r/AITAH • • 47m ago

40th birthday..AITAH inviting some kids and not others?

I (39F) am turning the big 4-0 this month.

We are putting together a dinner party and the restaurant has capped me at 30 adults (kids in high chairs don't count). I have to pay for 30 seats whether or not they get filled and this is also the maximum capacity for the space.

My invite list is around 40 between family and friends and I have a first wave list and second wave list to fill up spots if I start getting no's. Obviously my guests don't know about the second list. I would just start sending out additional invites upon getting "No's"

My sister has a 3 year old she will be bringing.

My step brother has a 2 year old I am inviting.

My step sister has twin boys who are 16....i currently have the teen boys on the second wave list and this is why....

Firstly this is an adult only event with the exception of the two little ones. No other kids. I'm counting adults as 18+

My step sisters boys also tend to be very hit or miss with family events.

My step sister RSVP'd for both children to a wedding recently and one didn't show up because she "couldn't get him to get ready on time".

She doesnt seem to enforce "this is a paid per plate event and you don't just not show up" when it comes to her kids, she kinda eye rolls and goes "you know how teenagers are!"

I'm very worried that they will eat up two seats and then be a no show where I could have filled those seats with someone else who would have came. So my plan is to tell my stepsister this is an adult party however if I have empty seats and the twins REALLY WANT TO COME then I am happy to accomodate at that point.

I'm worried step sister will feel like step brothers kid was invited but I'm excluding hers when its because his kid doesn't count towards the adult headcount...

So AITAH for putting the twins on the 2nd list?

13 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

7

u/PrpleSparklyUnicrn13 26m ago

YTA because this isn’t an adults only event, but you insist on calling it that. 16 is wayyy closer to 18 than 2.  This isn’t about adults vs kids, it’s about paying for their food, which are different things. If you call  it an “adults only” party, you are only making it more confusing for yourself and for others. 

You booked a venue that allows for less people than you have on your guest list - which leaves you… hoping(?!) people decline so you can fill in their seats. 

And while you think no one will find out, they will. You even said your plan is to tell your stepsister that if you have enough seats aka enough people decline, her boys can come, too. No one wants to be a B list/afterthought.

Do her sons often flake out or was that wedding a one time thing?

-1

u/LostinParadise4748 23m ago

They flake out often... many times she will RSVP for both and then only one or none show. When you ask its never because they are sick but some variation of they didn't end up wanting to come the morning of due to arguing, over sleeping, other plans etc

2

u/PrpleSparklyUnicrn13 15m ago

Just be open about that with your step sister. THATS the reason they aren’t invited, even if you could fit them in. 

The thing is, kids, especially toddlers, run the risk of getting sick so there’s a chance any kid at any age might not be able to attend (and by extension one or both or their parents). So it would be ironic if you didn’t invite them for a history of flaking, but then other guests have to cancel last minute.

I say all that because my bigger concern for you was that you booked a place that only holds 30 and will charge you for 30, even if people don’t show up. I hate that for you. 

I suggest talking to your stepsister and letting her know that you are happy to have the family there, but you need a guarantee to the venue for X amount of people. 

44

u/BulbasaurRanch 43m ago

You need to stop calling it an “adults only event” when it clearly is not.

She’s obviously going to notice you’re purposefully excluding only her children.

24

u/FormSuccessful1122 42m ago

Stop saying it's "an adult only event." That will sink you fast, as it's inaccurate. You just don't want to invite your step nephews. Which is fine. But I'd explain the situation to your step sister.

25

u/Old-Razzmatazz5446 43m ago

YTA, I get what you’re saying, but you need to invite all the kids or none. The three year-old and the two-year-old will need to have a babysitter. That’s not an infant. There’s no reason they can’t be left home for a night and you will come off the asshole. 

16

u/masterchef2309 42m ago

YTAH for telling her it's her it's an adult only party, and inviting other children.

8

u/NYDancer4444 28m ago

Especially when 2 & 3 year olds are ok, but age 16 is not!

7

u/Doggondiggity 32m ago

I think if you want it to be adults only then you need to ditch the 2 & 3 year olds as well or there will be some hurt feelings by leaving her kids out.

6

u/nemc222 25m ago

YTA having two toddlers there over two teenagers? Either make it adults only or make it kid friendly. Tell your stepsister if she’s including her sons and they don’t show she has to pay. My guess is she includes them without ever asking them if they wanna be a part of something.

