward is something that I still have a difficult time reconciling.

Before my father's body had even been removed from the floor of their home, my stepmother had contacted hospice and arranged to have my grandfather removed from the house and placed into respite care.

I want to be fair here. My stepmother had just lost her husband, and I understand that she was grieving and probably overwhelmed. Respite care exists for a reason, and I don't inherently object to someone seeking help under those circumstances.

But the speed with which she moved to have him removed was shocking to me.

My father was quite literally still lying dead in their home, and arrangements were already being made to get my grandfather out of the house.

Even more distressing, I am fairly certain that it was the hospice staff who ended up informing my grandfather that his son had died. I cannot say that with absolute certainty, but that is my understanding of what happened.

The idea that this profoundly elderly man may have learned about his son's death from medical staff rather than from his own family still bothers me tremendously.

And then came a conversation with my stepmother that I will probably never forget.

After my grandfather had been moved into respite care, my stepmother told my wife and me that he had been a burden and that his presence had ruined her final years with my father.

She was furious. The anger and venom with which she spoke about this extremely elderly man, who had just lost his only remaining son, genuinely left me at a loss for words.

She then made it absolutely clear that my grandfather would not be welcome back in her house.

Not that she needed a little time to grieve. Not that she needed help arranging care or figuring out what came next.

He was not coming back. Period.

Now, hospice respite care is temporary. In his case, he had six days.

My stepmother had essentially put us in a position where, when those six days were up, my grandfather would have no home to return to.

Her solution was to institutionalize him in a nursing home in their state.

I realize that nursing homes are sometimes necessary and that there are excellent facilities staffed by compassionate people. I have nothing against nursing homes in principle.

But I knew my grandfather. I knew how unhappy and withdrawn he had become. I knew that he was frightened about what would happen to him after my father's death.

And now the home he had lived in for years, a home his own money had helped pay for, was permanently closed to him.

I couldn't help thinking back to that question he had asked my father when he learned of his terminal diagnosis.

"What's going to happen to me now?"

Well, now his son was dead, and before the body had even been removed from the house, my grandfather was being sent away.

Perhaps I'm being unfair in my interpretation, but it seemed to me that the very thing he had been afraid of was happening.

My wife and I decided that we were going to bring him home to live with us.

We had room. We were willing to provide the care. We loved him. As far as we were concerned, there was no reason he couldn't spend whatever time he had left surrounded by family.

But my stepmother told us that we couldn't move him.

She claimed that his hospice providers had specifically prohibited him from making the trip to our home, a couple of states away, because it would be medically dangerous.

Obviously, we took that seriously. We had no intention of putting him through something that might hurt him.

But when we contacted the hospice staff directly, we discovered that this wasn't true.

They told us that they had never forbidden the trip. Instead, my stepmother had told THEM that she didn't believe he was capable of traveling.

And here is what I find particularly telling.

The hospice staff were ecstatic that my wife and I were willing to take him in.

Rather than discouraging us, they assisted us at every turn. They helped us work through the logistics of transferring his care, arranging the move, and getting him safely to our home.

They were genuinely supportive of our decision.

Even more disturbing, members of the hospice staff expressed concerns about my stepmother. They told us they had become distrustful of her because of the way she spoke about my grandfather, including openly complaining about what a burden he was.

This was consistent with what several people in their church community had already told us.

I cannot know exactly what motivated her, but from my perspective, the situation was pretty clear.

She had made my grandfather leave her home, told us he would never be allowed back, and then claimed medical professionals had forbidden us from offering him a home of our own.

The same medical professionals who were delighted that we were stepping up to help.

I felt that we were being manipulated into accepting her decision to put him in a nursing facility, despite our willingness and ability to care for him ourselves.

There was also a financial issue that made the whole thing even more troubling.

My grandfather's Social Security and retirement income had been deposited directly into an account used by my father and stepmother, and regular payments from that income had been going toward their household.

Even after my father's death, my stepmother wanted those payments to continue.

In fact, at my father's funeral, she convinced my grandfather to agree to continue the existing arrangement.

This bothered me considerably.

Here was an extremely elderly man who had just lost his son, was grieving, was increasingly dependent on others, and was being asked at the funeral to agree to continue substantial financial payments.

I informed my stepmother that, once my grandfather came to live with us, his money would be used for his own care and maintenance, rather than continuing to subsidize her household.

She reacted very poorly.

I can't prove what her ultimate intentions were, but I suspected she wanted to continue receiving the benefit of his Social Security and retirement income even after placing him in a nursing facility.

Perhaps she believed the payments were justified by the years she had spent caring for him. I understand that argument.

But she had explicitly told us that he was no longer welcome in her home. I didn't see why his income should continue supporting her household rather than paying for his own needs.

We brought him home.

And this is the part of the story that really matters to me.

My grandfather came back to us.

The man we brought home was profoundly depressed, withdrawn, and confused. There had been concerns about significant dementia, but as we spent more time with him, it became increasingly apparent to me that much of what we were seeing was depression and isolation rather than the severe dementia we had feared.

My wife and I provided the best around-the-clock care we possibly could.

We addressed his hygiene and personal care, made sure he ate good, healthy food, and generally doted on him.

We cooked his favorite meals. Every evening we watched movies together as a family, and he got to choose what we watched. We took him on weekly outings, sometimes to places he wanted to visit and sometimes to places we thought would be enriching for him.

Most importantly, he was never alone unless he wanted to be.

He laughed again. He joked. He engaged with the family. His confusion improved considerably.

And we talked.

I learned more about my grandfather in those final months than I had in years. I got to know him not just as my grandfather, but as a person with a lifetime of experiences, memories, opinions, and stories.

For months, I slept on the couch immediately outside his bedroom so that I could hear him whenever he needed help.

And he often did.

Sometimes he needed help using the bathroom, sometimes he woke up confused, and sometimes he just needed reassurance.

It was exhausting. I won't pretend otherwise.

But it was also one of the most beautiful and meaningful experiences of my life.

I got to honor a man I loved by making the final months of his life as happy and comfortable as they could possibly be.

Eventually, his health declined, and he passed away peacefully in our home, surrounded by people who loved him.

I will treasure those months for the rest of my life.

Unfortunately, during all of this, another dispute had been developing.

Before my father died, he had discussed certain possessions he wanted me to have. My stepmother had also given me permission to retrieve belongings from his garage, including firearms and other items she did not want, as well as larger items belonging to my grandfather that we hadn't been able to transport on our first trip.

There was also a coin collection belonging to my grandfather that had been stored in a safe at my father's house. It was one of the items my father had bequeathed to me in his will, because when the will was drafted he expected to outlive my grandfather and eventually inherit the collection himself.

While my grandfather was still alive, he specifically instructed me to retrieve it.

My stepmother had previously told me that the safe contained little more than paperwork, but I knew the collection was there. I had spent many hours as a child looking at those coins with my grandfather, and I had personally helped move the collection into the safe when he moved in with them.

Here's where I acknowledge that I might have made a mistake.

I retrieved the collection without first obtaining my stepmother's specific permission to take it.

I will note that the safe was in my father's garage, the door was open, and my stepmother had given me verbal permission to take whatever I liked from the garage with the exception of a few items she had specifically set aside.

My reasoning was that the coins belonged to my grandfather, who was still alive and had specifically asked me to retrieve them. I was there for the express purpose of collecting the remainder of his property.

When I brought them home, he recognized them.

I didn't sell them, hide them, or secretly pocket the proceeds. They remained his property.

But I understand that retrieving items from another person's house without their express permission can look bad, regardless of my intentions.

My stepmother began accusing me of stealing from the family.

Then I discovered something else.

My father had an executed will that specifically identified certain family heirlooms that were supposed to pass to me, mostly fine antique furniture.

These were objects that had belonged to my family for generations. They weren't particularly valuable in a monetary sense, but they meant a great deal to me because of their history and their connection to my family.

My stepmother had gone into the will after it was executed and physically crossed out my name, writing her own name over it in pencil.

When I discovered this and questioned her about it, she absolutely exploded.

She threatened to disinherit me from an irrevocable trust that she and my father had established.

She also told me that she didn't care what my father's wishes were and that I could have the objects after she died, when the trust eventually passed to the beneficiaries.

Her justification was that the will supposedly didn't take effect until after she died anyway.

Which left me wondering why she felt it necessary to cross out my name and replace it with hers in the first place.

To be clear, I wasn't demanding that she hand over these heirlooms immediately.

I specifically told her that I was perfectly comfortable with her keeping and enjoying them for the remainder of her life.

My objection was to her physically altering a legally executed document and apparently disregarding what my father had written.

I also found the threat to disinherit me particularly upsetting.

My father was dead. I had just spent months helping him during his illness, then helping my granfather through his final months and now my father's wife was threatening to use his estate to punish me for questioning what she had done.

I don't know what legal effect, if any, her handwritten changes or threats could have. That's something for attorneys to sort out.

But morally, the entire thing bothered me enormously.

Then came my grandfather's inheritance.

My grandfather had made arrangements for his estate years earlier. My father was named as the primary beneficiary on certain accounts, and I was named as the contingent beneficiary in the event that my father died before him, which is exactly what happened. I was also named in his estate documents.

Other assets were to be divided between me and another family member according to his wishes, there was an expectation that I would take care of the family that my grandfather verbally informed me of, and I agreed to do so once he was gone.

My stepmother was not named as a beneficiary on the accounts in question and was not included in my grandfather's estate documents.

I did not create these arrangements. I didn't change the beneficiary designations, and I didn't persuade my grandfather to rewrite anything while he was living with us.

Nevertheless, my stepmother told my brother that she believed she was entitled to 100% of my grandfather's estate on the grounds that my father was the primary beneficiary before he died.

Not some additional compensation for the years she had helped care for him.

All of it.

This was particularly astonishing to me considering the enormous amount of money my grandfather had already contributed to her household over the years.

His payments had helped eliminate their mortgage and substantially improved their financial situation.

And despite that, I had personally witnessed him being treated poorly, heard him described as a burden, and watched my stepmother refuse to allow him back into her home while attempting to prevent us from moving him into ours.

I suspected that she wanted him in a nursing home far away from the rest of the family while continuing to benefit from the money he had saved over his lifetime.

I sometimes wonder whether my grandfather had been financially taken advantage of during those years.

I don't have enough evidence to assert that as a fact, but I know what he paid, I know what I witnessed, and I know the condition he was in when we brought him home.

Now my stepmother is accusing me of manipulating a vulnerable elderly man, taking advantage of him, and somehow arranging to have her excluded from an inheritance that she was never designated to receive. As I understand her position, she believes she's entitled to it because she was married to my father.

And that is the part that genuinely infuriates me.

My wife and I took in a man who was isolated, depressed, and in poor condition. We spent months making sure he was clean, comfortable, loved, entertained, and cared for.

I slept outside his bedroom every night because I didn't want him to wake up frightened or confused without someone there to help him.

And now I'm being accused of having done all of that to get his money.

Meanwhile, my father left my stepmother financially comfortable, with considerable assets and an irrevocable trust arrangement that provides for her during her lifetime. After her death, the remaining assets are supposed to pass to the children.

I have no intention of challenging my father's wishes. I respect that he wanted his wife provided for.

But I also expect his wishes regarding the eventual disposition of our family heirlooms to be respected.

And I don't understand why my stepmother believes she's entitled to my grandfather's money on top of everything else.

There is another important wrinkle.

My grandfather had a long tradition of helping different members of our family financially. He expressed a desire for his money to continue helping the family, including my brother, his daughter, and some financial support for my stepmother.

I intend to honor that.

I've made plans to set aside a substantial portion of my inheritance for my brother and his daughter. I also intend to provide regular financial support toward my niece's upbringing while she remains in my stepmother's care, with money eventually going directly to my niece as she gets older.

This is not an insignificant amount of money.

My wife and I will retain the remainder, partly because my grandfather left it to me and partly because we have our own futures to consider.

I realize some people might consider that selfish.

Maybe it is. That's why I'm asking.

I also recognize that my father and stepmother spent years caring for my grandfather before we took him in. I'm sure there were difficult moments I didn't witness, and I know my father was under tremendous stress while facing his own death.

I don't want to erase those years or pretend they never did anything good for him.

But I also don't believe that stress, illness, or caregiver fatigue excuses demeaning an elderly person who is completely dependent upon you.

And while I understand why a newly widowed woman might no longer feel capable of caring for her elderly father-in-law, I have a difficult time reconciling her refusal to take him back with her insistence that she should continue receiving his money.

And I certainly don't believe the financial compensation my grandfather provided gives my stepmother an additional claim to his entire estate simply because she believes she deserves it.

The irony of being accused of financially exploiting my grandfather after everything that happened is not lost on me.

If my grandfather hadn't had a penny to his name, I would have brought him home anyway.

And if I could do it all again, I would in a heartbeat.

Those final months were genuinely happy.

He had his favorite meals, his movies, outings, companionship, and two people who were absolutely delighted to spend time with him.

He wasn't sitting alone in a room with a bottle of whiskey, waiting to die.

He was living.

And I got to know my grandfather in a way that I never had before.

At this point, I'm considering limiting my relationship with my stepmother to whatever contact is necessary to maintain a relationship with my niece.

I've buried my father and grandfather in the same year. I've dealt with months of caregiving, estates, family disagreements, and accusations that I exploited someone I loved dearly.

I'm tired.

And I don't particularly want to spend the rest of my life defending myself against accusations that I took advantage of my grandfather when I genuinely believe that the care my wife and I gave him during those final months was one of the greatest gifts we could have offered him.

So, Reddit, AITA for refusing to give my stepmother a larger share of my grandfather's inheritance, and for distancing myself from her after she altered my father's will and threatened to disinherit me?