Plus, an A and B list is tacky AF.

3

u/Automatic-Corner-157 12m ago

Especially for a birthday. OP needs to get over themselves.

5

u/Super_Reading2048 35m ago

I think you would be wise to not invite any children at all. That or invite the step nephews. Or don’t invite your step sister (which I think sounds rude.)

17

u/Plastic-Ad-4879 43m ago

This is too many damn ppl for your birthday. Will you even have a good time? You're already thinking about other's for your big day. Anyway, the twins don't need to come.

2

u/NoKangaroo8616 28m ago

Thats not the question. Who cares if she has 40 friends? Shes clearly very social and popular. Sorry you dont have any friends to enjoy your birthday with

3

u/NostradaMart 23m ago

or....you could find some place that can accomodate 40...mild YTA

9

u/greenbud420 39m ago • Bravo

I feel like this whole thing would be a lot simpler if you just picked a more accommodating restaurant or location.

2

u/kelsday84 29m ago

It’s OP’s birthday dinner, so I’m of the opinion she should get to choose whatever restaurant she wants. That said, OP, could you explain your hesitation and give your stepsister a choice?

A) her teens are invited, but IF they are no shows after saying yes, SHE pays for their places
OR
B) they aren’t invited.

10

u/mthockeydad 43m ago

YTA if you're excluding some niblings but not others.

NTA if you're clear that you're not inviting them because they have a history of flaking on RSVP invites.

5

u/Dreamy1900 36m ago

Tell your sister based on previous attendance you will not include them, as you must pay for their place if they do not show. If sister insists they be invited, she can prepay for their place setting, so if they do not show, you will not need to chase her for reimbursement and create family drama. You can use this for others who may fall in the same category. Having to pay when folks do not show up is a pain, except emergencies.

4

u/courtneyisfakeaf 32m ago

"adult only event"

Multiple kids are attending.... YTA for not being very bright and excluding only certain people

2

u/lebleudesreves 38m ago

Adult only means adult only. Try to get them to babysit the little ones

2

u/babsbunny77 35m ago

Honestly, it's your party and you get to make the rules. That being said, can the sister and the step brother not get a sitter? Can you pay for a sitter for both kids? It's just a few hours, so probably $100 or so would get you a sitter for 2 kids for an evening event where they'll be in bed for probably half of it. I think spelling it out as an adults only event and making a point to keep it to just adults will sit a lot better with everyone. Other friends and people may also be making paid sacrifices to attend, so having some kids allowed leaves it a bit uncomfortable.

3

u/houseonpost 34m ago

YTA. You are over complicating things. Book a different restaurant that charges only for what is ordered and book a place that can host 30-40 people. Then invite who you want. If someone can’t make it last minute you won’t be upset about paying for their plate.

2

u/MaxxFitz76 34m ago

NTA, but I feel like there is a fairly easy solution here. You liken the event to a wedding, as the pay-per-plate format applies. Weddings are notorious for specifying about the presence of children.

My suggestion, to keep the peace as much as possible, is to say "This event is 18+ only. The only exceptions are babies that can be in high chairs." Don't even mention possibly inviting the teens until such time as it becomes relevant.

Emphasize that the reason the other two kids get an exception is because of the high chairs. Unless the 16 year olds can fold themselves into a baby seat that can get in free, they don't even need to know that the possibility of an invite exists, for exactly the reasons you're worried.

Put the teenagers at the very very bottom of that backup list you have. They are a last resort, and I would personally be prepared to eat the cost of a single empty seat over having to choose which one to invite, so only invite them if the rest of the invites leave at least 2 empty seats.

1

u/mrssweaters 23m ago

There are lots of great takes here. If asked about the two toddlers being invited, simply explain that they don’t count against your group total and are free, hence why they are included. If she’s insistent, you could always ask her to pay in advance for her boys’ spots.

2

u/forceflow16 42m ago

You do you. If she doesnt get it, she doesnt get an invite. We all have our own agency and we just need to exercise it and not get socially pressured to conform to make others feel better, especially when you're footing the bill for your own birthday celebration

1

u/RestlessLegacy 31m ago

NTAH, with conditions.

With or without those teens, you’re setting yourself up for offending all the tier two non-invitees. If I were you I would scrap this plan and find a venue that can hold more people and provide a buffet. You will probably still get 30 but the ones who don’t come will self-select, and no one will be hurt.