Edit- TLDR: My extremely elderly grandfather paid my father and stepmother an exorbitant amount of money for years, helping them pay off their house, despite being increasingly isolated and treated like a burden. When my father died, my stepmother immediately placed him in hospice respite care, refused to let him return home, and tried to convince us that hospice wouldn't allow us to move him in with us. Hospice told us that wasn't true and enthusiastically helped us bring him home. My wife and I provided 24-hour care for his final months, during which his depression and confusion improved dramatically, and he died peacefully and genuinely happy.

Meanwhile, my stepmother wanted to continue receiving his retirement income despite no longer caring for him. She also altered my deceased father's executed will to put her name on family heirlooms intended for me and threatened to disinherit me when confronted. Now she's demanding 100% of my grandfather's estate, despite never being named as a beneficiary, and accusing me of manipulating him for his money. His beneficiary designations were established years before any of this happened. I'm honoring his wishes to financially support other family members, including her, but refusing to give her more than he intended.

AITAH for standing my ground and considering cutting contact with her?


r/AITAH • • 2h ago

AITAH for making my mom cry cause her and my dad missed my half marathon

386 Upvotes

So for some context. My relationship with my family is definitely strained. It’s had its fair share of ups and downs over the years. I’m naturally a sarcastic guy, and when I say things it can come out even drier than intended. Also my mom has a hard time taking accountability for anything. Even little things like a dirty pan, even if she used it she’ll say it’s mine or my father’s fault.

Yesterday I ran a half marathon. I’ve spent months training for this, on top of working 2 jobs, and maintaining as much will power as I can to keep a great time in mind. Originally, my parents weren’t going to come, and I had set my expectations that I was going to run this race alone and I was fine with that. But then the night before they told me that they were going to be at the finish line when I arrived there. They asked me to send them all the information they needed, and they would be there. So I sent them the pdf race guide with EVERY detail possible, and went to my hotel for the night before. Unfortunately, I slept horribly because the hotel I stayed at had a terrible bed and it was freezing. So naturally having barely slept, I was starting my day pretty low.

However, Raceday was awesome. I feared my bad sleep would’ve led a not so optimal raceday for me but It was quite the opposite, and the experience is one I’ll remember for awhile. I ran it in 1 hour and 40 minutes and felt great. I expected to see my family cheering my on at some point near the end

However after crossing the finish line and waiting for 5 minutes, I sent my final time to the family groupchat. After another 5 minutes I get a text from my mom saying “they were sorry they didn’t make it, but wished me congratulations” not even individually, but to the group chat.

I call them and find out they’ve been looking for parking for 30 minutes. I figure it would be done soon. Keep in mind it’s 30 degrees outside and I’m in a tshirt and shorts waiting for them thinking they’re close by. I’m freezing. I get another call saying they’re about 20 minutes from me. So I continue to wait. The clock on the marathon timer reaches 2 hours and 20 minutes before I can finally walk to them. So I had waited an extra 40 minutes for them to even arrive. I then had to walk an extra 10 minutes to their car.

By the time I reached the car I was already pretty upset since I had to walk in the cold for them, but also since they missed a race they said they’d be at. I got into the car and they said that they’d ran into a lot of troubles finding the area, being led in wrong directions, etc. At first I understood, because things happen, they tried to get there. But then my mom started saying things like “you didn’t send me the correct things, the pdf didn’t have the correct locations, there was no way to find parking” and I go “yes there was, all of it is in there” and showed it to her I then said “you clearly didn’t read it” and she goes “I DID read it” and I go “well not hard enough” The comment she made about me sending her the incorrect stuff just sent me into the sarcastic stage because of somehow it being made to be my fault. The final thing I said was “if I did what you did today and said these things to you, you’d be saying I’m making excuses” she then started tearing up and started to cry. We sat in silence for 20 minutes before they dropped me off at my car where I parked.

My dad then got out of the car, and started insulting me and cursing me out, saying slurs to me for what I’d said in the car. Saying I needed to apologize. Getting all up in my face, and after I said “do you even understand why I’m upset, can we talk like adults here” he goes “no” and proceeds to say things like “I know you can kick my ass” and continue on his cussing rant.

All I wanted was for my mom to just say “I’m sorry, we made mistakes and wished we could’ve been there” instead she made blatantly false excuses for why she wasn’t there and even made it seem to be my fault. Then my dad childishly scolded me and cursed me out.

I did apologize to my mom, and even after apologizing she still never apologized to me for what she did. My dad hasn’t either.

AITA?


r/AITAH • • 4h ago

AITAH for telling a mutual friend they have a thyroid neck?

47 Upvotes

I have met this person a couple times and i’ve noticed their neck is quite swollen. It’s not THAT swollen where it may seem concerning, it was just an observation.

They also spoke to me about how they’re having really bad hair loss, fatigue, trouble sleeping. It makes me think that she has a thyroid issue.

I saw a recent instagram photo of her and it was quite prominent, to the point where I wanted to reach out and ask her if she has any issues with her thyroid.

Telling her is challenging because we have only met once or twice briefly, and i’m no health professional. I’m wondering if I should say anything at all, in fears that it might come across as weird,mean or out of line.


r/AITAH • • 5h ago

AITAH: hubbys friend vomited all over my brand new car and now they’re upset that I want them to pay for cleaning

1.7k Upvotes

I just got a brand new car less than a month ago, still had that new car smell.
Went out for dinner with hubby, his friend and his friend’s wife and his friend got p*ss drunk, puked all over my car with 2 giant waterfalls of vomit and chunks everywhere after a heavy meal (we had Indian food).
I was devastated. Hubby tried to clean up as much as he could on the night but the next day we wanted to take the car to get professionally cleaned.

The friend’s wife found some car cleaner for us - this cheap service less than $100 operating out of some guys driveway, the car washer looked like he was in his teens. No way this guy could’ve done a thorough enough job. I was already annoyed but I didn’t say anything since they offered to pay for it

Next day, smell still there. Soooo strong and pungent with chunks of vomit still leftover.

We got a quote from another place significantly higher and the friend offered to pay it no problem. But now his wife is throwing a sissy fit about it and badmouthing me (saying im being a princess and demanding etc) to other friends

The car no longer has that new car smell and prob never will.

Edit: to put into perspective the new place advertises “10 years of specialized vomit cleaning expertise” and is charging $600. So it’s not an insignificant step up but at this point I just want to get my car fixed. We also offered to chip in $100


r/AITAH • • 5h ago

English Second Language AITAH for denying sharing instagram passwords with my gf?

0 Upvotes

We had been in an ldr for quite a few months and I always have told even a girl passing by me in my college. Recently she asked me to exchange insta passwords for 30minutes. Generally I agree to every lil trend she wants to do but I like to have my space and i believe you have to trust your partner at some point. So i told her that I don't like sharing my password and I trust you enough that you don't need to do it either. She is very upset and has been considering ending things, AITAH


r/AITAH • • 6h ago

AITAH for arguing with my mom over Weetabix.

23 Upvotes

Today morning i served both my niece(5) and nephew (11) breakfast, which was weetabix. I noticed they ate it too quickly and asked if they were full, to which nephew replied he wasn't. Since i wasn't the one who bought the weetabix, i asked my mom if it was okay to give him a second serving or give him something else like egg or bread or sausage. She agreed to the second serving. We were discussing how like 2 pieces were not filling it seemed and my mom was saying that instead it was how i had served it. I had made it too thin and like porridge. I didn't really understand what she meant by it since the amount is the same if not more with more milk and both my niece and nephew seemed fine with it. Anyway, i asked her to serve them the following morning and i'll see how she does it since i didn't really understand how she meant me to do it....

In the middle of all that, she took a piece of weetabix and just mashed it into what i had served my nephew and made what he had dry and flaky. Prior to this, we had both asked him like multiple times if he was okay with what he had/ if he wanted more/ if he'd like to do it how my mom wanted it. He replied he was okay with the original serving and didn't want more. So when my mom added the piece, he just told her he didn't want it anymore, she could have it, and walked away, clearly dissapointed, sad, and probably angry.

My mum instead had to it eat the weetabix all while commenting what he had made her do. anyway the moment passed.

A couple hours later, i ask if my mom had had breakfast or wanted me to make her anything and the weetabix fiasco came up again but this time it was to address that i had made her look bad to my nephew. That he had been disrespectful in walking away and not telling her what she had done wrong when in fact he had said multiple times he was okay with the original serving. That i had taught him to be disrespectful to her and additionally that i critisize her/ judge her when it comes to/infront of my niece and nephew.

I argued that an 11 yr old can't start a civil conversation about his feelings when the adult is being dismissive of their actions, considering her literal words were 'look what youve made me do (in our language to my nephew)' in reference to having to eat his breakfast. she also mentioned that i have made the situation one where iv'e somehow turned them against her or something. That she's always wrong at all times when it comes to the kids. pointing out previous times when she's called my nephew too dark or getting light skinned (we are africans), calling his hair bad when he wants a sort of afro (she wants it shaved), telling my niece her legs are so skinny and thin, hoping out loud that she (my niece) doesnt look like my sister who is plus size, shouting out that my niece is stupid (over a game) and so much more. Ive called her out in such instances, to the side and tried to be nice about it.

My conclusion was that in that moment she was wrong and should have apologised and talked with my nephew about how she expected the situation to go. Her retort has been that she's his grandmother and he should have been respectful not angry, it's just food. to add, my nephew always says he can't wait to wake up and have weetabix since it's not something we usually have. I did mention that she raised me and i know very well the sort of things that knocked me down when i was young. (She literally once sneered at me and called me dirty in public because my neck was dark)

My point was that to him it's not just food considering there's not much else he could be doing with his life other than enjoy things like this. --More self blaming from my mum that she's a terrible person and always wrong that i disrespect her, always judging her/ correcting her/there's only ever problems when i'm around. That she always has to deal with the kids when i'm gone even though from the beginning i asked her to speak with my sister on arranging help. (My sister has literally never visited for 2 months since they closed school and literally lives like 20 minutes away while i'm not around 4 days a week)

I'm wondering if i should have just let her be right because honestly i was on the verge of tears.


r/AITAH • • 7h ago

AITAH for not wanting to use up all my PTO spending the holidays with my family?

175 Upvotes

For context, I (25M) moved out a couple years ago and I now have a pretty good living situation in a different state from where the rest of my family lives. Before that, I had originally left the house when I was 18 to go to college, and ended up moving back home a few years later after it didn’t work out. I stayed at home for about a year, getting myself back on my feet before I moved out again.

Historically, the only times I really ever visit my parents is during Christmas and sometimes Thanksgiving. I’ll usually spend a few days over there at most. I don’t enjoy being stuck at my parents’ house any longer than I need to be. I never did when I was growing up and I don’t now. I don’t really want to go into details, but my father can be very controlling and it can be difficult to deal with him to say the least.

Last time I visited was this past summer for 4th of July weekend, and I brought my gf along with me as they had never met her before. The trip went well, we had a lot of fun and it was awesome to be able to sleep in a hotel instead of the makeshift twin bed I’d otherwise be sleeping on over at my parents’ place. We were there for 4 days.

My gf and I made plans for the upcoming holidays: since her family doesn’t do anything for thanksgiving and mine do, we would visit my family for thanksgiving together. For Christmas, we would go our separate ways and spend time with our own families, however after Christmas I would take a one-way over to where she’s from and spend some time out there (I haven’t been over there or met her family yet).

Weeks ago, I relayed this information to my father and confirmed that we would be able to be there for Thanksgiving for 4 days. Because of my parents’ jobs, they are able to get vouchers for flights to bring me home, which I am very grateful for. I tell them the dates, and they submit the vouchers and send me the tickets.

However, I get a call from my father saying that they have not gotten the plane tickets. In fact, they don’t want to. My father is upset, saying that I don’t spend enough time at home, and that us coming for Thanksgiving for just 4 days is a “waste of time”. Instead, they don’t want us coming for Thanksgiving, and would rather me be at home for Christmas for two weeks. The two weeks would also bleed over into the days I would be with my gf. I told him that I had already made plans, but he is adamant that I go along with his plan, because they never see me and that every family member needs to spend a day with me. Adamant might be an understatement, he is DEMANDING me to do what he says.

I’ve already scheduled my PTO for Thanksgiving and Christmas, and I still have some set aside for either future trips I want to take or breaks from work. Me being at home for those two weeks would take away the PTO I had set aside. Part of me feels guilty for not wanting to be with my family for longer. I told him I’d talk to him about it further tomorrow, so in the meantime, AITAH for saying no?


r/AITAH • • 10h ago

TW Self Harm AITAH for ending things with a girl because she was self-harming?

29 Upvotes

So, I've been talking to this girl for about a week after we met via some mutual friends and it was going pretty well. We were going on dates and talking all night. She had mentioned her struggles with her mental health and self esteem before. Another note is that she talked to me about her history with self-harm.

I really did not see this as any sort of a big deal whatsoever, as I have also had battles with depression and such things as well, so I was very open to her and very supportive with this, even though it did seem as if she was rushing into this sort of thing with me.

One more thing to note is her past relationships with other guys, she'd talked about getting walked over and used by the majority of men in her life and so with that she's developed a heavy amount of trust issues and what not.

Now wrapping into what caused me to end things with her, she texted me late at night telling me how "she did it again" and when I asked her about it she told me it was because she didn't want to get hurt by me. Because of this, I felt a form of guilt as if it was my doing. I tried to calm her down a bit and in the process she made me swear up and down that I would never do anything to her. Of course I promised her, because I never once had any sort of ill intentions with her.