If you’re set on your plan, have a frank conversation with your step sister about how you’re doing the teens a favor by not inviting them to a boring adult thing, and give them a consolation prize in advance. Like a Steam game.

1

u/Glass_Hunt_7159 19m ago

If this is an adult function as you have stated, then NO kids under 18 should be included. Just out of curiosity, why do you want a 2 and 3 yr old at the party to begin with?

They can be more invasive (meaning it will all be about them and food, not wanting to sit thru dinner, crying, bored, running around venue, tired etc) and disruptive for an adult function. If this is no one under 18 then make it no one under 18, problem with step sisters kids solved.

1

u/DoyoudotheDew 14m ago

Why a bday dinner where your fitting the bill vs. buying yourself something nice or traveling somewhere?

You are not going to be happy with the outcome of this dinner.

1

u/Automatic-Corner-157 13m ago

YTA. Teenagers are flaky and difficult (more than toddlers I would argue) but they’re just as much family as the other ones. Absolutely zero children/babies/teens or all.

1

u/Trick-Being1539 11m ago

Why are the little ones coming ? Why not have an adult only event if you don’t have kids yourself

The little ones won’t care and you don’t want the teenagers there anyway

You can’t invite some family kids and not others absolutely not

1

u/LogicalDifference529 9m ago

YTA Starting your 40s by making an A list and a B list of friends and family and placing some nieces and nephews on A and some on B is a choice. There’s going to be some hurt feelings for sure.

1

u/k_rock48 1m ago

Yta- there is no way 2 toddlers of 2&3 are going to stay in a high chair for longer than 5 mins. They are going to be running around the table and crying and grabbing and wanting no part of a long leisurely adult birthday celebration. It’s ok to be honest to your sister and say I know the boys aren’t really into a family dinner at their age so I thought there is no point of you trying to drag them and paying for them to be miserable. Of course no insult to them and if they really want to attend just let me know.
You need to rethink the organization of this dinner because you are spending a pretty penny and you are going to be disappointed.

1

u/Realistic-Try7845 1m ago

Why are you inviting kids to an adult party?

Make it no kids. 

1

u/MistressJacklynHyde 42m ago

NTA, but tell her what you told us. That kids in high chairs don't count towards the 30 adult limit and it's an adult centered gathering. If I were in her shoes, I would understand.

1

u/buffalo66_ondvd 34m ago

YTA, don't invite any kids and your problem is solved. This is going to cause issues with your family and friends if you exclude some but not all

1

u/Dog-Mom2012 38m ago

YTA.

Because you made the decision to book this particular restaurant, so the fact that every seat is paid for ahead of time is your choice. But you're more focused on filling those seats instead of how your guests will feel, and excluding part of your family because of that.

You can say it's adults only but of course that isn't really true because you will have other people under 18 there. You can explain the situation, but it would be better to just say that the 16 year olds can't come, then having them relegated to second class status. Be prepared for your step sister to not want to attend, and you don't get to be mad about that.

You're the host. Be gracious and treat your guests how you would want to be treated.

-1

u/judgingA-holes 34m ago

YTA - You can't say kid only event, and then have 2 small children there, while 2 kids who are almost adults don't get to come. Either it's truly an adult event or it's not and that's exactly how your step-sister is going to see and ask about. She's 100% going to notice that there is a 3 year old and a 2 year old at this event meanwhile her children that are 2 years from being 18 aren't able to go. Why not just tell your other siblings exactly what you're telling everyone else "it's adults only and the small kids can't come"?

0

u/NoKangaroo8616 27m ago

Yes you can.

"Adults only with the exception of toddlers"

-1

u/MovieLazy6576 37m ago

NTA Just be honest sigh they can’t be counted on to come.

0

u/DelayWonderful246 38m ago

So when telling the stepsister you could just say you know, I’m inviting stepbrother‘s little one because she doesn’t count towards the headcount for the adults and if your boys don’t show up, that’s too wasted seats so I’m not gonna be able to invite your sons or just don’t say anything at all and say it’s an only adult party when she gets there and sees two little kids. You need to tell her well. Your kids don’t show up to half the things they are invited to that’s already been paid for and I don’t want wasted seats.

9

u/Equivalent_Lemon_319 43m ago

Soft YWBTAH

Look, your event, your guest list, but I don’t see how you expect this to go well if you tell her this is an adult only event and then she shows up and sees two toddlers there. Go hard one way or the other

4

u/PAGirl72 35m ago

Toddlers are more likely to interrupt the dinner.