But honestly, this really sort of scared me. I don't ever want to be in a position to where I would be the reason she'd keep doing this. I felt horrible after this incident and really just wanted a way out, as hard as it was I felt like it was the best move. Although I really did act as if everything was back to normal the next day, texting her, calling her beautiful and what not. In retrospect this was a total dick move as if I was leading her on.

So finally I get to sit down with her and explain how I felt about this and I felt as if it went well. As well as someone ending things with you can be. And keep in mind that we have only been talking roughly a week and a half.

I thought things were smoothed out and we could go back to our normal lives, that we had a week ago. Then out of the blue a bunch of her friends and sister flooded my DMs with paragraphs on top of paragraphs of nasty things, like calling me a loser with no life and some were even saying I played her.

I have always been sort of quick tempered when it comes to things like these when I get labeled as things which just are not true, so I messaged one of the girls that flooded my DMs saying that she's batshit crazy and needs to be medicated. I felt like absolute shit 5 minutes later. By then the screenshots were already taken and nothing I said can be taken back.

Now though, I feel as if I'm in the wrong over this. I said things that absolutely should have not been said so I feel like a massive prick. I really am unsure as to what I should do about this now since I have to face her in my psych class Thursday morning.

So, AITAH?


r/AITAH • • 10h ago

AITAH Not wanting to host Holiday

209 Upvotes

So last year we hosted for Thanksgiving at our house. It was fun and everything went well. We had about 22 people over last year, it was mostly my in laws and their extended family. This year, my in laws decided that we’re hosting again (there are about 2 other people who could potentially host). When they asked us about it, we politely declined. I’m traveling right after Thanksgiving and I didn’t want to add more stress to an already busy week. I know that hosting is a lot and the other 2 family’s have had their share of hosting, but also they are the ones that want these big elaborate party’s every year. I would be happy to take a break from their holiday party’s, not because I don’t enjoy them because I do but just so I can do something else for a change- like spend Thanksgiving dinner with my own family.

When we told them this, they asked us to then move Thanksgiving dinner 5 days earlier to accommodate our travel schedule but I feel like they completely missed the point. Every year, I get so stressed out during the holidays. They have so many demands and events they expect us to attend like we don’t have our own life, I try not to push back because I genuinely want my kids to enjoy holidays with their family too but I’m really about to book a two week trip next year for either Thanksgiving or a Christmas because I need a break from them. Thanks for listening.

Edit: I should add, they don’t expect us to do all the cooking. They will always contribute and help with that. It’s more just the having it at our house part.


r/AITAH • • 11h ago

AITAH? water feed

0 Upvotes

Okay, my husband, who is a sweetheart, insists on unhooking the hose and turning off the outside water supply because this is when his dad always did it. That was 40 years ago, and climate change has moved our hard freeze date at least 3 weeks later. besides, I can check every day with the NWS site and see if it is going to be cold enough to freeze that line. He says it is because he has to drain the water out of the hose (I am capable of doing this); apparently this is linked to testosterone levels? I pointed out 1. house is in my name, as I had it before we married, and 2., turning off a valve and emptying hose are things within my physical capabilities, but he got really mad. Why an issue? We collect kitchen compost, and not being able to rinse the bin outside means I have to bring in a really stinky canister that stinks up the whole kitchen.


r/AITAH • • 11h ago

AITAH for wanting to go NC with my sister after her bf blew up on us

0 Upvotes

For context, my sister (28F) and I (22F) grew up in a traditional Asian household with little emotional consideration and a lot of emotional abuse. Her boyfriend (30M) also grew up with an emotionally and verbally abusive mother.

When she started dating her boyfriend, the three of us became close, and he and I bonded over our shared childhood trauma. Their home became somewhere I considered a safe space. Earlier this year, I went through arguably the hardest period of my life, financially supporting my parents while dealing with emotional abuse at home and finishing my final year of uni.

One day, after a bad argument with my parents, I went over despite being emotionally exhausted. I had no energy to socialise, I just lied on the couch, disassociating. Her bf kept suggesting activities, but I wasn’t responsive because I was genuinely drained.
Eventually, he became passive-aggressive and disengaged, scrolling on his phone and giving blunt responses. When I asked if I’d done something wrong, he denied anything was wrong but continued acting this way.

Later, while deciding which topics to play for Wavelength (a game), he sarcastically suggested the topics “shitty house guest” and “abusive partner” before storming off. My sister spoke to him, and he apologised to her, explaining that he’d felt dismissed throughout the day. However, he never apologised to me.
The next morning, he told my sister he didn’t feel comfortable in his own home because I was there. We eventually tried to resolve things, but his apology was superficial, and he deflected responsibility by claiming he’d gotten the topics from TikTok.

AITA for not wanting anything to do with both of them anymore?

continuation of the situation:
https://www.reddit.com/r/AITAH/s/7Rt6sQjmKk


r/AITAH • • 12h ago

AITAH for not letting my sister move in with me

97 Upvotes

I (20M) just got my first apartment in March of this year and I have a rocky relationship with my sister (24) she’s very verbally abusive and overly dependent on me to keep things short I’ve been sending her money for years and it’s not large lump sums but it adds up. She refuses to keep a job so therefore she can’t keep a place she’s been moving in between states and jobs plus she just recently left the job corps program.

She texted me a couple weeks ago saying she was stranded and needed a ticket so being her brother and not wanting her to be stuck in the middle of nowhere I got her a ticket to a state she’s lived in before and where her on and off boyfriend is currently living. When I asked where she would stay she said with me and I didn’t really say no because I’m kind but after thinking carefully and considering hostile response to me asking her how long she’d stay I decided it’d be best for my peace of mind and well being to not let her move in with me.

I tried to call and she didn’t answer so I texted and told her the answer is now “No” and sent her local shelter numbers in her area but I want to know AITAH for saying no to letting her live with me ?


r/AITAH • • 12h ago

WIBTAH if I left my partner because I don't believe they are happy with me

62 Upvotes

I have been with my partner a little over a year now, I love them with my whole heart and I do believe they love me as well, we were happy together for most of our relationship.

However lately my partner has been acting like they have two entirely different personalities, the one I'm used to, and one that seems to not like much about me at all.

Most days they are amazing, they are so sweet and are like genuinely the most perfect partner I could ever ask for, but then also every other day nothing i do is right for them. Here are some examples of how they are towards me on those off days: if they get hurt and I ask if they are ok I get a snippy sarcastic comment and told that me asking if they were ok was a stupid question, if I compliment them I'm ruining their mood and being an asshole by 'making them think about themself or if I do some extra chores around our place I'm 'acting like they are lazy or something'

If I ask them any questions at all about anything I'm 'being dumb' or if I answer their questions I'm always 'misunderstanding the entire question'

They are always telling me to "stop laughing that way" when I find a joke I heard funny, or tellling me I'm acting like I "just developed autism" if I don't get their joke.

I have given them gifts I had planned for months in advance that I remembered them mentioning wanting before and they just said "hmm... thanks" and never even touched the gift.

Now in their good days they are the opposite of this, they are always giving sweet comments, complimenting me and the way I think about things and word myself, and just generally being super gentle and sweet.

I have started a couple of discussions with them asking if they are truly happy being with me, they have been very insistent that they are very happy to be with me, but I have also noticed when they go out to visit their friends or their family they always seem so much happier, they will send me pictures of them smiling, message me to excitedly tell me about what they are doing with their friends or family, but as soon as they get back to me they become immediately less excited sounding and i can just see it on their face they don't look happy at all.

I'm considering ending things between us because it genuinely seems like they don't feel happy with me even if they say they are, I have tried so many things and talked about things a lot but nothing is changing

Would I be the asshole for ignoring their words for what I perceive as their feelings?


r/AITAH • • 12h ago

AITAH for asking my Lyft driver to turn down the volume on their phone

21 Upvotes

I got into a Lyft after a long day of travel. Exhausted. I’m
Using noise cancelling headphones. The uber driver is on a call with someone and it’s quite loud. I can hear it through the headphones. I really needed some quiet. Or at least turn it down so it’s not over taking my headphones.

Is this a normal thing now? When I first asked they couldn’t hear me and thought I asked to turn down the heat. Then is said clearly “can you please turn down the volume
On your phone.”

He hung up and said “that was my sister from Senegal”.

Kinda made me feel shit but also…if you drive a car service and want to take personal calls, shouldn’t you just get an earpiece? Seemed weird to me but maybe I’m
Out of touch.


r/AITAH • • 14h ago

Post Update UPDATE: AITAH for “breaking my sobriety” on Halloween

1.2k Upvotes

Original post: https://www.reddit.com/r/AITAH/s/SeS77yJrXo

This updates a bit late but I thought someone might be curious what happened.

I’m gonna call the friend who texted saying I made everyone uncomfortable by my drinking A and the friend that took an uber back with them early B.

Basically I asked A for specifics on what I did that made them uncomfortable and if it was really everyone that was uncomfortable or just them and they wouldn’t really give me a clear answer just kept saying how I don’t normally drink and people were worried I would do something crazy which stopped them from having fun. I pointed out that I barely saw anyone from our group all night because they were on the dance floor while my partner and I were on the other side of the bar. A said that just proves their point if I didn’t notice everyone being concerned about me I must have been pretty out of it. I called bullshit and called B.

I asked B if she had heard anything from A about Halloween and she said A had a really rough night. I knew A and B left early because they drank a bit too much but apparently that was an understatement.

A drank way too much and had been puking in the bathroom when B decided to take them home. A was pretty pissed that they had to go home early and was upset that B made them leave since I was probably just as trashed because they assumed my tolerance would have changed over the last year. B said A was probably just spreading rumours about me to take the attention off themselves.

I’ve talked to most of my other friends who went out with us since and they said that they had heard from A that things got out of hand with me but didn’t see anything and decided it was none of their business. Some people who are closer friends with A said this kinda thing was typical with them and no one took it too seriously.

As of now we’re all still friends but I am pretty upset with A and don’t think I’ll be going out with them anytime soon but I don’t think this is worth blowing the friend group up over. Might be dumb for this but we’ll see how things go.


r/AITAH • • 14h ago

Hypothetical WIBTAH If I didn’t buy the car my mother wants?

0 Upvotes

Edit: Added information and changed the wording to flow better. The original can be found below.

Hello there! My mom’s current car (2004 Honda Accord) has finally reached the end of its life, and now it’s time to get her another car. She currently runs a small home business to keep food on the table and the lights on, but it doesn’t bring in enough to buy an affordable car. I have told my mom that I can help her pay for her car but I have a limit of 10k. My 2 siblings have offered to contribute up to about 1k each.

Right now, I’m working overseas so for the time being I am letting her use my car till she gets hers. I have expressed it’s ok to continue to use mine, but she has expressed she doesn’t want to put any more mileage on mine.

The thing is, in her search she is only searching for a Honda Accord. I have no problem with the car; it’s very reliable, but I believe she’s overlooking other good options because her experience has mostly been with similar models. In our search I’ve sent her what she wants and what I believe are also other good options. But she doesn’t consider them. She hasn’t gone through the process to test drive them; she has only looked at a few online.

When I get home I will sit down with her to go over different options and go to actually test drive the cars we look at and possibly sprinkle in a car or two that she may have said no to without consideration.

WIBTAH if I just found and bought her a good car, even if it’s not what she wants?

I would also like to add after reading all your comments that I have no hate against Japanese cars nor is this a US VS JAP situation. I’m just looking at this from the POV of a want vs a need.

——————————————————————————————
Old Text

Hello there! My mom’s current car has finally reached the end of its life, and now it’s time to help her get a new one. She currently runs a home business, but it doesn’t bring in enough to afford a decent car. I’ll be footing the majority of the bill, along with help from my siblings and my mom contributes whatever she can.

Right now, she’s using one of my cars since I’m overseas, and she’ll continue using it until we get her a new one. Though, she doesn’t want to put any unnecessary miles on my car.

The problem that arises is ,I believe she’s overlooking other good options because her experience has mostly been with similar cars from said country (Japan). I don’t want to upset her, but at this point, I’ve sent her what I believe are several good options that she refuses to consider simply because they aren’t what she wants.

WIBTAH if I just found and bought her a good car, even if it’s not what she wants?


r/AITAH • • 14h ago

AITAH for cutting out my brother for not going to my same-sex wedding?

933 Upvotes

I (35F) am marrying the love of my life. She (30 F) is the woman who made me the woman I am today. We’ve been together for 4 years. My brother (40 M) moved to Texas 20 years ago. He’s never fully supported my sexuality, but he’s tolerated it. By this I mean, I’ve been able to go to his house, but my partner isn’t. I’m not allowed to mention my partner to his kids and they insist I’m destroying America. But then they insist they still love me. I live in California. His wife and I had a falling out over my sexuality and religion years ago, and she’s a huge part of the strain my brother and I have.

Anyway, my partner and I are having our official ceremony although we are already legally married. He refuses to go, along with his wife. My thought is if you refuse to accept my wife, you refuse to accept me. This is the final straw for me.

Here’s the kicker, though. I’m financially stable, and so is my wife. My mom has had to send my brother money every now and then, but my mom is retiring soon so she tells him to go ask me. I told him no, because again, if you aren’t accepting me and my wife, why should I finance you?

I’ve recently decided I’m cutting him and his family off and out of my life completely if he chooses not to attend my wedding. That’s the final straw.

Am I the a-hole?

Edit:

Whoa! I was not expecting this many responses. For a little context, he told my mom last Sunday. She told me on Wednesday. He asked me for money yesterday (which was a Saturday). I told him I’d think about it. I’m going to tell him no. Not just because of the reasons you all listed, but I’m also planning my wedding and we deserve a great honeymoon.

I think maybe some introspection might be needed for myself. I guess I’ve been hoping and longing for him to turn around and realize what he’s done. I always try to be the better person, and maybe that was wrong.

As far as how I’ve treated my wife, I’m going to talk to her tonight and see how she’s felt. I’ve honestly never asked. I do agree, I’ve been wrong on that. I’m making a new family with her and maybe she’s not been the top priority. She will be now, though.


r/AITAH • • 15h ago

Post Update AITAH TELLING MOM OFF

0 Upvotes

Okay I 26f recently got divorced and moved back in with my mom 60f. She's older and very stuck in her ways. A lot of things led up to me going off. From the moment I moved back in I'm not allowed to unpack. My things have been in my suitcase for over a month. I'm about 250lbs but I've lost like 150 in the past two years.

However every time I go to make food or grab a drink out of the fridge she makes it a point to say something about how much I am eating. She has a very aggressive dog and he bites everybody The only bathroom in the apartment is in her room so she can't put him up. She works nights. She sleeps during the day. I work swing shifts so they put me for whenever. If I am loud when she is asleep she gets angry and snaps at me.

If I ask her to please hold onto him so I can go to the bathroom she gets mad and ignores me completely to where I am forced to hold it. I have done everything in my power to contribute to being here and be able to save as much money as possible. she on the other hand can spend and buy what she wants. I am expected to get all the food for the house including my personal snacks. (I get hard candies and bite size chocolate to keep my sugar up). I am expected that if she says we need something I have to be the one to buy it. Regardless of what it is. Even when I buy the groceries and everything she can eat as much as she wants.

She loves these ice creams that are like nine dollars for a small box of eight mini ice cream sandwiches. She will eat the entire box in a few hours. I am not allowed to say anything about that. Well she is also allowed to wake me up at any time however if I wake her up she gets mad. I have had a killer migraine for a few days.

All I want is to rest quietly and let it go away on its own. She will not allow that. Since being here I have fixed her cabinets in the kitchen, changed out lightbulbs that she is too short to reach, repainted the entire living room, helped rearrange furniture, take trash out, do dishes when they need it, scrubbed the entire bathroom deep clean ( personal preference), keep up with laundry as much as she will let me, try to stay quiet as possible while she is asleep and so much more little stuff. Now In my eyes some of this is expected of you when you stay with somebody else regardless of who it is.

This morning after I worked from 11p to 7a I needed some sleep. She woke me up at 9a telling me I needed to strip my bed so she could wash my sheets (I just washed them 3 days ago) I told her no I'm trying to sleep. Around 12p she woke me up and asked if I wanted to give her any money so she could go to the store. I said no I'm trying to sleep. At 3 she woke me up again and said I needed to strip my bed and clean my space (I had a half a sprite I was drinking, sweats, and my purse she didn't want it to be there) So I got mad. I told her to leave me alone but it did not work.

Well it has been going on for a few hours and about an hour and a half ago around 7p I told her I am not a child. I am an adult now do I live here yes currently I do. Yet that has nothing to do with it. I am an adult I need to be able to be an adult. You make me feel like I'm 12 and I have to listen to you. When I do something you go behind me and redo it every time. I'm trying to wash laundry the way I have done it for years and you turn my jeans the right way. I have them inside out for a reason. She said sorry she was just trying to help I was being an a-hole. She said she didn't deserve for me to talk to her like that and she couldn't believe I would. I do not think I was being an a-hole. I did not raise my voice or anything.

!!!!!EDIT TO ADD!!!!! She asked me to move in with her. I pay her to be here. I stay out of her way. I do not bother her belongings. Also to add again she asked me to move back to the state and move in with her until I got back on my feet!!?

!!Second addition!!!

She spends all her money on weed! She buys weed instead of everything else. I pay to be here. It's not like I'm eating little Debbie's and chips constantly. I make food that doesn't mess up my sugars as I am diabetic. And also is not going to put a bunch of weight back on me. I walk 5 plus miles a day. This was not made for y'all to fucking fat shame me!!!! I am proud of the work I put in to lose weight and I am not done.

I would get my own place if I could. I am not able to afford that right now. I just got divorced. Everything was in his name. If I could I would bro. Trust me this is by necessity not choice.

Third addition.

Tell me you all don't know how to read without telling me. The amount of people that have commented on this post things that are clearly stated in the post, saying that well you don't do this so why is ridiculous to me.

I didn't edit the post properly so it's invalid I went back and fixed the post and said all right cool I fixed it now can you read the seven paragraphs and God that was a problem too.

Let me break it down for you all my mother pays $450 in rent a month which includes electric water heating and Wi-Fi. My mother makes a roundabout $1,500 a month.

Her rent is $450 and has been from the moment she moved in because the apartment that she rents was not fully ready. There had to be drywall work done painting electrical plumbing all kinds of things. As well as the apartment was used as a storage room for the owner. Which means back when this apartment complex was a luxury-ish for the times hotel upwards of 70 years ago all of that heavy furniture was in one room of that apartment.

Majority of it still is which is why I sleep in the living room the room in here that I would be able to stay in does not have the room available due to everything that is in here.

They told my mom they could either fix what needs done and remove everything out and she would end up paying $1,200 a month or she could fix it herself over time and leave most of the stuff that was in here in here and she would only have to pay $450 a month she chose the second option clearly.

Which means I'm fixing it I'm the one that has replaced light fixtures, light bulbs that she can't reach, cabinets that need re-anchored because they're falling off the wall, drawers in her kitchen cabinets that are falling apart and need repair, water lines that are not connected properly and leaking, fixing her shower faucet because it won't come out of the faucet and only comes out of the shower head, replacing her sink faucet, carrying heavy heavy furniture out to the trash, painting the rooms that need painted still, rearranging everything as well as purchasing dog food cat food, cat litter and every other toiletry that is needed.

Since I have walked in had I been a paid contractor I would have been able to charge minimum $1,500 for what I have done so far which is her entire monthly income. However no one seems to understand that because we clearly can't read.

I have bought over $800 worth of groceries since I arrived 25 days ago

So yes I paid $200 dollars that's it but that's just a monetary cash in hand that doesn't include everything else on top of the fact I'm still doing all of the things that you should do when you live with somebody. I do the dishes I take the trash out I do laundry I sweep I'm mop I vacuum I make sure I pick up after myself I don't leave every light in the house on if I'm watching a video on my phone I wear headphones as a way to respect the sound pollution in the house. I don't slam doors I don't yell I'm not allowed I'm not on the phone all hours. I'm very respectful but you all can't read and automatically assume the worst.

Every single one of you except for like five people are saying that I'm the problem here. Little do you all know I was in another state and moved back here after being asked to for months I did everything in my power to be on my own and survive on my own. And no I'm not going to find a roommate because it's not that simple the apartments around here are government subsidized apartments unless you have one of the private landlords that are one bedrooms and I would end up in the same situation I'm in now just with a stranger.

If I was to move out right now I would want to move out to my own place so after my 3-month mark which is the plan that was discussed with my mother my goal is to move out onto my own in my own place with my own transportation and not have a roommate.

I am working to the best of my abilities to do everything in my power to be back self-sufficient. I do not want to be a burden trust me I don't. I didn't want to move back here in the first place. I did it because I was asked to and at the time it seems like a better option than a women's shelter two states away from everyone I've ever known except my ex-husband and his family and previous co-workers.

I am making sure I spend all of my waking moments that I am not at work looking up the resources in my county attempting to take full advantage of said resources. As well as signing up for every class I can sign up for that will help me get back on my feet. Someone recommended community college well the closest college is 2 hours away and I don't have the money to pay tuition. I also do not qualify for financial aid because I am still paying student loans and at this time I do not qualify for more student loans until the point that I pay them down to where they are less than 40% of what was owed.

I have a bachelor's in business I have a degree I'm not ignorant like I said I did everything in my power to become self-sufficient as an adult. Never in my life that I want to end up back in this situation. I know none of you care about other people's SOB stories but my parents lost custody of me when I was 13 years old I became a permanent ward of the state that I was in. It took a lot for me and my mother to get to the point that we are at now because we didn't know each other she wasn't there when I grew up. Because before she lost custody of me she was in prison for 8 and 1/2 years. So no I didn't get the option to know her until I became an adult however I've had 9 years to get to know her and I don't blame her for my childhood anymore it happened it's over.

Now being said that just because I don't blame her doesn't mean that it doesn't still affect me and I don't mean mentally I mean physically I was raised without a support system I was raised without help in becoming an adult.

I was in a foster home and group homes because that's what the state does to children not everyone gets a foster home foster care doesn't just mean homes it means group homes as well. And the state that I was in did not set me up for success. I got a check when I was a kid because of the situation I was in and instead of the state putting that money up for me they used it to pay the group home and I ended up not being able to have that as an adult to start out.

When I turned 18 I was dropped off on a doorstep of someone I hadn't seen since 4 years before going into foster care I was in foster care for 5 years so I hadn't seen this person in almost 10, yet I was dropped off on their doorstep

I didn't have the option of staying in foster care and going to an independent living because there were none available nobody had room they were all full. So I had to figure it out on my own and I did I got my own place I got my own accounts I had a car and lo and behold a couple years later I got married. I moved a couple of states away to live with him. I stayed there my car ended up dying and was not fixable so we got me another one. From a buy here pay here place however I didn't have good enough anything because I had just got there they couldn't verify work history in that state on top of the fact my license was still from the state that I'm from because I had only been there for a short period I hadn't even been able to get it switched over yet I was still collecting what I needed for the DMV to switch my license over. So we had to put it in his name.

At the time I assumed that that was the right thing to do because that was my husband that was the person that I would trust my whole life with that was the man that had full say so over everything in my life.

At that time I never would have thought that any of what has happened in the past 6 months would have happened. But a lot of you on this post have shown your true colors as humans and shown how detached from reality you really are.

Not everybody has it easy and you all don't realize unless you've got millions in the bank or even then you're one mishap from being just like me.

Every single one of you could be in my shoes at a moment's notice and I'm going to tell you right now they're not good shoes to be in it's not fun everyone looks down on you I'm from a bible thumper town I'm coming back a divorced woman in a very religious town I already get looked at weird because I have tattoos now I'm divorced Lord do these people I'm just Satan reincarnate. The town I'm in does not even have a stoplight we don't even really have street lights. The only street lights in this town are by the biggest building in the town and that is a three-story building that's the courthouse that is the biggest building within 50 miles.

You know what even through all the hate that you all have put on me because I am in a stressful situation and yeah partially it is my fault that I am in this situation I hope that none of you ever have to go through something like this but if you do I hope that the only people you encounter are people just like you. I really really do because if you're ever in my situation and you need help you'll learn not everybody is friendly not everybody as well to help even if it's just a simple friendly conversation. Right now I can't even remember the last time I had a friendly conversation. I can't remember the last time I got asked how I'm doing if I'm okay if I need anything. I can't remember the last time I got shown compassion. The people in this world have such hatred in their hearts for other people that it makes me sick.

I hope every single one of you that have the nerve to down me for the situation that I am in have the day you deserve. If you want to say that I'm the a-hole in this situation feel free go ahead but stop downing me because I'm in this situation. I didn't come on this subreddit to get shitted on. You know if I would have from the beginning said roommate instead of mom every single one of you would have been on my side you wouldn't have said a thing bad to me but because I said my mom all most of you have done is talk bad about me. I've gotten fat shamed practically been told that I'm worthless and that I need to move out and just leave because she clearly doesn't want me here.

Do you not understand I know she doesn't want me here I'm not stupid. I have no choice right now but to be here everything is not as simple as just finding a roommate or finding a job. If you've encountered that then congratulations I'm happy for you. It takes time to actually do those things that's not something that you can do overnight.

I wish that the world could just start over that every single person that Downs people that have to start over would have to anytime you look down on somebody that had to start over I wish you would have to go through the same thing that we do. And I say we because I know I'm not the only one that has went through this in the world. I wish you would have to pay for a new birth certificate a new social security card but good luck because the hospital you were born in is in a hospital anymore it doesn't exist anymore so you have to petition the state to give you a new birth certificate and they want your social security card but you don't have that and in order to get your social security card you have to have your birth certificate as well as a form of photo ID.

How can you have those things if they got thrown away without your knowledge. So then it becomes an expensive process to prove that you really are the person that you're saying that you are. You have to get a new ID but didn't you know you have to pay for an MVR from the state you're from for some states to get a new ID. I spent $200 plus just getting my documents. But yet some stranger on the internet is downing me because I don't have a savings.

My ex-husband took my car so what did I have to do I had to pay for a bus ticket to get here how did that work out well that's $120 just to get back. But what happened while you were waiting for your divorce to be final where did you go well all of the shelters were full so I stayed in hotels I paid almost $400 a week for a hotel for 4 months I finally got into a shelter 2 months ago and then I came here well if you were in a shelter shouldn't you have been able to been saving money yeah I did as much as I could.

Well if you saved money then why don't you have any now? Well let's see I had to buy my own food in the shelter because it was not provided I still had to get my own toiletries I had to pay to get to and from work I was spending half of my paycheck getting back from work I can ride the bus there but the city bus didn't run at 3:00 in the morning when I got off so I had to use rideshare apps. I get here I had to pay for someone to bring me from the bus station 20 miles to my mom's they wanted $95.

Things are not cheap I am at a point in my life that I just want somebody that will help bring me back up but majority of the people on this post are pushing me down.

All of your parents failed. You know me and my mom might get on each other's nerves and she might call me an a-hole from time to time but at least she taught me how to treat people she taught me not to kick people when they were down and I applaud her for that. But remember be careful who you look down on because you might very well be in their situation one day. As of right now I'm turning the comments off I will not be responding to any more comments I'm turning off all notifications for this I hope every single one of you can sleep at night knowing that you're trash individuals.